Everything was great…
4 stars
The Pridwin Hotel
81 Shore Road, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11964, United States
Shelter Island Heights, NY
See location+1 631 749 0476Photos of The Pridwin Hotel
Overview
Shelter Island Heights Hotels The Pridwin Hotel is a unique all-American guest hotel welcoming guests on shelter island since 1927. It is located on a 10 acre site on Crescent Beach. It is a seasonal hotel open from May to the last weekend of June through Labor Day. Local activities include shopping, chartering a fishing boat, and swimming.
Breakfast is included. There is also free parking and a ferry terminal shuttle. Other features are the arcade and game room, porter and bellhop, ticket service, and laundry facilities. Resort amenities include two docks, a private pool, and a tennis club. Guests can use paddle boards, lounge chairs, and kayaks as well as single speed bikes. There is a bar and restaurant that overlooks the water. The fish served is caught locally, and the Wednesday Night Cookouts feature live music.
Guests can stay either in resorts or cottages. Cottage choices include two bedroom cottages with a fireplace, one bedroom cottages with a fireplace, or a studio cottage with a view of the water. There are three floors of rooms available, with a total of 40 rooms. The standard room has air conditioning, daily housekeeping, flat screen TV with remote, telephone, and feather duvet.
Book today for a unique seasonal stay with an award winning restaurant. It is a good choice for families or couples who want to enjoy a quiet vacation.
Amenities at The Pridwin Hotel
- Private beach
- Outdoor pool
- Spa and wellness center
- Fitness center
- Restaurant
- Bar/Lounge
- Free Wi-Fi
- Tea/coffee maker
- Free parking
- Free toiletries
Things to do
- Gift shop
- Hiking
- Fishing
- Game room
- Golf
- Cycling
- Table tennis
- Pool table
- Water sport facilities (on site)
Pool and spa
- Spa and wellness center
- Saltwater pool
- Massage
- Heated pool
- Outdoor pool
- Sauna
- Pool with a view
Basics
- Free Wi-Fi
- Internet
- Fire extinguisher
- Free toiletries
- Smoke alarms
- Heating
- Air-conditioned
Outdoor
- Terrace/Patio
- Beach towels
- Private beach
- Garden
Dining
- Special diet menus (on request)
- Restaurant
- Bar/Lounge
- Tea/coffee maker
Services and conveniences
- Concierge service
- Safety deposit box
- Meeting/Banquet facilities
- 24hr front desk
Family friendly
- Babysitting or child care
- Cribs available
- Kids meals
- Complimentary breakfast
Accessibility and suitability
- Non-smoking rooms available
- Increased accessibility
- Elevator
Parking and transportation
- Free parking
- Private parking
Bathroom
- Hairdryer
- Bathrobe
Fitness
- Fitness center
- Tennis
Laundry
- Iron and ironing board
General
- Storage available
Health and safety
- Daily housekeeping
Reviews of The Pridwin Hotel
9.4
Wonderful
174 verified ratings
Wonderful
85
Very good
24
Good
20
Okay
21
Fair
13
Mediocre
8
Poor
3
Summary of reviews
Guests say
Guests appreciated the hotel's great location and cleanliness, highlighting the beautiful views and well-maintained facilities. However, some reviews pointed out issues with service, mentioning inexperienced staff and a lack of responsiveness. Overall, the hotel offers a charming atmosphere and enjoyable amenities, making it a pleasant stay for many.AI-Generated from customer reviews
Reviews(1)
Q&A(5)
Tips(10)
Sort by:Most recent
Score by provider
9.4 out of 10
151 reviews
10 out of 10
2 reviews
10 out of 10
1 review
All reviews
The questions and answers provided in this section are generated by an artificial intelligence model based on a summarization of user hotel reviews and hotel information.See more
They offer insights and recommendations from previous guests and hotel information to help future visitors enhance their stay at the hotel.
What can I expect from the hotel's breakfast?
The breakfast is included and is praised for its delicious options, although some guests have mentioned that they would have preferred a la carte choices.
Are the rooms clean and well-maintained?
The hotel is well designed, furnished, and landscaped, and is very clean, although some guests have mentioned that the room was small but clean.
How is the hotel's customer service?
The staff is described as fantastic, warm, and friendly, although a few guests have mentioned poor customer service and slow check-in.
What activities are available at the hotel?
The hotel offers a variety of amenities, including paddle boards, kayaks, bikes, ping pong, and tennis, as well as a private pool and a tennis club.
Is parking available at the hotel?
Yes, there is free parking available at the hotel.
The questions and answers provided in this section are generated by an artificial intelligence model based on a summarization of user hotel reviews and hotel information.See more
They offer insights and recommendations from previous guests and hotel information to help future visitors enhance their stay at the hotel.
Book a Room with a View
Several guests mentioned that the views from the rooms were spectacular. Opting for a room with a balcony facing the water comes highly recommended.
Enjoy the Complimentary Activities
Take advantage of the complimentary paddle boards, kayaks, and single speed bikes provided by the hotel for a fun and active experience.
Check Out the Wednesday Night Cookouts
Guests enjoyed the live music and locally caught fish at the Wednesday Night Cookouts. It's a great way to experience the local cuisine and entertainment.
Consider Cottage Accommodation
If you prefer more privacy and a cozy atmosphere, consider staying in one of the cottages, which offer options with fireplaces and views of the water.
Explore Nearby Attractions
The hotel's convenient location allows easy access to nearby attractions such as the Shelter Island Country Club, Union Chapel, Sylvester Manor, and Gardiner's Bay Country Club.
Be Mindful of Breakfast Options
Some guests found the breakfast options limited and suggested having more a la carte choices. Consider exploring nearby dining options for breakfast if you prefer more variety.
Take Advantage of Resort Amenities
The hotel offers a range of amenities including a private pool, tennis club, and game room. Make sure to allocate time to enjoy these facilities during your stay.
Plan for Slow Check-In
Some guests experienced slow check-in processes, so it's advisable to plan accordingly, especially during peak times.
Consider Transportation Costs
Keep in mind that the ferry to the island can be expensive, so factor this into your overall budget when planning your stay.
Inquire About Weekly Activities
Guests noted that they did not receive information about weekly activities until shortly before their departure. It's recommended to inquire about available activities upon check-in to make the most of your stay.
Location
81 Shore Road, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11964
What's nearby
- Shelter Island Country Club1 mi
- Union Chapel1.3 mi
- Sylvester Manor1.9 mi
- Gardiner's Bay Country Club2.9 mi
Policies
Check-in/Check-out | Check in anytime after 4:00 PM, check out anytime before 11:00 AM |
|---|---|
Cancellation/prepayment | Cancellation/prepayment policies vary by room type and provider. |
Essential information about The Pridwin Hotel
Low season | March |
|---|---|
High season | August |
Average price (weeknight) | $691 |
Average price (weekend night) | $956 |
When to book a room at The Pridwin Hotel
Price per night. Prices are not fixed and may vary with time.
Average nightly price per month
Average nightly price
KAYAK's top tips for your stay at The Pridwin Hotel
FAQs when booking at The Pridwin Hotel
Nearby hotels and places to stay
Closest
See more nearby staysMost recommended
See most recommended stays in Shelter Island HeightsGood to know
Value for money | 8.4 |
|---|---|
Distance to city center | 1.4 mi |
Nearest Airport | Tweed-New Haven |
Distance to airport | 29.8 mi |
Everything you need to know for your stay in Shelter Island Heights
Complete your trip
Popular destinations