$228 Find Cheap Flights from Buffalo to the Cayman Islands - Compare and Save

1 adult
1 adult, Economy, 0 bags

Save 25% or more on flights. Compare deals from all over the web.

Never overpay with our price tracking tools.

Filter searches by price, airline and more to find your best flights.

Flight Deals
Booking Insights
Flight Deals
Booking Insights

Price, demand and travel trends for Buffalo to the Cayman Islands flights

Use KAYAK data on prices, travel dates, airlines and seasonal trends to compare options and book flights with more confidence.

What are the cheapest fares from Buffalo to the Cayman Islands right now?

The cheapest fare from Buffalo to the Cayman Islands in the last week was $457 round-trip, to George Town Owen Roberts Intl (GCM).

Which airport in the Cayman Islands is the cheapest to fly to from Buffalo?

All flights from Buffalo to the Cayman Islands arrive at George Town Owen Roberts Intl (GCM). On average, round-trip fares are around $555.

What’s the cheapest day to fly from Buffalo to the Cayman Islands?

Wednesday tends to be the cheapest day to fly from Buffalo to the Cayman Islands, while Monday is the most expensive. Fares run about 58% higher that day, based on the past 12 months of KAYAK data.

Key details for Buffalo to the Cayman Islands flights

Low season

September

Cheapest flight

$228
Beat the crowds with an average 94% drop in travelers.
The most popular month to fly with an average 123% increase in travelers.
One-way flight from Buffalo to George Town

Your Buffalo to the Cayman Islands flight questions, answered

Find helpful answers about this route, including flight times, airports, airlines and booking tips.

  • Is now a good time to book a flight from Buffalo to the Cayman Islands?

    Fares from Buffalo to the Cayman Islands are around their usual level right now. A round-trip under $347 is considered a good deal, so it's worth keeping an eye out, or setting a Price Alert to catch price changes.

  • How much should I budget for a flight from Buffalo to the Cayman Islands?

    Over the past 12 months, round-trip fares from Buffalo to the Cayman Islands have ranged from $347 to $608.

  • What airlines fly nonstop from Buffalo to the Cayman Islands?

    Based on the flight schedule for the next 3 months, no airline regularly operates nonstop flights from Buffalo to the Cayman Islands. One-stop options include:

    • Delta
    • American Airlines
    • Southwest

  • Which cabin classes are available on flights from Buffalo to the Cayman Islands?

    On flights from Buffalo to the Cayman Islands you can only book Economy Class.

Your guide to booking Buffalo to the Cayman Islands flights

Get tips on when to book, when to fly and what to know before your trip.
  • If your travel dates are flexible, book your trip for June when flights are typically cheapest and avoid February when prices are at their highest.
  • Flying on Wednesday is usually the cheapest. Flights on Monday cost about 58% more on average, so being flexible with your travel dates could help you save.
  • Start your trip in George Town, which is the most popular destination in the Cayman Islands. From there, it's easy to continue on to other popular destinations such as West Bay, East End and North Side.

Reviews of the top airline flying from Buffalo to the Cayman Islands

 
Need help choosing which airline to fly with from Buffalo to the Cayman Islands? KAYAK airline reviews give an overall score for each airline based on loads of factors, including comfort, boarding, in-flight entertainment and more, to make your decision easier. See airline scores according to verified KAYAK customer reviews.
7.0
American AirlinesOverall score based on 12210 reviews
6.4Food
7.1Comfort
7.9Crew
6.8Entertainment
7.4Boarding
Airline reviews

The delays were not communicated well at all. I was in the airport for over 9 hours with little knowledge of if I was actually going to reach my destination.

2.0 MediocreSophia, Oct 2026
Read more American Airlines reviews

The delays were not communicated well at all. I was in the airport for over 9 hours with little knowledge of if I was actually going to reach my destination.

It was OK, but it was delayed about an hour, and my luggage didn't arrive till about an hour and a half after the flight

Another American Airlines flight, another significant delay. At least this one wasn't canceled like many others have been. This time we sat on the runway at LaGuardia for 2.5 hours. By my count that is 7 American flights the last three months that have been delayed 2 hours or more or canceled entirely.

Our trip to Spain turned into a stressful ordeal with cockpit issues and FAA air traffic disruptions. Our American Airlines flight from Raleigh to JFK was delayed nearly four hours, causing us to miss our connections to Madrid and Jerez. We were left stranded in New York with children, even running out of diapers while trying to sort everything out. American refused to cover hotels or rental cars, leaving us to arrange and pay for them ourselves. The delays also disrupted our prepaid rental car reservations in Spain. It was a frustrating and expensive start to a family trip we had spent months planning.

Unfortunately the flight was delayed by almost 2 hours, so I missed an appointment arriving into DFW

Very cold on board it was like having 16hours sitting in a fridge

My experience was excellent for a business trip. I like the smaller jets because everyone gets either a window or aisle seat and the boarding and de-planing goes much faster. I really like the schedule American Airlines has between Atlanta and NY - lots of options. Crews are great and very accommodating. Sometimes the flights are not full and they let people move around once the boarding doors are shut to spread out.

Primary flight attendant in FC wasn't that engaged throughout the flight. All other aspects of flight were good.

On time departure & early arrival. Made a long day much better.

The flight from Buffalo to Chicago was on an older and smaller plane. Seating was tight. Looking closely at the interior of the aircraft there were definitely signs of aging and wear.

More options for your flight from Buffalo to the Cayman Islands

Complete your trip to the Cayman Islands with a hotel stay or car rental