Kelley House

Top Romantic Hotel

Pros: The room was very clean, and the staff was friendly with excellent service.

Pros: Perfect location, walking distance to beach, shops and movies. Made small accommodations for a late check out so I could run to the store. Windows could open to let in nice cool air off water. Room ...

Cons: Walls are thin, could hear everything outside rooms and next door. Microwave not standard in all rooms,but did have fridge and mini coffee. I went during refurbishing so they might be working on ...

Pros: beautiful / close to shop restaurant's

Cons: parking

Pros: Everything .

Cons: Heat did not work well but was compensated for more than fairly

location, location

Pros: Location, location, location! Right in downtown Edgartown. Could not be any more perfect centralized location. Main Street and the waterfront are only a few steps away just the perfect spot. The hotel is historic charming clean and the staff is friendly. You can leave the car at home for this one it's in just the perfect place. And it is just about a block from the bands and the loud bars so you have peace and quiet and serenity yet close to everything. we do plan on going back. I just wish they would add the bicycles as complementary to the room since the rooms are fairly priced to begin with