Il Carmine, Erice Hotels from $52

Guest reviews

All Reviews
Couples
Families
Business
Solo

Overall Rating

Based on 751 reviews

Location

9.3 "Terrific location."
Breakfast

9.1 "Excellent breakfast."
Service

8.7 "Great service."
Amenities

8.0 "Amenities are good."
Comfort

6.9 "Average comfort."
Room

5.7 "Rooms are ok."
WiFi

5.0 "Internet is average."

View all review categories

Overall Rating

Based on 578 reviews

Location

9.4 "Terrific location."

9.0 "Great parking, according to 90%."

9.0 "90% thought parking was inexpensive."

9.5 "City centre within easy reach, said 95%."
Breakfast

9.1 "Excellent breakfast."
Service

8.2 "Great service."

9.3 "93% found the staff to be very friendly."
Amenities

7.6 "Good amenities."

7.6 "76% thought the building was wonderful."
Cleanliness

5.9 "Average cleanliness."

5.7 "Only 57% said rooms were clean enough."
Room

5.6 "Rooms are ok."

5.7 "Only 57% said rooms were clean enough."

5.0 "Only 50% thought the shower was ok."
WiFi

4.8 "Internet is poor."

View all review categories

Overall Rating

Based on 150 reviews

Location

9.3 "Terrific location."

9.3 "Great parking, according to 93%."
Breakfast

9.3 "Excellent breakfast."
Service

8.7 "Great service."

9.4 "94% found the staff to be very friendly."
Comfort

6.8 "Average comfort."
Cleanliness

6.0 "Average cleanliness."

5.8 "Only 58% said rooms were clean enough."
Room

5.5 "Rooms are ok."

5.8 "Only 58% said rooms were clean enough."

Overall Rating

Based on 22 reviews

Location

9.4 "Terrific location."
Breakfast

9.2 "Excellent breakfast."
Service

8.6 "Great service."

9.5 "95% found the staff to be very friendly."
Room

5.1 "Rooms are ok."

Good to know

"Nice building"

"Very quiet"

"Accessible parking"

"Friendly atmosphere"

data provided by TrustYou

Recent Reviews

All reviews
Positive
Neutral
Negative

6.0

review from

Staff friendly.Efficient check in/out.Location superb.Buffet breakfast fine.Quiet and secure environment. No problem with parking in winter but may be a different issue in summer. Best food in Erice was in PentoLaccia. Try Cannoli in main street cake shop. Visit i Bucanieri in Marsala, by far best restaurant in area ....try bucanieri 11 (Pesce Misto) and Angus steak..............fantastic................ Florio winery a few doors away has excellent wines... try Passo delle Mule...........a red wine excellent with fish!. Garabaldi in old town also vg unlike Venus restaurant which was awful even though more expensive. Enjoy Erice............................ WIFI only works beside reception not in rooms....poor advertising....not a large cost to fix , surprising after all previous comments!!!. Time also to modernize bathroom and plumbing ,,,,,,,more modern shower and extractor fan required which was weak and not efficient and very noisy as was toilet flush.

Reviewed Dec 2010 by Anonymous
7.3

review from

Great situation in old convent. Spacious rooms, feather duvets, good heating.Breakfast was good.

Reviewed Nov 2010 by Anonymous
5.7

review from

the quietness the room was too narrow, the bed too hard

Reviewed Oct 2010 by Anonymous
7.3

review from

Unique experience. Very quiet and peaceful, original unmolestered historic monetry, good for couples wanting access to the wonderful hill top village of Erice, or a fun place to take the kids (to tell them ghost stories about headless Monks !! All in all memorable, thank you bookings.com and Il Carmine/ No

Reviewed Oct 2010 by Anonymous
7.7

review from

Staff members were very gfriendly and the location of the hotel is very good.

Reviewed Oct 2010 by Anonymous
6.0

review from

staff very nice Breakfast minimum and hard/hard bed...and we like firm beds

Reviewed Oct 2009 by Anonymous
6.6

review from

It is a really impressive monastery building perfectly renovated. The room was very spacious and comfortable. The view from our room was excellent. The atmospere of the place is really special. Everything was perfect.

Reviewed Oct 2009 by Anonymous
7.0

review from

Fabulous location, very friendly staff No evening meal available in mid Sept. and we chose it because people raved about the food

Reviewed Sep 2009 by Anonymous
6.6

review from

The building was lovely, an old monastery very simply decorated but a very tranquil place to stay.

Reviewed Sep 2009 by Anonymous
7.6

review from

The evening meal is a feast! It is so good and an amazing value for the money spent! Highly recommended! WIFI internet didn't work in the room, but it worked around the reception desk.

Reviewed Jun 2009 by Anonymous

7.3

review from

Great situation in old convent. Spacious rooms, feather duvets, good heating.Breakfast was good.

Reviewed Nov 2010 by Anonymous
7.3

review from

Unique experience. Very quiet and peaceful, original unmolestered historic monetry, good for couples wanting access to the wonderful hill top village of Erice, or a fun place to take the kids (to tell them ghost stories about headless Monks !! All in all memorable, thank you bookings.com and Il Carmine/ No

Reviewed Oct 2010 by Anonymous
7.7

review from

Staff members were very gfriendly and the location of the hotel is very good.

Reviewed Oct 2010 by Anonymous
6.6

review from

It is a really impressive monastery building perfectly renovated. The room was very spacious and comfortable. The view from our room was excellent. The atmospere of the place is really special. Everything was perfect.

Reviewed Oct 2009 by Anonymous
7.0

review from

Fabulous location, very friendly staff No evening meal available in mid Sept. and we chose it because people raved about the food

Reviewed Sep 2009 by Anonymous
6.6

review from

The building was lovely, an old monastery very simply decorated but a very tranquil place to stay.

Reviewed Sep 2009 by Anonymous
7.6

review from

The evening meal is a feast! It is so good and an amazing value for the money spent! Highly recommended! WIFI internet didn't work in the room, but it worked around the reception desk.

Reviewed Jun 2009 by Anonymous

6.0

review from

Staff friendly.Efficient check in/out.Location superb.Buffet breakfast fine.Quiet and secure environment. No problem with parking in winter but may be a different issue in summer. Best food in Erice was in PentoLaccia. Try Cannoli in main street cake shop. Visit i Bucanieri in Marsala, by far best restaurant in area ....try bucanieri 11 (Pesce Misto) and Angus steak..............fantastic................ Florio winery a few doors away has excellent wines... try Passo delle Mule...........a red wine excellent with fish!. Garabaldi in old town also vg unlike Venus restaurant which was awful even though more expensive. Enjoy Erice............................ WIFI only works beside reception not in rooms....poor advertising....not a large cost to fix , surprising after all previous comments!!!. Time also to modernize bathroom and plumbing ,,,,,,,more modern shower and extractor fan required which was weak and not efficient and very noisy as was toilet flush.

Reviewed Dec 2010 by Anonymous
5.7

review from

the quietness the room was too narrow, the bed too hard

Reviewed Oct 2010 by Anonymous
6.0

review from

staff very nice Breakfast minimum and hard/hard bed...and we like firm beds

Reviewed Oct 2009 by Anonymous

Il Carmine

$52+

Overall guest ratings

Review highlights

Good to know

Nearby

About

Amenities

Map

Photos

Guest reviews

Overall Rating

Overall Rating

Overall Rating

Overall Rating

Recent Reviews