Overview
Back to all Edinburgh hotels

Elder York Guest House
Top City Hotel

38 Elder Street, Edinburgh, EH1 3DX, United Kingdom
+44 131 556 1926

$75+

Check in
Check out
1 room, 2 guests
Rates
Elder York Guest House - Edinburgh - Dining room Provided by Hotel Website

Overall guest ratings

8.6/10 Excellent
Based on 1,222 reviews
See all reviews

Review highlights

  • 9.7
  • 9.5
  • 9.5
  • 4.6

Good to know

  • Friendly service
  • Good management

Nearby

    Show all

    Amenities

    • No smoking
    • Storage available
    • Free Wi-Fi
    Less More
    Map

    Map

    Photos
    Reviews

    Guest reviews

    • All Reviews
    • Couples
    • Families
    • Business
    • Solo

    Overall Rating

    8.5 Excellent
    Based on 1,200 reviews
    • 9.7 "Excellent breakfast."
    • 9.5 "World class service."
    • 9.5 "Food is to die for."
    • 9.1 "Terrific location."
    • 8.8 "Very good internet connection."
    • 4.6 "Vibe wasn't good."
    • 4.3 "Not very comfortable."
    • 2.7 "Terrible amenities."
    View all review categories

    Overall Rating

    8.4 Excellent
    Based on 804 reviews
    • 9.7 "Food is to die for."
    • 9.6 "Excellent breakfast."
    • 9.4 "World class service."
      9.6 "96% found the staff to be very friendly."
      10.0 "Management was excellent, said 100%."
      7.5 "75% said the reception staff was great."
      10.0 "100% thought the service was very professional."
    • 9.0 "Terrific location."
      10.0 "Near to public transport, according to 100%."
      7.7 "77% liked the proximity to sightseeing."
      10.0 "City centre within easy reach, said 100%."
      10.0 "100% liked the proximity to shopping."
      10.0 "100% thought it was easy to get to the train station."
    • 8.6 "Very good internet connection."
      8.8 "88% said the wifi quality was great."
    • 6.3 "Average value."
    • 4.9 "Rooms are not good."
      2.1 "79% said rooms were small."
      2.5 "75% complained about the bathroom."
      1.2 "88% criticized the small bathroom."
      3.6 "64% had problems with the shower."
      1.3 "For 87%, the rooms looked old."
      1.0 "90% thought the tv was sub-standard."
      3.0 "70% said the bathroom was dirty."
    • 4.5 "Vibe wasn't good."
      1.6 "84% criticized the unstylish hotel."
    • 3.5 "Not very comfortable."
      2.1 "79% said rooms were small."
      4.3 "57% thought it was too noisy."
      1.2 "88% criticized the small bathroom."
    • 2.7 "Terrible amenities."
      2.7 "73% thought the building wasn't nice."
      0.0 "100% complained about the elevator."
    View all review categories

    Overall Rating

    8.4 Excellent
    Based on 168 reviews
    • 9.7 "Excellent breakfast."
    • 9.5 "World class service."
      9.8 "98% found the staff to be very friendly."
      10.0 "Management was excellent, said 100%."
      7.6 "76% said the reception staff was great."
    • 9.4 "Food is to die for."
    • 9.2 "Terrific location."
    • 5.2 "Rooms are ok."
      5.9 "Beds were acceptable for 59%."
    • 4.2 "Not very comfortable."
      4.5 "55% thought it was too noisy."
      2.1 "79% said rooms were small."
    • 4.1 "Vibe wasn't good."
      2.0 "80% criticized the unstylish hotel."
    • 2.3 "Terrible amenities."
      2.3 "77% thought the building wasn't nice."
      0.0 "100% complained about the elevator."
    View all review categories

    Overall Rating

    8.9 Excellent
    Based on 228 reviews
    • 9.6 "Excellent breakfast."
    • 9.6 "World class service."
      9.9 "99% found the staff to be very friendly."
      10.0 "Management was excellent, said 100%."
      7.7 "77% said the reception staff was great."
    • 9.6 "Terrific location."
      10.0 "100% thought it was easy to get to the train station."
      10.0 "City centre within easy reach, said 100%."
      10.0 "Near to public transport, according to 100%."
    • 6.8 "Rooms are ok."
      6.7 "Beds were acceptable for 67%."
    • 4.9 "Vibe wasn't good."
    • 3.0 "Terrible amenities."
      3.0 "70% thought the building wasn't nice."
      0.0 "100% complained about the elevator."
    Hotel type
    City Hotel
    Guests say it is the perfect hotel for a city trip.
    Good to know
    "Friendly service"
    "Good management"
    data provided by TrustYou

    Recent Reviews

    • All reviews
    • Positive
    • Neutral
    • Negative
    Close
    Close
    Would you like to save as your currency permanently or for this visit only?
    Close