Guest reviews
-
All Reviews
-
Couples
-
Families
-
Business
-
Solo
Overall Rating
-
9.7 "Terrific location."9.4 "94%
liked the proximity to shopping ." 8.8 "Great parking , according to 88%." 10.0 "100%enjoyed the restaurants & bars nearby ." 10.0 "100%liked the proximity to sightseeing ." 10.0 "City centre within easy reach , said 100%." -
9.2 "Excellent pool."
-
9.2 "Food is to die for."9.8 "
Yummy desserts , said 98%." -
9.1 "World class service."9.6 "96% found the
staff to be very friendly ." 8.0 "80% thought theservice was very professional ." -
5.9 "Breakfast is mediocre."
-
4.8 "Rooms are not good."1.1 "89% thought they were
poorly maintained ." 1.0 "90%complained about the bathroom ." 4.4 "56% saidrooms were dirty ." 1.1 "For 89%, therooms looked old ." 2.9 "71% foundproblems with the furniture ." 2.3 "Air conditioning was criticized by 77%." 1.0 "90% hadproblems with the shower ." 0.0 "100% said thebathroom was dirty ." -
4.6 "Not very clean."4.4 "56% said
rooms were dirty ." 0.0 "100% said thebathroom was dirty ."
Overall Rating
-
9.7 "Terrific location."
-
9.4 "Incredible bar."
-
9.3 "Food is to die for."9.8 "
Yummy desserts , said 98%." -
9.0 "World class service."9.4 "94% found the
staff to be very friendly ." -
5.7 "Breakfast is mediocre."
-
5.1 "Vibe was decent."
-
4.6 "Rooms are not good."1.0 "90% thought they were
poorly maintained ." 0.9 "91%complained about the bathroom ." 4.3 "57% saidrooms were dirty ." 2.3 "Air conditioning was criticized by 77%." 0.9 "For 91%, therooms looked old ." 3.0 "70% foundproblems with the furniture ." -
4.5 "Not very clean."4.3 "57% said
rooms were dirty ."
Overall Rating
-
9.8 "Terrific location."
-
9.2 "Food is to die for."9.9 "
Yummy desserts , said 99%." -
9.2 "World class service."9.7 "97% found the
staff to be very friendly ." -
9.0 "Excellent pool."
-
6.7 "Average comfort."
-
4.9 "Vibe wasn't good."1.4 "86%
criticized the unstylish hotel ." -
4.7 "Rooms are not good."1.0 "90% thought they were
poorly maintained ." 1.0 "90%complained about the bathroom ." 4.7 "53% saidrooms were dirty ." -
4.6 "Not very clean."4.7 "53% said
rooms were dirty ."
Overall Rating
-
9.7 "Terrific location."
Recent reviews
- All reviews
- Positive
- Neutral
- Negative
-
5.4review from
The location was ideal in Edgartown. It was central to the Waterfront, shops, and restaurants. We were also very close to the Chappy Island ferry. Everything was dirty. They cleaned our room everyday, but it was clear the bathroom/ bathtub was not cleaned ever. The grime/ soap scum accumulated every day. When we arrived to check in there was no one there for a while. It was like that from time to time. Additionally, someone should recommend vacuuming the lobby steps maybe once in a while. It was really dirty. Lastly, I was pregnant. The first day/ night it was very hot. It was not until we complained that we were told the Central AC was broken and maybe they could bring us a window unit. We got a unit and things got more comfortable (thankfully) Overall, I would have gone to the Mansion House, Harbor Hotel down the street, or rented a house for the same price but better quality.
-
9.1review from
Location, location, location! Right in downtown Edgartown. Could not be any more perfect centralized location. Main Street and the waterfront are only a few steps away just the perfect spot. The hotel is historic charming clean and the staff is friendly. You can leave the car at home for this one it's in just the perfect place. And it is just about a block from the bands and the loud bars so you have peace and quiet and serenity yet close to everything. we do plan on going back. I just wish they would add the bicycles as complementary to the room since the rooms are fairly priced to begin with
-
10.0review from
The service was unbelievable. Staff was incredibly friendly.
-
9.1review from
Location, location, location! Right in downtown Edgartown. Could not be any more perfect centralized location. Main Street and the waterfront are only a few steps away just the perfect spot. The hotel is historic charming clean and the staff is friendly. You can leave the car at home for this one it's in just the perfect place. And it is just about a block from the bands and the loud bars so you have peace and quiet and serenity yet close to everything. we do plan on going back. I just wish they would add the bicycles as complementary to the room since the rooms are fairly priced to begin with
-
10.0review from
The service was unbelievable. Staff was incredibly friendly.
