Sidney James Mountain Lodge, Gatlinburg Motels from $45

Guest reviews

All Reviews
Couples
Families
Business
Solo

Overall Rating

Based on 2,822 reviews

Pool

8.9 "Pool is good."
Service

8.7 "Great service."

9.1 "91% found the staff to be very friendly."

8.6 "86% said the reception staff was great."

7.3 "73% thought the service was very professional."
Location

7.9 "Good location."

8.9 "City centre within easy reach, said 89%."

8.5 "85% enjoyed the restaurants & bars nearby."

9.6 "96% liked the proximity to shopping."

9.7 "97% liked the proximity to sightseeing."

7.3 "Business sites within easy reach, said 73%."
Wellness Area

7.5 "Wellness & sports facilities were pleasant enough."

8.1 "81% loved the sauna."
Food

5.7 "Food is average."
Amenities

4.8 "Bad amenities."

4.7 "53% thought the building wasn't nice."

0.7 "93% thought the facilities needed updating."

4.7 "Fair terrace, said 53%."

0.0 "100% didn't like the architecture."

0.5 "95% complained about the elevator."
Cleanliness

4.7 "Not very clean."

4.6 "54% said rooms were dirty."

1.9 "81% said the bathroom was dirty."

2.0 "Unclean dining area, according to 80%."

4.0 "60% said that wellness & sports facilities were unclean."
Comfort

4.5 "Not very comfortable."

3.8 "62% didn't like the uncomfortable beds."

1.3 "87% criticized the small bathroom."

2.8 "Air conditioning was criticized by 72%."
Room

4.2 "Rooms are not good."

4.6 "54% said rooms were dirty."

3.8 "62% didn't like the uncomfortable beds."

0.5 "95% thought they were poorly maintained."

2.0 "80% complained about the bathroom."

1.1 "For 89%, the rooms looked old."

1.3 "87% found problems with the furniture."

4.4 "56% were unsatisfied with the kitchenette."

1.9 "81% said the bathroom was dirty."

2.0 "80% had problems with the shower."

1.3 "87% criticized the small bathroom."

2.6 "74% thought the tv was sub-standard."

2.8 "Air conditioning was criticized by 72%."

4.5 "55% were disappointed with the minibar."
Vibe

2.3 "Horrible vibe."

1.6 "84% criticized the unstylish hotel."

2.0 "80% didn't like the unstylish hotel."

4.0 "60% criticized the plain hotel."

View all review categories

Overall Rating

Based on 1,580 reviews

Pool

8.7 "Pool is good."
Service

8.7 "Great service."

8.7 "87% said the reception staff was great."

7.5 "75% thought the service was very professional."
Location

7.5 "Good location."

8.8 "City centre within easy reach, said 88%."

8.7 "87% enjoyed the restaurants & bars nearby."

9.5 "95% liked the proximity to sightseeing."

9.5 "95% liked the proximity to shopping."
Breakfast

5.6 "Breakfast is mediocre."
Cleanliness

5.1 "Average cleanliness."

5.2 "52% thought the cleanliness of the hotel was average."

5.9 "Only 59% thought the pool was clean."
Comfort

4.7 "Not very comfortable."

4.0 "60% didn't like the uncomfortable beds."

1.2 "88% criticized the small bathroom."

2.9 "Air conditioning was criticized by 71%."
Room

4.4 "Rooms are not good."

5.0 "Only 50% said rooms were clean enough."

0.4 "96% thought they were poorly maintained."

4.0 "60% didn't like the uncomfortable beds."

2.0 "80% complained about the bathroom."

1.2 "For 88%, the rooms looked old."

1.2 "88% found problems with the furniture."

4.6 "54% were unsatisfied with the kitchenette."

2.1 "79% had problems with the shower."

2.0 "80% said the bathroom was dirty."

1.2 "88% criticized the small bathroom."

2.9 "Air conditioning was criticized by 71%."

2.9 "71% thought the tv was sub-standard."

4.4 "56% were disappointed with the minibar."
Vibe

2.2 "Horrible vibe."

1.5 "85% criticized the unstylish hotel."

1.9 "81% didn't like the unstylish hotel."
WiFi

1.4 "Disappointing internet connection."

1.1 "89% said the wifi quality was bad."

View all review categories

Overall Rating

Based on 1,185 reviews

Pool

9.0 "Excellent pool."
Service

8.3 "Great service."

8.5 "85% said the reception staff was great."

7.0 "70% thought the service was very professional."
Location

7.8 "Good location."

9.0 "City centre within easy reach, said 90%."

8.4 "84% enjoyed the restaurants & bars nearby."

9.4 "94% liked the proximity to shopping."

9.7 "97% liked the proximity to sightseeing."
Breakfast

5.7 "Breakfast is mediocre."
Food

5.6 "Food is average."
Cleanliness

4.4 "Not very clean."

4.3 "57% said rooms were dirty."

1.7 "83% said the bathroom was dirty."
Comfort

3.9 "Not very comfortable."

3.4 "66% didn't like the uncomfortable beds."

1.2 "88% criticized the small bathroom."

3.0 "Air conditioning was criticized by 70%."
Room

3.9 "Rooms are not good."

4.3 "57% said rooms were dirty."

3.4 "66% didn't like the uncomfortable beds."

0.4 "96% thought they were poorly maintained."

2.0 "80% complained about the bathroom."

1.1 "For 89%, the rooms looked old."

4.1 "59% were unsatisfied with the kitchenette."

1.4 "86% found problems with the furniture."

1.7 "83% said the bathroom was dirty."

1.7 "83% had problems with the shower."

1.2 "88% criticized the small bathroom."

2.3 "77% thought the tv was sub-standard."

3.0 "Air conditioning was criticized by 70%."
Vibe

2.1 "Horrible vibe."

1.6 "84% criticized the unstylish hotel."
WiFi

1.2 "Disappointing internet connection."

1.0 "90% said the wifi quality was bad."

View all review categories

Overall Rating

Based on 56 reviews

Service

8.5 "Great service."

9.1 "91% found the staff to be very friendly."
Value for money

8.5 "Good value."
Location

8.0 "Location is great."
Cleanliness

4.8 "Not very clean."

4.6 "54% said rooms were dirty."
Amenities

4.8 "Bad amenities."

4.7 "53% thought the building wasn't nice."
Room

4.3 "Rooms are not good."

4.6 "54% said rooms were dirty."