Great hotel. But it took three attempts to try and get the shower in my bathroom repaired.
4 stars
The Garden City Hotel
Photos of The Garden City Hotel
Overview
Garden City Hotel offers 4-star accommodation, plus an indoor pool, free bicycle rental and free Wi-Fi. It also features a 24-hour reception, valet parking and babysitting/child services.
Garden City Hotel has recently undergone refurbishment and offers a currency exchange, laundry facilities and a concierge. In sunny weather, an outdoor terrace provides an ideal spot to relax.
Rooms at the hotel feature a flat-screen television, a refrigerator and a radio. They are also equipped with a hair dryer, cable/satellite channels and a telephone.
During their stay at Garden City Hotel, guests can enjoy a meal at Red Salt Room and relax with a drink at Patio Bar. Packed lunches are provided for sightseers.
John F. Kennedy International Airport is a 25-minute drive from Garden City Hotel. It also is a convenient base to explore nearby New York City and Hempstead.
Latest deals for The Garden City Hotel
*Total includes estimated local taxes & fees payable on check out.
Prices are based on 1 night, not including taxes and fees
Amenities at The Garden City Hotel
- Indoor pool
- Fitness center
- Restaurant
- Bar/Lounge
- Room service
- Free Wi-Fi
- Coffee machine
- Valet parking
- Free parking
- Business center
Services and conveniences
- Conference rooms
- ATM on-site
- Business center
- Concierge service
- Safety deposit box
- Currency exchange on-site
- Meeting/Banquet facilities
- Room service
- Express check-out
- Private check-in/check-out
- 24hr front desk
Dining
- Grocery deliveries
- Packed lunches
- Special diet menus (on request)
- Restaurant
- Bar/Lounge
- Breakfast in the room
- Refrigerator
- Food can be delivered to guest accommodation
- Coffee machine
Basics
- Free Wi-Fi
- Internet
- Fire extinguisher
- Free toiletries
- Smoke alarms
- Heating
- Adapter
- Air-conditioned
Accessibility and suitability
- Pets allowed on request. Charges may apply.
- Increased accessibility
- Elevator
- Hypoallergenic
- Allergy-free room
- No smoking
- Designated smoking area
Things to do
- Gift shop
- Beach access
- Bicycle rental
- Fishing
- Golf
- Horse riding
Laundry
- Laundry facilities
- Ironing service
- Laundry service
- Iron and ironing board
- Pants press
General
- Family rooms
- Soundproof rooms
- Telephone
- Storage available
Media and entertainment
- Radio
- Flat-screen TV
- Cable or satellite TV
Bathroom
- Hairdryer
- Bathrobe
- Private bathroom
Bedroom
- Fold-up bed
- Alarm clock
- Wardrobe or closet
Family friendly
- Babysitting or child care
- Cribs available
- Kids meals
Parking and transportation
- Free parking
- Valet parking
Outdoor
- Terrace/Patio
- Garden
Workspace
- Fax/photocopying
- Desk
Health and safety
- Daily housekeeping
- Safe
Fitness
- Fitness center
Pool
- Indoor pool
Reviews of The Garden City Hotel
8.8
Very good
437 verified ratings
Wonderful
275
Very good
49
Good
47
Okay
20
Fair
18
Mediocre
7
Poor
21
Summary of reviews
Guests say
Guests appreciated the excellent location of the hotel, with many mentioning its proximity to various amenities and attractions. However, there were significant concerns regarding the service, with reports of rude staff and understaffing issues. Cleanliness was also a recurring theme, with several guests noting that their rooms were not cleaned properly during their stay. Overall, while the location is a highlight, improvements in service and cleanliness are needed.AI-Generated from customer reviews
Reviews(3)
Q&A(5)
Tips(10)
Sort by:Most recent
Score by provider
8.9 out of 10
339 reviews
8.2 out of 10
25 reviews
9.2 out of 10
13 reviews
8.5 out of 10
3 reviews
All reviews
The location is centrally located on Long Island which means it’s near to many of the area’s amenities and features places of interest. The hotel rooms are in need of updating; in particular the furniture and bathrooms.
Pros (+) In a really nice area, absolutely wonderful staff (best I've seen in a long time), comfortable large rooms, 24hr room service, on-site spa, indoor pool, close to cafes and restaurants.
Cons (-) Wish there were a sauna or steam-room.
The questions and answers provided in this section are generated by an artificial intelligence model based on a summarization of user hotel reviews and hotel information.See more
They offer insights and recommendations from previous guests and hotel information to help future visitors enhance their stay at the hotel.
What can I expect from the hotel's dining options?
You can enjoy a meal at Red Salt Room and relax with a drink at Patio Bar. Packed lunches are also provided for sightseers.
Are there any concerns about the cleanliness of the hotel?
Some guests mentioned issues with cleanliness, such as finding gum stuck to the sheets and unsanitary conditions in the room. However, others praised the hotel's cleanliness and the exceptionally clean rooms.
What are the hotel's unique amenities?
The hotel offers an indoor pool, free bicycle rental, and a spa. Additionally, there are outdoor terrace spaces for relaxation and a speakeasy for a unique evening experience.
Is the hotel staff friendly and helpful?
Many guests praised the staff for being incredibly friendly and helpful. However, a few mentioned instances of rudeness at the front desk.
What are the best times to visit the hotel?
The high season is in August, while the low season is in October. It's important to consider these factors when planning your visit.
The questions and answers provided in this section are generated by an artificial intelligence model based on a summarization of user hotel reviews and hotel information.See more
They offer insights and recommendations from previous guests and hotel information to help future visitors enhance their stay at the hotel.
Book a Room with a View
Several guests mentioned that the views from the rooms were spectacular. Opting for a room with a balcony facing the fountain comes highly recommended.
Take Advantage of Nearby Attractions
The hotel's proximity to attractions like Cathedral Of The Incarnation, Sunflower Fine Art, and Garden City Golf Club makes it convenient for guests to explore the area.
Consider Transportation Options
Guests highlighted the convenience of the hotel's location near the Long Island Railroad train station, providing easy access to New York City. It's worth considering this transportation option for city visits.
Check for Renovated Rooms
Some guests praised the renovated rooms for their cleanliness and modern amenities. Requesting a renovated room could enhance the overall stay experience.
Be Mindful of Noise Levels
A few guests mentioned noise disturbances from events like weddings. Light sleepers may want to inquire about potential noise disruptions during their stay.
Plan Spa Appointments in Advance
Guests recommended booking spa appointments ahead of time due to limited availability for walk-in services.
Be Aware of Additional Fees
Some guests were surprised by the high resort fee, while others noted unexpected charges like a deposit at check-in. It's advisable to clarify and understand all potential additional fees beforehand.
Consider Room Selection for Accessibility
Guests with mobility concerns suggested confirming the availability of rooms with specific accessibility features, such as walk-in showers, to ensure a comfortable stay.
Explore Dining Options
The hotel's restaurant, Red Salt Room, received positive feedback for its food and atmosphere. Guests may want to plan a meal at the restaurant or visit the Patio Bar for a relaxing experience.
Utilize Nearby Transportation
The hotel's proximity to John F. Kennedy International Airport and its convenient base for exploring New York City and Hempstead make it a strategic choice for travelers.
Location
45 Seventh Street, Garden City, NY 11530
What's nearby
- Cathedral Of The Incarnation0.3 mi
- Sunflower Fine Art0.3 mi
- Garden City Golf Club0.7 mi
- Adelphi University0.7 mi
Policies
Check-in/Check-out | Check in anytime after 4:00 PM, check out anytime before 11:00 AM |
|---|---|
Cancellation/prepayment | Cancellation/prepayment policies vary by room type and provider. |
Essential information about The Garden City Hotel
Low season | March |
|---|---|
High season | July |
Average price (weeknight) | $302 |
Average price (weekend night) | $664 |
When to book a room at The Garden City Hotel
Price per night. Prices are not fixed and may vary with time.
Average nightly price per month
Average nightly price
KAYAK's top tips for your stay at The Garden City Hotel
FAQs when booking at The Garden City Hotel
Nearby hotels and places to stay
Closest
See more nearby staysMost recommended
See most recommended stays in Garden CityGood to know
Value for money | 8.3 |
|---|---|
Distance to city center | 0.3 mi |
Nearest Airport | New York John F Kennedy Intl |
Distance to airport | 9.3 mi |
Everything you need to know for your stay in Garden City
Complete your trip
Popular destinations