My girlfriend and I adored our trip to Castara and our stay at Sealevel Guesthouse. The highlights for me included the close proximity to the beach (a ninety second walk) and the staff, specifically Josh, with whom we mainly dealt. He was informative and friendly, and checked on us enough to know he cared about us enjoying our stay, but not enough to annoy. The only things I could suggest were a few minor repairs that I brought to his attention just before checkout, but to think that a loose shower curtain rod could be enough to ruin someone's vacation is ridiculous. Also worth noting is that all the locals we met were very friendly and personable. I absolutely loved it and I will be back the next time I come to Castara.
There were a few small, minor repairs that needed to happen before I got there to make it perfect, but they were extremely minor. Our shower curtain rod was loose, for example, and that was the worst one. I will say that this place is best suited for people who are spending much of their time at the beach and don't care about having things like a TV, because we didn't have one. There is wifi, though, so you can watch Netflix or YouTube or something, but no TV.
