Coconut Cay Resort & Marina - Reviews

Great 'Key'sy Hotel... – Posted Jun 22 2011

Excellent

I spent 5 weeks here while my house was undergoing renovations. It is the perfect 'Key'sy hotel. Free paddleboats, kayaks and bicycles. The best bargain in town. I tell all my friends and family a

Good value... – Posted Jan 31 2011

Good

For the area this lodging is a good value. It is a 50's era motel with updates. The staff were very friendly and great at recommending attractions... more on Travelocity

Very Nice and Pleasant... – Posted Jan 16 2011

Good

I had a wonderful stay at Coconut Cay from January 5 through January 8, 2011.The staff was friendly and made sure the room met my standards.They... more on Travelocity

nice place coconut cay resort... – Posted Nov 8 2010

Good

efficient and comfortable place to stay. Provided an upgrade to waterfront room. Would return without reservation and recommend over most in Marathon.... more on Travelocity

Coconut Cay Resort, review of ... – Posted Apr 3 2010

Horrible

My wife and I stayed at Coconut Cay on March 27 and 28, we arrived about 4 PM, checked in and went to the room. The room was unacceptable as it was... more on Travelocity

Enjoyed the Hotel... – Posted Jan 10 2010

Good

We were in Miami for the Orange Bowl and decided to do a spur of the moment trip to the Middle Keys for all the nature/outdoor activities.The hotel... more on Travelocity

Lost in time....... – Posted Nov 5 2009

Horrible

The door reads "How it use to be".Dirty, Dirty, Dirty is what comes to mind.No phone, some kind of anomal hair on the bed (sign reads No Pets... more on Travelocity