Shelter Island Hotels

Search hundreds of travel sites at once for hotels in Shelter Island

Thu 10/19
Fri 10/20
Compare vs. KAYAK |

Good to know

Low Season
October
cheapest month to stay
33%
expected price decrease
High Season
November
most expensive time to stay
33%
expected price increase
Average price (weekend night):
$344
(price in the last 3 days)
Fri & Sat
(weekend night)

When to Book a Hotel in Shelter Island

Price per night / 3-star hotel. Prices are not fixed and may vary with time.
Average nightly price

Where to stay in Shelter Island?

Our Heatmaps tool will help you find the perfect place to stay in Shelter Island by showing you how close hotel options are to major activities

Best Shelter Island Hotels

FAQs when booking a Hotel in Shelter Island

How much is a cheap hotel in Shelter Island?
KAYAK users have found double rooms in Shelter Island for as cheap as $306 in the last 3 days. The average price is $201.
How can I find hotels near me?
Take a look at our extensive hotel Heatmaps to find the best hotels near you.