Find cheap flights from Peoria to Caribbean Islands

Find cheap flights from Peoria to Caribbean Islands

Round-trip
Economy
Peoria (PIA)
Caribbean Islands
Tue 3/2
Tue 3/9
Any month
Compare vs. KAYAK |
Search hundreds of travel sites at once for deals on flights to Caribbean Islands

Good to know

Low season

January Best time to beat the crowds with an average 4% drop in price.

High season

December Most popular time to fly with an average 5% increase in price.

Average price round-trip

$706 (avg. price over the last 2 weeks)

Good deal round-trip

$469 or less

Good deal one-way

$311 or less

Top tips for finding cheap flights to Caribbean Islands

  • Book at least 2 weeks before departure in order to get a below-average price.
  • High season is considered to be November and December. The cheapest month to fly to Caribbean Islands is August.
  • Morning departure is around 31% more expensive than an evening flight, on average*.
*Average of the lowest prices shown in KAYAK’s search results for departures within the next 30 days

FAQs - booking Caribbean Islands flights

How long is the flight to Caribbean Islands from Peoria?

How does KAYAK find such low prices on flights to Caribbean Islands?

How does KAYAK's flight Price Forecast tool help me choose the right time to buy my flight ticket from Peoria to Caribbean Islands?

What is the Hacker Fare option on flights to Caribbean Islands?

What is KAYAK's "flexible dates" feature and why should I care when looking for a flight to Caribbean Islands?

Top airlines flying Greater Peoria to Caribbean Islands

Scores according to KAYAK customer reviews

7.2
American Airlines
Overall score based on 45,155 reviews
7.5
Boarding
7.1
Comfort
7.8
Crew
6.8
Entertainment
6.7
Food
Airline reviews

Pros: "The price."
Cons: "Flight was delayed for 2 hours in Airbus 777 full of passengers. The reason was to fix some light and administrative error on a log book. This could have been prevented if they had done all of the checks beforehand. All of those passengers stuck in a plane during a pandemic. Not very smart !!!!"

Pros: "On time take off and the fact that we arrived alive."
Cons: "Hot meals and inflight entertainment. No even drinks were served."

Pros: "Great service and comfortable; well sanitized."
Cons: "TV screens for movies and shows."

Cons: "Almost 4 hour delay."

Pros: "Crew was snappy in getting people in plane and checking in carry ons since occupancy had been reached."
Cons: "Lack of adjustable headrest on seat."

Pros: "Smooth ride"

Cons: "Feeling of being cramped"

Cons: "Todo bien"

Pros: "Service from crew was fine"
Cons: "No delay! Got notification that our flight was one half hour earlier. Then boarded aircraft, and it had electrical problems. Delayed. We had to get off. Then board another aircraft."

Pros: "Checking in with my Mum who needs assistance was excellent."
Cons: "Lack of Entertainment."

Pros: "Time of flight"
Cons: "Aircraft had no screen, old, uncomfortable"

Cons: "Crampt space, cold cabin"

Pros: "None"
Cons: "Long delay"

Pros: "Movie options were good."
Cons: "The a/c was not working well and t"

Pros: "Reliability that your flight will not be cancelled. Punctuality."
Cons: "They charge you $125 for a dog in cabin (JetBlue and Southwest near $100, Frontier $75). There is NO benefit, even with this extra amount of money. I was assigned to enter the aircraft in Group 8... I suggest AA the benefit to enter (at least) in Group 5 for people with PAID in cabin dogs."

Pros: "Service"
Cons: "Seats and space"

Cons: "Entertainment via internet could NEVER be really be done complitly. And the flight attendants did not know how to help costumers"

Pros: "Turkey sandwich snd boarding went smoothly"
Cons: "There was no entertainment and since there is no WiFi for most of the flight due to being over water the flight seemed longer than what it actually was."

Cons: "Poor service"

Pros: "I liked that we got to San Juan safely. The crew on board was very accommodating."
Cons: "Due to the delays, we missed our jumper flight and American refused to compensate. Also, only had two cookies all day from 8:05am until 3:45 pm! No sandwiches as promised. We were delayed approximately 4 hours total. Had to take a taxi ($85) to Fajardo to HOPEFULLY catch last ferry to Culebra. Guess AmericansAirlines doesn’t care if you have to sleep at the dock!"

Cons: "Dallas to San Juan San Juan Dallas American Airlines has the worst seat of any airline flown by us fare almost 2000 dollars for round trip and the seat is small hard uncomfortable even for a short flight this is no business class!!"

Pros: "On time"
Cons: "Cold cabin"

Cons: "The seats are very tight."

Cons: "Last minute cancellation and reschedule if original flight with 20 people hounding the gate for standby status. Craziness. These last minute revisions mist stop"

Pros: "Direct flight"
Cons: "Horrible customer service, excessive baggage fees, rude counter staff, no leg room, narrow seats"

Pros: "USB Outlets are nice to have"
Cons: "Nothing was bad on this flight"

Pros: "Boarding process"
Cons: "Delay, no food,"

Pros: "Schedule was punctual. The entertainment was superb. Good crew. The overhead bins were, for some reason, larger which aided the boarding process."
Cons: "I guess the lack of snack options but that is just the way it is nowadays."

Pros: "Can't think of anything good"
Cons: "SEE: Customer Relations request #1-249830721"

Pros: "Nice crew clean airplane"
Cons: "Initial flight was cancelled after 2 hours delay. My next flight was scheduled the earliest possible by AA which was 24 hours later. No transportation,hotel or miles compensation for this. I had work and responsabilities the next day. TThe scheduled trip was supposed to take off at 7:45. Boarding started late and was very slow. My bag fit the meassurements and still was forced to check it (which I did not want to do as I did not want to be waiting an hour for my bag at my arrival as I had work early the next day. In addition there was airplaine traffic as it was "rush hour" instead of flying at 7:45 we departed almost at 9pm!!!! Have to pay for food Quality of tv monitors very poor And in an uncomfortable position No movie options No wifi although stated the aircraft has Non functioning electrical plug"

Pros: "On time smooth"

Pros: "The pilot was a riot, the flight was on time. Again, nothing wrong, nothing special. As it should be (if only we had more leg and seat room, and I am pretty streamline)."

Pros: "Friendly staff. Landed early. Offered a free bag."
Cons: "They moved the flight earlier, which was not fun. And, there were no entertainment centers."

Pros: "Nothing"
Cons: "Super old planes, no had a tv."

Pros: "Puntuality"

Cons: "There seets are two small. And they dont sell alcohol. That sucks."

Cons: "The plane had mechanical problems and was rescheduled to a different flight"

Cons: "The airline had trouble with the plane. After we waited 3 hrs in the plane they cancel the flight. They offer a hotel but it was very dirty"

Pros: "Nothing. My fight from San Juan to Miami on Friday Oct. 7 was cancelled because of hurricane Matthews, since I didnot buy a roundtrip with AA they did not reimburse or offer me a credit for my returning flight. I contacted AA in two ocassions and both times their personnel were impersonal and even rude to me with the whole situation. I ended up losing $250 because of choosing American Airlines. I will do my best to avoid traveling with American ever again, and I will spread the word, as well. I felt robbed, so unfair."
Cons: "Everything"

Cons: "No have owned screen TV"

Pros: "Even when the plane was full they managed to help passengers to get seated."
Cons: "If you still flying economy class, why would you have to pay extra for exit row where the seats are the same. Only received pretzel and a cup of drink on a 3 hour flight once."

Pros: "Everything"
Cons: "Nothing"

Pros: "Comfortable seat"
Cons: "Lack of entertainment"

Pros: "Overall good flight"
Cons: "I did not like the time needed for boarding/ settling in. But that is a factor of people not following instructions. Not the crew."

Pros: "I was going home"
Cons: "Late flight no pilots andt broke my luggage."

Cons: "Gg"

Pros: "Everything was on time, no delays."

Pros: "Should have individual tv's like jet blue does. There shoul be a family travel area for people travelin with todlers. better service and better food. Faster luggage pick up."
Cons: "Nothing. Expesive flights, an unprofessional flight attendant name Sarah, fighting with the customers. No entertainment. It was a nightmare"

Pros: "I live the service which make me feel good. Also the flight was very quiet and the crew help me in everything I asked."

Pros: "The food options and that we were offered drinks multiple times."
Cons: "Nothing! It was excellent"

Pros: "Nothing"
Cons: "Not having so many delay and not seating on a plane for over an hour to take off."

Pros: "Friendly crew"
Cons: "Leaving crying babies at home..."

Pros: "Crew was very nice!!"
Cons: "Space on seat not comfortable for tall people"

Cons: "Seats could have been better. Very uncomfortable seats"

Pros: "Nothing"
Cons: "Plane on time and it was very hot on the plane"

Cons: "Again, left stranded in SC."

Pros: "The crew was helpful and nice."
Cons: "It was delayed a lot."

Pros: "Comfortable seats with a touch screen with plenty to choose from to entertain. Updates from the cockpit often. Good music as we boarded and exited the plane to set the mood. Very attentive staff. Would love to fly with United again, soon."

Pros: "Crew was very nice"
Cons: "Sits are very uncomfortable"

Pros: "All in the prices!!! Accesibility!!!"
Cons: "The prices changes too much!"

Pros: "Nothing"
Cons: "I'm supposed to bring a carry on with me and they don't allowed me this time. They should be strict with other passengers who bring more than a carry on. I was SO MADDD"

Cons: "we took off over 1 hour late"

Pros: "Services , on time"

Pros: "All the way we had a great atencion from all the crew and airport facility thanks"

Cons: "See above."

Pros: "They gave me something to drink..."
Cons: "Didn't give us peanuts or any snack items and everything else had to be paid for which I think the pricing on those items were expensive that is abusive unacceptable and me as a military personnel I think there should be some kind of consideration in all those matters including paying for luggage $25..."

Pros: "Great service, it had been a while since I flew with United. Impressed with the new plane."

Pros: "clean; good movies"
Cons: "no kosher food option"

Pros: "Estaba supuesto ser un viaje barato y puntual"
Cons: "Pero no fue de esa manera yo soy un paciente esquizofrénico y padezco de vipolarida más tengo problema con el azúcar mas padezco de sleeping adnnea.y muchas otras condiciones.y mi vuelo no salió cuando. Tenía que salir.yo vivo en perth ambos y era muy difícil viajar para Mi en tren para luego tener que pasar todo lo que pase.deverian por lo menos recomendarme con algo desierta por todos mis inconvenientes."

Pros: "On time and comfort"

Cons: "My seat was the last line and it was uncomfortable."

Cons: "Not a crew or airline issue, but strong winds made for three attempted landings."

Pros: "That i had all four seat available to me and very helpful"

Pros: "Was fast and on time"
Cons: "Pushing back from gate took for ever due to mechanical problems and somebody got sick on the plane so their decision to wait until the person situation got better affected everyone else"

Pros: "very helpful"

Pros: "The service & how comfortable I was."
Cons: "That you have to pay for everything but I guess now a days every airline is doing the same thing."

Cons: "Thr boarding process was a mess, a lot of people didn't even have seats assigned."

Pros: "The personal are very amability"

Pros: "Love the crew!"

Pros: "Smooth ride and on time staff was great"
Cons: "I didn't like that I had to pay for my luggage that was really horrible they find anywhere to nickel and dime you but glad they let mine be a carry on"

Pros: "Delay, delay, delay"

Cons: "The delays was horrible!!"

Pros: "Fast and easy boarding"
Cons: "No tv, no , no magazines"

Pros: "United personal quickly found our bag location and made the arraingement to send it to us ASAP."
Cons: "The fact that the only bag we checked in with the airline did not arrived in our plane with out any warning what so ever."

Pros: "On time, friendly crew and very reliable"
Cons: "Where's the food?? Gas prices have dropped significantly but all airlines still skimp on food, charge for bags and tickets are still pricey"

Pros: "Everything was perfect, the crew was fantastic"
Cons: "Maybe a bit of food."

Cons: "The airline is horrible.. Poor customer service"

Pros: "Boarding"
Cons: "Excellent"

Pros: "The service since I am handicap"

Pros: "Nothing"
Cons: "Horrible phone customer serviceI."

Cons: "Comfortable and affordable!"

Pros: "What I like the most was that it was on time, also the crew was amicable."

Pros: "Very organized . On time"

Pros: "Everything! My grandparents needed special assistance with wheelchair and the crew was very helpful! They spoke Spanish and they were able to get a crew member to translate"

Pros: "Good trip"
Cons: "Nothing"

Cons: "They did not have TV and no wifi it was terrible. They only gave me a cup of soda nos even a potato chips which other airline do give."

Pros: "Getting from point a to point b."
Cons: "Lack of good free snacks. Not getting free bag checked."

Pros: "All very happy staff and super professional service."

Pros: "Boarding process"
Cons: "No food... Sporadic drinks.. Very cheap service"

Read more about American Airlines
COVID-19 information

Safety measures for airlines flying from Peoria to Caribbean Islands

Airlines flying from Peoria to Caribbean Islands have enacted additional safety measures and adjusted policies to better accommodate travelers. Policies vary by airline.

Heightened sanitation

Daily cleaning, installation of cabin HEPA filters on flights from Peoria to Caribbean Islands

Mandatory masks

Masks required on board, masks provided on flights from Peoria to Caribbean Islands

Social distancing seating

Middle seats unavailable to book on flights from Peoria to Caribbean Islands

Pre-flight testing

Testing for antibodies, testing for symptoms for flights from Peoria to Caribbean Islands

Book cheap flights from Peoria to Caribbean Islands

Recent round-trip flight deals

3/30
Tue
2 stops
American Airlines
15h 43m
PIA - SJU
4/6
Tue
2 stops
American Airlines
17h 38m
SJU - PIA
5/17
Mon
2 stops
American Airlines
12h 38m
PIA - SJU
5/24
Mon
2 stops
American Airlines
21h 00m
SJU - PIA
5/3
Mon
2 stops
American Airlines
19h 51m
PIA - SJU
5/7
Fri
2 stops
American Airlines
16h 21m
SJU - PIA
4/9
Fri
2 stops
American Airlines
19h 51m
PIA - SJU
4/13
Tue
2 stops
American Airlines
17h 38m
SJU - PIA
4/17
Sat
2 stops
United Airlines
15h 08m
PIA - SJU
4/24
Sat
2 stops
United Airlines
16h 26m
SJU - PIA
5/13
Thu
2 stops
United Airlines
15h 49m
PIA - STT
5/19
Wed
2 stops
United Airlines
21h 46m
STT - PIA
5/10
Mon
2 stops
American Airlines
13h 32m
PIA - STT
5/17
Mon
2 stops
American Airlines
21h 06m
STT - PIA
3/27
Sat
2 stops
American Airlines
31h 12m
PIA - SJU
3/31
Wed
2 stops
American Airlines
16h 01m
SJU - PIA
3/30
Tue
1 stop
American Airlines
14h 26m
PIA - SJU
4/6
Tue
2 stops
American Airlines
13h 26m
SJU - PIA
5/10
Mon
1 stop
American Airlines
26h 18m
PIA - STT
5/17
Mon
2 stops
American Airlines
21h 06m
STT - PIA
5/3
Mon
2 stops
American Airlines
12h 37m
PIA - SJU
5/8
Sat
1 stop
American Airlines
11h 32m
SJU - PIA
5/17
Mon
2 stops
American Airlines
15h 38m
PIA - SJU
5/23
Sun
1 stop
American Airlines
14h 31m
SJU - PIA
3/27
Sat
2 stops
American Airlines
31h 12m
PIA - SJU
3/31
Wed
1 stop
American Airlines
17h 40m
SJU - PIA
4/17
Sat
1 stop
American Airlines
24h 12m
PIA - SJU
4/24
Sat
2 stops
American Airlines
17h 38m
SJU - PIA
4/17
Sat
3 stops
Multiple Airlines
32h 08m
PIA - SJU
4/24
Sat
3 stops
Multiple Airlines
30h 18m
SJU - PIA
3/30
Tue
2 stops
United Airlines
12h 11m
PIA - SJU
4/5
Mon
2 stops
United Airlines
16h 26m
SJU - PIA
3/30
Tue
1 stop
United Airlines
12h 06m
PIA - SJU
4/5
Mon
2 stops
United Airlines
16h 26m
SJU - PIA
3/19
Fri
2 stops
United Airlines
27h 39m
PIA - STT
3/20
Sat
2 stops
United Airlines
30h 04m
STT - PIA
3/30
Tue
3 stops
Multiple Airlines
28h 13m
PIA - SJU
4/6
Tue
3 stops
Multiple Airlines
36h 57m
SJU - PIA
3/27
Sat
3 stops
Multiple Airlines
19h 02m
PIA - SJU
3/31
Wed
3 stops
Multiple Airlines
39h 12m
SJU - PIA
Show more results

Recent one-way flight deals

4/3
Sat
2 stops
United Airlines
17h 15m
PIA - SJU
4/3
Sat
1 stop
American Airlines
9h 16m
PIA - SJU
4/3
Sat
3 stops
United Airlines
18h 59m
PIA - SJU
-
1
  • Round-trip
  • One-way
  • Multi-city
  • Trip Builder
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
  • Multiple
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First