Shelter Island Hotels

(93)
 /  /  / Shelter Island
Shelter Island - Exterior
Check-inCheck-out
1 room 1 guest
Choose Sites to Compare vs. KAYAK all | none
Stars show all
  only
  only
  only
  only
Price show all
$75to$932
Hotel Name show all
Guest Rating show all
  only
  only
Amenities clear all
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
Ambiance clear all
  only
  only
Price Type -- Should never be visible show all
Property show all
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
ad
Check Rates
Save up to 60% on Shelter Island Hotels
Book now and get a 4 Star Hotel at 2 Star Prices with Hotwire Hot Rates
Hotwire.com
$325+
| Good - 22 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
With a stay at The Village Latch Inn Hotel in Southampton (Hamptons), you'll be minutes from Agawam Park. This inn is within the region of Old Whaler's Church and Osborn - Jackson House Museum. Make yourself at home in one of the 65 individually decorated guestrooms. Cable television is provided for your entertainment. Conveniences include wake-up calls, as...
Overall Rating - Good - 22 reviews
Hotel Building
Building is pleasant.
Service
100% found the staff to be very friendly.
The Village Latch Inn Hotel
$289+
no reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
The perfect waterfront choice for your Hamptons or Long Island Wine Country getaway. Breathtaking views and attention to detail make The Stirling House Bed & Breakfast Long Island's top-rated waterfront B&B. Walk to everything as Main Street is 2 minutes from the front steps. The inn is an 1880's era Victorian home that has been completely updated, with sta...
Overall Rating - Poor - 0 reviews
View
100% thought the view was good.
Nightlife
100% enjoyed the nightlife nearby.
Stirling House
$83+
| Good - 27 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
When you stay at The Bentley Southampton in Southampton (Hamptons), you'll be within the vicinity of Agawam Park. This hotel is within the region of Long Island Aquarium and Exhibition Center and Wolffer Estates Winery. Make yourself at home in one of the 39 air-conditioned rooms featuring kitchenettes. Rooms have private furnished balconies. Complimentary w...
Overall Rating - Good - 27 reviews
Room
Rooms are ok.
Hotel
Hotel is ok.
Poor 1.0
Oct 2 2013

Nobody answered the phone when I called to let them know I was coming over to check in. Nobody was there to receive me when I arrived to check in. Therefore, I was unable to check in.

Please read above. ... more
The Bentley Southampton
$449+
| Excellent - 5 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
With a stay at The Hedges Inn in East Hampton (Hamptons), you'll be convenient to Osborn - Jackson House Museum and East Hampton Windmill. This inn is within the vicinity of Pollack-Krasner House and Studio and Old Whaler's Church. Make yourself at home in one of the 12 air-conditioned rooms featuring LCD televisions. Complimentary wireless Internet access k...
Overall Rating - Excellent - 5 reviews
Grounds
Nice grounds.
Bathroom
88% were happy with the bathroom.
Also good to know about the hotel:
Good furniture
Great reception
The Hedges Inn
$384+
| Good - 16 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
With beautiful views of the sunsets over Long Island Sound, this Greenport resort features spacious grounds and a private beach. Free Wi-Fi is available in all areas. A private balcony provides a relaxing viewing point from each apartment of Cliffside Resort Condominiums – Greenport. A flat-screen TV, wine refrigerator and kitchenette are included. Guests...
Overall Rating - Good - 16 reviews
Room
Rooms are ok.
Hotel
Excellent hotel.
Cliffside Resort Condominiums - Greenport
$324+
| Excellent - 19 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Relax on the large wrap-around front porch of this bed and breakfast in Long Island, New York. Free Wi-Fi and daily continental breakfast are available. Cedar Beach is 1 mile away. Each uniquely styled room at A Walk in the Woods Bed and Breakfast features a fireplace and private bathroom. Decorated with antique accents, these rooms include a sitting area...
Overall Rating - Excellent - 19 reviews
Room
Rooms are outstanding.
Location
Terrific location.
A Walk in the Woods Bed and Breakfast
$83+
| Good - 150 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
When you stay at The Atlantic in Southampton (Hamptons), you'll be within the vicinity of Agawam Park. This hotel is within the region of Wolffer Estates Winery and Long Island Aquarium and Exhibition Center. Make yourself at home in one of the 62 air-conditioned rooms featuring refrigerators and flat-screen televisions. Your Select Comfort bed comes with co...
Overall Rating - Good - 150 reviews
Pool
Pool was lovely, according to 75%.
Reception
72% said the reception staff was great.
Okay 6.0
Oct 2 2013

Convenient for our immediate needs, spectators at Montauk Triathelon

... more
Good 7.0
Sep 26 2013

The room was spacious and clean.

Location wise it is well outside of Southampton. You can tell this by looking at a map. If you don't mind driving a few miles or getting a taxi then no worries.

This hotel was perfect for our trip into Long Island wine country. They are pet friendly which is nice to know and have well maintained grounds. The staff was present enough although we didn't really require much of them during our stay. ... more
The Atlantic
$138+
| Excellent - 33 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
With a stay at The Pridwin Hotel in Shelter Island Heights, you'll be near the bay and close to Shelter Island Country Club and Sylvester Manor. This beach hotel is within the vicinity of Mashomack Preserve and Horton Point Park. Make yourself at home in one of the 40 air-conditioned guestrooms. Complimentary wireless Internet access keeps you connected, and...
Overall Rating - Excellent - 33 reviews
Service
88% found the staff to be very friendly.
Pool
Pool was lovely, according to 85%.
Also good to know about the hotel:
Good beach sports
The Pridwin Hotel
$189+
no reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Overall Rating - Poor - 0 reviews
Heron Suites
$113+
| Good - 37 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Overall Rating - Good - 37 reviews
Service
95% found the staff to be very friendly.
Grounds
Beautiful grounds.
Excellent 10.0
Jan 17 2014

The Hamlet is a lovely little hideaway. The room was simple, spacious, comfortable and clean. Molly was a perfect hostess.

Great price for the room. I wish I could have stayed longer. ... more
Excellent 9.0
Oct 2 2013

The customer services was exceptional. I loved the area it's located, and the room itself. It was a quaint place.

The room is relatively small, but it was perfect for a weekend getaway with my spouse.

The Hotel was clean, neat, and well maintained. The area was beautiful, and although we did not use the pool it looked great. The room was small, but really quaint. The only complaint I had was with the cable, there wasn't a lot of channels, but it didn't affect us since we only went to the room to sleep. ... more
The Hampton Hamlet Inn
$196+
| Excellent - 45 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Overall Rating - Excellent - 45 reviews
Beds
83% said the beds were comfortable.
Hotel Cleanliness
100% thought it was clean.
Also good to know about the hotel:
Good kitchenette
Excellent 10.0
Jun 23 2013

The hotel was extremely clean and well maintained.Great attention paid to detail such as flower baskets everywhere and great product selection in the bthroom. The staff were efficient and very friendly.

Nothing

Perfect value hotel with nice rooms, TVs etc and well maintained grounds and pool. I would thoroughly recommend this hotel. ... more
The Blue Inn at North Fork
$98+
| Good - 82 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Located in Southampton (Hamptons), Southampton Long Island Hotel is convenient to Our Lady of Poland Catholic Church and Agawam Park. This hotel is within the vicinity of Halsey Homestead and Meschutt Beach. Make yourself at home in one of the air-conditioned rooms featuring refrigerators and microwaves. Complimentary wireless Internet access keeps you conne...
Overall Rating - Good - 82 reviews
Hotel Cleanliness
92% thought it was clean.
Sightseeing
80% liked the proximity to sightseeing.
Excellent 10.0
Jan 27 2014

The staff was friendly and extremely helpful. The room was warm and spotless upon arrival.

Terrific value, good location. ... more
Excellent 9.0
Oct 31 2013

Price and convenience.

It was perfect for my purposes, a reasonably priced, clean and safe room to stay in overnight. It is off season, so I can't say what it would be like during the summertime. ... more
Southampton Eqlipse Hotel
$114+
| Good - 42 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
The Enclave Inn Wainscott is located in the heart of the Hamptons . The property is only minutes away from the Atlantic Ocean, with five prime locations in Bridgehampton, Southampton and Wainscott . The hotel amenities includes business center, private wooded grounds with outdoor swimming pool, and continental breakfast . The room amenities includes pri...
Overall Rating - Good - 42 reviews
Price
Great price.
Room Cleanliness
75% said rooms were clean.
Also good to know about the hotel:
Best value for money
Excellent 9.0
Oct 4 2013

the unit had a nice kitchenette and had a queen and twin bed which was helpful for my trip's purposes as well as the price was reasonable relatively speaking for the area

the fridge door was not able to be closed or the fridge did not get cold

very good ... more
Good 7.0
Aug 17 2013

The owners are very kind & accommodating. There was a mix-up via Priceline's description and photo of the room, (we needed 2 beds, not one and a room, not a cabin), which the owners cheerfully resolved and refunded the difference. It's near the beach!

The motel is near the ever-busy Montauk Highway. Heavy traffic, but no noise at night.

The motel is simple, a bit bare bones in feel and plainly furnished. For our stay it was perfectly fine. The a/c and refrigerator worked fine. We didn't use the microwave, so I can't comment on it. The pillows were divine and the beds comfortable. At night we didn't hear noise from Montauk Highway which is a heavily traveled two lane road. Our family, adult and two teens, would neither walk nor bicycle anywhere because of the traffic and the tendency of drivers to abruptly drive on the shoulder to by-pass turning vehicles. The pool is rather small and just five feet at the deep end. It was clean and refreshin... ... more
380 Inn
$92+
| Okay - 672 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Conveniently located off Interstate 495, this Ramada Plaza Long Island MacArthur Airport hotel is near Lone Island Wine Country, Islip MacArthur Airport, Long Island Beaches, and corporations like Motorola and Northrup Grumman. After an exciting day, refresh at this smoke-free hotel with complimentary wireless Internet, on-site restaurant, fitness center, dr...
Overall Rating - Okay - 672 reviews
Value for money
Excellent value for money, said 100%.
Shopping
100% liked the proximity to shopping.
Also good to know about the hotel:
Close to public transport
Mediocre 3.0
Mar 3 2014

Nothing

They put a fifty ($50.00) hold on my card that has still NOT been refunded. Also I reserved a room with a king sized bed NOT two full sized beds.

Dirty. Spend an extra 50 and stay across the street. ... more
Poor 2.0
Feb 4 2014

The staff seemed to want to do better.

There are two entrances to the hotel. For those heading eastbound on the LIE it is okay and marked. Forget heading west bound. A disaster. Lobby is a disgrace. Rugs need cleaning. IF YOU REALLY WANT COMMENTS WHY NOT GIVE US ENOUGH ROOM TO WRITE THEM.

... more
Ramada Plaza Long Island MacArthur Airport
$318+
| Good - 23 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Overall Rating - Good - 23 reviews
Hotel
Hotel is ok.
Room
Rooms are ok.
Sunset Beach
«  Prev1234 … 7Next  »
Prices are either the average per night price per room or first night of stay. You can select to display the prices with or without our estimate of taxes & fees (which may not appear on provider's booking page but will be charged at hotel checkout). Before you complete your reservation, verify the total cost on the provider's site. Prices and availability are not guaranteed.

Here's why:

We’re not the seller
At KAYAK we don’t set prices, so it’s not possible for us to guarantee what other companies are selling.

We aggregate tons of data for you
Our service lets you quickly and easily compare results from hundreds of travel sites at once. In this sense, KAYAK is a search engine and we don't guarantee prices we find.

Why aren’t prices accurate 100% of the time?
Prices on airline seats, hotel rooms and car rentals can change frequently. Several people may also be trying to buy the same travel option simultaneously. As a result, you may find on occasion that certain prices are no longer available.

More questions or if you have a bad price to report to us
Please send us an email and someone from our team will get back to you promptly.

Loading map...

Compare Sites vs. KAYAK

Stars

©2014 KAYAK.com
Semantic analysis by TrustYou