Shelter Island motels
Mon 4/22
Fri 4/26
Search hundreds of travel sites at once for motels in Shelter Island
...and more
Let KAYAK do the searching
Best Shelter Island motels
Most recommended Shelter Island motels
Southold Beach Motel
$221+
$221+
Parking
Free Wi-Fi
$471+
Parking
Free Wi-Fi
Good to know
Low season | October |
|---|---|
High season | August |
Average price (weeknight) | $369 |
Average price (weekend night) | $276 |
When to book a motel in Shelter Island
Price per night / 3-star motel. Prices are not fixed and may vary with time.
Average nightly price per month
Average nightly price
Top tips for finding Shelter Island motel deals
- If you’re looking for a cheap motel in Shelter Island, you should consider going during the low season. You’ll generally find lower-priced motels in Shelter Island in October and June.
- Motel room prices vary depending on many factors but you’ll likely find the best motel deals in Shelter Island if you stay on a Thursday. The most expensive day for motel bookings is Sunday.
- If you want to ensure you grab a bargain, try to book more than 90 days before your stay to get the best price for a Shelter Island motel.
- The cheapest 3-star motel in Islip found on KAYAK in the last 2 weeks was $184, while the most expensive was $270.
- Don’t know how much time you need to see all the sights? KAYAK users usually book their motel in Islip for 1 day.
Where to find the best motels in Shelter Island?
Our map will help you find the perfect motel in Shelter Island by showing you the exact location of each motel.