Find Cheap Flights from Columbus to Islip Long Island (CMH - ISP)

Search hundreds of travel sites at once for deals on flights to Islip Long Island

Sat 2/17
Sat 2/24
Any month
Compare vs. KAYAK |

Top tips for Finding a Cheap Flight

Looking for a cheap flight? 25% of our users found flights on this route for $341 or less.

FAQs for Booking Columbus to Islip Long Island Flights

How long does a flight from Columbus to Islip Long Island take?
An average nonstop flight takes 3h 47m, covering a distance of 517 miles.
Which airlines provide the cheapest flights from Columbus to Islip Long Island?
In the past 3 days, the cheapest round-trip tickets were found on Frontier ($254), Multiple Airlines ($269) and American Airlines ($284).
Do I need a passport to fly between Columbus and Islip Long Island?
No.
What’s the cheapest day of the week to fly Columbus to Islip Long Island?
For Columbus to Islip Long Island, Sunday is the cheapest day to fly on average and Thursday is the most expensive. Flying from Islip Long Island back to Columbus, the best deals are generally found on Tuesday, with Saturday being the most expensive.

Book cheap flights from Columbus to Islip Long Island (round-trip)

Airports
Origin
Columbus
$254
only
$254
Destination
Islip
$254
only
$254
Sun, Feb 18
CMH
ISP
7h 51m
Sat, Feb 24
ISP
CMH
9h 14m
Trip: 7 days
5.7OkayShow reviews
Overall 5.7 Okay
Based on 33843 reviews
Overall
5.9
Boarding
6.4
Comfort
5.4
Crew
6.8
Entertainment
4.5
Food
4.7
MCO
CLT
Mediocre 3.3

The flight was ok

First of all the check in lady was rude and unprofessional. The company lost y luggage resulting in extra charges When I was looking for assistance mr Prince was extremely rude, rolling the eyes and not providing support, I was lost and seeking for guidance and I had to figure it out by myself

BUF
MCO
Mediocre 3.3

The service was Ok, but our flight was 4 hours delayed and it wasn't mechanical or weather related delay, the airline made a scheduling error, we almost missed our car rental and we didn't get to our destination til really late at night when it should been there in the daytime. Overall, won't fly with them again

DEN
SFO
Mediocre 2.0

The crew was rude to the passengers. They charge form 9$ to 40$ for seat selection. Charge for a Carry on bag (anything that doesn't fit under your seat). The flights had maintenance issue, hence delayed. I will absolutely avoid traveling with frontier in the future.

TPA
LAS
Okay 4.3

Very reasonable price.

You literally have to pay for even the basic things, including for seats to recline. Cushion on seats thin and seats don't recline. 5hrs flight and No entertainment, no tv, no radio, no complimentary food...they offered a cup of water.

ISP
MIA
Excellent 10.0

Great flight from Islip to MIA. Looked at another review about water on flights and I was told by the crew that water is FREE!

Seats are small but newly redesigned.

Sat, Mar 3
CMH
ISP
3h 47m
Tue, Mar 6
ISP
CMH
7h 28m
Trip: 4 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Tue, Apr 24
CMH
ISP
4h 20m
Tue, May 1
ISP
CMH
3h 41m
Trip: 8 days
7.2GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.2 Good
Based on 28211 reviews
Overall
7.4
Boarding
7.5
Comfort
7.1
Crew
7.8
Entertainment
6.7
Food
6.7
DFW
FLL
Excellent 8.0

No issues at all

N/A

LHR
ORD
Mediocre 2.0

Nothing really. I will never book from Kayak ever

Everything

LAS
DFW
Excellent 8.0

Flight was punctual and service was good.

Gate change

JAX
DFW
Excellent 8.6

Polite. Clean. Nice business class.

Would like more Western food.

PHL
YYZ
Good 6.0

On time

Small seats

Sun, Feb 18
CMH
ISP
7h 51m
Sat, Feb 24
ISP
CMH
7h 28m
Trip: 7 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Wed, Apr 25
CMH
ISP
4h 20m
Tue, May 1
ISP
CMH
3h 41m
Trip: 7 days
7.2GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.2 Good
Based on 28211 reviews
Overall
7.4
Boarding
7.5
Comfort
7.1
Crew
7.8
Entertainment
6.7
Food
6.7
DFW
SAN
Okay 5.3

Direct flight from desired origin to destination Boarding by zones

Uncomfortable, small, seat space with inadequate legroom. Lack of personal entertainment options. Paid extra for earlier boarding group which only benefited me by about 5 people. (NOT WORTH IT!) Lack of complimentary food options. (Pay for everything)

JAX
DFW
Excellent 8.6

Polite. Clean. Nice business class.

Would like more Western food.

CLT
ILM
Mediocre 3.0

Three hours delay. I paid for a upgrade to first class. But because of the flight change i didn't get to keep my upgrade and I had to beg for a refund. I have had two trips in the past 5 days and all flights have been anywhere from 1 to 3 hours late. Worst experience with AA I have had in a long time.

PHL
YYZ
Good 6.0

On time

Small seats

PHX
GEG
Good 7.3

The crew was friendly and informative. They were very helpful. The

The seats were uncomfortable. They were hard and so narrow I had to sit crooked in the seat to keep from getting banged into by the service carts and every person going by to the bathrooms. I'm not tiny, but I'm not huge either, it was just overcrowded. It was also very hot in the airplane the entire way from Phoenix to Spokane. My husband, who is always cold, was even hot.

Sat, Apr 28
CMH
ISP
4h 20m
Tue, May 1
ISP
CMH
3h 41m
Trip: 4 days
7.2GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.2 Good
Based on 28211 reviews
Overall
7.4
Boarding
7.5
Comfort
7.1
Crew
7.8
Entertainment
6.7
Food
6.7
DFW
SAN
Okay 5.3

Direct flight from desired origin to destination Boarding by zones

Uncomfortable, small, seat space with inadequate legroom. Lack of personal entertainment options. Paid extra for earlier boarding group which only benefited me by about 5 people. (NOT WORTH IT!) Lack of complimentary food options. (Pay for everything)

SJU
MIA
Excellent 9.3

New onboard entertainment

CLT
ILM
Mediocre 3.0

Three hours delay. I paid for a upgrade to first class. But because of the flight change i didn't get to keep my upgrade and I had to beg for a refund. I have had two trips in the past 5 days and all flights have been anywhere from 1 to 3 hours late. Worst experience with AA I have had in a long time.

DFW
FLL
Excellent 8.0

No issues at all

N/A

ORD
CLT
Mediocre 3.0

Three hours delay. I paid for a upgrade to first class. But because of the flight change i didn't get to keep my upgrade and I had to beg for a refund. I have had two trips in the past 5 days and all flights have been anywhere from 1 to 3 hours late. Worst experience with AA I have had in a long time.

Fri, Apr 13
CMH
ISP
7h 55m
Mon, Apr 16
ISP
CMH
7h 20m
Trip: 4 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Mon, Apr 23
CMH
ISP
6h 53m
Wed, Apr 25
ISP
CMH
4h 01m
Trip: 3 days
7.2GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.2 Good
Based on 28211 reviews
Overall
7.4
Boarding
7.5
Comfort
7.1
Crew
7.8
Entertainment
6.7
Food
6.7
ORD
CLT
Mediocre 3.0

Three hours delay. I paid for a upgrade to first class. But because of the flight change i didn't get to keep my upgrade and I had to beg for a refund. I have had two trips in the past 5 days and all flights have been anywhere from 1 to 3 hours late. Worst experience with AA I have had in a long time.

SAT
PHL
Excellent 8.0

I took American's first direct flight between Philadelphia and San Antonio. It was a nice plane, good service, and amenities for a cost. Love that the plane had plugs!

DFW
FLL
Excellent 8.0

No issues at all

N/A

PHL
YYZ
Good 6.0

On time

Small seats

DFW
SAN
Okay 5.3

Direct flight from desired origin to destination Boarding by zones

Uncomfortable, small, seat space with inadequate legroom. Lack of personal entertainment options. Paid extra for earlier boarding group which only benefited me by about 5 people. (NOT WORTH IT!) Lack of complimentary food options. (Pay for everything)

Thu, Feb 22
CMH
ISP
7h 51m
Sat, Feb 24
ISP
CMH
9h 14m
Trip: 3 days
5.7OkayShow reviews
Overall 5.7 Okay
Based on 33843 reviews
Overall
5.9
Boarding
6.4
Comfort
5.4
Crew
6.8
Entertainment
4.5
Food
4.7
ORD
RSW
Good 6.0

Crew was super nice

Delayed 3 hours, boarded and was told would be another 30minutes because of mechanical issues.

BUF
MCO
Mediocre 3.3

The service was Ok, but our flight was 4 hours delayed and it wasn't mechanical or weather related delay, the airline made a scheduling error, we almost missed our car rental and we didn't get to our destination til really late at night when it should been there in the daytime. Overall, won't fly with them again

TPA
LAS
Okay 4.3

Very reasonable price.

You literally have to pay for even the basic things, including for seats to recline. Cushion on seats thin and seats don't recline. 5hrs flight and No entertainment, no tv, no radio, no complimentary food...they offered a cup of water.

DEN
SFO
Mediocre 2.0

The crew was rude to the passengers. They charge form 9$ to 40$ for seat selection. Charge for a Carry on bag (anything that doesn't fit under your seat). The flights had maintenance issue, hence delayed. I will absolutely avoid traveling with frontier in the future.

BUF
MCO
Good 7.3

Flight was great. Checkin etc was great

Fri, Mar 2
CMH
ISP
11h 20m
Sun, Mar 4
ISP
CMH
9h 34m
Trip: 3 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Tue, Apr 24
CMH
ISP
4h 20m
Mon, Apr 30
ISP
CMH
3h 41m
Trip: 7 days
7.2GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.2 Good
Based on 28211 reviews
Overall
7.4
Boarding
7.5
Comfort
7.1
Crew
7.8
Entertainment
6.7
Food
6.7
DFW
FLL
Excellent 8.0

No issues at all

N/A

SAT
PHL
Excellent 8.0

I took American's first direct flight between Philadelphia and San Antonio. It was a nice plane, good service, and amenities for a cost. Love that the plane had plugs!

DFW
SAN
Okay 5.3

Direct flight from desired origin to destination Boarding by zones

Uncomfortable, small, seat space with inadequate legroom. Lack of personal entertainment options. Paid extra for earlier boarding group which only benefited me by about 5 people. (NOT WORTH IT!) Lack of complimentary food options. (Pay for everything)

SJU
MIA
Excellent 9.3

New onboard entertainment

ORD
CLT
Mediocre 3.0

Three hours delay. I paid for a upgrade to first class. But because of the flight change i didn't get to keep my upgrade and I had to beg for a refund. I have had two trips in the past 5 days and all flights have been anywhere from 1 to 3 hours late. Worst experience with AA I have had in a long time.

Sun, Feb 18
CMH
ISP
7h 51m
Tue, Feb 20
ISP
CMH
9h 01m
Trip: 3 days
5.7OkayShow reviews
Overall 5.7 Okay
Based on 33843 reviews
Overall
5.9
Boarding
6.4
Comfort
5.4
Crew
6.8
Entertainment
4.5
Food
4.7
ORD
RSW
Good 6.0

Crew was super nice

Delayed 3 hours, boarded and was told would be another 30minutes because of mechanical issues.

DEN
SFO
Mediocre 2.0

The crew was rude to the passengers. They charge form 9$ to 40$ for seat selection. Charge for a Carry on bag (anything that doesn't fit under your seat). The flights had maintenance issue, hence delayed. I will absolutely avoid traveling with frontier in the future.

DCA
DEN
Excellent 8.0

Friendly staff

Didn't like I wasn't offered a cup of water and they nickel and dime you for EVERYTHING!

MCO
CLT
Mediocre 3.3

The flight was ok

First of all the check in lady was rude and unprofessional. The company lost y luggage resulting in extra charges When I was looking for assistance mr Prince was extremely rude, rolling the eyes and not providing support, I was lost and seeking for guidance and I had to figure it out by myself

DEN
ORD
Excellent 9.6

They left me alone.

Fold down tables are tiny

Sun, Feb 18
CMH
ISP
7h 51m
Thu, Feb 22
ISP
CMH
7h 28m
Trip: 5 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Wed, Apr 25
CMH
ISP
4h 20m
Mon, Apr 30
ISP
CMH
3h 41m
Trip: 6 days
7.2GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.2 Good
Based on 28211 reviews
Overall
7.4
Boarding
7.5
Comfort
7.1
Crew
7.8
Entertainment
6.7
Food
6.7
SAT
PHL
Excellent 8.0

I took American's first direct flight between Philadelphia and San Antonio. It was a nice plane, good service, and amenities for a cost. Love that the plane had plugs!

ORD
CLT
Mediocre 3.0

Three hours delay. I paid for a upgrade to first class. But because of the flight change i didn't get to keep my upgrade and I had to beg for a refund. I have had two trips in the past 5 days and all flights have been anywhere from 1 to 3 hours late. Worst experience with AA I have had in a long time.

PHL
YYZ
Good 6.0

On time

Small seats

CLT
LGA
Excellent 10.0

Ability to upgrade to first class

Security taking forever

DFW
SAN
Okay 5.3

Direct flight from desired origin to destination Boarding by zones

Uncomfortable, small, seat space with inadequate legroom. Lack of personal entertainment options. Paid extra for earlier boarding group which only benefited me by about 5 people. (NOT WORTH IT!) Lack of complimentary food options. (Pay for everything)

Thu, Mar 15
CMH
ISP
7h 47m
Sun, Mar 18
ISP
CMH
9h 35m
Trip: 4 days
5.7OkayShow reviews
Overall 5.7 Okay
Based on 33843 reviews
Overall
5.9
Boarding
6.4
Comfort
5.4
Crew
6.8
Entertainment
4.5
Food
4.7
PHL
DEN
Mediocre 2.0

This is actually almost a funny question because Frontier is the worst Airlines well actually that's not true spirit is the worst Airlines the seats are uncomfortable it takes about an hour and a half to just put your bags and baggage drop and then when you get on the plane They don't serve you anything they have no entertainment your crowded in can't move people are rude worst hairlines ever

Every single thing

MCO
CLT
Mediocre 3.3

The flight was ok

First of all the check in lady was rude and unprofessional. The company lost y luggage resulting in extra charges When I was looking for assistance mr Prince was extremely rude, rolling the eyes and not providing support, I was lost and seeking for guidance and I had to figure it out by myself

BUF
MCO
Mediocre 3.3

The service was Ok, but our flight was 4 hours delayed and it wasn't mechanical or weather related delay, the airline made a scheduling error, we almost missed our car rental and we didn't get to our destination til really late at night when it should been there in the daytime. Overall, won't fly with them again

MKE
TPA
Mediocre 2.0

the flights and attendents were good ,flight was delayed almost 2 hours on my return flight

didnt have to pay for luggage on first flight put under seat on return flight the girl at ticket counter was rude to me and charged me 45.00 for my bag i put under my seat and she was not a pleasant person to deal with, i wouldnt fly frontier again

TPA
LAS
Okay 4.3

Very reasonable price.

You literally have to pay for even the basic things, including for seats to recline. Cushion on seats thin and seats don't recline. 5hrs flight and No entertainment, no tv, no radio, no complimentary food...they offered a cup of water.

Thu, Apr 26
CMH
ISP
4h 30m
Tue, May 1
ISP
CMH
3h 41m
Trip: 6 days
7.2GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.2 Good
Based on 28211 reviews
Overall
7.4
Boarding
7.5
Comfort
7.1
Crew
7.8
Entertainment
6.7
Food
6.7
JAX
DFW
Excellent 8.6

Polite. Clean. Nice business class.

Would like more Western food.

DFW
FLL
Excellent 8.0

No issues at all

N/A

LAS
DFW
Excellent 8.0

Flight was punctual and service was good.

Gate change

PHX
GEG
Good 7.3

The crew was friendly and informative. They were very helpful. The

The seats were uncomfortable. They were hard and so narrow I had to sit crooked in the seat to keep from getting banged into by the service carts and every person going by to the bathrooms. I'm not tiny, but I'm not huge either, it was just overcrowded. It was also very hot in the airplane the entire way from Phoenix to Spokane. My husband, who is always cold, was even hot.

CLT
LGA
Excellent 10.0

Ability to upgrade to first class

Security taking forever

Tue, Feb 20
CMH
ISP
7h 51m
Sat, Feb 24
ISP
CMH
7h 28m
Trip: 5 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Sat, Apr 28
CMH
ISP
4h 20m
Mon, Apr 30
ISP
CMH
3h 41m
Trip: 3 days
7.2GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.2 Good
Based on 28211 reviews
Overall
7.4
Boarding
7.5
Comfort
7.1
Crew
7.8
Entertainment
6.7
Food
6.7
DFW
SAN
Okay 5.3

Direct flight from desired origin to destination Boarding by zones

Uncomfortable, small, seat space with inadequate legroom. Lack of personal entertainment options. Paid extra for earlier boarding group which only benefited me by about 5 people. (NOT WORTH IT!) Lack of complimentary food options. (Pay for everything)

ORD
CLT
Mediocre 3.0

Three hours delay. I paid for a upgrade to first class. But because of the flight change i didn't get to keep my upgrade and I had to beg for a refund. I have had two trips in the past 5 days and all flights have been anywhere from 1 to 3 hours late. Worst experience with AA I have had in a long time.

LHR
ORD
Mediocre 2.0

Nothing really. I will never book from Kayak ever

Everything

PHL
YYZ
Good 6.0

On time

Small seats

SAT
PHL
Excellent 8.0

I took American's first direct flight between Philadelphia and San Antonio. It was a nice plane, good service, and amenities for a cost. Love that the plane had plugs!

Sun, Feb 18
CMH
ISP
7h 51m
Wed, Feb 21
ISP
CMH
7h 28m
Trip: 4 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Wed, Mar 28
CMH
ISP
6h 24m
Mon, Apr 2
ISP
CMH
8h 10m
Trip: 6 days
7.2GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.2 Good
Based on 28211 reviews
Overall
7.4
Boarding
7.5
Comfort
7.1
Crew
7.8
Entertainment
6.7
Food
6.7
SAT
PHL
Excellent 8.0

I took American's first direct flight between Philadelphia and San Antonio. It was a nice plane, good service, and amenities for a cost. Love that the plane had plugs!

CLT
LGA
Excellent 10.0

Ability to upgrade to first class

Security taking forever

DFW
FLL
Excellent 8.0

No issues at all

N/A

ORD
CLT
Mediocre 3.0

Three hours delay. I paid for a upgrade to first class. But because of the flight change i didn't get to keep my upgrade and I had to beg for a refund. I have had two trips in the past 5 days and all flights have been anywhere from 1 to 3 hours late. Worst experience with AA I have had in a long time.

LHR
ORD
Mediocre 2.0

Nothing really. I will never book from Kayak ever

Everything

Columbus to Islip Long Island Flight Information

Flights Arrive in Islip Long Island
Flights Depart from Columbus
Flight Price $254
Distance 517 miles
Airlines Frontier, American Airlines
*
Prices are per person and are for e–tickets and include all taxes & fees in USD.

We attempt to get accurate prices, however, prices are not guaranteed.

Here's why:

We’re not the seller.
At KAYAK we don’t set the prices, so it’s not possible for us to guarantee what other companies are selling.

We compile tonnes of data for you
Our service lets you quickly and easily compare results from hundreds of travel sites at once. In this sense, KAYAK is a search engine and we can't guarantee prices we find.

Why aren’t prices accurate 100% of the time?
Prices on airline seats, hotel rooms and car rentals can change frequently. Several people may also be trying to buy the same travel option simultaneously. As a result, you may find, on occasion, that certain prices are no longer available.

If you have more questions or if you have a bad price to report to us,
please send us an and someone from our team will get back to you promptly.

^
The fares displayed include all taxes and fees for economy class travel and were found by the provider in the last 72 hours. Seats are limited and may not be available on all flights and days. Fares are subject to change and may not be available on all flights or dates of travel. Some carriers charge additional fees for extra checked bags. Please check the carriers' sites.