The Roger Smith Hotel - Reviews

Decent. Rooms not that clean. ... – Posted Oct 2 2011

Okay

Decent. Rooms not that clean. Musty smell. Staff good and location good you.... more on MYTravelGuide

Don't select this hotel. It... – Posted Sep 18 2011

Horrible

Don't select this hotel. It is a dump.... more on MYTravelGuide

For what I paid, this hotel... – Posted Sep 15 2011

Horrible

For what I paid, this hotel did not live up to expectations. The main problems were comfort type issues. The air conditioner in the room was either... more on MYTravelGuide

I stayed at the Roger Smith... – Posted Aug 29 2011

Excellent

I stayed at the Roger Smith with my two sons. We all absolutely loved it! It is a historic hotel with charm and personality; and it is clean and... more on MYTravelGuide

The hotel was very dirty... – Posted Jul 5 2011

Horrible

The hotel was very dirty looking. For a hotel that price I thoughtI should of got a better hotel room.... more on MYTravelGuide

I feel like we paid way too... – Posted Jun 22 2011

Excellent

I feel like we paid way too much for this hotel, so this probably colors my view of it. For that amount of money I want a freaking rose on my pillow... more on MYTravelGuide

Had a great time and would... – Posted May 31 2011

Horrible

Had a great time and would stay here again. The location was great. The two staffs were standouts for their service. Internet access is included... more on MYTravelGuide

This is a clean, family... – Posted May 20 2011

Excellent

This is a clean, family friendly hotel in a great location. The staff was always helpful and friendly, the hotel restaurant was good (we had brunch... more on MYTravelGuide

The room was a good size and... – Posted Apr 1 2011

Okay

The room was a good size and the beds were comfortable... more on EasyToBook.com

Front Desk was very helpful.... – Posted Mar 29 2010

Good

Not very crowded and convenient to my meetins.... more on Travelocity

Hotel Roger Smith in Jan 2010... – Posted Feb 6 2010

Okay

The location of the hotel is excellent, and the breakfast at the restaurant in the hotel was also good. There is art throughout the hotel and it has... more on Travelocity

The Roger Smith Hotel... – Posted Sep 14 2009

Good

We were very satisfied with our Jr. Suite room, very spacious and comfortable, altho the bathroom was small. Staff at the hotel were very nice and... more on Travelocity

Relatively close to train... – Posted Jun 28 2009

Horrible

Relatively close to train station.Unable to reach anyone in case of emergency.“Needs updating: wallpaper, furniture, carpeting, bathrooms.”... more on MYTravelGuide

Convenient, clean,... – Posted Jun 13 2009

Excellent

Convenient, clean, priced-right, helpful.“Wonderful location, very cooperative staff, clean, excellent price, big rooms by NYC standards, we are... more on MYTravelGuide

Enjoyed art display... – Posted Jun 12 2009

Okay

Enjoyed art display.Desperately needs upgrading and refurbishing.“Hotel is somewhat dingy and definitely needs a facelift. Very, very outdated.”... more on MYTravelGuide

Friendly staff at front... – Posted Jun 6 2009

Good

Friendly staff at front desk/good interior design in rooms.Security isn't that great. There is a Starbucks that someone can walk into right off of... more on MYTravelGuide

It was artistic ,old but... – Posted Jun 1 2009

Good

It was artistic ,old but classy.Internet was weak.“I've been going to the Roger Smith for at least 10 years.The staff is excellent.Decor cool.”... more on MYTravelGuide

Room seemed unique, not... – Posted May 20 2009

Good

Room seemed unique, not cookie-cutter. Comfy too.HVAC needs an upgrade - room was hot and hard to regulate.“Rooms were fairly spacious for NYC and... more on MYTravelGuide

“I loved the atmosphere of... – Posted Apr 29 2009

Excellent

“I loved the atmosphere of this hotel. It had all of the amenities and luxuries of a hotel, but with the cozy community feel of a bed and breakfast... more on MYTravelGuide

Very cute, clean rooms, good... – Posted Apr 25 2009

Excellent

Very cute, clean rooms, good location.“I was pleasantly surprised by the Roger Smith Hotel. I had never heard of it and was apprehensive at first.... more on MYTravelGuide

Room had enough space for a... – Posted Apr 24 2009

Good

Room had enough space for a desk, bureau and two easy chairs with light to read.“Nice room, hallways clean, but could use new wallpaper, had tow... more on MYTravelGuide

I was impressed by the... – Posted Apr 23 2009

Excellent

I was impressed by the location and by the facilities offered and the price.Limited dining facilities.“I stayed at this hotel on the 19th & 20th... more on MYTravelGuide

Felt safe, was clean, staff... – Posted Apr 23 2009

Good

Felt safe, was clean, staff helpful, polite.As a person who lives in the country I could not sleep well due to street noise.“We liked it, have no... more on MYTravelGuide

The staff was very friendly... – Posted Apr 23 2009

Excellent

The staff was very friendly and accommodating. They also took us before initial check-in!I was not dissatified at all.“Located in a very convenient,... more on MYTravelGuide

Location and price.The room... – Posted Apr 21 2009

Good

Location and price.The room heating was erratic, often hot in the middle of the night.“I was traveling with my husband and in-laws. We had separate... more on MYTravelGuide

The location was great and... – Posted Apr 3 2009

Excellent

The location was great and the room was well decorated.As a smoker the ashtray was not present.“The hotel accommodations were more than well worth... more on MYTravelGuide

The room is a little out of... – Posted Mar 26 2009

Okay

The room is a little out of date and smelled.“The lobby was small but the staff was very helpful. The room was a little out of date for me.”... more on MYTravelGuide

Great location andgroovy feel.... – Posted Mar 16 2009

Good

Great location andgroovy feel.The Internet wireless connection was weak (but free).“This is a groovy hotel convenient to many NY attractions. Each... more on MYTravelGuide

Great service, quaint, big... – Posted Feb 24 2009

Excellent

Great service, quaint, big rooms and good location.Nothing.“This was a great hotel. The rooms each have a a different decor, which makes it feel like ... more on MYTravelGuide

Great location, quaint, and... – Posted Feb 19 2009

Good

Great location, quaint, and friendly staff.Outdated furnishings, and mold in shower.“Quaint nicely located, small hotel with very friendly and... more on MYTravelGuide

“Very friendly staff. Lounge/ ... – Posted Feb 14 2009

Good

“Very friendly staff. Lounge/ restaurant was an attractive intimate place, I didn't eat there but it looked good. Room decor was from the seventies,... more on MYTravelGuide

It was a nice experience... – Posted Jan 28 2009

Excellent

It was a nice experience.“This is a great find in a superb location. If old world charm and colonial style furniture make you comfortable, this place ... more on MYTravelGuide

Cozy and Classy Nook in the... – Posted Sep 30 2008

Excellent

I really liked this place.The room was super comfortable and I slept like a little puppy. The rooms have a classic feel and are really cozy. I felt... more on Travelocity

Location, nice bed and linens ... – Posted Sep 19 2008

Mediocre

Location, nice bed and linens and quiet room.Dated, in need of renovation and inadequate air condition.“Hotel is in good mid-town Manhattan location. ... more on MYTravelGuide

I love the Roger Smith... – Posted Sep 18 2008

Good

There are probably some bad things you could say about the Roger Smith, but I love it.I've stayed there many times and even though the lobby and the... more on Travelocity

Room was very spacious, had a ... – Posted Sep 11 2008

Okay

Room was very spacious, had a kitchenette.Very dated decor, stained carpet, bathroom was sub par.“Excellent location, huge room for NYC. However, the ... more on MYTravelGuide

Great location.Male... – Posted Jul 24 2008

Good

Great location.Male receptionist was not too friendly because there were 5 of us in 1 room.“Great location for the price.”... more on MYTravelGuide

Nothing!Everything!“Building... – Posted Jul 19 2008

Horrible

Nothing!Everything!“Building is old and run down. Not a pleasant experience at all.”... more on MYTravelGuide

The junior suite was huge and ... – Posted Jul 15 2008

Excellent

The junior suite was huge and charming.They had run out of shampoo. Not a good hair day.“I was in NYC for a funeral. I decided to try this hotel. It... more on MYTravelGuide

Location can't be beat.Could... – Posted Jul 8 2008

Excellent

Location can't be beat.Could not find AC controls in the hotel room.“Great hotel. Would stay there again.”... more on MYTravelGuide

Large room with comfortable... – Posted Jul 2 2008

Good

Large room with comfortable furniture.Construction was being done on building right outside our window.“In all respects this was a nice hotel in a... more on MYTravelGuide

Location is excellent.Soft... – Posted Jun 29 2008

Okay

Location is excellent.Soft bed, TV remote did not work, useless internet, and more.“If you like very soft beds, very dated decor, cramped lobby, poor ... more on MYTravelGuide

Roger Smith hotel Experience... – Posted Jun 8 2008

Horrible

The room was #610, it was very dirty, had not been vacuum cleaned nor dusted in many areas in a very long time. There were scaffolds outside our... more on Travelocity

Super comfortable, fabulous... – Posted May 21 2008

Excellent

Super comfortable, fabulous service (and complimentary wine one evening!) Like home, only better.Street noise was audible even on 10th floor.“The... more on MYTravelGuide

Large room, several windows... – Posted May 18 2008

Good

Large room, several windows that open, great location.Nearby construction, noisy during early evening.“Great location near the Marriott on Lexington; ... more on MYTravelGuide

Location.Poor staff.“There... – Posted May 15 2008

Mediocre

Location.Poor staff.“There were no newspapers daily, no air conditioning the first day and most of the second. The morning buffet was not free and... more on MYTravelGuide