NYC - LYB
Find cheap flights from New York to Little Cayman
Round-trip
1 adult
Economy
Fri 4/28
Fri 5/5
Here is why travelers choose KAYAK
Save 22% or moreCompare multiple travel sites with one search
Free to useThere are no hidden charges or fees.
Filter your dealsChoose cabin class, free Wi-Fi and more.
Bundle and saveSave money when you bundle your flight + hotel.
When to book flights from New York to Little Cayman
Estimated round-trip price
Average price per month
Flight prices as travel date approaches
Top tips for finding a cheap flight out of New York
- Looking for a cheap flight? 25% of our users found flights on this route for $356 or less one-way and $629 or less round-trip.
FAQs for booking flights from New York to Little Cayman
Top airline flying New York to Little Cayman
Scores according to KAYAK customer reviews7.8
Cayman AirwaysOverall score based on 200 reviews
8.2Boarding
8.1Comfort
8.4Crew
6.7Entertainment
7.2Food
Airline reviews
Flight crew made the flight very enjoyable as they were friendly, helpful and accommodating. Flight time was 3:40 compared to the 4:30 that was captured on our itinerary, so that was a pleasant surprise. In flight entertainment was good with plenty of selection, however some of the choices that my family tried were slow to load and stalled out a few times. We were able to restart and everyone finished watching their movies. Food was pretty basic: croissant, turkey or chicken lunch meat with Swiss cheese and a bag of Lay’s potato chips. Still a bonus considering most airlines offerings which is nothing but peanuts or a cookie.
Flight crew made the flight very enjoyable as they were friendly, helpful and accommodating. Flight time was 3:40 compared to the 4:30 that was captured on our itinerary, so that was a pleasant surprise. In flight entertainment was good with plenty of selection, however some of the choices that my family tried were slow to load and stalled out a few times. We were able to restart and everyone finished watching their movies. Food was pretty basic: croissant, turkey or chicken lunch meat with Swiss cheese and a bag of Lay’s potato chips. Still a bonus considering most airlines offerings which is nothing but peanuts or a cookie.
Best experience ever. Crew were amazing, kept me informed throughout. Boarding was on time and spot on. Id book again most def
Food
Food could have been better, and internet that allows texting/WhatsApp and other basics on the phone instead of just inflight entertainment would have been nice.
Pros: "yes as always. seats comfortable with sufficient leg room"
Cons: "missing in flight entertainment"
Cons: "More drinks/beverages"
Pros: "Boarding"
Cons: "The flight delayed and we weren't informed"
Cons: "Cayman Airways is always late."
Pros: "Crew great"
Cons: "Plane on time"
Pros: "Crew was good and plane was new...loved the big above storage"
Cons: "The online process was TERRIBLE. Navigating the website / getting boarding passes was like 1999. Need a massive upgrade. Also for a 4 hour flight, you need some kind of on-board entertainment. And if not, let passengers know."
Pros: "crew was courteous and helpful"
Cons: "in flight entertainment"
Pros: "Short ride"
Cons: "The plane was 3 1/2 hours late...I was constantly getting updated that the departure time was changed from 8:15pm to 9:30pm to 10:15pm finally to 11:05pm. When the plane did arrive, no one could tell us what happened—they literally said “we don’t know why it’s late”. YOU’RE THE AIRLINE; if any one should know what’s going on, it should be you!"
Pros: "Super nice people"
Cons: "Their airport under remodeling so from arrival gates to departure gates is a hike around the outside. Very crowded departure area with limited seats."
Pros: "Business Class staff friendly and professional"
Cons: "Paid for an upgrade , baggage wasn’t tagged as priority and came out last on arrival and box that was professionally wrapped and labeled fragile was crushed up and unrecognizable upon arrival. Baggage staff using unprofessional language, calling me “Baby”"
Pros: "I Marked only boarding lower because we did it twice. That was just fine though. The crew was apologetic for having to re board another plane for mechanical problems. They kept everyone up to date of the changes and how we were to progress along the route. Everyone on board understood the crew didn't want to change planes and redo all the pre- flight start ups more than passengers wanted to change after boarding. The crew was most apologetic and super efficient. Well done"
Pros: "The flight crew in the plane was terrific. Once the new airport is done is going to be fabulous."
Cons: "The gate area was overcrowded the sound system was terrible. Once the new airport is finished it will be wonderful. Until then we'll just get by."
Pros: "The seats are so much more roomy than the other airlines that fly there. It was very comfy."
Cons: "It was a short flight with no entertainment or food. Nothing not to like."
Cons: "We were in business class and it took 40 minutes to receive a drink. Also, there were no power/charging plugs anywhere. Very disappointed"
Cons: "i missed my flight and my ticket was worthless, no credit was given to alienate the financial burden of buying a one way ticket into Grand Cayman. Somewhat sad."
Pros: "Nothing"
Cons: "The pilot caused passengers to have major delays. He was rude and unprofessional."
Pros: "On time, room to spread out, and free rum punch - what more could you ask for."
Pros: "Crew in Grand Cayman did all they could to help us. Hotel and transfer help."
Cons: "Flight delayed missed connecting flight. No compensation."
Pros: "I liked the view and the flight attendants was very helpful."
Cons: "Nothing much was serve to eat just juice or tea, a small biscuit or chips could do."
Pros: "Personized service."
Cons: "Paid for business class and the seat was broken and did not move."
Cons: "The time to board process. They let up through flowing pre boarding then while.at the gate turned us bad only to be Called back again to walk some distance"
Pros: "Crew and food"
Cons: "No tv, movies"
Pros: "nothing i could not make it on flight as i was sick, and they wanted to charge me 600 + 200 usd for change of dates!!!"
Cons: "nothing i could not make it on flight as i was sick, and they wanted to charge me 600 + 200 usd for change of dates!!!"
Pros: "After Caribbean Air the seats feel like bussiness class even in cattle class. The staff are friendly, they (normally) give you an entire can of soda (no snack though - short flight). Seats are comfortable (for economy)."
Cons: "Always leave a little late. (But at least didn't leave a lot late.)"
Pros: "After being stranded in Chicago by Delta, Cayman Airways saved the trip! Crew was great and loved the rum punch served!"
Pros: "It was not crowded...arrived in a timely manner. Staff were warm and approachable."
Cons: "I liked everything. Flight was great. Nothing to complain about."
Pros: "I was not happy when I watched the ground crew drive off with my luggage because the flight was over weight. Seems to me the company should plan flights better."
Pros: "Very smooth flight from take-off to touch-down. Flight attendants were very polite."
Cons: "Unfortunately, our arrival gate was not available after an early landing which created a delay on the tarmac of about 45 minutes."
Pros: "Great plane on a new 737, with comfortable business class"
Cons: "Absolutely no food available, even in business class (no snacks/peanuts ) - was unacceptable following a lengthy delay"
Pros: "No food on these short flights and only juice or water is free to drink. I had a very short transit time and cabin crew were great in getting me off plane as quickly as possible."
Cons: "We departed later than planned due to late arrivals, so my arrival was delayed thus making my transit time even shorter. If people can't turn up on time on such a small island for an international flight they should be stopped from travelling."
Pros: "small plane and flying so low was a great experience!"
Pros: "provided a flight to la ceiba!"
Cons: "no complaints"
Pros: "there was food on the plane from new york"
Cons: "no complaints"
Pros: "There was no food or entertainment provided so not able to speak to that. The dring is refreshing and the staff pleasant"
Cons: "a minor snack say crackers and cheese or something else. this is especially recommended for the late and early flight"
Cons: "The flight was exactly 5 hours delayed (scheduled for 5:20 PM and departed at 10:20 PM). There was a small apology but that was it- no food or drinks offered, no voucher, etc. It was very disappointing. When we got on the plane, there was a 45 minute baggage loading delay. It seemed like there could have been more haste involved in loading considering at that point there had already been a considerable delay. The worst part was, there was very little update the whole time. At one point we were told there was a technical issue so a new plane was being brought in from Grand Cayman but they time delay kept increasing without an explanation. I understand delays but to have no updates is just inconsiderate. It just seemed like there was no consideration. I will not fly with this airline again."
Pros: "Wonderful to enjoy the only non-stop jet service from Cayman Brac direct to Miami."
Pros: "Free luggage check in 2 bags Free run rum punch"
Cons: "Absent entertainment (no tv, movies) No wifi"
Pros: "Fun flight attendants smooth ride easy exit"
Cons: "Perfect trip"
Pros: "A little slow on boarding....but overall good efficient crew. Love the luggage for free! We were able to take all of our snorkling gear and our sand shoes without having to buy them there!"
Pros: "Everything was great"
Pros: "Loved the no charge for 2 bags per customer and so nice at Cayman ticket cou ter"
Pros: "I have gotten into the habit of using Cayman Airways over American . The employees make you feel more comfortable in their desire to please. I return to Georgetown frequently. It is my favourite Caribbean island and Cayman Airways makes the trip even more pleasurable."
Cons: "No food served."
Pros: "They served a meal on flight."
Cons: "The cabin wad freezing! People were wearing winter jackets!"
Pros: "Not much."
Cons: "The ground crew broke the auxiliary power unit while de-icing the plane. We went back to the gate by bus, and we stood around for hours with no information from Cayman Airlines. Initial problem wasn't CA's fault, but they could have communicated better."
Book cheap flights from New York to Little Cayman
Recent round-trip flight deals
5/28Sun
1 stopCayman Airways
22h 40mJFK-LYB
6/3Sat
1 stopCayman Airways
4h 55mLYB-JFK
$381
5/28Sun
1 stopCayman Airways
6h 05mJFK-LYB
6/3Sat
2 stopsCayman Airways
5h 45mLYB-JFK
$410
5/28Sun
2 stopsCayman Airways
30h 50mJFK-LYB
6/3Sat
2 stopsCayman Airways
34h 40mLYB-JFK
$421
4/17Mon
2 stopsCayman Airways
30h 50mJFK-LYB
5/13Sat
2 stopsCayman Airways
5h 45mLYB-JFK
$435
4/17Mon
2 stopsCayman Airways
30h 50mJFK-LYB
5/13Sat
1 stopCayman Airways
5h 00mLYB-JFK
$437
4/17Mon
1 stopCayman Airways
6h 05mJFK-LYB
5/13Sat
1 stopCayman Airways
10h 05mLYB-JFK
$462
8/5Sat
2 stopsMultiple Airlines
10h 55mEWR-LYB
8/12Sat
2 stopsMultiple Airlines
10h 13mLYB-EWR
$781
8/5Sat
1 stopMultiple Airlines
7h 21mEWR-LYB
8/12Sat
1 stopMultiple Airlines
9h 13mLYB-EWR
$828
6/24Sat
2 stopsMultiple Airlines
26h 40mEWR-LYB
6/28Wed
2 stopsMultiple Airlines
15h 12mLYB-EWR
$922
8/5Sat
2 stopsMultiple Airlines
10h 26mLGA-LYB
8/12Sat
2 stopsMultiple Airlines
12h 09mLYB-LGA
$987
6/24Sat
1 stopMultiple Airlines
26h 01mEWR-LYB
6/28Wed
2 stopsMultiple Airlines
13h 09mLYB-EWR
$1,009
Search by stops
Search by airline
Search by price
Flights to Little Cayman
Browse destinations:
$929