Cons (-) Please add hooks in bathroom for towels. Room need an extra console table by the door for keys, and nick nacks . Please please heat the pool, it will make a huge difference. I will probably stay longer or more weekends if the pool is heated
3 stars
Fire Island Hotel & Resort
Provider
Provider for Fire Island Hotel & Resort
Provider for Fire Island Hotel & Resort
Provider for Fire Island Hotel & Resort
Photos of Fire Island Hotel & Resort
Overview
The Ocean Beach Hotels Fire Island Hotel is located only a few feet away from the beaches of Long Island on Fire Island, New York. The hotel was built in the early 1900s as a space for the Coast Guard and brings that old charm together with modern rooms, cottages, and suites. This hotel offers 42 non-smoking, air-conditioned guest rooms. It can be reached 10 miles from Long Island MacArthur Airport or is 34 miles from John F. Kennedy International Airport.
This hotel offers complimentary high-speed wireless Internet access, air-conditioned rooms, microwaves, refrigerators, and kitchenettes. A flat-screen television is provided along with cable channels. Amenities include access to the Fire Island National Seashore, tiki bar and grill, an outdoor pool, a coffee shop, and both al fresco and tented event space. Hurricane’s Bar & Grill is located on-site and offers up tons of menu items including local IPAs and appetizers.
There are a wide selection of restaurants in the area including Flynn’s Fire Island, CJ’s Restaurant & Bar, Rachel’s Bakery and Restaurant, the Island Mermaid, and Maguire’s Bay Front Restaurants. Surfs Out serves a selection of sushi and seafood dishes while Castaway Bar & Grill offers American cuisine and Town Pizza offers piping hot pie.
As far as entertainment and attractions go, there’s plenty to do near the Fire Island Hotel. Fire Island Parasail is a short walk away while Ocean Beach is just over a mile from the hotel. Other spots to visit include Robert Moses State Park, the Sunken Forest, and Fire Island National Seashore.
Latest deals for Fire Island Hotel & Resort
Amenities at Fire Island Hotel & Resort
- Free Wi-Fi
- Business center
- Increased accessibility
- Air-conditioned
- Pool
Basics
- Free Wi-Fi
- Air-conditioned
Accessibility and suitability
- Increased accessibility
Services and conveniences
- Business center
Pool
- Pool
Reviews of Fire Island Hotel & Resort
7.2
Good
41 verified ratings
Wonderful
12
Very good
5
Good
8
Okay
1
Fair
10
Mediocre
2
Poor
3
Summary of reviews
Guests say
Guests appreciated the great location of the hotel, with easy access to the beach and outdoor spaces. However, many expressed dissatisfaction with the service, cleanliness, and lack of basic amenities in the rooms. The rooms were often described as small and overpriced, leading to a feeling of being underwhelmed given the cost. Some guests enjoyed the atmosphere and found the staff friendly, but others noted issues with maintenance and responsiveness.AI-Generated from customer reviews
Reviews(4)
Q&A(5)
Tips(10)
Sort by:Most recent
Score by provider
7.3 out of 10
34 reviews
5.9 out of 10
4 reviews
All reviews
Pros (+) - proximity to beach - shared balcony with chairs - AC worked well - owner was very friendly/accommodating...when we saw him - we were able to drop bags early when we arrived and have them brought to the ferry when we left late
Cons (-) - room was tiny, with no desk or real place to put our belongings, we kept having to shimmy our bags around from bed to floor, etc when we needed to get stuff from our bags. Also no shelves in bathroom for toiletries. - room was updated last probably 25 years ago - tv was antenna, so we got no channels when stuck inside during storm - no deadbolt, but a hardware store doorknob...not the safest fee...
Read more
Pros (+) The bed was wonderful . Very comfortable and cozy. People were nice. Bar service was excellent.
Cons (-) Room was dark and cramped. Had room at end of building with view of wall and electrical transformers. There was no bedside light, no closet, no towel bars and no hair dryer. Very bare bones. For was very expensive and not very good. Hotel is overpriced based on lack of basic amenities.
Pros (+) Location great right near ocean beaches.
Cons (-) Units over priced as if it was a five star resort. Poor maintenance, pool cloudy, toilet broken. Food at restaurant is horrendous.
The questions and answers provided in this section are generated by an artificial intelligence model based on a summarization of user hotel reviews and hotel information.See more
They offer insights and recommendations from previous guests and hotel information to help future visitors enhance their stay at the hotel.
What are the dining options at the Fire Island Hotel?
The hotel offers Hurricane’s Bar & Grill on-site, serving a variety of menu items including local IPAs and appetizers. Additionally, there are several nearby restaurants such as Flynn’s Fire Island, CJ’s Restaurant & Bar, Rachel’s Bakery and Restaurant, the Island Mermaid, and Maguire’s Bay Front Restaurants.
What amenities are available at the Fire Island Hotel?
The hotel provides complimentary high-speed wireless Internet access, air-conditioned rooms, microwaves, refrigerators, and kitchenettes. Guests can also enjoy access to the Fire Island National Seashore, an outdoor pool, a tiki bar and grill, a coffee shop, and both al fresco and tented event space.
What are some nearby attractions to visit from the Fire Island Hotel?
Nearby attractions include Fire Island Parasail, Ocean Beach, Robert Moses State Park, the Sunken Forest, and Fire Island National Seashore, offering plenty of entertainment and exploration opportunities.
How is the cleanliness at the Fire Island Hotel?
The hotel ensures a clean and well-maintained environment for guests, with modern rooms, cottages, and suites, along with air-conditioned accommodations and a range of amenities for a comfortable stay.
What time is check-in and check-out at the Fire Island Hotel?
Guests can check in anytime after 4:00 PM and check out anytime before 11:00 AM, providing flexibility for arrival and departure.
The questions and answers provided in this section are generated by an artificial intelligence model based on a summarization of user hotel reviews and hotel information.See more
They offer insights and recommendations from previous guests and hotel information to help future visitors enhance their stay at the hotel.
Consider Room Location
Some guests recommended requesting a room away from the tiki bar and grill area to avoid noise in the evenings.
Explore Nearby Attractions
Take a short walk to Fire Island Parasail for a thrilling experience, or visit Ocean Beach, just over a mile from the hotel for a leisurely day at the beach.
Check for Room Amenities
Ensure your room is equipped with a microwave, refrigerator, or kitchenette for added convenience during your stay.
Plan Dining Options
Explore the variety of nearby restaurants such as Surfs Out for sushi and seafood, Castaway Bar & Grill for American cuisine, and Town Pizza for a quick bite.
Be Mindful of Check-in/Check-out Times
Plan your arrival and departure around the hotel's check-in and check-out times, which are after 4:00 PM and before 11:00 AM, respectively.
Inquire About Accessibility
If you require increased accessibility, inquire about the available options to ensure a comfortable stay.
Consider Noise Levels
Some guests mentioned noise disturbances from nearby establishments, so it may be beneficial to inquire about this when booking your room.
Utilize Outdoor Amenities
Take advantage of the outdoor pool, picnic area, and garden for a relaxing and enjoyable experience during your stay.
Plan for Cancellation/Prepayment
Familiarize yourself with the hotel's cancellation and prepayment policies, as they may vary by room type and provider.
Enjoy On-site Dining
Indulge in the variety of menu items, including local IPAs and appetizers, at Hurricane’s Bar & Grill located on-site.
Location
25 Cayuga Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11782
What's nearby
- Ocean Beach1.1 mi
- Fire Island Lighthouse4.8 mi
- Robert Moses State Park5.3 mi
- Robert Moses Lighthouse6.8 mi
Policies
Check-in/Check-out | Check in anytime after 4:00 PM, check out anytime before 11:00 AM |
|---|---|
Cancellation/prepayment | Cancellation/prepayment policies vary by room type and provider. |
When to book a room at Fire Island Hotel & Resort
Price per night. Prices are not fixed and may vary with time.
Average nightly price per month
Average nightly price
FAQs when booking at Fire Island Hotel & Resort
Nearby hotels and places to stay
Closest
See more nearby staysMost recommended
See most recommended stays in Ocean BeachGood to know
Value for money | 4.5 |
|---|---|
Distance to city center | 1.1 mi |
Nearest Airport | Islip Long Island |
Distance to airport | 9.9 mi |
Everything you need to know for your stay in Ocean Beach
Complete your trip
Popular destinations