Sag Harbor hotels

Sat 4/13
Wed 4/17

Search and compare hundreds of travel sites at once for hotels in Sag Harbor, New York. Bundle your hotel + flight and save!

...and more

Let KAYAK do the searching

Save on your next stay

Search and compare hundreds of travel sites at once for hotels in Sag Harbor, New York State

We’re completely free to use – no hidden charges or fees

Filter by free cancellation, free breakfast and more

Bundle your flight + hotel and save

Best Sag Harbor hotels

Most recommended Sag Harbor hotels

Show all
Baron's Cove - Sag Harbor - Building
Baron's Cove
8.5 Very good
$500+
$500+
Parking
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
Pet friendly
Hampton Inn Long Island-Brookhaven - Farmingville - Patio
$184+
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
Pet friendly
Shelter Island House
4 Mediocre
$326+
$326+
Parking
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
Pet friendly
Topping Rose House
7.9 Good
$1,040+
$1,040+
Parking
Free Wi-Fi
Pool
Pet friendly

Good to know

Low season

January

High season

July

Average price (weeknight)

$150

Average price (weekend night)

$177
Cheapest month to stay with an average 40% drop in price.
Most expensive month to stay with an average 45% rise in price.
Average Sun - Thu price over the last 2 weeks.
Average Fri & Sat price over the last 2 weeks.

When to book a hotel in Sag Harbor

Price per night / 3-star hotel. Prices are not fixed and may vary with time.
Average nightly price per month
Average nightly price

Top tips for finding Sag Harbor hotel deals

  • If you’re looking for a cheap hotel in Sag Harbor, you should consider visiting during the low season. You'll find cheaper hotels in Sag Harbor in January and December.
  • Hotel room prices vary depending on many factors but you’ll most likely find the best hotel deals in Sag Harbor if you stay on a Monday. The opposite is true for, Thursday, which is usually the most expensive day.
  • The cheapest 3-star hotel room in Sag Harbor found on KAYAK in the last 2 weeks was $194, while the most expensive was $708.
  • How long should you stay? KAYAK users usually book their hotel in Sag Harbor for 2 days.
  • If you would like to be a quick walk from a handful of museums, look for hotels in Sag Harbor that are close to Main Street, such as the Quintessential Sag Harbor Village Retreat. This will put you less than a 15min walk from both Sag Harbor Historical Society: The Annie Cooper Boyd House and the Sag Harbor Whaling & Historical Museum.
  • Those that are hoping to play a round or two of golf during their stay in Sag Harbor will want to look for lodging in the eastern part of the city, as this will put you near the Sag Harbor Golf Course. The Perfect Sag Harbor Vacation is less than a 5min drive from the course entrance.
  • To spend some quality time in nature and go on a walk or hike, stay somewhere that is near the Linda Gronlund Memorial Nature Preserve in the eastern part of the city. The Luxury Sag Harbor Water Views & Private Beach Steps Away is less than a 10min drive from this preserve.
  • Art enthusiasts will want to stay somewhere near Division Street, such as at the charming hotel known as Baron’s Cove. You will find several local art galleries near this street, including the Grenning Gallery and the Monika Olko Gallery.
  • Visitors that want to spend their time soaking up some sun and lounging by the ocean should look for hotels that are close to Long Beach. The Newly Renovated 3 Bedroom Cottage By Best Bay Beach is less than a 5min walk from here.

FAQs when booking a hotel in Sag Harbor

  • What is a good part of Sag Harbor to stay in if I will be visiting with children?

    If you’ll be visiting the area with little ones, try to stay somewhere that is close to Mashashimuet Park, a large green space that has a fun playground and plenty of room for children to stretch their legs. The Mid century Ranch can be found just a short drive from here.

  • What are the best hotels in Sag Harbor if I want to be near a few different restaurants?

    There are quite a few delicious local restaurants that can be found near Noyack Road, including establishments like M.J. Dowling's, Bell & Anchor, and Cappelletti Restaurant & Take Out. If you would like to be able to walk to these dining options, you can always choose to stay at the Chic Sag Harbor Cottage Walking Distance To Beaches And Restaurants.

  • Is there a part of Sag Harbor that is known for being particularly affordable?

    If you’re traveling on a budget, you will want to stay in the southern part of Sag Harbor, as this area is inland and typically more affordable than on the coast. The Fabulous Contemporary Barn On Landscaped 2.8 Acres With Pool And 5 Bedrooms is a reasonable option, as well as the Sag Harbor Gem With Pool Near Town And Beach!

  • What part of Sag Harbor should I stay in if I would like to be in a scenic area?

    To be in a particularly scenic part of Sag Harbor, you will want to make sure that you select lodging that is on the coast. The Waterfront on the Bay A beautiful 5 bedroom home with dock and walk to Beach has direct views of the water.

  • What are the best hotels near Sag Harbor Whaling Museum?

    If you are looking for a hotel close to Sag Harbor Whaling Museum, you should consider staying at Baron's Cove, as it is the most recommended by KAYAK users.

  • How much does a hotel cost in Sag Harbor?

    $548 is the average price for a double room in Sag Harbor, but our users have found rooms for as cheap as $222 in the last 3 days.

  • How do I find a hotel in central Sag Harbor?

    After you launch a hotel search on KAYAK, you can refine your research by neighborhood, which allows you to pick the central Sag Harbor districts. You can also do a search using the city map to choose a specific location, like Sag Harbor city center.

  • How can I find hotels near me?

    Take a look at our extensive hotel map to find the best hotels near you.

  • Are there Sag Harbor hotels with free parking?

    There are many hotels in Sag Harbor that offer both parking and free parking. Popular choices among KAYAK users include Baron's Cove, Shelter Island House and Holiday Inn Long Island - Islip Arpt East.

Where to stay in Sag Harbor?

Our map will help you find the perfect place to stay in Sag Harbor by showing you the exact location of each hotel.