Find cheap flights from Islip to New York

Search hundreds of travel sites at once for deals on flights to New York. Bundle your flight + hotel and save!

ISP — NYC
May 26 — Jun 21
Round-trip
1 adult
Economy
0 bags
From?
To?
Thu 5/26
Thu 6/2

When to book flights from Islip to New York

Estimated round-trip price
Average price per month
Flight prices as travel date approaches

Top tips for finding a cheap flight

  • Morning departure is around 51% cheaper than an evening flight, on average*.
*Average of the lowest prices shown in KAYAK’s search results for departures within the next 30 days

FAQs for booking flights from Islip to New York

Top airlines flying Islip Long Island to New York

Scores according to KAYAK customer reviews
7.2
American AirlinesOverall score based on 47703 reviews
7.5Boarding
7.1Comfort
7.9Crew
6.9Entertainment
6.7Food
Airline reviews
Pros: "Nothing"
Cons: "Nothing"
Read more about American Airlines
Pros: "Nothing"
Cons: "Nothing"
Pros: "Special assistance readily available"
Cons: "The weather"
Cons: "A tv on plane"
Pros: "nothing"
Cons: "delayed almost 5 hours due to “air traffic,” flight had plenty of room and they did not offer any upgrades"
Cons: "Baggage handler lost my bag, grabbed it off plane cabin, never found"
Cons: "Too freakin cold."
Cons: "No personal entertainment system. Has to use my phone."
Pros: "Seats were pretty comfortable. We were allowed to deplane down a staircase off the back of the plane. Very cool."
Cons: "N/A"
Cons: "There crew was not welcoming nor understanding of the passengers' frustrations caused by the delays. There was no air-conditioning on the flight, no air circulation to speak of. No food was served due to turbulence or so we were told."
Pros: "no"
Cons: "on time departure"
Pros: "The crew were nice people."
Cons: "There was no air conditioning and we were re-routed all the way down to Kentucky on the way back!"
Pros: "Everything. The entertainment was ok. I think a movie would be better than the shows"
Cons: "if I would’ve been in first :)"
Cons: "Delayed"
Cons: "The seats could be bigger."
Cons: "Everything was fine, crew was great, but the wifi entertainment system is a joke. Its nice to allow passengers to connect and watch movies or shows, however, when trying to watch a movie it constantly buffers. More buffering then watching, to the point of just stopping and skipping it all together."
Pros: "Knowing what carousel luggage was at - I suppose."
Cons: "Extended wait times in taxi departing and landing - took over an hour longer than expected. LaGuardia airport forced passengers to take their car services by walking outside and waiting in a parking garage with (12 degree Fahrenheit feels like -4 and 20 mph winds). Felt frostbite, couldn’t move fingers, and have a sinus headache. absolutely appalling this is NY and USA - yet we can’t have car services pick up pasengers outside the door of the airport, instead require to walk 7 minutes and stand in a freezing air tunnel airport garage. Changes my mind on flying to LAGUARDIA in the future"
Pros: "Comfortable seats and snack / drinks service"
Cons: "Delayed flight departure and bumpy landing"
Pros: "Plane too cold hard to sleep, no blankets or pillows"
Cons: "late cold plane"
Pros: "Wi-Fi was adequate"
Cons: "I paid extra for a better seat, but it still felt cramped. The tray was crooked and I had no priority boarding."
Cons: "Flight cancelled and had to travel 60 miles at my expense to a different airport to get another flight same day"
Pros: "Legroom"
Cons: "Snacks, non usable Wi-Fi"
Cons: "Our last 6 flights have all been changed or delayed significantly. Then they loose our bags on a direct flight. Won’t fly America airlines again!"
Cons: "Time consuming during check in. Was not allowed to do the pre check in, so arrived to airport, waited around 20 minutes to check in, including my luggage. After that, had to wait around 45 minutes to drop my suitcase. After that, process was good and efficient. Plane left on time LIMA to Miami, and then Miami to NYC."
Pros: "We had to wait in the airplane upon arrival in La Guardia NY because wheelchair was not ready."
Pros: "i like the wifi internet that AA provided. Great movies"
Cons: "The flight attendants were highly rude and i felt as if i was discriminated on. I was sitting in the back and the flight attendant who was suppose to assist us made us feel like i was a bother to her. First of all she just rudly dropped biscuits on my table didnt ask if i wanted and then I had to ask her for coffee, she didnt ask me if i wanted something to drink. Finally she brought my daughter and I some coffee. i ask for sugar and she said im very busy you have to wait....eventually she gave me one packet of sugar. I had to ask for another sugar for my daughter , so when i ask she gets upset and tells me i have to wait but there as a white who ask for assistance and she was very polite to her."
Cons: "I am missing two items that I had in my checked bag and my clothes and belongings were all messy as if it had been gone through. I am very upset that these items were likely taken by whoever went through my bag."
Cons: "Boarded the plane and had to wait on the runway for almost 3 hours after being delayed at the gate. Absolutely horrible with no compensation for our time whatsoever."
Cons: "Late late cancelled chaos in reassignment late late One agent threw up hands said I'm done and left with long line of passengers not yet reassigned Person behind me asked why didn't we take Delta?"
Pros: "Arrived to the airport well ahead of time and encountered lines so long that we were not able to make our flight. Only 2 attendants working and so many people had to be rebooked we didn't get another flight for 3 days. Did I mention I was traveling with a baby?"
Pros: "Full meal service, friendly and helpful crew, checkin agent went above and beyond to get us checked in even though we were late in getting to the airport."
Cons: "Ancient plane with old, uncomfortable seats and no in-seat entertainment. AA should warn customers when booking these old planes."
Cons: "Everything was great."
Pros: "Nothing"
Cons: "Both flights, to and from around had to go search for my baggage and on the return flight I even had to go to a different terminal. The service is unacceptable. I will never fly with AA again."
Pros: "It was good fly can't complaint the attention was great"
Cons: "When I was flying to Arkansas from NY they didn't give anything to eat"
Pros: "Nothing"
Cons: "Poor customer service and late departures."
Pros: "Also quick and painless flight"
Cons: "Flight attendants where kind of rude."
Cons: "I paid extra money to sit in the front of the plane due to traveling with my dog... when I looked at my boarding pass I realized I was sitting in the last row of the plane ... the cabin was booked and they could not move my seat! Really upsetting and frustrating!"
Pros: "On time departure/early arrival"
Cons: "Boarding g process a bit chaotic"
Cons: "The crew was late arriving to the gate which delayed boarding and then the plane had an electrical problem that could not be quickly fixed so had to deplane, go to another gate and board another plane. We were an hour and a half late leaving."
Pros: "the flight was on time coming and going"
Cons: "Once again the boarding process was a mess. No clear directions given on when groups should board so everyone from every group bombarded the gate. This slowed down finding overhead bin space and getting seated for everybody. Delayed everything when there was such an easy solution."
Pros: "The gate crew in Roanoke were professional and helpful. The next day's flight was on time and uneventful."
Cons: "The flight attendant was unfriendly at boarding. He did not say or play any pre-flight safety announcements. We were told the flight might have to refuel in Richmond due to major weather delays in LGA. When we were landing they said they expected a refuel and a quick turnaround in Richmond. On the plane after landing, I learned via my phone's internet the flight was cancelled. They never announced it on the plane. At the final moment before we disembarked, the crew told us to be sure to take our belongings. When we landed, Flightaware showed delays of 45 minutes at LGA. AA never took responsibility for the problem though the gate crew mentioned they canceled the flight because the crew was going to be over their maximum hours. AA really couldn't plan to allow for up to an hour delay? I feel disrespected and even deceived. Although it was clear that flight attendant really needed to get off that plane. At the gate, we were told there were no available flights to NYC and were stranded overnight in Richmond. AA did offer a hotel pretending it was a courtesy since they claimed the problem was weather related and not theirs. We chose to stay with relatives and were told AA could only provide transportation from the airport which we did not need. We often have problems and cancellations on this route from when it was branded a US Air route to the present, but this was egregious."
Pros: "Flight crew very welcoming, flight was pleasant."
Cons: "Seating a bit tight. Didn't offer any snacks only ice water."
Cons: "Refer to above. Both flights were horrible."
Cons: "Everyone excellent"
Pros: "boarding was in time, and comfort."
Cons: "comfort was very good"
Cons: "Not flying."
Pros: "On time"
Cons: "No refreshments"
Pros: "Everything!"
Pros: "Staff was pleasant"

Was traveling with a family of 4 with 2 toddlers on a Friday afternoon, the flight was on time and the staff was professional, will fly again!

Although we also had a 3 hour delay. The flight was pleasant. The pilot was amazing. We had a lot of turbulence but the pilot seemed to know what he was doing.

On the mike they said if you can breathe it means your not wearing your mask properly

Nice flight. Seats are very uncomfortable though

It was good experience

The flight was on time and the crew was excellent.

Pros: "Nice crew and flight was mostly on time."
Cons: "I had to pay double my ticket price in hidden fees - very frustrating and unexpected. Also, no drinks/snacks on board and no entertainment."
Pros: "Nothing"
Cons: "The crew, the turbulence, the screaming kids, the rude people yelling across rows CONSTANTLY, at each other"
Cons: "Clean, comfortable plane. Smooth ride. Departed on time, arrived ahead of time:)"
Cons: "Awful flight and experience in general. Totally enjoyed being surrounded by individuals vomiting"
Cons: "The fees for the baggage are ridiculous"
Cons: "For budget airline it’s awesome. Couldn’t ask more"
Pros: "I was in row 2 and it had reclining seats."
Cons: "They did not have enough people to push wheelchairs at Mac Arthur airport. My husband had to push me & since we don’t know the airport we had to ask every step we went, they had no signs leading the way."
Cons: "Never happened, the flight was cancelled and never rebooked."
Cons: "The flight was delayed, it was a mess."
Pros: "We finally made it to the destination"
Cons: "the flight was delayed more than once. and it seems to be common on this route"
Pros: "The anouncements in Islip explaining the boarding process and warning people about bringing carry ons that they did not pay for were clear, loud and understandable. Crew was great."
Cons: "the seats hurt my butt, not sure if I could do a longer flight on this plane"
Pros: "Crew was very nice. Boarding was efficient."
Cons: "Snack selections are very limited. If we are paying for it anyway the choices should be a little more varied."
Cons: "3 hours delayed. I was late for a important interview. I lost money because of it"
Pros: "The price is right. I do not take any of the extras, do not be tricked by the website that you have to pick a seat. Charging more for carry on keeps the cabin clear, buy a bottle of water in the airport and skip the in flight food service. Planes are clean, reasonabley comfortable. Crews are professional."
Cons: "Boarding could be better. Why don't they load the back of the plane first? Mostly because people can't learn to get themselves on and off a plane. Get on and sit down. Then on arrivial standing in the isle fumbleling to get their overhead bags."
Pros: "Nothing"
Cons: "Everything. Really bad seats, no room for you. Carry on - charge $50. No free beverages ."
Cons: "Frontier services is the worst."
Cons: "We sat on plane at gate for 1 1/2 hour while crew attempted to fix mechanical problems."
Pros: "Plane was new"
Cons: "They want $40 for a carry on backpack! And you have to pay more to choose a seat snd even more for one that reclines... the space under the seats is purposely blocked to only fit tiny bags so they can charge you. A low cost airline is not low cost I'd think they make you pay extra for every little thing. It's very misleading."
Pros: "Nothing"
Cons: "Got to the airport at 4am for a flight that was supposed to leave at 6am. The flight finally departed at 11:40am. I missed my non-refundable connecting flight and had to book a new flight. All in all I probably lost $300 because of this situation. On top of that it was my birthday."
Pros: "I liked that the gave us food vouchers for our wait"
Cons: "That I really wanted to get home. One person missed is brother’s funeral, another person missed their connecting flight. I thought it was poor planning on frontiers part. Many people were getting very upset with the crew and calling customer service. I felt very bad feeling f the crew and many people who needed to be in Chicago when they promised for us to get there. It was upsetting, just tried to make lemonade out of lemons."
Cons: "Booked with kayak. Reservation came from KIwi.com? Frontier flight was canceled for maintenance. No email notification that I was automatically rebooked onto United flight by frontier. 4 hrs spent trying to get through to frontier booking agent to find out. No way to call internation number at kiwi.com. Will NOT ever book again with kayak."
Pros: "Great flight from Islip to MIA. Looked at another review about water on flights and I was told by the crew that water is FREE!"
Cons: "Seats are small but newly redesigned."
Pros: "In flight crew was cordial, warm, professional"
Cons: "Everything else was a sh*tshow: bad information, confused and angry employees, flight was 7-hours late"
Cons: "Poor customer service at service desk"
Cons: "Let's begin with the need to pay for your seat selection. Then the fact that the seats do not recline at all, so you are forced to sit upright the entire flight. Good luck if you are over 5'8", seats are not intended for taller people. Also, how can an airline not have wifi or inflight entertainment. Not a bargain at all. Oh and $45 per checked bag, nice touch. Avoid if possible."
Pros: "Once in air it was uneventful"
Pros: "everything"
Cons: "wished they had free snacks"
Pros: "The price"
Cons: "The seats were uncomfortable, having to pay for a carry on"
Cons: "$200 ticket and I still have to pay $45 to bring a bag?"
Pros: "McArthur Airport and checkin, a breeze. Boarding,stress free. Attitude of crew, at gate and on plane, wonderful. Nice re-seating available before take off."
Cons: "No free snacks."
Pros: "Ease of boarding, and the fact that we took of 30 minutes late and still landed just about on time"
Cons: "Seats are a bit hard and don’t recline at all"
Cons: "There was a lack of communication, our flight was delayed however there was no explanation as to why."
Pros: "Very friendly flight crew!"
Cons: "Nothing."
Pros: "The on board crew do not compare to the quality service in other flights but are much better than the frontier boarding crew"
Cons: "The service was absolutely terrible, the front desk crew did not want to let me in 40 minutes to my flight because they stated I need to be there 2 hrs earlier. This was ofcourse despite me having only a person item and having prepped in order to not have the slightest delay with TSA. I missed all my apartment viewings because of this and an additional flight delay with the replacement flight I purchased. This rendered my trip absolutely useless and an extra cost because I arrived after hours to my car rental and lost my reservation. If I buy a flight, why can't I stand? IF I CANNOT STAND WHY AM I PURCHASING A SEAT SEPERATELY???"
Pros: "Flight crew"
Cons: "Carry-on fee"
Pros: "Crew was friendly and seats were comfortable ."
Cons: "No gluten free food ootions"
Pros: "The price was right"
Cons: "Long lines to check your bags and confusion at the gate in Islip plus seats are uncomfortable on the plane and the only thing they give you for free is water"
Cons: "There were no snacks, not one drink was free, and the seats did not even recline. I will not be purchasing any further trips with Frontier no matter the price."
Cons: "The counter employees were not friendly. I had friends and other customers did not pay for sitting nor did they pay for a carryon. I paid for both. My carryon was small enough to put under seat. I was charge $85 in total. The seats were very uncomfortable. I will not be traveling on Frontier ever."
Cons: "Frontier is the worst airline I have ever traveled on. The planes were dirty, each flight was very delayed without any explanation, the chairs are worse than bleacher seats and they charge for EVERYTHING. I would rather pay a lot more for another airline than deal with Frontier again."
Cons: "For my over night flight I paid an additional fee for a window seat, instead I received an aisle. In addition, I paid a fee for a carry on bag and watched other passengers take on bags of similar size without paying."
Pros: "The price of the tickets. The crew on the flight was very nice."
Cons: "Cost of food. Seats had room but you might as well sat on a board. The cheap seats were offset by having to pay for a carry on and pay for food."
Pros: "The seating was very comfortable"
Cons: "There was a three hour delay and at no point during this time did a gate attendant make an announcement. The only reason I even found out about the delay is because I checked the flight status on my phone. There was very poor communication"
Pros: "Smooth ride."
Cons: "One of the Flight Attendents really messed it up for the staff. Very rude."
COVID-19 information

Safety measures for airlines flying from Islip to New York

Airlines flying from Islip to New York have enacted additional safety measures and adjusted policies to better accommodate travelers. Policies vary by airline.

Heightened sanitation

Daily cleaning, installation of cabin HEPA filters on flights from Islip to New York

Mandatory masks

Masks required on board, masks provided on flights from Islip to New York

Social distancing seating

Middle seats unavailable to book on flights from Islip to New York

Pre-flight testing

Testing for antibodies, testing for symptoms for flights from Islip to New York

Flexible cancellations

Waiving of change fees. Search flexible flights from Islip to New York

Book cheap flights from Islip to New York

Recent round-trip flight deals

6/8Wed
2 stopsMultiple Airlines
17h 26mISP-LGA
6/12Sun
1 stopMultiple Airlines
10h 53mLGA-ISP
$319
6/4Sat
2 stopsMultiple Airlines
13h 00mISP-LGA
6/6Mon
1 stopMultiple Airlines
12h 55mLGA-ISP
$325
7/12Tue
1 stopMultiple Airlines
8h 07mISP-LGA
7/27Wed
1 stopMultiple Airlines
9h 00mLGA-ISP
$332
6/8Wed
1 stopMultiple Airlines
11h 11mISP-LGA
6/12Sun
1 stopMultiple Airlines
10h 53mLGA-ISP
$337
6/5Sun
1 stopMultiple Airlines
27h 05mISP-SWF
6/12Sun
1 stopMultiple Airlines
15h 04mSWF-ISP
$343
7/12Tue
1 stopMultiple Airlines
8h 07mISP-LGA
7/16Sat
1 stopMultiple Airlines
9h 00mLGA-ISP
$354
7/12Tue
1 stopMultiple Airlines
8h 07mISP-LGA
7/26Tue
1 stopMultiple Airlines
9h 00mLGA-ISP
$365
7/12Tue
1 stopMultiple Airlines
8h 01mISP-LGA
7/24Sun
1 stopMultiple Airlines
10h 30mLGA-ISP
$377
7/12Tue
1 stopMultiple Airlines
8h 07mISP-LGA
7/23Sat
1 stopMultiple Airlines
9h 00mLGA-ISP
$387
6/29Wed
2 stopsAmerican Airlines
12h 52mISP-LGA
7/6Wed
2 stopsAmerican Airlines
17h 12mLGA-ISP
$393
7/14Thu
1 stopMultiple Airlines
8h 01mISP-LGA
7/24Sun
1 stopMultiple Airlines
10h 30mLGA-ISP
$399
7/12Tue
1 stopMultiple Airlines
8h 01mISP-LGA
7/25Mon
1 stopMultiple Airlines
9h 04mLGA-ISP
$400
6/23Thu
2 stopsAmerican Airlines
16h 53mISP-LGA
6/27Mon
2 stopsAmerican Airlines
17h 09mLGA-ISP
$445
7/14Thu
2 stopsAmerican Airlines
24h 58mISP-LGA
7/26Tue
2 stopsAmerican Airlines
13h 57mLGA-ISP
$470
7/12Tue
2 stopsAmerican Airlines
10h 57mISP-LGA
7/24Sun
2 stopsAmerican Airlines
25h 57mLGA-ISP
$485
6/8Wed
2 stopsAmerican Airlines
16h 53mISP-LGA
6/12Sun
2 stopsAmerican Airlines
23h 59mLGA-ISP
$490
6/8Wed
2 stopsAmerican Airlines
16h 53mISP-LGA
6/12Sun
2 stopsAmerican Airlines
23h 59mLGA-ISP
$497
7/12Tue
2 stopsAmerican Airlines
14h 40mISP-JFK
7/16Sat
2 stopsAmerican Airlines
13h 37mJFK-ISP
$527
7/12Tue
2 stopsAmerican Airlines
12h 47mISP-JFK
7/15Fri
2 stopsAmerican Airlines
37h 37mJFK-ISP
$530
6/8Wed
2 stopsAmerican Airlines
12h 46mISP-JFK
6/12Sun
2 stopsAmerican Airlines
13h 24mJFK-ISP
$537

Search by stops

Search by airline

Search by price

Recent one-way flight deals

5/31Tue
1 stopMultiple Airlines
21h 35mISP-LGA
$117
6/20Mon
1 stopMultiple Airlines
14h 19mISP-LGA
$159
5/31Tue
1 stopFrontier
15h 23mISP-SWF
$204
8/23Tue
2 stopsAmerican Airlines
12h 49mISP-JFK
$227
8/23Tue
2 stopsAmerican Airlines
12h 58mISP-LGA
$227
6/23Thu
2 stopsAmerican Airlines
11h 56mISP-LGA
$282
7/29Fri
2 stopsAmerican Airlines
26h 52mISP-LGA
$285
5/31Tue
2 stopsMultiple Airlines
11h 30mISP-LGA
$287
7/29Fri
1 stopMultiple Airlines
8h 01mISP-LGA
$306
6/23Thu
2 stopsAmerican Airlines
12h 46mISP-JFK
$307
6/20Mon
2 stopsAmerican Airlines
12h 52mISP-LGA
$307
7/29Fri
2 stopsAmerican Airlines
12h 47mISP-JFK
$332
6/20Mon
2 stopsAmerican Airlines
14h 40mISP-JFK
$339
8/23Tue
1 stopMultiple Airlines
8h 00mISP-LGA
$368
5/31Tue
2 stopsAmerican Airlines
8h 35mISP-JFK
$497
6/23Thu
2 stopsMultiple Airlines
31h 10mISP-SWF
$2,990

Search by stops

Search by airline

Search by price

Islip - New York Flights

Departure:

Islip (ISP)United States

Return flight deals:

New York - Islip

Cabin classes:

Browse origins:

$325