Fire Island Pines vacation rentals

KAYAK searches hundreds of travel sites at once for vacation home deals in Fire Island Pines

Here is why travelers choose KAYAK

Free to useThere are no hidden charges or fees.

Filter your dealsFilter by free cancellation, free breakfast and more.

Millions of reviewsCheck ratings based on millions of real guest reviews.

Recommended by KAYAK
Useful Info
Recommended by KAYAK

Best Fire Island Pines vacation rentals

Most recommended vacation rentals in Fire Island Pines

Show all
Family Beach House 1 Block From The Beach! - Fire Island Pines - Living room
Family Beach House 1 Block From The Beach!
Fire Island Pines, NY
Free Wi-Fi
$1,240+
Check availability
The Great Escape at a Great Location! - Fire Island Pines - Patio
The Great Escape at a Great Location!
Fire Island Pines, NY
Free Wi-Fi
$1,279+
Check availability
Gorgeous Bay Front Home with Water Views and Stunning Sunsets - Fire Island Pines - Balcony
Gorgeous Bay Front Home with Water Views and Stunning Sunsets
Fire Island Pines, NY
Free Wi-Fi
Pet friendly
Spa
$2,637+
Check availability
Affordable Ocean Beach, Fire Island Studio Sleeps 2 Max, Wifi, 31\' Smart Roku Tv - Fire Island Pines - Patio
Affordable Ocean Beach, Fire Island Studio Sleeps 2 Max, Wifi, 31\' Smart Roku Tv
Fire Island Pines, NY
Free Wi-Fi
Pet friendly
$652+
Check availability
3BR/2.5bath Ocean View Home in Fire Island Pines with heated pool - Fire Island Pines - Living room
3BR/2.5bath Ocean View Home in Fire Island Pines with heated pool
Fire Island Pines, NY
Pool
$1,497+
Check availability
Oceanfront Home In Ocean Bay Park With Pool - Fire Island Pines - Pool
Oceanfront Home In Ocean Bay Park With Pool
Fire Island Pines, NY
$3,325+
Check availability
Private 3BR 3BA Fire Island Cottage w/pool 4 min to harborl - Fire Island Pines - Pool
Private 3BR 3BA Fire Island Cottage w/pool 4 min to harborl
Fire Island Pines, NY
Free Wi-Fi
$875+
Check availability
3rd house from the ocean, great ocean breeze and views, quietest block in OBP - Fire Island Pines - Beach
3rd house from the ocean, great ocean breeze and views, quietest block in OBP
Fire Island Pines, NY
Free Wi-Fi
Pet friendly
$1,697+
Check availability
Stay on the beach in a 5 bedroom Ocean Front home sleeps 12 Ocean Bay Park - Fire Island Pines - Bedroom
Stay on the beach in a 5 bedroom Ocean Front home sleeps 12 Ocean Bay Park
Fire Island Pines, NY
Free Wi-Fi
$1,391+
Check availability
Seaview: Clean, Quiet, & Convenient. Close To Beach, Bay, Market, And Oceanbeach - Fire Island Pines - Living room
Seaview: Clean, Quiet, & Convenient. Close To Beach, Bay, Market, And Oceanbeach
Fire Island Pines, NY
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
$1,189+
Check availability
The Pines Men-Only Stay - Fire Island Pines
The Pines Men-Only Stay
Fire Island Pines, NY
9.1Wonderful(15)
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
Pet friendly
$374+
Check availability
Sweet Summer in a Traditional Fire Island Home - Fire Island Pines
Sweet Summer in a Traditional Fire Island Home
Fire Island Pines, NY
Pet friendly
$736+
Check availability
Lovefins - Fire Island Pines
Lovefins
Fire Island Pines, NY
Pet friendly
$241+
Check availability
Sea Capt's Cottage, Steps to ocean - Fire Island Pines
Sea Capt's Cottage, Steps to ocean
Fire Island Pines, NY
Pet friendly
$396+
Check availability
Charming 4 bedroom Beach House on Fire Island - Fire Island Pines
Charming 4 bedroom Beach House on Fire Island
Fire Island Pines, NY
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
Pet friendly
$1,192+
Check availability
Kismet Beach House 4 Bedrooms - Fire Island Pines
Kismet Beach House 4 Bedrooms
Fire Island Pines, NY
Pet friendly
$986+
Check availability
Go to map

Search by review score

6+ Okay7+ Good8+ Great9+ Excellent

Search by price

$0 - $832$832 - $1,663$1,663 - $2,494$2,494 - $3,325$3,325+ per night

Property Types

ApartmentCottageHomestayHouse

Search by freebies

Free cancellationFree breakfastFree parkingFree internet
Useful Info

Good to know

Low season

March

High season

June

Average price (weeknight)

$363

Average price (weekend night)

$1,264
Cheapest month to stay with an average 58% drop in price.
Most expensive month to stay with an average 14% rise in price.
Average Sun - Thu price over the last 2 weeks.
Average Fri & Sat price over the last 2 weeks.

KAYAK's top tips for finding Fire Island Pines vacation rental deals

  • Vacation rentals are a popular choice for both long and short-term stays. KAYAK users usually book their vacation rental in Fire Island Pines for 3 days.

FAQs when booking a vacation home in Fire Island Pines

  • What types of vacation rentals are available in Fire Island Pines?

    There are loads of different property types that you can make your vacation home in Fire Island Pines. You’ll find apartments, cottages, houses, homestays and luxury tents.

  • Are there any pet-friendly vacation rentals in Fire Island Pines?

    There are a number of dog and pet-friendly Fire Island Pines vacation rentals, with around 41% allowing you to bring your pet along with you.

  • How can I find vacation rentals near me in Fire Island Pines?

    Take a look at our vacation rentals map to find the best vacation rental homes near you.

Where to stay in Fire Island Pines?

Our map will help you find the perfect place to stay in Fire Island Pines by showing you the exact location of each vacation rental.

Everything you need to know for your stay in Fire Island Pines

Fire Island Pines vacation rental deals. Search for vacation homes, apartments, condos, cabins, cottages, villas and more in Fire Island Pines. Find cheap vacation homes to rent in Fire Island Pines. KAYAK searches hundreds of travel sites to help you find and book a vacation rental in Fire Island Pines that suits you best.

Not what you’re looking for? Find thousands of other hotels, flights, car rentals and package deals with KAYAK.