Search
Best rentals
When to book
Tips
FAQs
Map

New Buffalo vacation rentals

Thu 6/6
Fri 6/7

Search hundreds of travel sites at once for vacation home deals in New Buffalo

...and more

Let KAYAK do the searching

Save on your next stay

Search and compare hundreds of travel sites at once for vacation rentals in New Buffalo, Michigan

We’re completely free to use – no hidden charges or fees

Best New Buffalo vacation rentals

Most recommended vacation rentals in New Buffalo

Show all
Lake Michigan's Gem - New Buffalo - Balcony
Lake Michigan's Gem
8.1 Very good
$289+
$289+
Free Wi-Fi
Pet friendly
Anchors Away
8.5 Very good
$502+
$502+
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
Whispering Pines
8.6 Very good
$324+
$324+
Free Wi-Fi
Pet friendly
Spa
Surf's Up
9 Wonderful
$783+
$783+
Free Wi-Fi
Pet friendly

Good to know

Low season

February

High season

September

Average price (weeknight)

$442

Average price (weekend night)

$333
Cheapest month to stay with an average 40% drop in price.
Most expensive month to stay with an average 114% rise in price.
Average Sun - Thu price over the last 2 weeks.
Average Fri & Sat price over the last 2 weeks.

When to book a vacation rental in New Buffalo

Price per night / rental. Prices are not fixed and may vary with time.
Average nightly price per month
Average nightly price

Top tips for finding New Buffalo vacation rental deals

  • Vacation rentals in New Buffalo are around 67% more expensive than hotels on average. Search here to compare prices for all accommodation types in New Buffalo.
  • The best vacation rental properties in New Buffalo are 'Stones Throw' Lakeside Home - Walk to Marina + Town + Assoc Beach (10.0, 28 reviews), The White House - Brand New 5 Bedroom, With Hot Tub - Blocks From Everything!!!! (10.0, 30), and Charming & Cozy In-Town Retreat In The Heart Of New Buffalo (10.0, 51), based on ratings and reviews from real travelers.
  • If you’re looking for a cheap vacation rental in New Buffalo, you should consider visiting during the low season. The cheapest vacation homes in New Buffalo can be found in February and January.
  • The cheapest night for renting a vacation home in New Buffalo is Saturday. In contrast, the most expensive is Wednesday.
  • Book your New Buffalo vacation rental at least 65 days before your stay begins to get the best price.
  • Vacation rentals are a popular choice for both long and short-term stays. KAYAK users usually book their vacation rental in New Buffalo for 2 days.
  • The cheapest New Buffalo vacation rental found on KAYAK in the last 2 weeks was $73, while the most expensive was $102.

FAQs when booking a vacation home in New Buffalo

  • How much is a vacation rental for a week in New Buffalo?

    The average price for a weekly New Buffalo vacation rental found by KAYAK users in the last 2 weeks is $3,979.

  • How much is a vacation rental for a month in New Buffalo?

    The average price for a monthly New Buffalo vacation rental found by KAYAK users in the last 2 weeks is $17,055.

  • What types of vacation rentals are available in New Buffalo?

    There are loads of different property types that you can make your vacation home in New Buffalo. You’ll find agritourism, apartments, condos, cottages, houses, lodges and villas.

  • Are there any pet-friendly vacation rentals in New Buffalo?

    There are a number of dog and pet-friendly New Buffalo vacation rentals, with around 17% allowing you to bring your pet along with you.

  • How much is a vacation rental in New Buffalo?

    KAYAK users have found vacation rentals in New Buffalo for as cheap as $500 in the last 3 days. The average price is $568.

  • How much is a vacation rental in New Buffalo for tonight?

    In the last 72 hours, users have found New Buffalo vacation rentals for tonight for as low as $318. Search here for similar prices

  • How can I find vacation rentals near me in New Buffalo?

    Take a look at our vacation rentals map to find the best vacation rental homes near you.

Where to stay in New Buffalo?

Our map will help you find the perfect place to stay in New Buffalo by showing you the exact location of each vacation rental.