MISSING STRING [CITY_HOTELS_HEADER_TEXT]

Amagansett hotels

Search hundreds of travel sites at once for hotels in Amagansett

Amagansett, NY
Check-in
Check-out
Compare vs. KAYAK |

Good to know

Low season November
High season November
  Average price (weeknight): $186

cheapest month to stay

0%

expected price decrease

most expensive time to stay

0%

expected price increase

(avg. price over the last 2 weeks)

Sun - Thu

(weeknight)

How much does a hotel in Amagansett cost?

Best prices found by KAYAK users in the past 24 hours.

FAQs when booking a hotel in Amagansett

How much is a cheap hotel in Amagansett?
KAYAK users have found double rooms in Amagansett for as cheap as $167 in the last 3 days. The average price is $1007.
How much is a hotel in Amagansett for this weekend?
In the last 72 hours, users have found Amagansett hotels for this weekend for as low as $197 per night. Users have also found 3-star hotels from $197 and 4-star hotels from $251.
How can I find hotels near me?
Take a look at our extensive hotel Heatmaps to find the best hotels near you.

Where to stay in Amagansett?

Our Heatmaps tool will help you find the perfect place to stay in Amagansett by showing you how close hotel options are to major activities

Best Amagansett hotels

Show all
The 1770 House Restaurant & Inn - East Hampton - Living room
1
9.5 Excellent (95 reviews)
Overview
With a stay at The 1770 House Restaurant & Inn in East Hampton, you'll be by the ocean, just steps from Guild Hall and a 4-minute drive from LongHouse Reserve. Featured amenities include complimentary newspapers in the lobby and luggage storage. Free self parking is available onsite.
The Hedges Inn - East Hampton - Building
2
9.4 Excellent (159 reviews)
Overview Reviews
A stay at The Hedges Inn places you in the heart of East Hampton, a 1-minute drive from Guild Hall and 11 minutes from Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum. Featured amenities include a computer station, complimentary newspapers in the lobby, and a 24-hour front desk. Free self parking is available onsite.
9.6 Excellent
Pros: Situation excellent. Overall ambiance and quality of breakfast choices. One of the best bb inns we have stayed in the States.
Cons: No in room guidance for use of TV.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Great place
Cons: If during off hours no one to ask questions of
9.6 Excellent
Pros: Would come again !!!!,perfect location
9.2 Excellent
Cons: The place was immaculately kept and made best use of what seems to be an old facility
9.6 Excellent
Pros: Late arrival was made possible. Good location. A charming place. We were upgraded to a larger room. Breakfast perfect.
Cons: Nothing
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The Hedges Inn, a historic, beautiful Hampton property, was lovely from top to bottom. Our room was spacious, pristine, and very comfortable. The Inn provided an unbelievable, more than "full" breakfast with a daily hot menu, a chef's special choice, and a buffet of everything you could possibly dream of. The Management staff were engaged and very helpful. We had a lovely retreat and will certainly return. Carole & Richard, Clemson, SC
Overview Reviews
With a stay at East Hampton Art House Bed & Breakfast in East Hampton (Clearwater Beach), you'll be within a 5-minute drive of Pollock-Krasner House and Study Center and Three Mile Harbor. Featured amenities include multilingual staff, luggage storage, and an elevator. Free self parking is available onsite.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Amazing location, you feel like you are in another wonderful place entirely. The quality of the rooms, linens, woodwork, amenities and the hosts hospitality is unsurpassed. The rock surrounded hot tub and lap pool are fabulous! You’ll share the grounds with live turtles. You’ll want to meander the gardens, rest in the hammock, and enjoy drinks in the garden for days. We are already planning our next visit.
Cons: I wish we lived closer so we could visit more often!
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The house is magical - its a beautiful building with comfortable furnishings, gorgeous artwork & stunning outdoor spaces. Breakfast was cooked to order & there was anything you could possibly want in the kitchen. A real gem!
9.6 Excellent
Pros: Home like feeling with the 5 star Resort Luxury
Cons: The house is gorgeous. Breakfast is incredible
9.5 Excellent
Pros: A beautiful and peaceful place, big comfortable rooms and bed, wonderful breakfast and snacks, great hosts.
Cons: Everything was great, no issues
8.8 Excellent
Pros: Breakfast was superb every day, and we were always so well looked after by Michael and Rosalind who were attentive and helpful. Wonderful facilities in the room and hotel.....lovely art and decor around the place. On the day the weather finally decided to play nice, the garden, pool and jacuzzi all came into their own.
Cons: Sofa bed could be a little more comfy for the kids.......
The Baker House 1650 - East Hampton - Bedroom
4
9.3 Excellent (43 reviews)
Overview Reviews
When you a stay at The Baker House 1650 in East Hampton, you'll be near the beach, within a 5-minute walk of Home Sweet Home Museum and Guild Hall. Featured amenities include a business center, complimentary newspapers in the lobby, and dry cleaning/laundry services. Free self parking is available onsite.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The hotel and staff are extremely polite and nothing was to much trouble, excellent breakfast and facilities,room was fantastic.the manager Karen was especially helpful and friendly.
Cons: Nothing
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Stunning inside and out!
Cons: Nothing!
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Perfect location for walking around the community of East Hampton. Quaint room overlooking the backyard and pool with a comfortable King bed and spacious bathroom. The property is amazing with outdoor vanishing edge pool and indoor pool and spa. Made to order breakfast very morning. Wonderful staff.
Cons: Nothing.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The Baker house was a fantastic experience. The breakfast exceeded any other bed and breakfast we had visited. Everyone was so warm and friendly and that made our stay even better. We loved the spa as it was so relaxing. It was home away from home!
9.6 Excellent
Pros: Staff very accommodating. Breakfast very high quality with fresh juice and berries. Most comfortable living room with massive fireplace of any of the dozens of Select BnBs in which we have stayed. Wonderful proximity to Main St. Shops and restaurants.
Cons: Unusually high shower tub in the Dayton room difficult to climb into and out of. Silly for this type of Inn to charge for bottled water.
8.8 Excellent
Pros: Homey atmosphete
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The people who work there! All are wonderful and the location is ideal
Ocean Vista Resort - Amagansett - Beach
5
8.8 Excellent (197 reviews)
Overview
With a stay at Ocean Vista Resort in Amagansett, you'll be within a 5-minute drive of Napeague State Park and Hither Woods Preserve. Planning an event in Amagansett? This hotel has facilities measuring 792 square feet (71 square meters), including a meeting room. Free self parking is available onsite.
Journey East Hampton - East Hampton - Building
6
9.0 Excellent (56 reviews)
Overview Reviews
With a stay at Journey East Hampton in East Hampton (East Hampton North), you'll be within a 5-minute drive of Amelia Cottage Museum and Amagansett Square. Featured amenities include complimentary wired Internet access, complimentary newspapers in the lobby, and dry cleaning/laundry services. Free self parking is available onsite.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The staff, facilities, calm, quiet and peaceful setting, room, cleanliness, convenience to town. I would highly recommend this facility over its competitors in the area.
Cons: The $40 daily resort fee was surprising, especially since the continental breakfast was weak, it was fall season and the pool was not able to be used. It’s not a Ritz Carlton or Four Seasons resort on the beach, which have the similar level of resort fees, and this facility should not have a resort fee.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Everything is new and there is all we need for a great stay. Good breakfast. Amazing interior design. Lovely and cute room.Thank you!! And special thanks to Jennifer for her smile and help!!!
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The staff was great. Juan and Ellaine, were phenomenal. They truly made our stay fantastic. We felt at home and the hotel is absolutely beautiful.
Cons: The ventilation system in the bathroom should have a separate switch from the lighting one. It is a bit noisy and you don’t need it on every time you use the restroom.
9.2 Excellent
Pros: The staff and the hotel are lovely. Everyone was welcoming and it felt like a calm retreat. I loved using the bikes and having breakfast available all morning. The mini-fridge was stocked with water and juices. And cookies in the afternoon is a great touch.
Cons: I would have loved a full-length mirror in the room. It's hard to get dressed and go out without one.
7.9 Good
Pros: Clean, new update facilities
Cons: Located outside Main Street, not well marked from street, lack of hot water
9.2 Excellent
Pros: Lovely place and staff was lovely as well. Would highly recommend it.
Cons: Is off highway and a bit noisy
10.0 Excellent
Pros: The decor was divine and the bed was the most comfortable I have ever slept on. It had a refined feeling about it and understated but it was very chic.
Cons: Nothing
Hampton Inn Long Island-Brookhaven - Farmingville - Building
7
8.7 Excellent (1,039 reviews)
Overview Reviews
The Hampton Inn Long Island/Brookhaven hotel in New York is conveniently located in the center of Long Island's most popular attractions and major business districts. Local companies include Symbol Technologies, Computer Associates, Brookhaven National Lab, and Adesa Long Island. We offer complimentary shuttle to Islip's MacArthur Airport and the Long Island Railroad Ronkonkoma. The Hampton Inn Long Island/Brookhaven is just north from Fire Island Beaches and a short drive east to The Hamptons, Long Island's Wine Country, Tanger Factory Outlet and Splish Splash Water Park for your leisurely enjoyment. All Hampton Inn Long Island/Brookhaven hotel guests enjoy complimentary high-speed wireless internet, indoor heated pool, well-equipped fitness center and complimentary On the House breakfast. If your trip to New York requires a meeting room, The Hampton Inn Brookhaven hotel features meeting facilities that comfortably accommodate groups up to 120. We love having you here at the Hampton Inn Long Island/Brookhaven hotel in New York.
8.0 Excellent
Pros: Clean, good breakfast
Cons: Hard to access from expressway
1.0 Poor
Pros: Room was comfortable and clean
Cons: Poor breakfast. Shower very slippery. Had to wait 20 minutes for elevator due to one being out of service for two days.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: It was clean, comfortable and accommodated an early check-in. Breakfast and staff were very nice. Liked the hotel all around.
8.0 Excellent
Pros: Tea and coffee whenever you want. Nice clean rooms and cozy bed.
Cons: The breakfast was blah, to say the least.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Customer Service, location and cleanliness. Very kind and accommodating.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Very clean & very comfortable.
Cons: No room service
6.0 Good
Pros: Breakfast was good. Location suited our purpose but wouldn’t be my choice for a vacation spot.
Cons: Hotel needs a restaurant/bar.
9.6 Excellent
Pros: The help yourself breakfast was adequate for folks on the move & loved that you could get coffee 27x7. This was my 3rd Hampton Inn on this trip and all of them were, as usual, very satisfactory. The Brookhaven hotel was right off the Long Island Expressway, so very convenient, and was easy for local family to get to us. Sonoma Grill across the hwy was excellent for us to all meet up for dinner and although very crowded, was excellent food and service. Love the Hampton Inns, they are always excellent.
Cons: Didn't like to have to pay $10.00 for outside parking at this hotel. None of the other Hampton's we stayed in charged for parking, so thought this charge was outrageous! In addition the pillows are too soft.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: It was such a relaxing experience. The room was clean and comfortable. The staff was friendly and helpful. I don't know why the toliet was running but I closed the bathroom door and solved that problem. It was definitely a pleasant experience.
6.0 Good
Pros: The price was good
Cons: It was sufficient and affordable
8.3 Excellent
Pros: Kevin at th front desk was AMAZING! He went above and beyond to be helpful and accommodating! Should be a manager, if he's not! Cleaning staff very polite and also very accommodating. The girl that took care of breakfast every day by herself was very polite, kept refilling what was offered constantly !!
Cons: Breakfast area floor was always sticky. Not much variety of breakfast foods. It was somewhat difficult to communicate with cleaning staff and service staff as they understood and spoke minimal English.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Good food and service friendly staff
Cons: Nothing very nice hotel
The Maidstone - East Hampton - Building
8
8.8 Excellent (102 reviews)
Overview Reviews
With a stay at The Maidstone in East Hampton, you'll be a 3-minute walk from Home Sweet Home Museum and 6 minutes by foot from Guild Hall. Featured amenities include a business center, complimentary newspapers in the lobby, and a library. Free self parking is available onsite.
9.2 Excellent
Pros: Very nice having the great restaurant/ bar downstairs to be used as communal area especially during non-busy hours. The bathtub & robes were delightful. Ideal for the winter months, with cozy fireplace. Centrally located on Main Street, short walk from the Jitney stop.
Cons: Heat was too high and we were not able to adjust, had to prop the windows open with books. Didn't bother me, but it is across the street from a cemetery (but there's also a nice pond where 2 swans were wading).
9.6 Excellent
Pros: A little confusion with the payment
6.7 Good
Pros: The I’ve of the pace is great. Art and relaxed attitude.
Cons: Bathroom was all that clean. The trash was not removed. The bedroom was super tiny for the price.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Such a beautiful place with loads of character
Cons: The room was right above the restaurant so it could be noisy. We had to be up early but if we didn’t we would’ve been down there enjoying the evening
8.0 Excellent
Pros: Decor and cleanliness of rooms. Beautiful hotel inside
Cons: Not applicable
8.8 Excellent
Pros: Great restaurant and included breakfast was delicious!
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Liked it all cozy ..close to all
Cons: Was a great place to stay ..great bar n restaurant..also room and grounds were in wonderful shape..coming again soon
6.7 Good
Pros: Location was good, walked to town and the beach, each about a 15 min walk in either way The garden was nice, staff very friendly and helpful
Cons: I expected a little more for the money, the property was much older than I thought it would be but I guess you are paying for the area we had a baby so couldn't bring the stroller upstairs - no elevator located on a very busy Road, not much to do as the weather wasn't great
Overview Reviews
Welcome to the newly renovated Holiday Inn Express Stony Brook. We are less than 1 mile from Stony Brook State University and Stony Brook School of Medicine. We are the official host hotel for the Stony Brook Seawolves and welcome visiting sports teams, doctors, professors, nurses, students and their families. We are conveniently located a short distance from Brookhaven National Laboratory, CEWIT, Long Island High Tech Incubator and Renaissance Technologies. Our free shuttle provides transportation to/from Long Island MacArthur Airport, Port Jefferson Ferry, Stony Brook University, Stony Brook University Hospital, Stony Brook Train Station, New York Blood & Cancer Research Center, Stony Brook Children’s Hospital, Stony Brook Cancer Center, Smith Haven Mall and a 3 mile radius of the hotel. This Centereach, Setauket hotel accepts Alipay & WeChat and is minutes from Port Jefferson Village, Stony Brook Village, Long Island Museum and Tanger Outlets. We offer free, hot deluxe breakfast with hot & fresh coffee available 24/7. Stay connected with our free Wi-Fi and 24-hour business center. Stay relaxed and fit using the indoor, heated swimming pool with a new 24-hour fitness center. This 100% smoke-free hotel has newly renovated sleeping rooms, executive suites, our "Pink Sweet" and Jacuzzi tub rooms, all equipped with microwave, mini fridge & Keurig coffee maker.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: This is one of the friendliest staff I met. They are extremely accommodating. People from Long Island are just wonderful in general. The parking is so convenient.
6.7 Good
Pros: Mattress was amazing
Cons: Room was out dated
6.0 Good
Pros: Good location for us. We liked the gym. Good breakfast
Cons: The outside looked better than the inside rooms.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Beautiful and Clean
Cons: Nothing
5.0 Okay
Cons: Non acommadating rules
5.0 Okay
Cons: Whole building smelled like chlorine. Hot breastfast foods were available but no way to make hot
4.0 Okay
Cons: The breakfast was terrible! Ran out of most everything. Everyday food got worse. Things were cold and stale. Poor selection of food. The pool was not clean. Pool high chlorine burned our skin.
9.0 Excellent
Pros: The location was great!
Cons: It was a little expensive
6.3 Good
Pros: Bedding. Nice front desk gal on 28 SEP 2019 around 11 PM and checked us out 29 SEP,2019 around 0830. Lobby.
Cons: Very poor value for the price. Here's why: Except for the lobby, which looked nice, the hotel had an overall shabby feel to it. Beds and bedding comfortable but rest of room - decor was very worn, bathroom had the bare necessities but not comfortable.
8.0 Excellent
Pros: The big soft comfortable bed and the oh so soft pillows were the best. The lady at the desk was sweet, and the room was very clean. I would definitely go back again.
2.0 Mediocre
Pros: The staff was very nice and attentive.
Cons: The price was too high for a very old and run down hotel that is off a highway. I can’t believe the pricing. Would not stay there again. I would rather travel further to a better hotel.
8.0 Excellent
Pros: Location, physical plant, breakfast, 24 hour coffee, market.
Cons: Parking, (far from doors), plastic cups, spotty housekeeping.
East Hampton Point - East Hampton - Bedroom
10
9.1 Excellent (30 reviews)
Overview Reviews
Located in East Hampton, East Hampton Point is on the waterfront, within a 10-minute drive of Guild Hall and LongHouse Reserve. Featured amenities include a business center, dry cleaning/laundry services, and luggage storage. This hotel has 2 meeting rooms available for events. Free self parking is available onsite.
3.3 Mediocre
Pros: Restaurant which is not affiliated
Cons: Smell of mold in ground level of cottage, no hot water first night and run down state of cottage and garden even had mushrooms growing in garden
Overview Reviews
The Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport hotel is located just a half mile from the MacArthur Airport and is in the heart of the Ronkonkoma, Bohemia, and Western Suffolk business districts of New York. Our complimentary airport shuttle is also available to drive guests to the nearby Long Island Railroad station, offering direct access to New York City's Penn Station. Take advantage of our central location to travel east to the Tanger Outlets in Riverhead, the Long Island Vineyards, and the Hamptons or travel only three miles to the Fire Island ferries. The Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport hotel offers deluxe accommodations, friendly service and a relaxed atmosphere that awaits our guests. Certain to please the busy executive or leisure traveler, our rooms and suites are well appointed with a variety of amenities including a 27'' television, complimentary high-speed Internet access, two dual-line phones with data port and voicemail, and the Hilton Clock Radio which provides a mini-plug for your MP3 Player. Our large desks make working on the road easier with desk level outlets and ergonomic chair. Each room also offers a refrigerator and microwave, as well as an iron and ironing board. Travelers at the Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport hotel are sure to enjoy the On Command video, TV video games, complimentary HBO and USA Today each weekday morning. At the Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport hotel, enjoy a brisk workout in our on-site fitness center, take a swim in the indoor heated swimming pool or relax in our whirlpool. We also offer complimentary access to our business center 24-hours a day. Relax and unwind from the day's events in our Pavilion Lounge. The Great American Grill features our cooked-to-order full American breakfast buffet daily and a relaxed dinner menu nightly. ***** Everything. Right where you need it. *****
8.3 Excellent
Pros: Clean and quiet. Parking lot was well lighted.
Cons: Bathroom exhaust fan not working when we checked in.
9.4 Excellent
Cons: The bed could have been a bit more firm
9.0 Excellent
Pros: Made-to-order eggs for breakfast...
Cons: Vending and ice machines were far from room
8.8 Excellent
Pros: The staff was excellent with giving instructions and assistance the shopping locations. Also, surprise given the 45th anniversary.
Cons: nothing
8.0 Excellent
Pros: Very friendly staff, and eager to please the clients
10.0 Excellent
Cons: Breakfast lacks REAL food, we r fussy about what we eat and processed meals( is powdered eggs) are unappealing, we ate elsewhere and paid 1/2 as much for better. Although hotel food is more convenient, it’s fast food made to look like it’s not
7.1 Good
Cons: Dirty chair, gross.... matress soft sags in middle
5.0 Okay
Pros: Front desk assistant very nice
Cons: Bathroom floor tiles all cracked. Not very clean bathroom.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: When my wife mentioned to the cleaning staff I had a cold, they left extra tissues and a note to feel better soon. Very thoughtful.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: best omelets for breakfast
8.0 Excellent
Pros: Clean. Staff most helpful Room spacious clean Bed's very comfy
Cons: Need more carts for luggage
5.0 Okay
Pros: Took ish 40 minutes to get into room No crowds at all Delays because NO Carts*** for luggage Our room key did not work Took 3 truhe's. Staff had to come to open Finally
Cons: The worse check in experience My husband has heart condition Needed cart Needed to get into room he was tired as I was Really great staff had to carry by hand our luggage After. 40 mins to get in our room
East Hampton House Resort - East Hampton - Building
12
8.6 Excellent (109 reviews)
Overview Reviews
Located in East Hampton (East Hampton North), East Hampton House Resort is within a 15-minute walk of First United Methodist Church and Old Hook Mill. Featured amenities include a 24-hour front desk, luggage storage, and laundry facilities. Free self parking is available onsite.
5.0 Okay
Cons: 1. Room sound insulation is too bad. Disturbed by footsteps coming from upstairs. 2. No continental breakfast
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Modern room. Microwave frig. Balcony
7.1 Good
Pros: Heated Pool was absolutely great especially after a long day. Water temp was perfect.
Cons: There wasn't 24hr staffing. I like getting a wake up call in the morning. Not a deal breaker. Also no breakfast.
9.0 Excellent
Pros: Room was spacious. Nice balcony, pool, yard etc.
Cons: Walking distance to town is a little long. It would be great if they had bikes that you could borrow.
7.5 Good
Pros: Location, pool, garden, large rooms, parking
Cons: The room was a bit outdated
Ocean Colony Beach & Tennis Club - Amagansett - Building
13
8.6 Excellent (99 reviews)
Overview Reviews
With a stay at The Ocean Colony Beach & Tennis Club in Amagansett, you'll be steps from Napeague State Park and a 3-minute drive from Hither Woods Preserve. The front desk is staffed during limited hours. Free self parking is available onsite.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Great place to stay.... we had a weekend wedding in Montauk... great to stay in the dunes with a great view. Easy access trail to nice beach. Our 1 BR unit with queen bed and loft with two twins was immaculate and well stocked! Bed was very good!
Cons: NA
9.2 Excellent
Pros: We stayed in room 1211 in the Love building. It had plenty of space and was nice and clean when we checked in. We loved being on the main level and having a private deck that we could access from multiple rooms. The room with two beds was perfect for my two small kids because the beds were close to the floor. Nice to have two restaurants within walking distance. We only stayed for one night in early October so we can’t speak for the beach but when we went down it was big and beautiful and EMPTY
Cons: The property had the classic beach mildew smell but we quickly got used to it. The building we were in was one of the farthest from the beach but still just a quick walk and not inconvenient.
9.6 Excellent
Pros: Clean, right on the water, and quiet
Cons: Only that it was quite expensive; but I suppose that’s the Hamptons for you!
9.6 Excellent
Pros: Everything! Near perfect away to the east end.
7.1 Good
Pros: Great location for the beach, lovely apartment with all the equipment needed, onsite laundry was very useful
Cons: You need a car to access the local town and shops, the pool was nice but was closed on two separate days
8.3 Excellent
Pros: Beautiful views, comfortable beds, great location
Cons: At the steep price, would have expected there to at least be water bottles in the room
7.9 Good
Cons: i think it is a bit overpriced but overall it was a good experience
Overview Reviews
The Courtyard Long Island hotel is centrally located between the Long Island Expressway and the MacArthur Airport, offering complimentary airport shuttle service from 7am-11pm, and hotel-wide WiFi. Our hotel offers large rooms that feature a sleeper sofa, work space with writing desk, a mini fridge and microwave, and plush bedding as well as spacious suites with separate living and sleeping spaces, fully equipped kitchens, whirlpool tubs, and a dining area that is ideal for traveling families or groups. Guests interested in exploring Long Island will appreciate our ideal location that offers easy access to popular attractions, landmarks, and communities such as Fire Island, Lake Ronkonkoma, and the Long Island Maritime Museum. This MacArthur Airport hotel in Long Island offers modern conveniences such as a heated indoor pool, a 24-hour business center, onsite fitness studio, an onsite restaurant and bar, and over 6,000 sq. ft. of flexible event space to host business or social occasions.
6.3 Good
Cons: Charged you to park, was told 10.00 PER vehicle only to find out that was incorrect. .. charged credit card for unknown charges over 100.00 that manager couldn't explain. No continental breakfast
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Room was clean, quiet, and easily darkened for sleeping in. The bed was comfortable, staff friendly and helpful. The pool, hot tub, and surrounding area were clean and well maintained.
7.0 Good
Pros: Right off the expressway. Nice pool, great hot/tub spa.
Cons: Staff needs to replace coffee used in the AM. Food in the restaraunt was overpriced.
1.0 Poor
Pros:  
Cons:  
7.1 Good
Cons: very dissatisfied with having to pay for parking. we have used this hotel quite a few times previously and never had to pay to park in a lot that was half full. i just don't get it, except that it is an easy way to increase the cost. I question whether I return simply on principle of not being advised when I made reservation that the parking policy had changed.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Friendly, expierence, and helpful staff at the front end.
Cons: Location. Hard to find even using gps.
9.6 Excellent
Pros: Cleanliness and comfortable bed.
Cons: N/A
7.5 Good
Pros: The staff saved this place. They were extremely friendly!
Cons: The property itself is pretty old and the rooms are dated & worn
7.5 Good
Pros: Staff was very friendly
Cons: Older hotel that could use some TLC
8.0 Excellent
Pros: Employees were helpful and courteous, The bed was very comfortable.
8.0 Excellent
Pros: Everyone was very pleasant
Cons: Not enough options for breakfast used to have more options,.
9.0 Excellent
Pros: Good breakfast options for the whole family healthy choices!
Overview Reviews
At the Residence Inn Long Island Holtsville, enjoy spacious studio and one-bedroom suites that are 50% larger than traditional hotel rooms. Our suites offer separate living, eating and sleeping areas, complimentary high-speed Internet, sofa beds and fully equipped kitchens. Enjoy a complimentary hot breakfast buffet daily and a nightly social mix Monday-Wednesday, on-site exercise room and indoor pool and whirlpool. Practice your team-building by visiting our Sport Court for basketball, tennis and volleyball. You'll have access to dining, entertainment and cultural options in the area and SUNY Stony Brook University is just 15 minutes away. In the summer enjoy Splish Splash Water Park, Fire Island and the East End Wineries, or take in the beauty of Montauk and the Hamptons. Across from Zebra, minutes from Hauppauge Industrial Park and an hour from JFK and LaGuardia airports, the Residence Inn Long Island Holtsville offers ideal accommodations for business or leisure travelers.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Spacious accommodation, pool and jacuzzi, fitness center and a plentiful breakfast made this a great stay!
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Buffet breakfast was excellent
Cons: They were going to charge me a parking fee AFTER I already paid for the room online. I told them I was dropped off and they removed the charge.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Staff was very friendly Room was very clean Breakfast was very good
Cons: No
5.0 Okay
Pros: We liked the location and the fact their was a kitchenette.
Cons: The smoke detector really bright light shined on us. difficult to sleep. Also the floor in the dining area and bathroom were damp. Doors, handles, microwave touch pad, etc. were dirty. Sofa bed had crumbs under cushions.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: All food was fresh and area was so clean
9.0 Excellent
Pros: Proximity to LIE and entertainment
5.4 Okay
Pros: Staff. Very friendly and professional.
Cons: Bed was awful!! Carpet loose and seams separating in various. Room was not cleaned once during our stay. Room rates different each day with last being $314.00!! Really?? Then to add insult to injury we get charged an extra $10.00 per day to park!! Now that’s some real bullshit right there!! Marriott will never get another dime of my money!!
8.0 Excellent
Pros: What I liked best about the hotel was the set up of the room!
Cons: I did not like that sometimes housekeeping would skip my room!
6.0 Good
Cons: Too expensive for the location and for what you get
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Their price was cheaper than yours even though I only got one night
Cons: That I booked 2 nights and only got 1
10.0 Excellent
Pros: This was a great stay. I loved my room. Even the complimentary breakfast was awesome.
Cons: Nothing bad to say
3.0 Mediocre
Cons: Staff/ manager customer experience was poor
White Sands Motel - Amagansett
16
8.9 Excellent (26 reviews)
Sea Crest Resort - Amagansett - Building
17
8.4 Excellent (292 reviews)
Overview Reviews
With a stay at Sea Crest Resort in Amagansett, you'll be within a 15-minute walk of Napeague State Park and Walking Dunes Trailhead. The front desk is staffed during limited hours. Free self parking is available onsite.
9.0 Excellent
Pros: This will be my new family place to go.
Cons: Nothing.
7.9 Good
Pros: We liked the location for the activities that our family had planned. The room was clean and adequate for the length of stay planned.
Cons: We didn’t like getting a parking ticket for parking in the spaces across from the Sea Crest and not receiving notification that the spaces were allowed by beach permit only. We checked in late and did not receive any notice in our online confirmation or with the keys to our room.
Windward Shores Ocean Resort - East Hampton - Bedroom
18
8.4 Excellent (189 reviews)
Overview Reviews
With a stay at Windward Shores Ocean Resort in Amagansett, you'll be on the beach, just steps from Napeague State Park and a 3-minute drive from Hither Woods Preserve. Featured amenities include complimentary newspapers in the lobby and laundry facilities. Free self parking is available onsite.
5.4 Okay
Pros: The beach was close by
Cons: Room was not as described; facilities were poor (nowhere to purchase any basics like milk or bread), staff weren’t overly helpful - because of this it was expensive and poor value
7.0 Good
Pros: We needed late check-in and I was concerned that would be a hassle, but it wasn’t. The apartment was nice enough, it was clean and comfortable. Could use a little updating! The kitchen area was tiny. We were able to heat up a casserole for breakfast, but it’s too small to do any actual cooking. The absolutely best part about this place was the beach!!! Our second floor deck had beautiful views and the beach was so close!!! Listening to the waves all night was wonderful. The beach itself was gorgeous. Soft sand and a lot of space. The pool was also nice and my 13 yo son loved the ping-pong table. The location was great too. A very short drive to both Amagansett and Montauk. The “Best Pizza” was nearby and just OK, but the bagel store less than .25 miles away was terrific.
Cons: We had a little trouble controlling the AC, when it was on the first floor was freezing and the loft was still hot. But it was really not a big deal!
9.6 Excellent
Pros: Room was big enough for 2 people. Liked the kitchen
Cons: Light bulbs in the bathroom need to be brighter
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Location to ocean, very clean quiet property, beach not crowded , 2 bedroom suites are amazing with very nice size kitchen!
Cons: It’s perfect, but could use a gym, although we enjoyed the tennis court. Only has one running machine nothing else!
6.7 Good
Pros: You have to update the room. Bathroom equipment is dated and not in good shape, faucets are almost inoperable. I.m sure cleaning service does what it can, but update would help.
7.1 Good
Pros: Location was amazing
Cons: Room needs updating especially bathroom and furniture
8.8 Excellent
Pros: We were there late October so it was rather cold but the location would have been perfect in summer. It was good that there was a full Bathroom on each floor especially for the room upstairs. Ample parking spots for residents staying at the property. There was a coin operated washing machine and dryer on site (1 of each). USD2 for each.
Cons: The kitchen layout wasn't the best especially the pots and pan corner cupboard. A broom would have been good to have available for the verandah as it had lots of sand.
7.9 Good
Pros: Close to Montauk and right on beach.
Cons: Our bed was very uncomfortable.
10.0 Excellent
Pros: Considering the comparative price, the room was much larger and more comfortable than expected. I also was not expecting a kitchen so I was pleasantly surprised. The thoroughness and attention to detail shown by the cleaning staff was remarkable. The front desk clerk was extremely friendly and very helpful with local recommendations.
Cons: I wish the sliding glass door had a better curtain, there was a curtain in my room, it covered the glass enough, but I always had a sliver that could be seen through. The other side of the glass was a lovely private patio, beyond that was a large dune, so I didn't have any reason to believe anyone would be looking in.

Best rooms in Amagansett

Ocean Vista Resort - Amagansett - Beach
1
8.8 Excellent (197 reviews)
Overview
With a stay at Ocean Vista Resort in Amagansett, you'll be within a 5-minute drive of Napeague State Park and Hither Woods Preserve. Planning an event in Amagansett? This hotel has facilities measuring 792 square feet (71 square meters), including a meeting room. Free self parking is available onsite.
Sea Crest Resort - Amagansett - Building
2
8.4 Excellent (295 reviews)
Overview Reviews
With a stay at Sea Crest Resort in Amagansett, you'll be within a 15-minute walk of Napeague State Park and Walking Dunes Trailhead. The front desk is staffed during limited hours. Free self parking is available onsite.
9.0 Excellent
Pros: This will be my new family place to go.
Cons: Nothing.
7.9 Good
Pros: We liked the location for the activities that our family had planned. The room was clean and adequate for the length of stay planned.
Cons: We didn’t like getting a parking ticket for parking in the spaces across from the Sea Crest and not receiving notification that the spaces were allowed by beach permit only. We checked in late and did not receive any notice in our online confirmation or with the keys to our room.