Hotels
Flights
Cars
Deals
Vacations
Cruises
Trips
Home
»
United States
»
New York
»
Shelter Island
»
Hotels
»
Hotel
Shelter Island Guide
Shelter Island Hotels
Flights to Shelter Island
Select to narrow hotel list
Stars
Any
3-star hotels in Shelter Island
Amenities
Any
Shelter Island hotels with A/V equipment rental
Shelter Island hotels with ATM/Bank
Shelter Island hotels with Air-conditioned
Shelter Island hotels with Babysitting or child care
Shelter Island hotels with Bar/Lounge
Shelter Island hotels with Beach access
Shelter Island hotels with Bikes
Shelter Island hotels with Cable or satellite TV
Shelter Island hotels with Complimentary breakfast
Shelter Island hotels with In-room wireless internet
Shelter Island hotels with Kitchenette
Shelter Island hotels with Non-smoking room
Shelter Island hotels with Parking (free)
Shelter Island hotels with Restaurant
Shelter Island hotels with Room service
Shelter Island hotels with Smoke alarms
show more »
« show less
Property type
Any
Hotels in Shelter Island
Nearby Cities
Shelter Island Heights Hotels
(2 mi)
Greenport Hotels
(4 mi)
East Marion Hotels
(5 mi)
Southold Hotels
(6 mi)
Sag Harbor Hotels
(6 mi)
Orient Hotels
(6 mi)
Bridgehampton Hotels
(7 mi)
Peconic Hotels
(8 mi)
Shelter Island Hotels
Hotel
« Prev
—
Next »
2 Shelter Island Hotels
Sort:
Popularity
Price
Name
Stars
Distance
Azalea House
Get rates
Get rates
map
details
Moderate
1 Thomas Avenue Shelter Island, NY
see website
see rates
6317494252
Popularity ranking
#
1
of 2
Charming reasonably priced bed and breakfast in the center of shelter island. Private Bath master bedroom, several shared bath rooms, apartments and suites with kitchens also available.
Parking (free)
Complimentary breakfast
Recent reviews
3.0
/ 5 average rating
1 reviews
"pros: Inexpensive, fabulous l..."
Aug 21 2008
see photos
Sunset Beach
$241-$511
Get rates
Get rates
map
details
Moderate
35 Shore Road Shelter Island, NY
see website
see rates
+1 631 749 2001
Popularity ranking
#
2
of 2
Sunset Beach is nestled on the sands of Shelter Island with twenty exquisite rooms each with its own private sun deck with a bay view.
Air-conditioned
Non-smoking room
In-room wireless internet
ATM/Bank
Parking (free)
Recent reviews
1.5
/ 5 average rating
1 reviews
"hated 1. the big long black..."
Jul 14 2007
see photos
« Prev
1
Next »
close
Get hotel rates
Where
Check-in
Check-out
Guests
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Rooms
1
2
Shelter Island Hotel Search
Where
Check-in
MM/DD/YYYY
Check-out
MM/DD/YYYY
Guests
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Rooms
1
2
Get Rates
Get Rates
Shelter Island Hotels
Cheap flights to Shelter Island
Los Angeles (LAX)
$219
San Francisco (SFO)
$219
San Juan (SJU)
$256
San Diego (SAN)
$230
Fort Lauderdale (FLL)
$187
Seattle (SEA)
$239
London (LHR)
$440
Tel Aviv Yafo (TLV)
$639
Orlando (MCO)
$169
Oakland (OAK)
$216
Atlanta (ATL)
$192
Dallas/Fort Worth (DFW)
$184
Miami (MIA)
$169
Minneapolis (MSP)
$209
London (LON)
$440
Burbank (BUR)
$219
San Jose (SJC)
$219
Detroit (DTW)
$240
Santa Ana (SNA)
$233
Las Vegas (LAS)
$219