Overview

Amara Cay Resort
Best Vibe

80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036, United States
+1 305 664 0073

$283+

Overall guest ratings

8.5/10 Excellent
Based on 1,413 reviews

Review highlights

  • 8.9
  • 8.7
  • 6.7
  • 6.3

Good to know

  • Nice building
  • Modern Hotel
  • Stylish hotel

Nearby

    Show all

    About

    This newly refreshed Florida Keys resort getaway is an iconic property that offers the retro, throwback feel of a nostalgic American beach vacation, combined with modern amenities, designer furnishings and a touch of whimsy. We are currently undergoing a 'stem to stern' refresh here on property, including updates at the Tiki Bar, event venues, sleeping rooms, front lobby, landscaping and exteriors. We are exciting about the changes happening and hope you'll come see for yourself.

    Less More
    Amara Cay Resort

    Amenities

    • Fitness center
    • Facilities for Disabled Guests
    • Concierge service
    • Cribs available
    • Gift shop
    • Laundry facilities
    • Meeting/Banquet facilities
    • Bicycle rental
    • Outdoor pool
    • No smoking
    • Restaurant
    • Bar/Lounge
    • Express check out
    • Cable or satellite TV
    • Air-conditioned
    • 24 Hour Front Desk
    • Safe
    • Pets not allowed
    • Free parking
    • Playground
    • Private beach
    • Designated smoking area
    • Storage available
    • Wedding services
    • Terrace/Patio
    • Business center
    • Internet
    • Wi-Fi
    • Spa
    Less More
    Reviews

    Guest reviews

    Overall Rating

    8.4 Excellent
    Based on 1,381 reviews
    • 8.9 "Location is great."
      10.0 "100% enjoyed the restaurants & bars nearby."
      9.4 "94% liked the proximity to shopping."
      10.0 "100% appreciated the closeness to the beach."
      8.1 "81% liked the proximity to sightseeing."
      10.0 "100% thought parking was inexpensive."
    • 8.7 "Vibe was good."
      8.7 "87% thought, the hotel was modern."
      9.6 "96% said it was a stylish hotel."
      7.7 "77% enjoyed the friendly atmosphere."
      9.1 "91% enjoyed the lobby entrance."
      7.5 "75% thought the hotel was luxurious."
    • 8.2 "Great service."
      9.8 "98% were happy with the shuttle service."
      7.1 "Management was excellent, said 71%."
    • 7.1 "Nice rooms."
      7.2 "72% said rooms were clean."
      7.9 "79% said the beds were comfortable."
      9.5 "95% thought the view was good."
      10.0 "100% appreciated the modern rooms."
      8.6 "86% enjoyed the balcony."
    • 6.9 "Pool is mediocre."
    • 6.7 "Food is average."
      6.7 "Desserts were ok, said 67%."
      5.7 "Only 57% thought the fish/seafood dishes were good."
    • 6.3 "Bar is ok."
    • 4.6 "Internet is poor."
      3.3 "67% said the wifi quality was bad."
    • 4.0 "Value below average."
      0.5 "The price was too high for 95%."
      1.8 "82% said the breakfast was too expensive."
      0.0 "100% said beverages were too expensive."
    • 3.8 "Wellness & sports facilities were not very nice."
      3.1 "69% didn't like the fitness area."
    View all review categories

    Overall Rating

    8.4 Excellent
    Based on 704 reviews
    • 8.8 "Location is great."
      10.0 "100% enjoyed the restaurants & bars nearby."
      10.0 "100% appreciated the closeness to the beach."
    • 8.6 "Vibe was good."
      8.4 "84% thought, the hotel was modern."
      9.7 "97% said it was a stylish hotel."
      9.1 "91% enjoyed the lobby entrance."
      7.6 "76% enjoyed the friendly atmosphere."
    • 7.9 "Good service."
      9.0 "90% found the staff to be very friendly."
      7.0 "70% said the reception staff was great."
      9.7 "97% were happy with the shuttle service."
    • 7.7 "Good amenities."
      7.7 "77% thought the building was wonderful."
      9.1 "91% enjoyed the lobby entrance."
      9.5 "95% thought the architecture was beautiful."
      7.2 "72% said the facilities were very new."
    • 7.2 "Tasty food."
    • 6.6 "Pool is mediocre."
    • 6.3 "Bar is ok."
    • 4.9 "Breakfast is below average."
      1.8 "82% said the breakfast was too expensive."
    • 3.6 "Value below average."
      1.8 "82% said the breakfast was too expensive."
      0.7 "The price was too high for 93%."
    View all review categories

    Overall Rating

    8.3 Excellent
    Based on 662 reviews
    • 8.7 "Vibe was good."
      8.6 "86% thought, the hotel was modern."
      7.8 "78% enjoyed the friendly atmosphere."
      9.7 "97% said it was a stylish hotel."
      9.0 "90% enjoyed the lobby entrance."
    • 8.7 "Location is great."
      10.0 "100% appreciated the closeness to the beach."
      7.1 "Great parking, according to 71%."
    • 7.9 "Good service."
      9.8 "98% were happy with the shuttle service."
    • 6.9 "Rooms are ok."
      6.2 "Only 62% thought the furniture was functional."
    • 6.7 "Pool is mediocre."
    • 6.3 "Food is average."
    • 5.3 "Breakfast is mediocre."
    • 4.9 "Internet is poor."
    • 4.0 "Wellness & sports facilities were not very nice."
    • 3.7 "Value below average."
      0.4 "The price was too high for 96%."
      1.9 "81% said the breakfast was too expensive."
    View all review categories

    Overall Rating

    9.1 Excellent
    Based on 13 reviews
    • 8.5 "Vibe was good."
    • 8.4 "Great service."
    • 7.6 "Good amenities."
    • 7.1 "Nice rooms."
    • 6.9 "Average comfort."
    Hotel type
    Family Hotel
    Guests think this is a family-friendly hotel.
    Beach Hotel
    Guests consider it an awesome beach hotel.
    Good to know
    "Nice building"
    "Modern Hotel"
    "Stylish hotel"
    data provided by TrustYou

    Recent Reviews

    Find reviews that mention
    More
    More

    Photos
    Map

    Map

    Close