Find cheap flights from West Tisbury Martha's Vineyard to New York John F Kennedy Airport

MVY - JFK

Find cheap flights from West Tisbury Martha's Vineyard to New York John F Kennedy Airport

Round-trip
Economy
West Tisbury (MVY)
New York John F Kennedy Intl
Fri 11/27
Fri 12/4
Any month
Compare vs. KAYAK |
Search hundreds of travel sites at once for deals on flights to New York John F Kennedy Airport

Good to know

Low season

October Best time to beat the crowds with an average 48% drop in price.

High season

April Most popular time to fly with an average 28% increase in price.

Average price round-trip

$422 (avg. price over the last 2 weeks)

Good deal round-trip

$265 or less

Good deal one-way

$149 or less

When to book flights from West Tisbury to New York John F Kennedy Intl

Estimated round-trip price
Average price per month

Top tips for finding a cheap flight

  • Looking for a cheap flight? 25% of our users found flights on this route for $149 or less one-way and $265 or less round-trip.
  • High season is considered to be March, April and May. The cheapest month to fly is October.
  • Morning departure is around 117% more expensive than an evening flight, on average*.
*Average of the lowest prices shown in KAYAK’s search results for departures within the next 30 days

FAQs for booking West Tisbury Martha's Vineyard to New York John F Kennedy Airport flights

How does KAYAK find such low prices on flights from West Tisbury Martha's Vineyard to New York John F Kennedy Airport?

How does KAYAK's flight Price Forecast tool help me choose the right time to buy my flight ticket from West Tisbury Martha's Vineyard to New York John F Kennedy Airport?

What is the Hacker Fare option on flights from West Tisbury Martha's Vineyard to New York John F Kennedy Airport?

What is KAYAK's "flexible dates" feature and why should I care when looking for a flight from West Tisbury Martha's Vineyard to New York John F Kennedy Airport?

Top airline flying West Tisbury Martha's Vineyard to New York John F Kennedy Intl

Scores according to KAYAK customer reviews

7.9
Cape Air
Overall score based on 243 reviews
8.3
Boarding
7.7
Comfort
8.7
Crew
7.3
Entertainment
6.9
Food
Airline reviews

Pros: "Regular"

Pros: "The pilot was kind and to the point."
Cons: "The guy who boarded us told me to wait as his computer could not check me in. 10min later he is rushing me to get on the runway. It was 30min before scheduled take off. I had ordered food and had to cancel my order before the café had finished, so he wasted food and did not get paid and I was hurried and boarded the plane hungry. I probably won't use Cape Air again unless it's an emergency situation"

Cons: "Boarded half hour late. No explanation. Pretty standard on Cape Air these days"

Pros: "Chance to see the coast and internal from above"

Pros: "Pilot did a great job, flight was as smooth as glass for the 7 of us passengers!"

Cons: "Bumpy ride. Blame it on the wind."

Pros: "Such a small plane didn’t expect the seats to recline. Liked the view but Boy is it warm onboard"
Cons: "Not much you can change on a puddle jumper"

Pros: "Cape Air never disappoints. A great option other than driving . Not to mention a great value"

Cons: "My Pre TSA Check did not apply to flight"

Pros: "Flight from Havre to Billings was fine, from check in through security and to the flight. Smoke from CA, OR, NV fires really limited the view, but CapeAir did fine with their service"
Cons: "Seats are a little small, but that is to be expected in such a small plane. Other than that, the flight was great."

Pros: "Excellent woman taking care of a delayed flight. Handled passenger and boarding process as well as check in beautifully and so kind and efficiently!!"
Cons: "The delay due to mechanical problems"

Pros: "Smooth flight. Nice option to fly to small airport closer to home."

Pros: "Got to sit next to the pilot!"
Cons: "Nothing, it was an absolutely breath taking flight!!"

Cons: "Connection booked too close. Missed flight, new flight delayed. Kayak booking does not leave enough time to transfer."

Pros: "Friendliest flight crew, airport attendants and security agents anywhere."

Pros: "Got a shuttle from the plane to my terminal at STL. Very convenient."
Cons: "Rather loud, but I don’t think there was much the airline could do about that. Maybe earplugs."

Pros: "Flight on time. Nice smooth ride. Very friendly pilot."

Pros: "Crew was pilot and helpful in explaining the situation to me."
Cons: "Got bumped from a flight to make way for a pilot in training. The fact that this happened on christmas eve made it even worse. Had to wait until boarding to find out that was being bumped and was told I shouldn't have been allowed to check in."

Pros: "small plane soft landing"
Cons: "pilote acts like army general single pilote only air vent poor in plane"

Pros: "You see there was a terrible storm that closed the EIS Beef Island Airport. But because I booked through ya'll I was totally screwed. The individual Airlines are not permitted to rebook my ticket because you are a third party carrier. and You would not rebook because the airline could not change the flight status on the first plane from Mayaguez to San Juan - that flight was not cancelled due to the closure but because I would be stuck in San Juan for possibly 2 days with no money and no where to sleep, well you get the point. So InterCaribbean and Cape Air came to the rescue and after a 4-5 hour ordeal and having to travel to Mayaguez airport I am now rebooked."
Cons: "Y'all and will never ever ever book through a third party again."

Pros: "Friendly & informative pilot, smooth efficient ground crew: they didn't bang up my vintage Levi's back pack..."
Cons: "No complaints...A+"

Pros: "My first time on a such small plane and the ride and the landing were very smooth with great views!!"

Pros: "Shirt flight no food, but bumpy. I almost threw up on a 25 minute flight"

Pros: "Hate crew diligently kept me informed of my bag connecting from my 45 minute late "on time" united flight."

Pros: "The flight itself was nice"
Cons: "Being delayed and the process of dealing with the delays was a real headache"

Pros: "I sat in the copilot seat since plane was so small."
Cons: "Delayed so I missed my connection in Boston. I ran to catch it but the door was closed and they wouldn't let me on, even though plan was still sitting at the gate. I had 8 min to spare."

Pros: "Got me to Boston, eventually, safely. Nice view from low altitude. Plane provides for an intimate experience with pilot and fellow passengers"
Cons: "2.5 hour delay with no information or confusing information about departure prospects."

Pros: "Flights across the east coast were delayed, luckily ours was only 15min late to take off."

Cons: "Landing crew in Boston was rude, bossy, and repetitively sciolding, just because I touched the door of the plane. No instructions nor to or warnings were posted, but he kept harassing me and the other passengers.about "our safety"."

Pros: "The view from PR to St Thomas was amazing!"
Cons: "The departure was late for no apparent reason that complicated my meeting with family members in St Thomas."

Cons: "Convenience"

Cons: "Too expensive. 399 for a 40 minute plane ride? Really?"

Pros: "Great timing"

Pros: "Nothing!"
Cons: "The flight was cancelled because of engine trouble. As a result we miss our connecting flight to our final destination."

Pros: "They plain didn't crash although it sounded like that was likely when we were taking off."
Cons: "The lack of ear protection to cancel out some of the loudness of the small aircraft would have been REALLY nice."

Pros: "Everything! Staff, captain, plane, efficiency, intimacy of the small plane. I don't love flying - it's a means to an end. But, this flight was fun. No food, but it was a 30 minute flight, so no refreshment needed."

Pros: "All aspects of the flight were smooth on a nice day and I really enjoyed flying at 7k feet. A lot of people don't like flying in small planes but I do. There is no bathroom, food or entertainment available and all of your bags go into cargo. I was the only passenger so it felt like a chartered trip. Arrived about 5 minutes early."

Pros: "I loved the whole experience."

Cons: "taking off almost an hour late for a 20-minute flight. poor planning re weight restrictions so that luggage for several passengers had to be put on a future flight. no information given re delay."

Cons: "Booked with Cape Air a month before our trip to Bimini. We had quite a few reasonable trip options but decided the float plane would be fun. One week before our departure Cape Air cancels the tickets. No explanation, no rebooking, just a "I'm sorry, too bad, go find something else," we ended up paying full fares through United for another $1000. So much for our affordable weekend getaway. Thanks Cape Air."

Pros: "It was my first solo flight, as well as first flight in a small plane. Quick, easy check in and boarding in Mayaguez, PR. In San Juan, exiting and meeting family was not easy, due to terminal design. Overall, great experience."

Pros: "Everything"

Pros: "Good, efficient flight to Bar Harbor from Boston!"

Pros: "Great. But you have to not be scared of small planes. The plane only seats 8 people. You can high five the pilot."
Cons: "Very small. I'm 6'4" very tight fit"

Pros: "Crew is very friendly and the views are beautiful."
Cons: "This plane is an 8-seater, so no food, no drinks, no entertainment and no lavatory. Short flight, though, so not a big deal."

Cons: "Was very disappointed. I missed my next flight in Boston because this one was cancelled 15 mins before we were supposed to take off- leaving little to no time to make other arrangements. When I first checked in I was told there was a slight delay due to 'wildlife management' then we got word that it is cancelled because of ice in Boston- it was 46 degrees. There was no compensation because the cancellation was due to weather. However, we were later informed that it was due more to lack of equipment. I have lost my faith in cape air"

Pros: "Great flight Albany to BOS. Cessna turbo prop. Super flight crew. Sure beats driving to Boston."

Pros: "Pilots, checking in and boarding process."
Cons: "Nothing"

Pros: "*No security (skip TSA) *Private, intimate experience with just 6 other passengers (but without the luxury of a charter since the tiny plane has no amenities, entertainment, food, or even water)"
Cons: "*UNSAFE -- you better hope your pilot doesn't have a heart attack or seizure or even arm cramp mid-air as the shaky, ratchety little 8-seater doesn't have a second pilot. Airline unconcerned w/liability. *Pilot (Captain Darryl) was a jerk, which the ground crew warned us about - unlike Air Sunshine and Seaborne (which we flew to other islands during the same trip), he didn't allow you to take pictures w/your phone in airplane mode. *Price was much costlier than Seaborne and Air Sunshine flights; when I learned of competitors and tried to switch, no cancellation (even within a day of booking). *Customer service almost impossible to reach; long hold times, limited hours. *They commit consumer fraud by charging for carry-on luggage in addition to checked baggage without ever disclosing that prior to the flight (and the normal airline baggage policy doesn't apply). *With much better and cheaper options, NEVER fly this airline for your own safety, cost consciousness, and well-being."

Read more about Cape Air
COVID-19 information

Safety measures for airlines flying from West Tisbury Martha's Vineyard to New York John F Kennedy Intl

Airlines flying from West Tisbury Martha's Vineyard to New York John F Kennedy Intl have enacted additional safety measures and adjusted policies to better accommodate travelers. Policies vary by airline.

Heightened sanitation

Daily cleaning, installation of cabin HEPA filters

Mandatory masks

Masks required on board, masks provided

Social distancing seating

Middle seats unavailable to book

Pre-flight testing

Testing for antibodies, testing for symptoms

Book cheap flights from West Tisbury Martha's Vineyard to New York John F Kennedy Airport

Recent one-way flight deals

12/27
Sun
1 stop
Multiple Airlines
4h 34m
MVY - JFK
12/3
Thu
1 stop
Multiple Airlines
5h 02m
MVY - JFK
12/27
Sun
nonstop
Cape Air
1h 23m
MVY - JFK
12/3
Thu
nonstop
Cape Air
1h 23m
MVY - JFK
12/3
Thu
1 stop
Multiple Airlines
15h 00m
MVY - JFK
12/3
Thu
nonstop
Cape Air
1h 23m
MVY - JFK
12/3
Thu
2 stops
Multiple Airlines
12h 10m
MVY - JFK
12/27
Sun
2 stops
Multiple Airlines
7h 55m
MVY - JFK
12/3
Thu
3 stops
Multiple Airlines
26h 25m
MVY - JFK
12/27
Sun
3 stops
Multiple Airlines
27h 20m
MVY - JFK
12/3
Thu
2 stops
Multiple Airlines
17h 25m
MVY - JFK
Show more results
-
1
  • Round-trip
  • One-way
  • Multi-city
  • Trip Builder
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
  • Multiple
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First