West Tisbury hotels

West Tisbury hotels

Search hundreds of travel sites at once for hotels in West Tisbury

Check-in
Check-out
Compare vs. KAYAK |

Good to know

Low Season September
High Season July
  Average price (weeknight): $195
  Average price (weekend night): $309

cheapest month to stay

90%

expected price decrease

most expensive time to stay

48%

expected price increase

(avg. price over the last 2 weeks)

Sun - Thu

(weeknight)

(avg. price over the last 2 weeks)

Fri & Sat

(weekend night)

FAQs when booking a hotel in West Tisbury

How much is a cheap hotel in West Tisbury?
KAYAK users have found double rooms in West Tisbury for as cheap as $178 in the last 3 days. The average price is $462.
How can I find hotels near me?
Take a look at our extensive hotel Heatmaps to find the best hotels near you.

Where to stay in West Tisbury?

Our Heatmaps tool will help you find the perfect place to stay in West Tisbury by showing you how close hotel options are to major activities

Best West Tisbury hotels

Show all
Isabelle's Beach House - Oak Bluffs - Building
1
9.7 Excellent (176 reviews)
10.0 Excellent
Quiet, charming, GREAT location, very decent breakfast every morning and baked choc and chip cookies every afternoon. Its walking distance to the center of Oak Bluffs and the bus stops right in front of this beach front property. We returned to fresh towels, made up bed and an endless supply of coffee's and tea's. We had a great time at Isabelle's, who even made dinner reservations for us, and will certainly be staying there when we are on the island again.
Pros: Hotel Employee is extremely friendly and filled with great advice and knowledge of the island. Couldn't ask for more in a host.
Charles and Charles MV - Vineyard Haven - Building
2
9.7 Excellent (125 reviews)
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Nice home-made breakfasts, friendly and helpful owner, free bicycle, large and clean bath room, comfortable bed, walking distance to ferry, quiet location.
Cons: I do not have.
The Christopher - Edgartown - Building
3
9.6 Excellent (74 reviews)
Overview
Located in Edgartown, The Christopher is in the historical district, within a 5-minute walk of Edgartown Public Library and Old Whaling Church. The front desk is staffed during limited hours. Free self parking is available onsite.
Mansion House Inn And Spa - Vineyard Haven - Building
4
9.3 Excellent (409 reviews)
Overview Reviews
A stay at Mansion House Inn And Spa places you in the heart of Vineyard Haven, steps from Martha's Vineyard Chamber of Commerce and 4 minutes by foot from Vineyard Playhouse. Featured amenities include a computer station, complimentary newspapers in the lobby, and dry cleaning/laundry services. Free self parking is available onsite.
9.7 Excellent
Pros: All the physical features and fixtures of the room were of high quality and in top shape. The public areas were spotless, with interesting thematic display cases of items from Martha's Vineyard history. The staff was friendly and responsive.
2.0 Mediocre
Pros: I did not like the rude staff or owner it made everything horrible !
Cons: We reserved a pet friendly room . We were harassed for having the pet . To the point my wife left in an ambulance to Martha's Vineyard emergency room ; what a nightmare. The owner did not even apppologize she even insulted us further . The island is wounderul just this hotel is horrible !
Hob Knob - Edgartown - Building
5
9.5 Excellent (73 reviews)
The Oak Bluffs Inn - Oak Bluffs - Building
6
9.4 Excellent (80 reviews)
Overview
Located in Oak Bluffs, The Oak Bluffs Inn is near the beach, within a 5-minute walk of Trinity Park Tabernacle and Cottage Museum.
Kelley House - Edgartown - Building
7
9.1 Excellent (478 reviews)
Overview Reviews
A stay at Kelley House places you in the heart of Edgartown, steps from Edgartown Public Library and 4 minutes by foot from Old Whaling Church. Featured amenities include complimentary wired Internet access, express check-out, and complimentary newspapers in the lobby. Planning an event in Edgartown? This hotel features 500 square feet (46 square meters) of event facilities. Free self parking is available onsite.
6.2 Good
Cons: The door to my room didn’t even fully shut. You could hear every step from the people above you. $25 bike rental fee, whereas other hotels on the island offer as a complimentary amenity
5.4 Okay
Pros: The location was ideal in Edgartown. It was central to the Waterfront, shops, and restaurants. We were also very close to the Chappy Island ferry.
Cons: Everything was dirty. They cleaned our room everyday, but it was clear the bathroom/ bathtub was not cleaned ever. The grime/ soap scum accumulated every day. When we arrived to check in there was no one there for a while. It was like that from time to time. Additionally, someone should recommend vacuuming the lobby steps maybe once in a while. It was really dirty. Lastly, I was pregnant. The first day/ night it was very hot. It was not until we complained that we were told the Central AC was broken and maybe they could bring us a window unit. We got a unit and things got more comfortable (thankfully) Overall, I would have gone to the Mansion House, Harbor Hotel down the street, or rented a house for the same price but better quality.
9.1 Excellent
Pros: Location, location, location! Right in downtown Edgartown. Could not be any more perfect centralized location. Main Street and the waterfront are only a few steps away just the perfect spot. The hotel is historic charming clean and the staff is friendly. You can leave the car at home for this one it's in just the perfect place. And it is just about a block from the bands and the loud bars so you have peace and quiet and serenity yet close to everything. we do plan on going back. I just wish they would add the bicycles as complementary to the room since the rooms are fairly priced to begin with
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The service was unbelievable. Staff was incredibly friendly.
Pequot Hotel - Oak Bluffs - Building
8
9.1 Excellent (440 reviews)
Overview Reviews
Visit the Pequot Hotel in historic Oak Bluffs, Massachusetts, to experience classic and quaint cottage lodging in Martha’s Vineyard. The Pequot Hotel is located just one block from the beach and a short walk to Circuit Avenue—Oak Bluffs’ main street for shopping, dining, and other entertainment. With the ferry about four blocks from Pequot Hotel, guests are within walking distance of everything they might need during a Martha’s Vineyard vacation. Guest quarters at the Pequot Hotel are comfortable and cozy, with amenities such as private baths with Gilchrist & Soames products, air conditioning, and complimentary WiFi. Each room is individually decorated in homey styles, and a variety of room variations are available, including twin beds, queen beds, a king bed, or a three-bedroom apartment suite. Pequot Hotel offers its guests a number of amenities to enhance their stay. Guest rates include daily continental breakfast, with a variety of options including muffins, fresh fruit, oatmeal, and quiche. For beach-goers, the hotel offers complimentary towels, chairs, and umbrellas to enjoy during their day. The hotel’s common room is popular place to relax, featuring a large flat-screen TV and a cozy fireplace for chillier days. If guests want to explore the area, bike rentals are available to be delivered to the hotel. Perhaps what makes the Pequot Hotel special, though, is that it makes guests feel right at home—with comfortable rocking chairs on the front porch, fresh-baked cookies every afternoon, Sunday morning mimosas, complimentary beach chairs, and Friday porch parties. A favorite accommodation of Martha’s Vineyard visitors for almost 100 years, the Pequot Hotel channels a thoughtful, cozy, and welcoming atmosphere for its guests, along with standard amenities and personalized service.
9.6 Excellent
Pros: Charming setting with in walking distance of the beach, shops, and restaurants. The staff was wonderful and the breakfast was great. Would definitely stay there again.
9.7 Excellent
Pros: The hotel itself was adorable and a close walk to the beach and all of the shops and restaurants in oaks bluffs. About 10 minutes into town walking, also close to the "gingerbread houses"
Cons: A bit on the pricy side, but that's Marthas Vineyard in the summer!!
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The staff was very friendly, amenities were modern, room was super clean, an overall enjoyable experience!
Cons: Nothing!
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Great staff, closeness to beach, shopping and restaurants, cookies and lemonade in the afternoon, rocking on the front porch
Cons: Small stall shower
Crocker House Inn - Vineyard Haven - Building
9
9.8 Excellent (22 reviews)
Thorncroft Inn - Vineyard Haven
10
9.2 Excellent (69 reviews)
The Sydney - Edgartown - Bedroom
11
9.2 Excellent (67 reviews)
Overview
With a stay at The Sydney in Edgartown, you'll be within a 5-minute walk of Edgartown Public Library and Old Whaling Church. Featured amenities include express check-in and express check-out.
The Ashley Inn - Edgartown - Building
12
9.0 Excellent (125 reviews)
Overview Reviews
Located in Edgartown, The Ashley Inn is near the beach, within a 5-minute walk of Old Whaling Church and Vincent House Museum. The front desk is staffed during limited hours. Free self parking is available onsite.
9.1 Excellent
Pros: When we arrived they told us that the room had already been booked, due to another person changing the booking for another website. They quickly told us not to worry and they would honor our booking and work to re-book the other person at another location. In two hours, while we ate lunch, they called and told us that we could check into the room
Summercamp - Oak Bluffs - Bedroom
14
8.8 Excellent (287 reviews)
Overview Reviews
With a stay at Summercamp in Oak Bluffs, you'll be within a 5-minute walk of Cottage Museum and Flying Horses Carousel. Featured amenities include a 24-hour front desk and luggage storage. Free self parking is available onsite.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: We toured the whole island and this was the cutest place so glad it was our hotel. Very relaxing. Best view.
Cons: Small bathroom
9.7 Excellent
Pros: I loved the style of the boutique hotel and the friendly staff!
Cons: There isn't a thing I didn't love about our stay.
MV Surfside Hotel - Oak Bluffs - Outdoors view
15
8.9 Excellent (91 reviews)
Overview
When you a stay at MV Surfside Hotel in Oak Bluffs, you'll be in the historical district, just steps from Flying Horses Carousel and Oak Bluffs Harbor. Featured amenities include complimentary newspapers in the lobby, luggage storage, and coffee/tea in a common area. Free self parking is available onsite.
Madison Inn - Oak Bluffs - Bedroom
16
9.1 Excellent (41 reviews)
Overview Reviews
A stay at Madison Inn places you in the heart of Oak Bluffs, steps from Flying Horses Carousel and Ocean Park. Featured amenities include luggage storage, a library, and coffee/tea in a common area.
9.7 Excellent
Cons: Shower water pressure was very weak.
The Lightkeepers Inn - Edgartown - Bedroom
17
9.2 Excellent (32 reviews)
Overview
When you a stay at The Lightkeepers Inn in Edgartown, you'll be near the beach, within a 5-minute walk of Edgartown Public Library and Vincent House Museum. Featured amenities include express check-out, complimentary newspapers in the lobby, and luggage storage. Free self parking is available onsite.
Hanover House Inn - Vineyard Haven - Building
18
8.7 Excellent (150 reviews)
9.3 Excellent
Pros: Comfortable rooms, friendly staff, fresh-baked muffins and cookies, nice landscaping
Martha's Vineyard Resort - Oak Bluffs - Lobby
19
9.0 Excellent (38 reviews)
Overview
Located in Oak Bluffs, Martha's Vineyard Resort is within a 5-minute drive of Oak Bluffs Public Library and Flying Horses Carousel. Free self parking is available onsite.
Lamberts Cove Inn - West Tisbury - Building
20
8.7 Excellent (120 reviews)
Overview Reviews
Located in Vineyard Haven, Lamberts Cove Inn is a 3-minute drive from Lambert's Cove Beach and 7 minutes from Polly Hill Arboretum. Featured amenities include limo/town car service, multilingual staff, and coffee/tea in a common area. A roundtrip airport shuttle is complimentary (available 24 hours).
6.5 Good
Pros: Very friednly staff . Location , good excess to beach .
Cons: Room was too small for the price, bathroom was very uncomfortable .