Bay Shore vacation rentals

KAYAK searches hundreds of travel sites at once for vacation home deals in Bay Shore

Here is why travelers choose KAYAK

Free to useThere are no hidden charges or fees.

Filter your dealsFilter by free cancellation, free breakfast and more.

Millions of reviewsCheck ratings based on millions of real guest reviews.

Recommended by KAYAK
Useful Info
Recommended by KAYAK

Best Bay Shore vacation rentals

Go to map

Search by review score

6+ Okay7+ Good8+ Great9+ Excellent

Search by price

$74 - $728$728 - $1,382$1,382 - $2,036$2,036 - $2,690$2,690+ per night

Property Types

ApartmentCottageHomestayHouse

Search by freebies

Free cancellationFree breakfastFree parkingFree internet

Most recommended vacation rentals in Bay Shore

Show all
Bay Shore Vacation Rental ~ 7 Mi to the Beach - Bay Shore - Living room
Bay Shore Vacation Rental ~ 7 Mi to the Beach
Bay Shore, NY
9.0Wonderful(5)
House
$300+
Check availability
1 bedroom 1 bath private entrance - Bay Shore - Bedroom
1 bedroom 1 bath private entrance
Bay Shore, NY
8.5Very good(18)
Apartment
$198+
Check availability
Bay Shore Condo Close to Outdoor Sports & Institutes! - Bay Shore - Building
Bay Shore Condo Close to Outdoor Sports & Institutes!
Bay Shore, NY
8.8Very good(15)
Apartment
Free Wi-Fi
$222+
Check availability
Luxury Bay Shore Home - Bay Shore - Kitchen
Luxury Bay Shore Home
Bay Shore, NY
House
$619+
Check availability
Beach Lover's Paradise - Kismet, Fire Island - Bay Shore - Living room
Beach Lover's Paradise - Kismet, Fire Island
Bay Shore, NY
9.5Wonderful(4)
House
$1,381+
Check availability
Fair Harbor, Fire Island, NY Magical Place- 700 feet to ocean or bay. Wonderful! - Bay Shore - Patio
Fair Harbor, Fire Island, NY Magical Place- 700 feet to ocean or bay. Wonderful!
Bay Shore, NY
10Wonderful(5)
House
$785+
Check availability
Fire Island Beach House - Bay Shore - Balcony
Fire Island Beach House
Bay Shore, NY
10Wonderful(7)
House
$998+
Check availability
Spacious 4-bedroom house with WiFi, fitness room in amazing Bay Shore - Bay Shore - Living room
Spacious 4-bedroom house with WiFi, fitness room in amazing Bay Shore
Bay Shore, NY
House
$753+
Check availability
Fire Island Beach House - Atlantique - Bay Shore - Balcony
Fire Island Beach House - Atlantique
Bay Shore, NY
9.8Wonderful(10)
House
Free Wi-Fi
$1,151+
Check availability
2br Private Apt, Pet Pal, Events, Ltr, Str, Cozy - Bay Shore - Living room
2br Private Apt, Pet Pal, Events, Ltr, Str, Cozy
Bay Shore, NY
9.8Wonderful(10)
Apartment
$185+
Check availability
South Shore Long Term Stays - Bay Shore - Kitchen
South Shore Long Term Stays
Bay Shore, NY
9.0Wonderful(2)
House
Free Wi-Fi
$205+
Check availability
Chalet-By-The-Sea - Bay Shore - Patio
Chalet-By-The-Sea
Bay Shore, NY
10Wonderful(1)
House
$1,308+
Check availability
The President Mansion Luxurious Family Retreat - 1.5 Miles to Beach - Bay Shore - Bedroom
The President Mansion Luxurious Family Retreat - 1.5 Miles to Beach
Bay Shore, NY
10Wonderful(13)
House
Free Wi-Fi
$3,045+
Check availability
Cozy Nesting - Bay Shore
Cozy Nesting
Bay Shore, NY
9.6Wonderful(1)
Homestay
Parking
Free Wi-Fi
$79+
Check availability
Bay Shore Vacation Rental with Shared Yard! - Bay Shore
Bay Shore Vacation Rental with Shared Yard!
Bay Shore, NY
9.9Wonderful(12)
Apartment
Free Wi-Fi
$477+
Check availability
The President Mansion Luxurious 7BR Family Retreat home - Bay Shore
The President Mansion Luxurious 7BR Family Retreat home
Bay Shore, NY
House
Parking
Free Wi-Fi
$2,709+
Check availability
Useful Info

Good to know

Low season

High season

Average price (weeknight)

Average price (weekend night)

August
October
$474
$512
Cheapest month to stay with an average 56% drop in price.
Most expensive month to stay with an average 144% rise in price.
Average Sun - Thu price over the last 2 weeks.
Average Fri & Sat price over the last 2 weeks.

KAYAK's top tips for finding Bay Shore vacation rental deals

  • If you’re looking for a cheap vacation rental in Bay Shore, you should consider visiting during the low season. The cheapest vacation homes in Bay Shore can be found in August and July.
  • The cheapest night for renting a vacation home in Bay Shore is Sunday. In contrast, the most expensive is Saturday.
  • Vacation rentals are a popular choice for both long and short-term stays. KAYAK users usually book their vacation rental in Bay Shore for 4 days.

FAQs when booking a vacation home in Bay Shore

  • What types of vacation rentals are available in Bay Shore?

    There are loads of different property types that you can make your vacation home in Bay Shore. You’ll find agritourism, apartments, caravans, houses and homestays.

  • How can I find vacation rentals near me in Bay Shore?

    Take a look at our vacation rentals map to find the best vacation rental homes near you.

Where to stay in Bay Shore?

Our map will help you find the perfect place to stay in Bay Shore by showing you the exact location of each vacation rental.

Everything you need to know for your stay in Bay Shore