Kelleys Island vacation rentals

KAYAK searches hundreds of travel sites at once for vacation home deals in Kelleys Island

Here is why travelers choose KAYAK

Free to useThere are no hidden charges or fees.

Filter your dealsFilter by free cancellation, free breakfast and more.

Millions of reviewsCheck ratings based on millions of real guest reviews.

Recommended by KAYAK
Useful Info
Recommended by KAYAK

Best Kelleys Island vacation rentals

Most recommended vacation rentals in Kelleys Island

Show all
Iroquois Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort - Kelleys Island - Living room
Iroquois Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort
Kelleys Island, OH
Free Wi-Fi
$242+
Check availability
Cedar Cottage - Kelleys Island (Lake Erie) Vacation Retreat - Kelleys Island - Building
Cedar Cottage - Kelleys Island (Lake Erie) Vacation Retreat
Kelleys Island, OH
Free Wi-Fi
Pet friendly
$484+
Check availability
New Construction for 2023. Lake Home with Quarry Views. - Kelleys Island - Bedroom
New Construction for 2023. Lake Home with Quarry Views.
Kelleys Island, OH
$754+
Check availability
Cheeky Cherry Cottage - Kelleys Island - Balcony
Cheeky Cherry Cottage
Kelleys Island, OH
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
$286+
Check availability
New! Kelleys Island Condo - Kelleys Island - Balcony
New! Kelleys Island Condo
Kelleys Island, OH
9.0Wonderful(1)
Parking
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
$261+
Check availability
Brand new vacation home, built 2022! Great Location on Kelleys Island! - Kelleys Island - Living room
Brand new vacation home, built 2022! Great Location on Kelleys Island!
Kelleys Island, OH
Free Wi-Fi
$496+
Check availability
Kelleys Island Luxury Home On Secluded Private Road - Kelleys Island - Patio
Kelleys Island Luxury Home On Secluded Private Road
Kelleys Island, OH
$417+
Check availability
Screened in back porch is a haven! - Kelleys Island - Bedroom
Screened in back porch is a haven!
Kelleys Island, OH
9.6Wonderful(26)
Free Wi-Fi
$259+
Check availability
The Old Nest Vacation Waterfront Home - Kelleys Island - Living room
The Old Nest Vacation Waterfront Home
Kelleys Island, OH
$629+
Check availability
Kelleys Island Luxury Lake Shack - Kelleys Island - Kitchen
Kelleys Island Luxury Lake Shack
Kelleys Island, OH
$857+
Check availability
Superb 4,000 sq/ft Lake View - Kelleys Island - Balcony
Superb 4,000 sq/ft Lake View
Kelleys Island, OH
$827+
Check availability
Summer Wind Lake House - Kelley's Island, Oh - Kelleys Island - Living room
Summer Wind Lake House - Kelley's Island, Oh
Kelleys Island, OH
$1,186+
Check availability
Conti's Cottage-Lake Views - Kelleys Island - Living room
Conti's Cottage-Lake Views
Kelleys Island, OH
Free Wi-Fi
$475+
Check availability
Chalet, \'On the Rock\' Kelleys Island Ohio - Kelleys Island - Living room
Chalet, \'On the Rock\' Kelleys Island Ohio
Kelleys Island, OH
$328+
Check availability
Escape to our Kelleys Island cottage: where comfort meets tranquility. - Kelleys Island - Living room
Escape to our Kelleys Island cottage: where comfort meets tranquility.
Kelleys Island, OH
Free Wi-Fi
$934+
Check availability
'Our House' - 4 Bedroom - Perfect for families! - Kelleys Island
'Our House' - 4 Bedroom - Perfect for families!
Kelleys Island, OH
Free Wi-Fi
$342+
Check availability
Go to map

Search by review score

6+ Okay7+ Good8+ Great9+ Excellent

Search by price

$0 - $297$297 - $593$593 - $890$890 - $1,186$1,186+ per night

Property Types

ChaletCondoCottageHouse

Search by freebies

Free cancellationFree breakfastFree parkingFree internet
Useful Info

Good to know

Low season

October

High season

March

Average price (weeknight)

$409

Average price (weekend night)

$628
Cheapest month to stay with an average 49% drop in price.
Most expensive month to stay with an average 83% rise in price.
Average Sun - Thu price over the last 2 weeks.
Average Fri & Sat price over the last 2 weeks.

KAYAK's top tips for finding Kelleys Island vacation rental deals

  • Vacation rentals in Kelleys Island are around 11% cheaper than hotels on average. Search here to compare prices for all accommodation types in Kelleys Island.
  • The best vacation rental properties in Kelleys Island are Escape to our Kelleys Island cottage: where comfort meets tranquility. (10.0, 40 reviews), Brand new vacation home, built 2022! Great Location on Kelleys Island! (9.9, 23), and Quarry Vista Kelleys Island, 3 Bedroom, Golf Cart, Hot Tub (9.9, 27), based on ratings and reviews from real travelers.
  • Vacation rentals are a popular choice for both long and short-term stays. KAYAK users usually book their vacation rental in Kelleys Island for 2 days.

FAQs when booking a vacation home in Kelleys Island

  • What types of vacation rentals are available in Kelleys Island?

    There are loads of different property types that you can make your vacation home in Kelleys Island. You’ll find apartments, caravans, chalets, condos, cottages and houses.

  • Are there any pet-friendly vacation rentals in Kelleys Island?

    There are a number of dog and pet-friendly Kelleys Island vacation rentals, with around 11% allowing you to bring your pet along with you.

  • How much is a vacation rental in Kelleys Island for tonight?

    In the last 72 hours, users have found Kelleys Island vacation rentals for tonight for as low as $342. Search here for similar prices

  • How can I find vacation rentals near me in Kelleys Island?

    Take a look at our vacation rentals map to find the best vacation rental homes near you.

Where to stay in Kelleys Island?

Our map will help you find the perfect place to stay in Kelleys Island by showing you the exact location of each vacation rental.

Everything you need to know for your stay in Kelleys Island

Kelleys Island vacation rental deals. Search for vacation homes, apartments, condos, cabins, cottages, villas and more in Kelleys Island. Find cheap vacation homes to rent in Kelleys Island. KAYAK searches hundreds of travel sites to help you find and book a vacation rental in Kelleys Island that suits you best.

Not what you’re looking for? Find thousands of other hotels, airline tickets, car rentals and package deals with KAYAK.