Shelter Island Hotels

(94)
 /  /  / Shelter Island
Shelter Island - Exterior
Check-inCheck-out
1 room 1 guest
Choose Sites to Compare vs. KAYAK
Stars Show all
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
Price Show all
$75$932
Hotel Name Show all
Amenities clear all
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
Ambiance clear all
  only
  only
Price Type -- Should never be visible Show all
Property Show all
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
  only
$138+
| Good - 57 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Located in Shelter Island Heights, The Pridwin Hotel is near the bay, minutes from Shelter Island Tennis Club, and close to Crescent Beach. This hotel is within close proximity of Shelter Island Country Club and The Old Field Vineyards. Make yourself at home in one of the 40 air-conditioned guestrooms. Complimentary wireless Internet access keeps you connect...
Overall Rating - Good - 57 reviews
Location
Cleanliness
Rooms
Price
Service
Ambiance
The Pridwin Hotel
$189+
| no reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Overall Rating - Poor - 0 reviews
Heron Suites
$289+
| no reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
The perfect waterfront choice for your Hamptons or Long Island Wine Country getaway. Breathtaking views and attention to detail make The Stirling House Bed & Breakfast Long Island's top-rated waterfront B&B. Walk to everything as Main Street is 2 minutes from the front steps. The inn is an 1880's era Victorian home that has been completely updated, with sta...
Overall Rating - Poor - 0 reviews
The Stirling House B&B Greenport
$144+
| Good - 63 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Located on Long island, this Greenport hotel is 2 miles from Sandy Beach. Featuring a 1950’s retro décor, the rooms at The Greenporter Hotel are stylish but also have modern amenities like a flat-screen cable TV and a refrigerator. Guests can enjoy dining breakfast, lunch and dinner at the on-site Cuvee Seafood and Grille. A continental breakfast with bag...
Overall Rating - Good - 63 reviews
Location
Cleanliness
Rooms
Price
Service
Ambiance
The Greenporter Hotel
$196+
| Excellent - 88 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Overall Rating - Excellent - 88 reviews
Location
Cleanliness
Rooms
Price
Service
Ambiance
Okay 6.0
Aug 12 2014 Posted by Jo

We stayed over a weekend and we had a continental breakfast, which was just OK, but we could eat outside under a canopy and it was very relaxing.

Excellent 10.0
Jun 3 2014 Posted by Verified Hotel Guest

Immaculate and just renovated. Beat our expectations. Also- there is a restaurant/bar on premises for guests only- the chef cooked us our own personal lunch- one of the best meals I have ever had- not exaggerating. GREAT value for Long Island.

Very well run. Mary is organized, and responsive. She called me about a late arrival and offered good travel advice. Lovely staff. Have told our family to stop going where they go and come here instead.
The Blue Inn at North Fork
$125+
| no reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Overall Rating - Poor - 0 reviews
The Hermitage
$150+
| Excellent - 33 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Overall Rating - Excellent - 33 reviews
Location
Cleanliness
Rooms
Price
Service
Ambiance
Excellent 10.0
Jul 19 2014 Posted by Christine

Location was great and the private beach

No

Staff was nice fully stocked kitchen. Location was prefect and the beach was beautiful
Good 8.0
Jun 3 2014 Posted by Jane

The proximity to the private beach was wonderful and the upkeep of the inside and outside areas was a pleasant surprise.

From the road it doesn't look like much...but drive under the dated looking canopy and you will be pleasantly surprised. The private beach was clean and just beautiful.
Ocean Vista Resort
$113+
| Good - 99 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Overall Rating - Good - 99 reviews
Location
Cleanliness
Rooms
Price
Service
Ambiance
Excellent 9.0
Aug 15 2014 Posted by John

It was small and quiet. Very Clean and the staff was wonderful. It was easy to fine and located so that you could visit the Hamptons(all of them) easily. We were also near Sag Harbor.

Good 8.0
May 19 2014 Posted by Verified Hotel Guest

The staff were friendly

To far from town to walk to it

The Hampton Hamlet Inn
$114+
| Good - 75 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Overall Rating - Good - 75 reviews
Location
Cleanliness
Rooms
Price
Service
Ambiance
Excellent 10.0
Aug 6 2014 Posted by Anonymous

The owners were incredibly helpful and accommodating throughout my stay.

Excellent 9.0
Oct 4 2013 Posted by Elizabeth

the unit had a nice kitchenette and had a queen and twin bed which was helpful for my trip's purposes as well as the price was reasonable relatively speaking for the area

the fridge door was not able to be closed or the fridge did not get cold

very good
380 Inn
$263+
| no reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Arbor View House Bed & Breakfast Inn in East Marion is a Romantic Long Island New York B&B near Greenport. Voted “Best of the Best”, this romantic North Fork Wine Country B&B offers Deluxe Accommodations, award winning gourmet, SPA services (Massages, Facials, Baths, etc.) breakfasts , gas fireplaces, comfortable beds and fine linens and private baths with...
Overall Rating - Poor - 0 reviews
Arbor View House Bed And Breakfast
$165+
| Good - 15 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Overall Rating - Good - 15 reviews
Location
Cleanliness
Rooms
Price
Service
Ambiance
Southampton Inn
$108+
| no reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Overall Rating - Poor - 0 reviews
The Ocean Colony
$432+
| Okay - 40 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Located in Southampton (Hamptons), The Capri is convenient to Our Lady of Poland Catholic Church and Southampton Historical Museum. This hotel is within close proximity of Agawam Park and Southampton Cultural Center. Make yourself at home in one of the air-conditioned guestrooms. Complimentary wireless Internet access is available to keep you connected. Bath...
Overall Rating - Okay - 40 reviews
Location
Cleanliness
Rooms
Price
Service
Ambiance
The Capri
$249+
| Mediocre - 3 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
With a stay at The Inn at Baron's Cove in Sag Harbor (Hamptons), you'll be minutes from Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum and close to Bay Street Theatre. This inn is within close proximity of Sag Harbor Marine Park and Old Whaler's Church. Make yourself at home in one of the air-conditioned rooms featuring refrigerators and microwaves. Cable programm...
Overall Rating - Mediocre - 3 reviews
Poor 2.0
May 15 2013 Posted by Sue61
This place is a Poorly maintained condo. It is musty and unkept. Rotten decks and bathrooms that are repaired poorly. The toilet was constantly running. Nothing was up to code. Slider old and hard to move. Bathroom had no exhaust fAn and the bathroom window did not open.
Poor 2.0
May 15 2013 Posted by MePSP
This hotel is so very, very, very run down. There is rotting wood on the decks of the rooms, the rooms are not clean smelling and feeling damp,  bathroom had loose tiles around the tub and was dirty looking. If you planned to play tennis on those courts they show in the pictures on line, not possible, the courts are full of weeds. The pool had a green hugh on the bottom of it, the parking lot had holes all over the place....if we planned to stay more than one night I would have done everything I could to fine something elsewhere!!
The Inn at Baron's Cove
$318+
| Good - 27 reviews
Air-conditioned
Internet
Pool
Airport shuttle
Parking
Kitchenette
 
 
 
 
Overall Rating - Good - 27 reviews
Location
Cleanliness
Rooms
Price
Service
Ambiance
Sunset Beach
«  Prev1234 … 7Next  »
Prices are either the average per night price per room or first night of stay. You can select to display the prices with or without our estimate of taxes & fees (which may not appear on provider's booking page but will be charged at hotel checkout). Before you complete your reservation, verify the total cost on the provider's site. Prices and availability are not guaranteed.

Here's why:

We’re not the seller
At KAYAK we don’t set prices, so it’s not possible for us to guarantee what other companies are selling.

We aggregate tons of data for you
Our service lets you quickly and easily compare results from hundreds of travel sites at once. In this sense, KAYAK is a search engine and we don't guarantee prices we find.

Why aren’t prices accurate 100% of the time?
Prices on airline seats, hotel rooms and car rentals can change frequently. Several people may also be trying to buy the same travel option simultaneously. As a result, you may find on occasion that certain prices are no longer available.

More questions or if you have a bad price to report to us
Please send us an email and someone from our team will get back to you promptly.

Loading map...
©2014 KAYAK.com
Semantic analysis by TrustYou