Sanibel Cottage Rentals

KAYAK searches hundreds of travel sites at once for cottage deals in Sanibel

Here is why travelers choose KAYAK

Free to useThere are no hidden charges or fees.

Filter your dealsFilter by free cancellation, free breakfast and more.

Millions of reviewsCheck ratings based on millions of real guest reviews.

Recommended by KAYAK
Booking Insights
Recommended by KAYAK

Best Sanibel cottage rentals

Go to map

Search by review score

6+ Okay7+ Good8+ Great9+ Excellent

Search by price

$105 - $418$418 - $731$731 - $1,044$1,044 - $1,356$1,356+ per night

Search by freebies

Free breakfastFree parkingFree cancellationFree internetFree airport shuttle

Most recommended cottage rentals in Sanibel

Show all
Seahorse Cottages on Sanibel - Adults Only - Sanibel - Patio
Seahorse Cottages on Sanibel - Adults Only
Sanibel, FL
9.0Wonderful(260)
Cottage
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
$401+
Check availability
West End Paradise Unit Coral 4 - One bedroom efficiency suite - Sanibel - Bedroom
West End Paradise Unit Coral 4 - One bedroom efficiency suite
Sanibel, FL
8.9Very good(8)
Cottage
Free Wi-Fi
$340+
Check availability
Beachview Cottages - Sanibel - Bedroom
Beachview Cottages
Sanibel, FL
8.9Very good(52)
Cottage
Free Wi-Fi
$325+
Check availability
West End Paradise Sanddollar 7 - Quaint Hotel Style Room near the Beach - Sanibel - Pool
West End Paradise Sanddollar 7 - Quaint Hotel Style Room near the Beach
Sanibel, FL
7.4Good(7)
Cottage
Free Wi-Fi
$235+
Check availability
West End Paradise Unit Scallop 5 - One bedroom suite w/water views - Sanibel - Living room
West End Paradise Unit Scallop 5 - One bedroom suite w/water views
Sanibel, FL
8.5Very good(4)
Cottage
Free Wi-Fi
$356+
Check availability
West End Paradise Unit Seahorse 3 - two bedroom suite w/water views - Sanibel - Bathroom
West End Paradise Unit Seahorse 3 - two bedroom suite w/water views
Sanibel, FL
8.1Very good(6)
Cottage
Free Wi-Fi
$591+
Check availability
The Rosella-Great Value On Sanibel! Walk To Dining, Shops And The Lighthouse-On Historic East End! - Sanibel - Beach
The Rosella-Great Value On Sanibel! Walk To Dining, Shops And The Lighthouse-On Historic East End!
Sanibel, FL
9.0Wonderful(21)
Cottage
Free Wi-Fi
$382+
Check availability
Newly remodeled Parakeet cottage! Walking distance to beach, restaurants, shops! - Sanibel - Bedroom
Newly remodeled Parakeet cottage! Walking distance to beach, restaurants, shops!
Sanibel, FL
9.4Wonderful(38)
Cottage
Free Wi-Fi
$418+
Check availability
Sanibel-Style on the East End! Walk to restaurants and the lighthouse. NEW! - Sanibel - Beach
Sanibel-Style on the East End! Walk to restaurants and the lighthouse. NEW!
Sanibel, FL
9.5Wonderful(26)
Cottage
Free Wi-Fi
$435+
Check availability
Coastal Chic Cottage 'Sandpiper' minutes to the beach! Free bikes - Sanibel - Living room
Coastal Chic Cottage 'Sandpiper' minutes to the beach! Free bikes
Sanibel, FL
10Wonderful(3)
Cottage
Free Wi-Fi
$465+
Check availability
Gorgeous Newly Renovated Coastal Cottage 'Egret' Minutes To The Beach And Free Bikes!! July Savings! - Sanibel - Living room
Gorgeous Newly Renovated Coastal Cottage 'Egret' Minutes To The Beach And Free Bikes!! July Savings!
Sanibel, FL
9.2Wonderful(5)
Cottage
Free Wi-Fi
$434+
Check availability
Gorgeous Coastal Cottage 'Ibis' Minutes To The Beach And Free Bikes! July Savings - Sanibel - Patio
Gorgeous Coastal Cottage 'Ibis' Minutes To The Beach And Free Bikes! July Savings
Sanibel, FL
8.8Very good(9)
Cottage
Free Wi-Fi
$457+
Check availability
The Lovebird-Sleeps 3! Great Value On Sanibel-Walk To Dining, Shops And Historic East End Lighthouse - Sanibel - Building
The Lovebird-Sleeps 3! Great Value On Sanibel-Walk To Dining, Shops And Historic East End Lighthouse
Sanibel, FL
9.0Wonderful(27)
Cottage
Free Wi-Fi
$525+
Check availability
Near Beach! 2 Bedroom Cottage Sanibel Island - Sanibel - Beach
Near Beach! 2 Bedroom Cottage Sanibel Island
Sanibel, FL
9.0Wonderful(18)
Cottage
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
$320+
Check availability
Romantic Getaway, #302, 2 min walk to the beach. - Sanibel - Beach
Romantic Getaway, #302, 2 min walk to the beach.
Sanibel, FL
8.6Very good(9)
Cottage
Free Wi-Fi
$448+
Check availability
Newly remodeled Parrot Nest Toucan Cottage! Walk to beach, shops, restaurants! - Sanibel - Building
Newly remodeled Parrot Nest Toucan Cottage! Walk to beach, shops, restaurants!
Sanibel, FL
9.1Wonderful(29)
Cottage
Free Wi-Fi
$412+
Check availability
Booking Insights

KAYAK’s Insights for cottages in Sanibel

Discover seasonal trends, ideal booking windows, and other data-driven tips to plan your stay in Sanibel with confidence.

Which month has the cheapest cottage rates in Sanibel?

Cottages are cheapest in Sanibel in August, with average rates of $167/night. In comparison, February is the most expensive month, with prices at $498/night.

What is the cheapest day of the week to book a cottage in Sanibel?

Tuesday offers the lowest rates in Sanibel, with an average nightly price of $234/night. The highest prices are found on Sunday, with average rates at $513/night.

How early should you book a cottage in Sanibel?

Book at least 31 days before your stay begins to get the best price for your Sanibel cottage.

Find deals

Good to know

Low season

High season

Average price (weeknight)

Average price (weekend night)

August
February
$342
$391
Cheapest month to stay with an average 44% drop in price.
Most expensive month to stay with an average 66% rise in price.
Average Sun - Thu price over the last 2 weeks.
Average Fri & Sat price over the last 2 weeks.

KAYAK's top tips for finding Sanibel vacation rental deals

  • For the cheapest cottage rental in Sanibel, try to visit during the low season and outside of main travel peaks. The cheapest rates can be found in August and October.
  • The cheapest night of the week to rent a cottage in Sanibel is Tuesday. On the other hand, the most expensive is Sunday.

FAQs when Booking a cottage in Sanibel

Where to stay in Sanibel?

Our map will help you find the perfect place to stay in Sanibel by showing you the exact location of each vacation rental.

Everything you need to know for your stay in Sanibel