Best Pittsburgh inns
Overall 9.6 Excellent
Based on 27 reviews
All reviews
- All reviews
Details
Reviews
Located in Pittsburgh (Shadyside), Mansions on Fifth Hotel is within a 15-minute walk of University of Pittsburgh and Carnegie Mellon University. Featured amenities include a 24-hour business center, complimentary newspapers in the lobby, and dry cleaning/laundry services. Planning an event in Pittsburgh? This hotel has facilities measuring 5000 square feet (465 square meters), including a conference center. Free valet parking is available onsite.
Overall 8.9 Excellent
Based on 540 reviews
All reviews
- All reviews
- Couples
- Families
Excellent
10.0
Pros: Friendly staff. Very accommodating
Excellent
10.0
Pros: Friendly accommodating staff. Beautiful property and location. The room was cozy, clean and comfortable.
Okay
4.0
Pros: Position and rooms
Excellent
10.0
Good
7.0
Pros: The hotel is wonderful and appears to be well-maintained, particularly for such an old structure. The daytime staff were excellent and discovered several errors made by the evening staff. If you can obtain a discounted rate, I highly recommend Mansions.
Good
6.0
Pros: Ornate architectural design in lobby/breakfast area. Good breakfast.
Excellent
8.3
Pros: It was close to Carnegie Mellon- where I needed to be. It had a lot of charm and even though historic, well-kept up. I liked that it had a bar and ability to order a little food. Comfortable bed and large bathroom. The staff were wonderful!!
Good
7.0
Pros: Beautiful historic building, lovely rooms, great location (I wanted to be walking distance to Shadyside and Oakland, so perfect for that).
Okay
5.4
Excellent
10.0
Pros: The Mansion on Fifth Far exceeded my expectations. It felt like we were stepping back into the early 1900s. The staff was warm and helpful and if there were lots of cool places to relax including a bar with live music at night.
Excellent
10.0
Pros: We visited Pittsburgh just a few days before Halloween. This treasure is amidst a lovely neighborhood that was all decked out with spooky decorations! The Mansion itself was elegant and well cared for. The beds & pillows were very comfortable. My party had 3 Rooms - we’ll be back!
Excellent
10.0
Pros: Full of old-world class and charm, yet extremely clean and well-cared for.
Details
Reviews
Overall 8.9 Excellent
Based on 540 reviews
Vibe
9.3
Bar
9.3
Location
9.1
Value
8.5
Service
8.4
Room
7.9
Amenities
7.7
Breakfast
7.4
WiFi
5.0
Vibe
9.1
Service
8.7
Comfort
7.6
Amenities
7.4
Room
7.2
Location
9.1
Service
8.2
Amenities
7.7
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Friendly staff. Very accommodating
Cons:
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Friendly accommodating staff. Beautiful property and location. The room was cozy, clean and comfortable.
Cons: Not a thing!
4.0 Okay
Pros: Position and rooms
Cons: When we checked in the staff were not very friendly. I also felt that during breakfast.
10.0 Excellent
Pros:
Cons: The water pressure was terrible
7.0 Good
Pros: The hotel is wonderful and appears to be well-maintained, particularly for such an old structure. The daytime staff were excellent and discovered several errors made by the evening staff. If you can obtain a discounted rate, I highly recommend Mansions.
Cons: There were several significant errors regarding our evening check-in. First, the night check-in staff lost my driver's license (it was later found and mailed to me). Also, the check-in staff entered the incorrect rate and name into the system.
6.0 Good
Pros: Ornate architectural design in lobby/breakfast area. Good breakfast.
Cons: Pullout couch for our daughter uncomfortable. She was unhappy with our stay because couldn't sleep/sore back. Our bed was fine.
8.3 Excellent
Pros: It was close to Carnegie Mellon- where I needed to be. It had a lot of charm and even though historic, well-kept up. I liked that it had a bar and ability to order a little food. Comfortable bed and large bathroom. The staff were wonderful!!
Cons: My bedroom was loud from the traffic from the street even with some kind of fan that ran all night. It needed a good vacuuming and the shower pressure was so low, I didn’t dare wash my hair.
7.0 Good
Pros: Beautiful historic building, lovely rooms, great location (I wanted to be walking distance to Shadyside and Oakland, so perfect for that).
Cons: Difficult to track down staff, no one was manning the front desk 2 out of the 3 times we needed someone. They should get a bell. I even tried to call the desk while standing in front of it to get someone to come out, but it just rang to voicemail. Ants.
5.4 Okay
Pros:
Cons: Staff stood by while we struggled to open the front door with luggage. No elavator and no help with bags. Front desk not friendly. Didn't bother to say goodbye even though the 3 staff standing near knew we were leaving. Black mold around shower. Room hot.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The Mansion on Fifth Far exceeded my expectations. It felt like we were stepping back into the early 1900s. The staff was warm and helpful and if there were lots of cool places to relax including a bar with live music at night.
Cons:
10.0 Excellent
Pros: We visited Pittsburgh just a few days before Halloween. This treasure is amidst a lovely neighborhood that was all decked out with spooky decorations! The Mansion itself was elegant and well cared for. The beds & pillows were very comfortable. My party had 3 Rooms - we’ll be back!
Cons: Had no issues
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Full of old-world class and charm, yet extremely clean and well-cared for.
Cons: Not one thing.
Located in Pittsburgh (Shadyside), Mansions on Fifth Hotel is within a 15-minute walk of University of Pittsburgh and Carnegie Mellon University. Featured amenities include a 24-hour business center, complimentary newspapers in the lobby, and dry cleaning/laundry services. Planning an event in Pittsburgh? This hotel has facilities measuring 5000 square feet (465 square meters), including a conference center. Free valet parking is available onsite.
Where to stay in Pittsburgh?
Our Heatmaps tool will help you find the perfect place to stay in Pittsburgh by showing you how close inns are to major activities