The Sydney, The Edgartown Collection

The hotel offers a lovely light continental breakfast with a varied array of food options, including coconut chia pudding, healthy smoothies, bacon, and more. Guests have also enjoyed the delicious breakfast buffet with simple but tasty options.

Some guests have mentioned that the walls and floors are thin, and they could hear guests thumping about upstairs. Additionally, there were comments about noise from other rooms and the corridor. However, the staff has been described as friendly and accommodating.

The hotel's location is described as perfect, being in the center of town with easy access to restaurants, shops, galleries, and the harbor. Guests have also appreciated the convenient location for exploring Edgartown and its interesting shops and lively dining spots.

The hotel is praised for being extremely clean with beautiful decor and for having exceptional staff who are knowledgeable about the island and go above and beyond to ensure guest satisfaction. Some guests have also highlighted the friendly and very helpful staff, particularly mentioning specific staff members by name.

The hotel provides a safety deposit box, express check-out, a bottle of water, 24-hour front desk service, and a lovely central courtyard with a fire pit for guests to enjoy. Additionally, the hotel has a beachy Scandinavian vibe and offers a diverse selection of foods for breakfast.

Guests praised the new building, mentioning its nice accommodations and welcoming staff.

The courtyard with a fire pit was highlighted as a great place to relax and enjoy a glass of wine before heading out to dinner.

While the Captain's House was noted to be nice, it was also mentioned that it could be noisy, so consider this when choosing a room.

The hotel's central location was praised for its convenience, allowing guests to easily walk to restaurants, shops, and galleries.

Guests loved the hotel's charming and modern decor, creating a serene and relaxing atmosphere.

Some guests mentioned that the walls and floors were thin, leading to noise from other rooms. Consider this when booking a room.

The light continental breakfast was described as lovely, with a varied array of food options, including healthy choices and delicious treats.

The hotel's beautiful gardens and Adirondack chairs in the front yard were highlighted as fantastic, providing a great spot to unwind.

Many guests praised the staff for being friendly, accommodating, and knowledgeable about the island, contributing to a wonderful overall experience.

While parking on-site was available, it was noted to be limited, so guests may want to explore off-site parking options, especially during peak seasons.