Islamorada Hotels near Theater of the Sea on Islamorada

(20)
 /  /  /  / Theater of the Sea on Islamorada
Islamorada - Beach
Islamorada - Exterior
Check-inCheck-out
1 room 1 guest
Choose Sites to Compare vs. KAYAK all | none
Stars show all
  only
  only
  only
  only
Price show all
$168to$730
Hotel Name show all
Guest Rating show all
Amenities clear all
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
Ambiance clear all
  only
  only
  only
Price Type -- Should never be visible show all
Property show all
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
ad
Check Rates
Save up to 60% on Islamorada Hotels
Book now and get a 4 Star Hotel at 2 Star Prices with Hotwire Hot Rates
Hotwire.com
$197+
| Okay - 290 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Located in Islamorada, Coconut Cove Resort and Marina is on the Strip and minutes from Theater of the Sea on Islamorada and Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State Park. This hotel is within the vicinity of Hurricane Monument and Bud n' Mary's Dive Center. Make yourself at home in one of the 20 air-conditioned rooms featuring LCD televisions. Rooms have pri...
Overall Rating - Okay - 290 reviews
Pool
Pool was lovely, according to 100%.
Management
Management was excellent, said 91%.
Mediocre 3.0
Mar 10 2014

Location and landscaping including pool

Nothing on the rooms was maintained. Walls needed painting, beds were junk furniture was close to junk. Towels were small. Bar was not operating. No breakfast like many have now days. Ocean beach was unusable. Etc

... more
Coconut Cove Resort and Marina
$168+
| Okay - 601 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
With a stay at Harbor Lights, you'll be centrally located in Islamorada, steps from Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State Park and minutes from Theater of the Sea on Islamorada. This beach motel is within the vicinity of Hurricane Monument and Bud n' Mary's Dive Center. Make yourself at home in one of the 32 individually decorated guestrooms. Relax and ta...
Overall Rating - Okay - 601 reviews
Hotel Cleanliness
87% thought it was clean.
Management
Management was excellent, said 78%.
Poor 1.0
Mar 30 2014

Location was good. Room was clean and newly painted.

There was only one small light blub to light the room. Some of the outlets didn't work. The entertainment center was leaning way to the right, looked like it was going to fall over. Two of the drawer handles were falling off. I could go on and on.

When I asked for more light they gave me a larger light bulb which was burned out. They said they would have another in the morning. They didn't. The bathroom sink had no counter so there was nowhere to put grooming stuff. This is undoubtedly the worst place we have ever stayed. ... more
Excellent 9.0
Mar 28 2014

Location and cleanliness

Rooms need updating. new beds, mattresses, modern blankets-not something from the 80's. Pool could be cleaner.

Great location. Would be nice if they added a tiki bar where the grill area is. Not the Hilton, but fantastic for the price and location if you don't mind 'old Florida'! ... more
Harbor Lights
$211+
| Good - 195 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
When you stay at Pelican Cove Resort & Marina in Islamorada, you'll be on the waterfront and convenient to Theater of the Sea on Islamorada and Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State Park. This beach hotel is within the vicinity of Hurricane Monument and Bud n' Mary's Dive Center. Make yourself at home in one of the 63 air-conditioned rooms featuring refri...
Overall Rating - Good - 195 reviews
Hotel Cleanliness
78% thought it was clean.
Nightlife
90% enjoyed the nightlife nearby.
Also good to know about the hotel:
Nice balcony
Good 8.0
Apr 8 2014

location

small roaches in the bathroom and kitchen.

staff was lovely and very pleasant. they made it worth the while. ... more
Good 8.0
Jan 14 2014

Location is very nice. All the rooms have ocean views. It's a great spot to stay that's not to far from Key West if you want to venture down for the day.

... more
Pelican Cove Resort & Marina
$207+
no reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
With a stay at Drop Anchor Resort and Marina in Islamorada, you'll be on the beach and minutes from Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State Park, and close to Theater of the Sea on Islamorada. This beach hotel is within the vicinity of Hurricane Monument and Bud n' Mary's Dive Center. Make yourself at home in one of the 18 air-conditioned rooms featuring fl...
Overall Rating - Poor - 0 reviews
Drop Anchor Resort and Marina
$244+
| Good - 832 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
When you stay at Postcard Inn at Holiday Isle in Islamorada, you'll be on the waterfront and convenient to Theater of the Sea on Islamorada and Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State Park. This beach resort is within the vicinity of Hurricane Monument and Bud n' Mary's Dive Center. Make yourself at home in one of the 150 air-conditioned rooms featuring pla...
Overall Rating - Good - 832 reviews
Pool
Pool was lovely, according to 84%.
Beds
77% said the beds were comfortable.
Excellent 9.0
Mar 31 2014

The Postcard Inn exceeded my expectations. Our room was on the ground level, across from the beach and pool in the 2nd building. There were several spots to eat and relax with a drink, and a lovely beach and pool. The staff was very accomodating.

None.

Great location, central to many restaurants. The marina next door offered boat trips, and there were kayak, seadoo, and SUP rentals available right off the Postcard Inn's beach. ... more
Excellent 9.0
Mar 31 2014

I liked that a well known restaurant Shula's was on the property and the other bars were nice to have too. The beds were very comfortable

The air conditioner was little too loud when it kicked on.

The staff there was wonderful. we enjoyed staying there and it wasn't a far drive to Key West. We liked the area so much that we decided to stay another night and the staff was very easy to work with and let us stay another night. ... more
Postcard Inn Beach Resort and Marina at Holiday Isle
$219+
| Good - 481 reviews
8.3 mi from Islamorada (city center)
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
When you stay at Chesapeake Beach Resort in Islamorada, you'll be by the ocean and convenient to History of Diving Museum and Theater of the Sea on Islamorada. This beach resort is within the vicinity of Founders Park and Bud n' Mary's Dive Center. Make yourself at home in one of the 65 air-conditioned rooms featuring refrigerators and flat-screen televisio...
Overall Rating - Good - 481 reviews
Room Cleanliness
77% said rooms were clean.
Hotel Building
Building is pleasant.
Excellent 10.0
Apr 3 2014

Convenience of room to parking lot and beautiful scenery/ocean view

The patio sliding door couldn't be closed once we opened it - left open all night, safety issue

... more
Excellent 10.0
Mar 31 2014

The pool area was great lots of lounge chairs,the screened in porches outside of your rooms,the cleaning staff supplied your room with free bottles of water everyday,lots of lounge chairs on sand by the ocean,great location.

no

the staff was wonderful and very helpful they gave us list of restraunts to eat at and the best ones. they also provided us with fishing charter info.The hotel has free breakfast, free internet, free parking ... more
Chesapeake Beach Resort
$385+
no reviews
7.5 mi from Islamorada (city center)
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Islamorada’s newest adult boutique resort destination features eight luxurious suites with breathtaking ocean views and private gardens, a private beach, and stunning tropical gardens. Ocean House amenities include a saltwater swimming pool, an oceanfront spa pool, beachside firepit, and private poolside cabanas with stunning views of the Atlantic Ocean, co...
Overall Rating - Poor - 0 reviews
Ocean Dawn Suites
$205+
| Okay - 64 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Welcome to the Days Inn and Suites Key Islamorada - gateway to the tropical Florida Keys. A peaceful relaxing hotel with personal service, the 36-unit Islamorada-Days Inn offers large rooms and suites overlooking the Atlantic Ocean. Guest rooms also available by our Courtyard and Poolside. All of our guest rooms are comfortably furnished and amenities in our...
Overall Rating - Okay - 64 reviews
Room
Rooms are not good.
Hotel
Hotel is ok.
Excellent 10.0
Nov 3 2010 Posted by Anonymous
I just got married (unplanned) and desided to honeymoon in the Keys. I didn't plan on staying at a 'Days Inn' but everything else was booked on such short notice. I was very surpised when I got there. This was not like any 'Days Inn' I'd ever seen... it was beatiful! The hotel manager (I think her name was Debbie) was a joy to meet. The whole staff was very professional and curtious. Our suite overlooked the Atlanic Ocean and was HUGE! We went deep sea fishing right from the hotel had a great time and I will never again judge a hotel by it's name. ... more
Okay 6.0
Jan 4 2008 Posted by Anonymous
The two things I look for in a hotel for family trips are free continental breakfast and free internet. We rented a villa which included a kitchen and, since their website says 'continental breakfast,' we did not pack any breakfast foods. Their idea of a continental breakfast was coffee, tea and a few packaged Litltle Debbie cakes which, upon opening, were stale. It's pretty easy and relatively inexpensive to provide a decent continental breakfst for your guests which I've found is done much better at many other hotels in this same price range. They also advertise 'wireless internet ' but that was only available in the lobby and courtyard area. The beds were extremely hard and the couch that made into a bed was not useable. My son had to sleep on the couch instead which was more comfortable. We paid $12 per night for an extra person and the maids continually left only two sets of towels (even after straightening the couch where obviously another person had slept). One night,... ... more
Days Inn and Suites Key Islamorada
no prices
no reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Overall Rating - Poor - 0 reviews
Sunset Inn
$528+
| Excellent - 8 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Overall Rating - Excellent - 8 reviews
Breakfast
85% found the breakfast to be wonderful.
Pool
Pool was lovely, according to 95%.
Also good to know about the hotel:
Great reception
Good beach sports
Casa Morada
$450+
| Excellent - 985 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
With a stay at Cheeca Lodge & Spa in Islamorada, you'll be convenient to Hurricane Monument and History of Diving Museum. This 4-star resort is within the vicinity of Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State Park and Founders Park. Make yourself at home in one of the 212 air-conditioned rooms featuring refrigerators and DVD players. Rooms have private balcon...
Overall Rating - Excellent - 985 reviews
Wellness
Wellness & sports facilities were pleasant enough.
Nightlife
80% enjoyed the nightlife nearby.
Also good to know about the hotel:
Accessible parking
Good 7.0
Apr 6 2014

Beach location, nice restaurant, beautiful grounds and scenery.

Could not check in early. Snubbed at restaurant for not having reservation.

Charged additional to upgrade to ocean view per night.,while many ocean rooms vacant. Wanted additional $ for late check out. ... more
Excellent 10.0
Feb 23 2014

For $39 daily charge you get 6 tennis courts (the back ones were always empty), a par 3 golf course (great for teaching the kids), tons of yoga and fitness classes, 3 great pools, bikes, valet parking, wi-fi, etc¿The grounds were amazing!

The rooms need an update, but were very comfortable. We upgraded to a king suite on the ocean side for---- a night additional and was well worth it! I hear the non-lodge rooms aren't as nice.

The staff was very welcoming and the service was great. Even at full occupancy I never felt crowded or had to wait for anything. There are so many spaces to choose from that you can find time alone in what felt like a private lounge or even along the beach (man-made but nice) in lounge chairs. We never had to wait for service or lounge chairs. ... more
Cheeca Lodge & Spa
$227+
| Excellent - 1318 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Located in Islamorada, Islander Resort, a Guy Harvey Outpost is by the ocean and convenient to Hurricane Monument and History of Diving Museum. This beach resort is within the vicinity of Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State Park and Founders Park. Make yourself at home in one of the 114 air-conditioned rooms featuring kitchens with refrigerators and sto...
Service
87% found the staff to be very friendly.
Room Cleanliness
76% said rooms were clean.
Also good to know about the hotel:
Good kitchenette
Good restaurant service
Good 7.0
Sep 26 2013

Location

Wifi never worked despite my multiple requests. AC is window unit was very loud.

Excellent old style keys resort type. AC way too loud in room 134 and not very efficient, never abel to truly cool the room. My guess is the lowest temperature possible was about 70 or 71. ... more
Excellent 10.0
Jan 11 2013 Posted by Jrzygrl64
This was my first stay at the islander and will def be back. Met the manager Sandy, a very hospitable host, she made me feel very welcome. The rooms are outfitted like little apts with every amenity you could need. The staff is very friendly and the views are spectacular. Very relaxing and right in the center of town with lots to do. ... more
Islander Resort
$450+
no reviews
6.6 mi from Islamorada (city center)
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Located in Islamorada, The Caribbean Resort is by the sea and convenient to Hurricane Monument and History of Diving Museum. This resort is within the vicinity of Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State Park and Founders Park. Make yourself at home in one of the 14 individually decorated guestrooms, featuring kitchens with refrigerators and stovetops. Rooms...
Overall Rating - Poor - 0 reviews
The Caribbean Resort
no prices
no reviews
12.1 mi from Islamorada (city center)
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Casa Thorn is a wonderful secluded get away, very private and quiet. All rooms have private sliding glass doors looking into the garden or the pool. There are upper and lower sun decks. 3 streets from a nice beach. This is a tropical romantic setting. Included in all the following room; large color TV, VCR and dvd videos, CD's for your listening pleasure, te...
Overall Rating - Poor - 0 reviews
Casa Thorn
$730+
no reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Tucked away in a small corner of Islamorada, Florida, under a lush canopy of coconut palms, lies one of South Florida’s most hidden treasures. This barefoot retreat features 18 luxurious cottages offering guests absolute privacy and tranquility with all of the comforts of home, including well-equipped kitchens, laundry facilities, spacious living and dining...
Overall Rating - Poor - 0 reviews
The Moorings Village & Spa
«  Prev12Next  »
Prices are either the average per night price per room or first night of stay. You can select to display the prices with or without our estimate of taxes & fees (which may not appear on provider's booking page but will be charged at hotel checkout). Before you complete your reservation, verify the total cost on the provider's site. Prices and availability are not guaranteed.

Here's why:

We’re not the seller
At KAYAK we don’t set prices, so it’s not possible for us to guarantee what other companies are selling.

We aggregate tons of data for you
Our service lets you quickly and easily compare results from hundreds of travel sites at once. In this sense, KAYAK is a search engine and we don't guarantee prices we find.

Why aren’t prices accurate 100% of the time?
Prices on airline seats, hotel rooms and car rentals can change frequently. Several people may also be trying to buy the same travel option simultaneously. As a result, you may find on occasion that certain prices are no longer available.

More questions or if you have a bad price to report to us
Please send us an email and someone from our team will get back to you promptly.

Loading map...
©2014 KAYAK.com
Semantic analysis by TrustYou