Introduction
Where to eat
When to visit
How to get there
Where to stay
Renting a car

Shelter Island travel guide

Shelter Island Tourism | Shelter Island Guide

You're Going to Love Shelter Island

With a population of 1,333, Shelter Island is a must-see destination in New York State, United States. Consider staying at least one whole day in Shelter Island to see all of its attractions.

Where to Eat in Shelter Island

If you’re looking for affordable options, 18 Bay (23 North Ferry Rd (rte. 114)) and SALT Shelter Island (63 S Menantic Road) are great picks.

When to visit Shelter Island

Shelter Island in March
Estimated hotel price
$197
1 night at 3-star hotel
Shelter Island in March
Estimated hotel price
$197
1 night at 3-star hotel

How to Get to Shelter Island

Plane

When flying to Shelter Island, you’ll arrive at Islip Long Island (ISP), which is located 44 miles from the city center. The shortest domestic flight to Shelter Island departs from Fort Lauderdale and takes around 2h 50m.

Car

Another option to get to Shelter Island is to pick up a car rental from New York, which is about 89 miles from Shelter Island. You’ll find branches of Turo and Payless, among others, in New York.

Plane

When flying to Shelter Island, you’ll arrive at Islip Long Island (ISP), which is located 44 miles from the city center. The shortest domestic flight to Shelter Island departs from Fort Lauderdale and takes around 2h 50m.

Car

Another option to get to Shelter Island is to pick up a car rental from New York, which is about 89 miles from Shelter Island. You’ll find branches of Turo and Payless, among others, in New York.

Airports near Shelter Island

ISPIslip Long Island
BDLHartford Bradley Intl
JFKNew York John F Kennedy Intl

Airlines serving Shelter Island

Lufthansa
Good (7,044 reviews)
KLM
Good (1,334 reviews)
British Airways
Good (6,836 reviews)
SWISS
Good (1,588 reviews)
Delta
Excellent (7,935 reviews)
Turkish Airlines
Good (3,790 reviews)
Iberia
Good (2,698 reviews)
Air France
Good (1,446 reviews)
Austrian Airlines
Good (780 reviews)
United Airlines
Good (8,696 reviews)
Emirates
Excellent (3,215 reviews)
Qatar Airways
Good (3,563 reviews)
Air Canada
Good (9,243 reviews)
Scandinavian Airlines
Good (1,349 reviews)
Brussels Airlines
Good (346 reviews)
LOT
Good (1,069 reviews)
Finnair
Good (1,275 reviews)
Alaska Airlines
Excellent (9,967 reviews)
TAP AIR PORTUGAL
Good (1,851 reviews)
Etihad Airways
Good (1,203 reviews)
Show more

Where to stay in Shelter Island

Average rates range from around $831 per night for a double room in a 3-star hotel to $514 and up for a 5-star experience.

Where to stay in popular areas of Shelter Island

Most booked hotels in Shelter Island

See all
Holiday Inn Long Island - Islip Arpt East
3 stars
Excellent (8.6, 824 reviews)
$124+
View
House on Chase Creek
2 stars
Excellent (8.5, 81 reviews)
$140+
View
The Harbor Front Inn
3 stars
Excellent (8.3, 415 reviews)
$231+
View
Hampton Inn Long Island/Brookhaven
2 stars
Excellent (8.1, 794 reviews)
$118+
View
Sound View Greenport
4 stars
Excellent (8, 471 reviews)
$311+
View
The Rams Head Inn
3 stars
Good (7.7, 60 reviews)
$599+
View

Renting a car in Shelter Island

Expect to pay $3.41 per gallon in Shelter Island (average price from the past 30 days). Depending on the size of your rental car, filling up the tank will cost between $40.88 and $54.51.

Expect to pay $3.41 per gallon in Shelter Island (average price from the past 30 days). Depending on the size of your rental car, filling up the tank will cost between $40.88 and $54.51.

Shelter Island Travel Guide - View the KAYAK Shelter Island city guide for the best Shelter Island travel tips. To help you organize your Shelter Island trip ideas, this Shelter Island visitors guide provides travel information and trip tips about how to get there, where to stay, what to do, where to eat and more.