Sag Harbor Hotels near Old Whalers Church

20 of 75 hotels
Check-in
Check-out
Compare vs. KAYAK all | none
Sag Harbor - Exterior
Sag Harbor, NY
Aug 27 Aug 28 Change
STARS Show all
Price Show all
$79$875
Nearby Show all
Nearby
Filters Reset all
Hotel Name Show all
Amenities clear all
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
Ambience clear all
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
Price Type -- Should never be visible Show all
Property Type Show all
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
$274+
Check-in
Check-out
Get Rates
Excellent  (79 reviews)
31 W. Water Street, Sag Harbor
0.4 mi from Old Whalers Church
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Parking
Wi-Fi
Restaurant
Baron's Cove
$236+
Check-in
Check-out
Get Rates
Good  (23 reviews)
Air-conditioned
Internet
Parking
Wi-Fi
Forever Bungalows
$198+
Check-in
Check-out
Get Rates
Good  (58 reviews)
2668 Montauk Highway, Bridgehampton
4.1 mi from Old Whalers Church
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Parking
Wi-Fi
The Bridge Inn
$710+
Check-in
Check-out
Get Rates
Excellent  (29 reviews)
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Parking
Wi-Fi
Restaurant
Topping Rose House
$155+
Check-in
Check-out
Get Rates
Good  (153 reviews)
380 Montauk Highway, Wainscott
4.2 mi from Old Whalers Church
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Parking
Wi-Fi
380 Inn
$769+
Check-in
Check-out
Get Rates
Good  (17 reviews)
295 Three Mile Harbor Road, East Hampton
5.8 mi from Old Whalers Church
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Parking
Wi-Fi
East Hampton Point
 
Check-in
Check-out
Get Rates
Excellent  (5 reviews)
181 Main St
6.0 mi from Old Whalers Church
The Baker House 1650
$415+
Check-in
Check-out
Get Rates
Excellent  (34 reviews)
207 Main Street, East Hampton
6.0 mi from Old Whalers Church
Air-conditioned
Internet
Parking
Wi-Fi
Restaurant
c/o The Maidstone
$875+
Check-in
Check-out
Get Rates
Excellent  (5 reviews)
143 Main Street
6.1 mi from Old Whalers Church
The 1770 House
$290+
Check-in
Check-out
Get Rates
A Walk in the Woods Bed and Breakfast
$685+
Check-in
Check-out
Get Rates
Excellent  (69 reviews)
Air-conditioned
Internet
Parking
Wi-Fi
The Hedges Inn
$307+
Check-in
Check-out
Get Rates
no reviews
11 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island
6.2 mi from Old Whalers Church
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Parking
Wi-Fi
Restaurant
Shelter Island House
$280+
Check-in
Check-out
Get Rates
Seven - Shelter Island Guest House
$530+
Check-in
Check-out
Get Rates
Sunset Beach
$278+
Check-in
Check-out
Get Rates
Good  (161 reviews)
81 Shore Road, Shelter Island Heights
6.5 mi from Old Whalers Church
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Wi-Fi
Restaurant
The Pridwin Hotel
$240+
Check-in
Check-out
Get Rates
Excellent  (19 reviews)
3 Locust Ave., Shelter Island
6.5 mi from Old Whalers Church
Air-conditioned
Internet
Parking
Wi-Fi
House on Chase Creek
$249+
Check-in
Check-out
Get Rates
Excellent  (20 reviews)
23 Grand Ave, Shelter Island Heights
6.8 mi from Old Whalers Church
Air-conditioned
Internet
Parking
Wi-Fi
Restaurant
The Chequit Inn
$257+
Check-in
Check-out
Get Rates
Excellent  (93 reviews)
226 Pantigo Rd
6.9 mi from Old Whalers Church
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Parking
Wi-Fi
East Hampton House Resort
 
Check-in
Check-out
Get Rates
Excellent  (11 reviews)
26 Royal Street
7.0 mi from Old Whalers Church
Internet
Parking
Wi-Fi
Hamptons Brazil Guesthouse
$553+
Check-in
Check-out
Get Rates
Excellent  (5 reviews)
371 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill
7.3 mi from Old Whalers Church
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Parking
Wi-Fi
White Fences Inn
Prices are either the average per night price per room or first night of stay. You can select to display the prices with or without our estimate of taxes & fees (which may not appear on provider's booking page but will be charged at hotel checkout). Before you complete your reservation, verify the total cost on the provider's site. Prices and availability are not guaranteed.

Here's why:

We’re not the seller.
At KAYAK we don’t set the prices, so it’s not possible for us to guarantee what other companies are selling.

We compile tonnes of data for you
Our service lets you quickly and easily compare results from hundreds of travel sites at once. In this sense, KAYAK is a search engine and we can't guarantee prices we find.

Why aren’t prices accurate 100% of the time?
Prices on airline seats, hotel rooms and car rentals can change frequently. Several people may also be trying to buy the same travel option simultaneously. As a result, you may find, on occasion, that certain prices are no longer available.

If you have more questions or if you have a bad price to report to us,
please send us an email and someone from our team will get back to you promptly.

Wi-Fi quality and speed data © hotelwifitest.com
Change
Old Whalers Church