Shelter Island Heights hotels

KAYAK searches hundreds of travel sites at once for hotels in Shelter Island Heights, New York

Here is why travelers choose KAYAK

Free to useThere are no hidden charges or fees.

Filter your dealsFilter by free cancellation, free breakfast and more.

Millions of reviewsCheck ratings based on millions of real guest reviews.

Bundle and saveSave money when you bundle your flight + hotel.

Recommended by KAYAK
Useful Info
Recommended by KAYAK

Best Shelter Island Heights hotels

Discover the best prices by selecting your travel dates on KAYAK.

Most recommended Shelter Island Heights hotels

Show all
The Chequit - Shelter Island Heights - Bedroom
The Chequit
Shelter Island Heights, NY
9.0Wonderful(56)
Parking
Free Wi-Fi
Pet friendly
$361+
Check availability
The Pridwin Hotel - Shelter Island Heights - Living room
The Pridwin Hotel
Shelter Island Heights, NY
9.4Wonderful(178)
Parking
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
$396+
Check availability
Sound View Greenport - Greenport - Dining room
Sound View Greenport
Greenport, NY
8.1Very good(471)
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
Pet friendly
$321+
Check availability
Hotel Moraine - Greenport - Building
Hotel Moraine
Greenport, NY
9.5Wonderful(27)
Parking
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
Pet friendly
$493+
Check availability
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows - Greenport - Bedroom
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows
Greenport, NY
9.6Wonderful(48)
Parking
Free Wi-Fi
$223+
Check availability
The Blue Inn at North Fork - East Marion - Building
The Blue Inn at North Fork
East Marion, NY
8.4Very good(213)
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
Pet friendly
$111+
Check availability
Holiday Inn Long Island - Islip Arpt East - Holtsville - Bedroom
Holiday Inn Long Island - Islip Arpt East
Holtsville, NY
8.7Very good(833)
Parking
Airport shuttle
Free Wi-Fi
$135+
Check availability
Courtyard by Marriott Long Island MacArthur Airport - Ronkonkoma - Bar
Courtyard by Marriott Long Island MacArthur Airport
Ronkonkoma, NY
8.4Very good(260)
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
$162+
Check availability
Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Holtsville - Holtsville - Lounge
Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Holtsville
Holtsville, NY
8.3Very good(319)
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
Pet friendly
$150+
Check availability
La Quinta Inn & Suites by Wyndham Islip - MacArthur Airport - Bohemia - Lounge
La Quinta Inn & Suites by Wyndham Islip - MacArthur Airport
Bohemia, NY
6.4Okay(1624)
Parking
Airport shuttle
Free Wi-Fi
Pet friendly
$112+
Check availability
The Menhaden Hotel - Greenport - Bar
The Menhaden Hotel
Greenport, NY
9.2Wonderful(89)
Parking
Free Wi-Fi
Pet friendly
$437+
Check availability
Greenporter Hotel - Greenport - Lobby
Greenporter Hotel
Greenport, NY
7.9Good(193)
$190+
Check availability
Holiday Inn Express Stony Brook-Long Island - Centereach - Bedroom
Holiday Inn Express Stony Brook-Long Island
Centereach, NY
8.4Very good(570)
Parking
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
$179+
Check availability
Dering Harbor Inn - Shelter Island
Dering Harbor Inn
Shelter Island, NY
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
$8+
Check availability
The Skybreeze Inn - Bohemia
The Skybreeze Inn
Bohemia, NY
5.7Fair(193)
Parking
Free Wi-Fi
$101+
Check availability
Townsend Manor Inn - Greenport
Townsend Manor Inn
Greenport, NY
7.2Good(172)
Free Wi-Fi
$162+
Check availability

Popular filters in Shelter Island Heights hotels

Hotels with parking
The Chequit, The Pridwin Hotel and others
Find stays
Go to map

Search by stars

2+ stars3+ stars4+ stars

Search by review score

6+ Okay7+ Good8+ Great9+ Excellent

Search by price

$8 - $156$156 - $304$304 - $452$452 - $599$599+ per night

Search by freebies

Free cancellationFree breakfastFree parkingFree internet
Useful Info

KAYAK’s insights for hotels in Shelter Island Heights

Discover seasonal trends, ideal booking windows, and other data-driven tips to plan your stay in Shelter Island Heights with confidence.

What is the cheapest day of the week to book a hotel in Shelter Island Heights?

Wednesday offers the lowest rates in Shelter Island Heights, with an average nightly price of $385. The highest prices are found on Friday, with average rates at $1,088.

How much is a hotel in Shelter Island Heights for tonight?

The best deal for a 3-star hotel room in Shelter Island Heights found by KAYAK users in the last 3 days was $562, while a 4-star hotel the lowest price was $424. The cheapest room found overall was for $424.

How much is a hotel in Shelter Island Heights for this weekend?

The cheapest hotel room in Shelter Island Heights for the upcoming weekend found on KAYAK in the last 3 days was for $656 per night. For the same dates, 3-star hotel rooms have been found for as low as $690 per night and 4-star hotel rooms from $656 per night.
Find deals

Good to know

Low season

May

High season

July

Average price (weeknight)

$387

Average price (weekend night)

$531
Cheapest month to stay with an average 31% drop in price.
Most expensive month to stay with an average 87% rise in price.
Average Sun - Thu price over the last 2 weeks.
Average Fri & Sat price over the last 2 weeks.

KAYAK's top tips for finding Shelter Island Heights hotel deals

  • The cheapest 3-star hotel room in Islip found on KAYAK in the last 2 weeks was $557, while the most expensive was $746.
  • How long should you stay? KAYAK users usually book their hotel in Islip for 1 day.

FAQs when booking a hotel in Shelter Island Heights

  • What are the best hotels near Shelter Island Country Club?

    The Chequit, West Neck Guesthouse and Seven - a boutique B&B on Shelter Island are very popular with users who want to stay within walking distance of Shelter Island Country Club.

  • How do I find a hotel in central Shelter Island Heights?

    After you launch a hotel search on KAYAK, you can refine your research by neighborhood, which allows you to pick the central Shelter Island Heights districts. You can also do a search using the city map to choose a specific location, like Shelter Island Heights city center.

  • How can I find hotels near me?

    Take a look at our extensive hotel map to find the best hotels near you.

  • Are there Shelter Island Heights hotels with free parking?

    There are many hotels in Shelter Island Heights that offer both parking and free parking. Popular choices among KAYAK users include The Chequit, The Pridwin Hotel and Hotel Moraine.

Where to stay in Shelter Island Heights?

Our map will help you find the perfect place to stay in Shelter Island Heights by showing you the exact location of each hotel.

Everything you need to know for your stay in Shelter Island Heights

Shelter Island Heights Hotel Deals. Search and compare hotels in Shelter Island Heights. Find cheap hotel rooms in Shelter Island Heights. KAYAK searches hundreds of travel sites to help you find cheap hotels and book the room that suits you best.

Not what you’re looking for? Find thousands of other hotels, airline tickets, car rentals and package deals with KAYAK.