House on Chase Creek

3 Locust Ave., Shelter Island, NY 11965, United States
+1 631 559 2296

Cheapest
rate per night

8.7

Excellent
based on 46 reviews
House on Chase Creek - Shelter Island, NY
Check-in
-
Check-out
Compare vs. KAYAK |

Provider Nightly total
Hotels.com $112
Priceline $396
Booking.com $417
Hotels.com
Priceline
Booking.com

Good to know

Value for money 7.7
Distance to city center 1.3 mi
Location rating 9.5

Rooms

Check-in
Check-out

Standard Rooms

$112+

Photo
Bed Type
Provider
Nightly
IMAGE
Queen bed
$112 per night

King Rooms

$396+

Photo
Bed Type
Provider
Nightly
IMAGE
Unknown
$396 per night
IMAGE
Unknown
$417 per night

Reviews

Traveler rating

45
4
3
0
0

Time of year

Traveler type

Show reviews that mention

+
  • Excellent
    Aug 2019
    10.0

    Beautiful vintage house with authentic decor and furnishings, felt like we went back in time! The house is within walking distance to stores, a market and restaurants which was great. beautiful view of Chase Creek right outside the front door.

    Breakfast could be better.

  • Good
    Jul 2019
    7.9

    Beautiful spot Quiet and convenient Breakfast was minimal Host affable and knows everything about Shelter Island

    Breakfast minimal Someplumbingvchallenges

  • Excellent
    May 2019
    10.0

    Peaceful and perfectly comfortable. Bill was also super accommodating, helpful and fun.

  • Excellent
    May 2019
    9.2

    The location is amazing! So beautiful.. even with bad weather! The host was great and understanding as we arrived quite late at night and he even let us have a better room than the one we have booked.. beautiful, stylish and cozy room! Light breakfast but perfect to get your day started!

    The only thing a little unexpected (our bad that we did not research this better) is that we had to pay 30 dollars for ferry rides - to and from Shelter Island - as the round trip fare (17usd) is not good if you are staying overnight at the island.. and they only take cash!

  • Excellent
    Apr 2019
    10.0

    My wife and I booked a room at the House on Chase Creek for a relaxing weekend getaway. We had such a wonderful time. Bill is a great host, very welcoming and available. He provided great restaurant and activity recommendations. The house is beautifully maintained, and has a lovely sense of antique-charm. Sophie, Bill’s incredibly cute doggie compatriot, is a talented and charming co-host. Everything was very clean and quiet. We can’t wait to come back to stay at the House on Chase Creek again during the warmer months.

    None

No reviews found. Try removing a filter, changing your search, or clear all to view reviews.

About

Overview

With a stay at House on Chase Creek in Shelter Island Heights (The Heights), you'll be within a 5-minute drive of Shelter Island Country Club and Sylvester Manor. Free self parking is available onsite.

Hotels.com

More

Features

Free parking
Free airport shuttle
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
Pet friendly
Spa

8.7 Excellent

based on 46 reviews

9.2

Cleanliness

8.8

Comfort

8.8

Staff

7.7

Value for money

Check in

3:00 PM

Check out

11:00 AM

Cancellation/prepayment

Policies vary by room type and provider.

Amenities

Complimentary breakfast
Free Wi-Fi
Internet
Bicycle rental
No smoking
Air-conditioned
24hr front desk
Free parking
Storage available
Terrace/Patio
Pets not allowed
Room service
Hot tub

Photos

House on Chase Creek - Shelter Island - Building All Photos (25)
House on Chase Creek - Shelter Island - Bathroom Bathroom (1)
House on Chase Creek - Shelter Island - Bedroom Bedroom (5)
House on Chase Creek - Shelter Island - Building Building (2)
House on Chase Creek - Shelter Island - Dining room Dinning room (2)

Location

Most Popular Landmarks

  • Havens House 1.7 mi
  • Mashomack Preserve 2.4 mi

Getting Around

Tweed-New Haven 30.4 mi
New Shoreham Block Island 40.8 mi
Old Saybrook 15.2 mi
New London 23.2 mi

Nearby hotels

Closest

9 Excellent (153 reviews)
0.28 mi
9.5 Excellent (16 reviews)
0.36 mi
8.4 Excellent (18 reviews)
0.49 mi
Best prices found by KAYAK users in the past 72 hours.

Cheapest

8.4 Excellent (18 reviews)
0.49 mi
9 Excellent (153 reviews)
0.28 mi
8.5 Excellent (55 reviews)
0.7 mi
Best prices found by KAYAK users in the past 72 hours.

Most recommended

9.7 Excellent (102 reviews)
0.66 mi
9.5 Excellent (16 reviews)
0.36 mi
9.5 Excellent (23 reviews)
1.3 mi
Best prices found by KAYAK users in the past 72 hours.