Ruschmeyer's

161 Second House Road, Montauk, NY 11934, United States
+1 631 668 2877

Cheapest
rate per night

7.9

Good
based on 248 reviews
Ruschmeyer's - Montauk, NY
Check-in
-
Check-out
Compare vs. KAYAK |

Provider Nightly total
TripAdvisor $195
$273
TripAdvisor
TravelCLICK

Good to know

Distance to city center 0.4 mi
Location rating 9.2
Nearest Airport New York John F Kennedy Intl
Distance to airport 98.9 mi

Rooms

Check-in
Check-out

Standard Rooms

$195+

Photo
Bed Type
Provider
Nightly
IMAGE
Unknown
$195 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
$273 per night

Deluxe Rooms

$441+

Photo
Bed Type
Provider
Nightly
IMAGE
Unknown
$441 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
$441 per night

Reviews

Pros

Cons

Traveler rating

52
17
16
5
0

Time of year

Traveler type

Show reviews that mention

+
ant infestation in 3 reviews
bonus points in 3 reviews
breakfast was great in 26 reviews
comfee in 3 reviews
different areas in 6 reviews
great location in 15 reviews
great stay in 4 reviews
older traveler in 6 reviews
party goers in 3 reviews
room small in 26 reviews
staff were friendly in 42 reviews
  • Okay
    Sep 2019
    5.0

    530 dollars for one night, the room is like in a scout camp, loud music until 3:00 AM, very poor breakfast. The price is crazy to what you get.

    530 dollars for one night, the room is like in a scout camp, loud music until 3:00 AM, very poor breakfast. The price is crazy to what you get.

  • Good
    Sep 2019
    6.7

    Nice small rustic place like camping for grown-ups. Bike rental was included for the whole stay, just a short ride to the beach and some great restaurants. We got an upgrade to a bigger room.

    Way too expensive for what you get. Same breakfast every day, rustic place, pretty loud on weekends

  • Excellent
    Sep 2019
    10.0

    The property was beautiful,staff all so nice. The night life was amazing

  • Okay
    Aug 2019
    5.0

    Only good thing was the wifi connection, and staff was extremely polite!

    Well, the photos make it seem like it’s a very upscale and clean environment but it’s the absolute opposite. there’s two old ping pong tables alongside an EXTREMELY dirty and old pool table. the Pool table only had 6/10 pool balls. the table was dirty and uneven. There are Bean bag games but the bean bags are dirty and soggy. no use even playing outside games. The entire atmosphere is run-down. NEXT. the breakfast was horrible. fresh fruit was very nice but the eggs and toast were in-edible! They blast music until 10pm and do not care about guests being noisy all throughout the night. We got no sleep. Not worth 350$. End of rant.

  • Excellent
    Aug 2019
    10.0

    Beautiful hotel. Lots of activities and the staff was super friendly. The rooms were clean and they even let us check in early

No reviews found. Try removing a filter, changing your search, or clear all to view reviews.

About

Overview

Boutique with 19 cabin inspired guest rooms. Restaurant and Bar located on premise with outdoor lounge area overlooking Fort Pond. Amenities include free wifi, complimentary cold breakfast and free bicycle rentals available.

iHotelier/iStay

More

Features

Free parking
Free airport shuttle
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
Pet friendly
Spa

7.9 Good

based on 248 reviews

9.2

Location

8.8

Breakfast

4.0

Cleanliness

3.7

Comfort

Things to Know

  • Friendly service
  • Friendly atmosphere

Check in

4:00 PM

Check out

11:00 AM

Cancellation/prepayment

Policies vary by room type and provider.

Amenities

ATM on-site
Internet
Bicycle rental
Restaurant
Bar/Lounge
Air-conditioned
Night club
Free parking
Pool table
Free Wi-Fi
Pets allowed on request. Charges may apply.
Terrace/Patio
Hiking
24hr front desk

Photos

Ruschmeyer's - Montauk - Bedroom All Photos (22)
Ruschmeyer's - Montauk - Banquet hall Banquets (2)
Ruschmeyer's - Montauk - Bar Bar (3)
Ruschmeyer's - Montauk - Bedroom Bedroom (2)
Ruschmeyer's - Montauk - Living room Living room (2)

Location

Most Popular Landmarks

  • Montauk Downs State Park 1.4 mi
  • Ditch Plains Beach 2.3 mi
  • Lake Montauk 2.6 mi
  • Hither Hills State Park 3.3 mi
  • Deep Hollow Ranch 3.4 mi
  • Camp Hero State Park 4.8 mi

Getting Around

New Shoreham Block Island 21.8 mi
Tweed-New Haven 50.5 mi
Mystic 21.5 mi
New London 22.8 mi

Nearby hotels

Closest

7.5 Good (201 reviews)
0.36 mi
8.4 Excellent (137 reviews)
0.69 mi
8.2 Excellent (144 reviews)
0.71 mi
Best prices found by KAYAK users in the past 72 hours.

Cheapest

7.9 Good (33 reviews)
0.88 mi
8.7 Excellent (337 reviews)
0.94 mi
8.9 Excellent (1,902 reviews)
0.86 mi
Best prices found by KAYAK users in the past 72 hours.

Most recommended

9.6 Excellent (296 reviews)
0.88 mi
9.5 Excellent (205 reviews)
0.91 mi
9.2 Excellent (150 reviews)
0.82 mi
Best prices found by KAYAK users in the past 72 hours.