Overview

Elder York Guest House
Top City Hotel

38 Elder Street, Edinburgh, EH1 3DX, United Kingdom
+44 131 556 1926

$75+

Check in
Check out
Rates

Overall guest ratings

8.6/10 Excellent
Based on 1,222 reviews
See all reviews

Review highlights

  • 9.7
  • 9.5
  • 9.5
  • 4.6

Good to know

  • Friendly service
  • Good management

Nearby

    Show all

    Amenities

    • No smoking
    • Storage available
    • Free Wi-Fi
    Less More
    Map

    Map

    Photos
    Reviews

    Guest reviews

    Overall Rating

    8.5 Excellent
    Based on 1,200 reviews
    • 9.7 "Excellent breakfast."
    • 9.5 "World class service."
    • 9.5 "Food is to die for."
    • 9.1 "Terrific location."
    • 8.8 "Very good internet connection."
    • 4.6 "Vibe wasn't good."
    • 4.3 "Not very comfortable."
    • 2.7 "Terrible amenities."
    View all review categories

    Overall Rating

    8.4 Excellent
    Based on 804 reviews
    • 9.7 "Food is to die for."
    • 9.6 "Excellent breakfast."
    • 9.4 "World class service."
      9.6 "96% found the staff to be very friendly."
      10.0 "Management was excellent, said 100%."
      7.5 "75% said the reception staff was great."
      10.0 "100% thought the service was very professional."
    • 9.0 "Terrific location."
      10.0 "Near to public transport, according to 100%."
      7.7 "77% liked the proximity to sightseeing."
      10.0 "City centre within easy reach, said 100%."
      10.0 "100% liked the proximity to shopping."
      10.0 "100% thought it was easy to get to the train station."
    • 8.6 "Very good internet connection."
      8.8 "88% said the wifi quality was great."
    • 6.3 "Average value."
    • 4.9 "Rooms are not good."
      2.1 "79% said rooms were small."
      2.5 "75% complained about the bathroom."
      1.2 "88% criticized the small bathroom."
      3.6 "64% had problems with the shower."
      1.3 "For 87%, the rooms looked old."
      1.0 "90% thought the tv was sub-standard."
      3.0 "70% said the bathroom was dirty."
    • 4.5 "Vibe wasn't good."
      1.6 "84% criticized the unstylish hotel."
    • 3.5 "Not very comfortable."
      2.1 "79% said rooms were small."
      4.3 "57% thought it was too noisy."
      1.2 "88% criticized the small bathroom."
    • 2.7 "Terrible amenities."
      2.7 "73% thought the building wasn't nice."
      0.0 "100% complained about the elevator."
    View all review categories

    Overall Rating

    8.4 Excellent
    Based on 168 reviews
    • 9.7 "Excellent breakfast."
    • 9.5 "World class service."
      9.8 "98% found the staff to be very friendly."
      10.0 "Management was excellent, said 100%."
      7.6 "76% said the reception staff was great."
    • 9.4 "Food is to die for."
    • 9.2 "Terrific location."
    • 5.2 "Rooms are ok."
      5.9 "Beds were acceptable for 59%."
    • 4.2 "Not very comfortable."
      4.5 "55% thought it was too noisy."
      2.1 "79% said rooms were small."
    • 4.1 "Vibe wasn't good."
      2.0 "80% criticized the unstylish hotel."
    • 2.3 "Terrible amenities."
      2.3 "77% thought the building wasn't nice."
      0.0 "100% complained about the elevator."
    View all review categories

    Overall Rating

    8.9 Excellent
    Based on 228 reviews
    • 9.6 "Excellent breakfast."
    • 9.6 "World class service."
      9.9 "99% found the staff to be very friendly."
      10.0 "Management was excellent, said 100%."
      7.7 "77% said the reception staff was great."
    • 9.6 "Terrific location."
      10.0 "100% thought it was easy to get to the train station."
      10.0 "City centre within easy reach, said 100%."
      10.0 "Near to public transport, according to 100%."
    • 6.8 "Rooms are ok."
      6.7 "Beds were acceptable for 67%."
    • 4.9 "Vibe wasn't good."
    • 3.0 "Terrible amenities."
      3.0 "70% thought the building wasn't nice."
      0.0 "100% complained about the elevator."
    Hotel type
    City Hotel
    Guests say it is the perfect hotel for a city trip.
    Good to know
    "Friendly service"
    "Good management"
    data provided by TrustYou

    Recent Reviews


    Close
    Would you like to save as your currency permanently or for this visit only?
    Close