×
Your browser will soon be unsupported by KAYAK.
Update now and keep on traveling with us!

Shelter Island Bed & Breakfasts

8 of 33 hotels
Thu 12/8 Check in
Fri 12/9 Check out
Any stars
Any price range
Any guest rating
Traveling for:
Compare vs. KAYAK all | none
Stars Show all
Review Score Show all
Price Show all
Hotel Name Show all
Location reset
Any miles
from
Check-in
Check-out
Excellent breakfast
Nice rooms
Wi-Fi
Parking
Air-conditioned
Spa
Tennis
Bicycle rental
Details
Map
Arbor View House Bed & Breakfast Inn in East Marion is a Romantic North Fork, Long Island New York B&B near Greenport. We have been voted Best of the Best by Dans Papers for our breakfasts and our spa services. We have also won the TripAdv... Read more
Breakfast
10.0
Room
7.7
Wi-Fi
Parking
Air-conditioned
Spa

A Walk in the Woods Bed and Breakfast

  3
Excellent 8.9
Top Romantic Hotel
$296+
Check-in
Check-out
Terrific location
Perfectly clean
Great service
Wi-Fi
Parking
Air-conditioned
Bicycle rental
No smoking
Check-in
Check-out
Excellent breakfast
Wi-Fi
Parking
Air-conditioned
Bicycle rental
No smoking
Storage available
Details
Map
Located in Greenport, Stirling House Bed & Breakfast is on the waterfront and minutes from East End Seaport Maritime Museum and Railroad Museum of Long Island. This eco-friendly bed & breakfast is within close proximity of Kontokosta Winery... Read more
Breakfast
10.0
Wi-Fi
Parking
Air-conditioned
Bicycle rental

Seven - Shelter Island Guest House

  3
Excellent 9.6
Top Romantic Hotel
$176+
Check-in
Check-out
Very comfortable
Food is to die for
Excellent breakfast
Wi-Fi
Parking
Air-conditioned
Tennis
Bicycle rental
Business center
Details
Map
With a stay at SEVEN - Shelter Island Guest House in Shelter Island Heights, you'll be next to a golf course and minutes from Shelter Island Country Club, and close to Crescent Beach. This bed & breakfast is within close proximity of Shelte... Read more
Comfort
10.0
Food
10.0
Breakfast
9.9
Service
9.9
Wi-Fi
Parking
Air-conditioned
Tennis
Check-in
Check-out
Wonderful beach
Terrific location
Excellent amenities
Wi-Fi
Parking
Air-conditioned
Bicycle rental
No smoking
Storage available
Details
Map
Beach
10.0
Location
10.0
Amenities
10.0
Room
6.9
Wi-Fi
Parking
Air-conditioned
Bicycle rental

Fordham House

  2
no reviews
$262+
Check-in
Check-out
Wi-Fi
Parking
Details
Map
This historic home is located in Greenport Village, just minutes away from North Fork wineries, and all the best that the North Fork has to offer. Regardless of the season, the Fordham House's location offers countless ways to fulfill your... Read more
Wi-Fi
Parking
Check-in
Check-out
Details
Map
The Morning Glory is located in the historic whaling and seaport village of Greenport, New York, in the heart of Wine Country on the North Fork of Long Island. Originally built in 1822, this charming home has been meticulously restored to m... Read more
Check-in
Check-out
Excellent breakfast
Wi-Fi
Parking
Air-conditioned
Spa
Bicycle rental
Business center
Details
Map
The closer you get to Quintessentials Bed & Breakfast and Spa, the more serene and inviting the scenery becomes. Past the wineries and farm stands and nestled between the beaches of the Peconic Bay and the Long Island Sound, New York, you a... Read more
Breakfast
10.0
Wi-Fi
Parking
Air-conditioned
Spa
Shelter Island

Popular in Shelter Island

Neighborhoods in Shelter Island

Landmarks in Shelter Island

Accommodations

Close
Would you like to save as your currency permanently or for this visit only?
Close
    Close
    Find Hotel Deals