Fire Island Pines Hotels

(27)
 /  /  / Fire Island Pines
Check-inCheck-out
1 room 1 guest
Choose Sites to Compare vs. KAYAK all | none
Stars show all
  only
  only
  only
Price show all
$75to$256
Hotel Name show all
Guest Rating show all
Amenities clear all
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
Ambiance clear all
  only
Price Type -- Should never be visible show all
Property show all
  only
ad
Check Rates
Save up to 60% on Fire Island Pines Hotels
Book now and get a 4 Star Hotel at 2 Star Prices with Hotwire Hot Rates
Hotwire.com
$92+
| Okay - 672 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Conveniently located off Interstate 495, this Ramada Plaza Long Island MacArthur Airport hotel is near Lone Island Wine Country, Islip MacArthur Airport, Long Island Beaches, and corporations like Motorola and Northrup Grumman. After an exciting day, refresh at this smoke-free hotel with complimentary wireless Internet, on-site restaurant, fitness center, dr...
Overall Rating - Okay - 672 reviews
Value for money
Excellent value for money, said 100%.
Shopping
100% liked the proximity to shopping.
Also good to know about the hotel:
Close to public transport
Mediocre 3.0
Mar 3 2014

Nothing

They put a fifty ($50.00) hold on my card that has still NOT been refunded. Also I reserved a room with a king sized bed NOT two full sized beds.

Dirty. Spend an extra 50 and stay across the street. ... more
Poor 2.0
Feb 4 2014

The staff seemed to want to do better.

There are two entrances to the hotel. For those heading eastbound on the LIE it is okay and marked. Forget heading west bound. A disaster. Lobby is a disgrace. Rugs need cleaning. IF YOU REALLY WANT COMMENTS WHY NOT GIVE US ENOUGH ROOM TO WRITE THEM.

... more
Ramada Plaza Long Island MacArthur Airport
$144+
| Excellent - 226 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Overall Rating - Excellent - 226 reviews
Reception
93% said the reception staff was great.
Service
75% thought the service was very professional.
Also good to know about the hotel:
Great pool
Good 8.0
Dec 4 2013

The staff at the hotel were very friendly. When we needed something they quickly and nicely provided us with service.

The hotel is off the highway so the views from the room are bland.

... more
Poor 1.0
Aug 20 2013

Booked a king size room and got two twin sized beds

... more
Islandia Marriott Long Island
$105+
| Good - 503 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Restaurant serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner daily. Brickyard Bar/Lounge open 2PM - Midnight/later on weekends. Shuttle to ISP airport 5:30am - Midnight and local venues within 3 miles from hotel. Outdoor pool, fitness center, gift shop, business center on premise. Private Lounge for CP Members open Monday thru Thursday 6-8PM. Pets NOT accepted. Must be 21...
Overall Rating - Good - 503 reviews
Value for money
Excellent value for money, said 100%.
Dining Experience
92% loved the dining experience.
Also good to know about the hotel:
Great shopping
Close to public transport
Poor 1.0
Apr 8 2014

The location and price were very suitable for our needs. I enjoyed having a microwave mini fridge unit in the room.

There was an obscene amount of noise in the hallway keeping us awake until after 3am!!! Horrible. Staff did not handle the problem when notified at 12 am. Also room service would not deliver, perhaps they were understaffed.

... more
Excellent 9.0
Apr 7 2014

The location was very accessable to mid LI

Was a little noisy.

... more
Clarion Hotel
$117+
| Excellent - 297 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Located in the center of Long Island, The Holiday Inn Express Hauppauge accommodates every type of traveler. With our friendly and helpful staff we try to go above and beyond for our guest. Being located right off the Long Island Expressway we are one of the most convenient hotels for business and leisure travelers. We offer different amenities for our guest...
Overall Rating - Excellent - 297 reviews
Room Cleanliness
76% said rooms were clean.
Hotel Cleanliness
85% thought it was clean.
Also good to know about the hotel:
Best value for money
Excellent 10.0
Apr 6 2014

Breakfast buffet was a wonderful surprise. Room was large, clean and smelled fresh. Desk personnel were pleasant and helpful..

... more
Excellent 9.0
Jan 21 2014

Fitness room and pool worked out well for me and my kids.

Staff had difficulty with the English language and created an uncomfortable feeling especially when a stranger knocked at the door who ended up being a hotel employee but did not understand my response.

Good value. ... more
Holiday Inn Express Hauppauge-Long Island
$93+
| Excellent - 318 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
With a stay at Hilton Garden Inn Islip in Ronkonkoma (Ronkonkoma - Long Island MacArthur Airport), you'll be within the vicinity of Smithaven Mall and Stonebridge Golf Links and Country Club. This hotel is within the region of Bay Shore Manor Park and Stony Brook University. Make yourself at home in one of the 164 air-conditioned rooms featuring refrigerator...
Overall Rating - Excellent - 318 reviews
Breakfast
78% found the breakfast to be wonderful.
Beds
75% said the beds were comfortable.
Also good to know about the hotel:
Great reception
Pleasant entrance area
Excellent 10.0
Apr 8 2014

good location - accommodating staff - clean - very comfortable bed

no.

If I ever need to stay at a hotel in Long Island again, this will be the hotel I choose. the staff was very friendly, the hotel is located in a convenient spot and easy to find. the room was spacious and comfortable. ... more
Excellent 10.0
Feb 22 2014

The entire staff was friendly and accommodating!

... more
Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport
$110+
| Excellent - 372 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
When you stay at Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia in Islandia, you'll be close to Stonebridge Golf Links and Country Club. This hotel is within the region of Fair Harbor Ferry Terminal and Bay Shore Manor Park. Make yourself at home in one of the 120 air-conditioned rooms featuring refrigerators and microwaves. Complimentary wired and wireless Internet acces...
Overall Rating - Excellent - 372 reviews
Beds
79% said the beds were comfortable.
Hotel Cleanliness
84% thought it was clean.
Excellent 10.0
Apr 2 2014

every thing was great

pool was a little cold for a heated pool

... more
Excellent 10.0
Mar 5 2014

I LOVED the breakfast area had a nice chic feel to it rooms were comfy gym was pretty cool too wish there were more resistance machines though.

... more
Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia
$132+
| Excellent - 193 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Overall Rating - Excellent - 193 reviews
Room Cleanliness
84% said rooms were clean.
Pool
Pool was lovely, according to 89%.
Also good to know about the hotel:
Impressive bathroom
Nice tv
Excellent 10.0
Feb 19 2014

It felt like a home away from home! Very comfortable!

... more
Excellent 10.0
Jan 22 2014

I've stayed before, great service.

nope.

Great value, friendly staff. ... more
Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Holtsville
$256+
no reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
On Fire Island, this Ocean Bay Park hotel is a 2-minute walk from the beach and is less than 2 miles from the Sunken Forest. There is an outdoor pool and on-site dining. Each room at the Fire Island Hotel Ocean Bay Park has an iPod docking station and a flat-screen TV. A desk is also included. Guests can enjoy on-site dining and drinks at Hurricane’s Bar a...
Overall Rating - Poor - 0 reviews
Food
Tasty food. 70% of guests mentioned it positively.
Pool
Pool was lovely, according to 71%.
Also good to know about the hotel:
Clean hotel facilities
Fire Island Hotel Ocean Bay Park
$108+
| Excellent - 375 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
When you stay at Hampton Inn Long Island-Brookhaven in Farmingville (Ronkonkoma - Long Island MacArthur Airport), you'll be within the vicinity of Baseball Heaven. This hotel is within the region of Port Jefferson and Stonebridge Golf Links and Country Club. Make yourself at home in one of the 161 air-conditioned rooms featuring refrigerators and microwaves...
Overall Rating - Excellent - 375 reviews
Pool
Pool was lovely, according to 85%.
Hotel Cleanliness
90% thought it was clean.
Also good to know about the hotel:
Good management
Close to public transport
Okay 5.0
Jan 31 2014
The hotel had a fire drill at 10:30 pm on our first night stay. There was no indication from the staff if it were safe if we waited in the lobby instead of the below freezing weather outside in our PJ's. (No adjustments to bill or complimentary items.) There was a loud noise constantly heard in our room at night. I assumed there was a construction zone or factory that did not close located near the hotel. I was exhausted and sick and knew that the noise could probably be heard no matter what room we were in. I also imagined the sound to be one of those rotating fans on the roof that lets heat out, but my son did not want to change our room. The shower did not look like it was wiped down every day. And there was a black type mold near the ceiling that I was hoping would not get us sick. Parking was excellent. There was a simple maze type road to get to the hotel amply located next to a retail center and a few places to eat. Check out was amazing with Priceline.com. ... ... more
Excellent 10.0
Jan 7 2014

location and friendly staff

the heat was not working properly

Location, is wonderful! Right of LIE Next to main Restaurants. Stores etc. Breakfast was fine, quiet and private. ... more
Hampton Inn Long Island-Brookhaven
$132+
| Excellent - 291 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Overall Rating - Excellent - 291 reviews
Beds
71% said the beds were comfortable.
Room Size
79% thought rooms were spacious.
Also good to know about the hotel:
Good minibar
Pleasant entrance area
Good 7.0
Jan 26 2014

The spacious room, convenient and stocked downstairs bar, the pool/hot tub, and the customer service.

House keeping never called me back about an item I left in my room. ... more
Excellent 10.0
Oct 2 2013

The hotel staff was extremely friendly and went above and beyond to ensure our stay was perfect! I especially was most happy with their efficient personal van shuttle to and from the train station and our room itself was very well maintained and clean.

The bathroom needs an overhead fan installed...the mirror was completely fogged up after showering and the steam took a long while to clear up.

I thought this hotel was an excellent place to stay for the price. It was very clean, had the most friendly and efficient staff, and was conveniently located close to the expressway and the Ronkonkoma train station. I would highly recommend this hotel and I would personally stay here again. ... more
Courtyard by Marriott Long Island MacArthur Airport
$105+
| Excellent - 385 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
The La Quinta Inn & Suites Islip/MacArthur Airport was recently named a 2013 TripAdvisor Certificate of Excellence award winner! NEW! Samsung Flat-panel TVs w/30 channels of HD programming. Easy-access Plug-and-Play feature makes it simple to connect electronics. Less than a mile from MacArthur Airport, the La Quinta Inn & Suites Islip MacArthur Airpor...
Overall Rating - Excellent - 385 reviews
Hotel Cleanliness
97% thought it was clean.
Beds
76% said the beds were comfortable.
Okay 5.0
Apr 1 2014

I liked the fact that they took dogs...and there was no extra fee. I also liked that they gave a small breakfast.

I didn;t like the carpet in the room, it was VERY old and worn...fibers were torn out of it...the rest of the room was old but nice however. Although they gave some breakfast, they advertised a full breakfast which they didn;t have.

... more
Excellent 9.0
Mar 30 2014

Value for price

Clean and comfortable,can't ask for more

... more
La Quinta Inn & Suites Islip MacArthur Airport
$152+
| Good - 416 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Set in a stunning, resort-like setting with an 18-hole championship golf course, this remarkable Hyatt hotel offers business and leisure travelers the best of hotels on Long Island - along with convenient access to New York City and a great getaway location. Guest rooms feature breathtaking views of the rolling countryside and thoughtful amenities like pill...
Overall Rating - Good - 416 reviews
Beds
73% said the beds were comfortable.
Pool
Pool was lovely, according to 85%.
Also good to know about the hotel:
Good nightlife
Best value for money
Excellent 10.0
Apr 9 2014

Wonderful public spaces, room and bath -

Nope...

Modern - clean - quiet, comfortable room - accommodating staff. This weary traveler had a great night's sleep : ) ... more
Good 8.0
Mar 30 2014

Nice quiet property and friendly staff

Snack bar prices were way too high

Good location ... more
Hyatt Regency Long Island
$132+
| Excellent - 73 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Overall Rating - Excellent - 73 reviews
Pool
Pool was lovely, according to 71%.
Room Size
74% thought rooms were spacious.
Also good to know about the hotel:
Good furniture
Accessible parking
Okay 5.0
Feb 7 2014

The hotel staff was very nice and attentive and the breakfast was very good.

I specifically chose this hotel because the room I chose said it would have a fireplace. When I checked in the room I was given didn't have a fireplace. I would have booked a different hotel if that wasn't an option.

... more
Excellent 10.0
May 8 2013

The rooms at the Residence Inn are magnificent. Super clean and wonderfully stocked with the mini kitchen, full fridge and living area. Excellent hotel. And pet friendly, always a plus for me!

... more
Residence Inn Long Island Hauppauge/Islandia
$141+
| Excellent - 25 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Located On Prestigious North Shore, Minutes From Stony Brook University and Hospital Our award-winning Holiday Inn Express hotel in Long Island is the best choice of hotels near Stony Brook Medical Center and other attractions and businesses. It offers the name you trust with the quality you deserve at a price you can afford. In Long Island, sports fans can...
Overall Rating - Excellent - 25 reviews
Location
Terrific location.
Breakfast
100% found the breakfast to be wonderful.
Excellent 10.0
Feb 24 2014

The hotel was conveniently located and easy to find. The free breakfast was very good. The front desk staff was very helpful. Great water pressure.

No complaints.

... more
Excellent 10.0
Jan 9 2014 Posted by krmac
My family was recently displaced by a collapsed ceiling in our home.  The staff is SUPER nice and accommodating.  Free breakfast is a nice add-on, as well as the 1 hour complimentary bar.  Clean, comfortable, and modern.  We are very happy!!! ... more
Holiday Inn Express Stony Brook-Long Island
$111+
| Excellent - 280 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Overall Rating - Excellent - 280 reviews
Room Size
80% thought rooms were spacious.
Beds
80% said the beds were comfortable.
Also good to know about the hotel:
Pleasant entrance area
Accessible parking
Excellent 10.0
Apr 6 2014

Spacious, comfortable, great design! Beautiful decor and great room layout. Complimentary breakfast was excellent.

... more
Okay 6.0
Apr 5 2014

Noise in the middle of the night. Management called me at 1:30 AM to apologize. The call woke me up.

... more
Springhill Suites Long Island Brookhaven
«  Prev12Next  »
Prices are either the average per night price per room or first night of stay. You can select to display the prices with or without our estimate of taxes & fees (which may not appear on provider's booking page but will be charged at hotel checkout). Before you complete your reservation, verify the total cost on the provider's site. Prices and availability are not guaranteed.

Here's why:

We’re not the seller
At KAYAK we don’t set prices, so it’s not possible for us to guarantee what other companies are selling.

We aggregate tons of data for you
Our service lets you quickly and easily compare results from hundreds of travel sites at once. In this sense, KAYAK is a search engine and we don't guarantee prices we find.

Why aren’t prices accurate 100% of the time?
Prices on airline seats, hotel rooms and car rentals can change frequently. Several people may also be trying to buy the same travel option simultaneously. As a result, you may find on occasion that certain prices are no longer available.

More questions or if you have a bad price to report to us
Please send us an email and someone from our team will get back to you promptly.

Loading map...

Compare Sites vs. KAYAK

Stars

©2014 KAYAK.com
Semantic analysis by TrustYou