Corstorphine Lodge Hotel, Edinburgh Hotels from $54

Guest reviews

All Reviews
Couples
Families
Business
Solo

Overall Rating

Based on 802 reviews

Service

9.1 "World class service."
Breakfast

8.7 "Breakfast is good."
Location

8.4 "Location is great."
Comfort

5.9 "Average comfort."
Room

5.3 "Rooms are ok."
Vibe

3.9 "Vibe wasn't good."
Amenities

3.6 "Bad amenities."

View all review categories

Overall Rating

Based on 417 reviews

Service

9.1 "World class service."

9.6 "96% found the staff to be very friendly."

8.5 "85% said the reception staff was great."

9.0 "90% thought the service was very professional."
Breakfast

8.7 "Breakfast is good."
Location

7.9 "Good location."

9.5 "Good access to the airport, said 95%."

7.0 "City centre within easy reach, said 70%."

10.0 "Near to public transport, according to 100%."
Comfort

5.5 "Average comfort."

6.0 "For only 60%, the noise level was all right."
WiFi

4.9 "Internet is poor."

3.4 "66% said the wifi quality was bad."
Room

4.4 "Rooms are not good."

4.0 "60% didn't like the uncomfortable beds."

2.1 "79% complained about the bathroom."

0.1 "99% thought they were poorly maintained."

1.8 "82% had problems with the shower."

1.3 "For 87%, the rooms looked old."

1.8 "82% criticized the small bathroom."

1.4 "86% found problems with the furniture."
Vibe

3.7 "Vibe wasn't good."

1.1 "89% criticized the unstylish hotel."
Amenities

3.5 "Bad amenities."

3.7 "63% thought the building wasn't nice."

View all review categories

Overall Rating

Based on 272 reviews

Service

9.0 "World class service."

9.4 "94% found the staff to be very friendly."
Location

8.9 "Location is great."

9.5 "Good access to the airport, said 95%."
Breakfast

8.6 "Breakfast is good."
Comfort

6.1 "Average comfort."
Room

5.5 "Rooms are ok."
Vibe

4.5 "Vibe wasn't good."

1.3 "87% criticized the unstylish hotel."

Overall Rating

Based on 112 reviews

Service

8.9 "Great service."

9.7 "97% found the staff to be very friendly."
Breakfast

8.8 "Breakfast is good."
Value for money

8.8 "Good value."
Location

8.5 "Location is great."
Cleanliness

7.7 "Good cleanliness."

7.2 "72% said rooms were clean."
Comfort

6.2 "Average comfort."

5.1 "Beds were acceptable for 51%."

6.4 "For only 64%, the noise level was all right."
Room

5.7 "Rooms are ok."

5.1 "Beds were acceptable for 51%."
Vibe

3.7 "Vibe wasn't good."
Amenities

3.1 "Terrible amenities."

3.2 "68% thought the building wasn't nice."

View all review categories

Good to know

"Spacious rooms"

"Friendly service"

data provided by TrustYou

Recent Reviews

All reviews
Positive
Neutral
Negative

5.7

review from

room really nice and great breakfast.close to the airport room too cold due to the insulation. they charge you the day of the booking plus commission on credit card

Reviewed Nov 2010 by Anonymous
4.3

review from

Staff were helpful and courteous, the room was quiet and the breakfast reasonable. The room was in dire need of refurbishment, badly equipped with poor heating arrangements and unwelcoming

Reviewed Nov 2010 by Anonymous
6.0

review from

the quietness of enviroment, the space of the room, the good feeling of having breakfast in the conservatory. not much choice for breakfast

Reviewed Nov 2010 by Anonymous
6.4

review from

Hotel was convenient to the airport and satisfactory in terms of comfort. Staff person was friendly and hotel was accommodating to my scheduling needs. Two things: first, I was pulling heavy luggage and went to the 186 address on the website. I then had to drag all luggage over to 188 to check in (around 9pm). I would have appreciated knowing in advance where to go. Second, while most areas of the room were very clean, the corners and near the nightstand had not been cleaned in some time and had some dust and debris.

Reviewed Nov 2010 by Anonymous
5.7

review from

I wanted a clean, functional accommodation for 4/5 nights. This fitted the bill (however, I paid up front for 5 nights - only ended up staying for 5 and was disappointed to be - not at the least - offered a refund for the 5th night - as a gesture of goodwill). Parking was not as I'd hoped for.

Reviewed Nov 2010 by Anonymous
5.6

review from

location was good

Reviewed Aug 2007 by Anonymous
6.8

review from

good value

Reviewed Jul 2007 by Anonymous
4.0

review from

The people were friendly Very noisy in the middle of the night from other guests.Very old fashioned, and needs decorating and a good through clean

Reviewed Jul 2007 by Anonymous
2.0

review from

Nothing The hotel was dirty with wallpaper coming off walls & damp. The breakfast was awful

Reviewed Jun 2007 by Anonymous
7.2

review from

The service and friendliness of the staff was excellent. The breakfast was first class. Having a room with a sky light on a rainy night did not aid a good sleep

Reviewed May 2007 by Anonymous

6.8

review from

good value

Reviewed Jul 2007 by Anonymous
7.2

review from

The service and friendliness of the staff was excellent. The breakfast was first class. Having a room with a sky light on a rainy night did not aid a good sleep

Reviewed May 2007 by Anonymous

5.7

review from

room really nice and great breakfast.close to the airport room too cold due to the insulation. they charge you the day of the booking plus commission on credit card

Reviewed Nov 2010 by Anonymous
4.3

review from

Staff were helpful and courteous, the room was quiet and the breakfast reasonable. The room was in dire need of refurbishment, badly equipped with poor heating arrangements and unwelcoming

Reviewed Nov 2010 by Anonymous
6.0

review from

the quietness of enviroment, the space of the room, the good feeling of having breakfast in the conservatory. not much choice for breakfast

Reviewed Nov 2010 by Anonymous
6.4

review from

Hotel was convenient to the airport and satisfactory in terms of comfort. Staff person was friendly and hotel was accommodating to my scheduling needs. Two things: first, I was pulling heavy luggage and went to the 186 address on the website. I then had to drag all luggage over to 188 to check in (around 9pm). I would have appreciated knowing in advance where to go. Second, while most areas of the room were very clean, the corners and near the nightstand had not been cleaned in some time and had some dust and debris.

Reviewed Nov 2010 by Anonymous
5.7

review from

I wanted a clean, functional accommodation for 4/5 nights. This fitted the bill (however, I paid up front for 5 nights - only ended up staying for 5 and was disappointed to be - not at the least - offered a refund for the 5th night - as a gesture of goodwill). Parking was not as I'd hoped for.

Reviewed Nov 2010 by Anonymous
5.6

review from

location was good

Reviewed Aug 2007 by Anonymous
4.0

review from

The people were friendly Very noisy in the middle of the night from other guests.Very old fashioned, and needs decorating and a good through clean

Reviewed Jul 2007 by Anonymous
2.0

review from

Nothing The hotel was dirty with wallpaper coming off walls & damp. The breakfast was awful

Reviewed Jun 2007 by Anonymous

Corstorphine Lodge Hotel

$54+

Overall guest ratings

Review highlights

Good to know

Nearby

About

Amenities

Map

Photos

Guest reviews

Overall Rating

Overall Rating

Overall Rating

Overall Rating

Recent Reviews