Find Cheap Flights from Key West to New York (EYW - NYC)

Search hundreds of travel sites at once for deals on flights to New York

Sat 12/16
Sat 12/23
Any month
Compare vs. KAYAK |

Good to Know

Average Price:
$394
(avg. price over the last 2 weeks)
Good Deal:
$294
or less (round trip)

When to Book Flights from Key West to New York

Flight prices as travel date approaches
-1 day
-2 days

Top tips for Finding a Cheap Flight

Looking for a cheap flight? 25% of our users found flights on this route for $294 or less.
The cheapest flight from Key West to New York was found 45 days before departure, on average.
Book at least 4 weeks before departure in order to get a below-average price.
Morning departure is around 12% more expensive than an evening flight, on average*.
*Average of the lowest prices shown in KAYAK’s search results for departures within the next 30 days

FAQs for Booking Key West to New York Flights

How long does a flight from Key West to New York take?
An average nonstop flight takes 3h 05m, covering a distance of 1206 miles.
How many flights are there between Key West and New York?
There are 15 (nonstop) flights between Key West and New York per week, averaging 2 per day.
Which airlines provide the cheapest flights from Key West to New York?
In the past 3 days, the cheapest round-trip tickets were found on Multiple Airlines ($251), JetBlue ($304) and American Airlines ($401).
Do I need a passport to fly between Key West and New York?
No.
Which airlines fly most frequently between Key West and New York?
United (2 times daily) are the most frequent flyers on this route.
What’s the cheapest day of the week to fly Key West to New York?
For Key West to New York, Friday is the cheapest day to fly on average and Thursday is the most expensive. Flying from New York back to Key West, the best deals are generally found on Wednesday, with Friday being the most expensive.

Book cheap flights from Key West to New York (round-trip)

Airports
Origin
Key West
$251
only
$251
Destination
New York
$254
only
$254
$332
only
$332
Newark
$251
only
$251
Fri, Jan 12
EYW
EWR
6h 09m
Mon, Jan 15
EWR
EYW
5h 04m
Trip: 4 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Thu, Feb 8
EYW
EWR
8h 29m
Sun, Feb 11
EWR
EYW
5h 39m
Trip: 4 days
8.2ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.2 Excellent
Based on 7213 reviews
Overall
8.2
Boarding
8.3
Comfort
8.3
Crew
8.6
Entertainment
8.0
Food
7.8
MCO
DCA
Excellent 10.0

Left on time and arrived early both ways.

JFK
ABQ
Good 7.3

I know it's hard to make a 14+ hour flight in economy enjoyable, but more varied food selections and better/more current movies to choose from would have helped.

BOS
DCA
Mediocre 2.0

There was a huge glitch in your ticketing, resulting in me confirming the same ticket 3 times. After calling Jetblue for customer service per your advice, they first suggested to give Jetblue credits for extra tickets. When I insisted that the issue was solely caused by kayak-jetblue ticketing connection issues, they supervisor approved to cancel 2 credit card payments... BUT I have to wait for 2 weeks to see the cancellation on my credit card. Unfair and ridiculous, if you as me.

SFO
FLL
Good 7.0

Once again the system for my seat did not work. Fortunately, the middle seat was empty and I wa able to watch that screen.

Entertainment System did not work at my seat. WiFi signal was not strong enough for me to watch any videos on my device.

JFK
SYR
Good 7.0

TV didn't work

Fri, Jan 5
EYW
JFK
5h 32m
Sat, Jan 6
JFK
EYW
5h 42m
Trip: 2 days
7.2GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.2 Good
Based on 26055 reviews
Overall
7.3
Boarding
7.5
Comfort
7.1
Crew
7.8
Entertainment
6.7
Food
6.6
ORD
LAX
Excellent 9.5

Easy, smooth.

YUL
MIA
Excellent 10.0

First time flyer with American airlines and the service was impeccable

Nothing to dislike

ATL
CLT
Excellent 9.6

The flight was late

BNA
DFW
Good 7.3

Everything else

LAX
LHR
Excellent 9.2

Easy and efficient boarding for a busy flight. Efficient, attentive and intuitive cabin crew. Good in-flight entertainment and facilities.

The aircraft was extremely cold throughout the duration of the flight. Of all of the long haul airlines I've flown with, I find that American Airlines offers the least leg room.

Fri, Mar 16
EYW
LGA
12h 11m
Mon, Mar 19
LGA
EYW
8h 44m
Trip: 4 days
7.0GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.0 Good
Based on 52353 reviews
Overall
7.2
Boarding
7.4
Comfort
6.9
Crew
7.7
Entertainment
6.5
Food
6.4
LAX
NRT
Good 7.3

Good price

Stink in the plane

MIA
ORD
Excellent 9.0

That it got me to Paris safe

No outlets to charge your phone, and the tv played the same movie over and over. The meals were also cheap. Didn't like any of them. Should have flown southwest or delta.

RSW
EWR
Okay 5.3

Waiting

IAD
MUC
Good 6.3

Crew and food.

The old bait and switch. United is not and will never be Lufthansa. Cattle call seating.

RSW
EWR
Okay 5.3

Boarding quickly

No PED was available didn’t have anything for entertainment if you weren’t buying it seems every thing available for 3 hour flight and flight was scheduled for 2 hours and 55 minutes No snacks made available came thru once had a small bag of pretzels cup of coffee and never came back

Wed, Feb 7
EYW
LGA
5h 35m
Sat, Feb 10
LGA
EYW
20h 58m
Trip: 4 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Fri, Dec 29
EYW
LGA
6h 17m
Wed, Jan 3
LGA
EYW
8h 31m
Trip: 6 days
7.8GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.8 Good
Based on 14257 reviews
Overall
8.0
Boarding
8.1
Comfort
7.7
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
7.5
Food
7.3
JFK
MIA
Okay 5.3

Some of the flight attendants were rude and not very welcoming at all.

LGA
ORD
Excellent 10.0

Flight was on time. Boarded quickly with no fuss.

MSP
YXE
Excellent 9.3

I was traveling for medical reasons and the Delta crew took great care of me, made sure I was at my connecting gate on time, and even put me in a better seat on the plane. Not sure if that was a coincidental upgrade, or intentional, but it was perfect.

ATL
ABE
Okay 4.0

Long wait for de-Icing. Got on and off the plane 3 times. First wait was 1 hour, but plane aborted takeoff. Second plane waited at gate with all aboard for 2-1/2 hours and never got slot and de-planed. Third plane waited 1-1/2 hours for de-Icing and finally we were headed home. Arrived 8.5 hours after schedule.

JFK
ATL
Excellent 8.3

We had the best flight attendant ever! Her name was Sharon on Eandeavor / Delta Cnx, and she made the experience the best flight I've experienced. Thanks Sharon for being awesome!

window seat in back didn't have window

Thu, Feb 15
EYW
LGA
5h 00m
Wed, Feb 21
LGA
EYW
5h 53m
Trip: 7 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Fri, Mar 16
EYW
EWR
9h 27m
Mon, Mar 19
EWR
EYW
6h 36m
Trip: 4 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Thu, Feb 8
EYW
LGA
5h 30m
Sun, Feb 11
LGA
EYW
7h 08m
Trip: 4 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Thu, Feb 15
EYW
EWR
10h 44m
Wed, Feb 21
EWR
EYW
8h 00m
Trip: 7 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Sat, Jan 6
EYW
LGA
8h 05m
Wed, Jan 10
LGA
EYW
5h 25m
Trip: 5 days
7.2GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.2 Good
Based on 26055 reviews
Overall
7.3
Boarding
7.5
Comfort
7.1
Crew
7.8
Entertainment
6.7
Food
6.6
CLE
JFK
Mediocre 3.3

Plane was dirty and crew inattentive.

SFO
DFW
Excellent 10.0

On time. Comfortable seat. Courteous crew. Easy transfer.

YUL
MIA
Excellent 10.0

First time flyer with American airlines and the service was impeccable

Nothing to dislike

ORD
LAX
Excellent 9.5

Easy, smooth.

LAX
AKL
Okay 5.6

Smooth operation, on time

Seat pitch on the plane unbelievably cramped. When seats are so close that if you drop something on the floor you have to be a contortionist to get it, you know it's a problem NEVER fly the 787-900 economy.

Sat, Dec 16
EYW
JFK
7h 50m
Sun, Dec 17
JFK
EYW
5h 47m
Trip: 2 days
8.2ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.2 Excellent
Based on 7213 reviews
Overall
8.2
Boarding
8.3
Comfort
8.3
Crew
8.6
Entertainment
8.0
Food
7.8
MCO
PVD
Excellent 10.0

Great flight great experience

Long lines at TSA checkpoint.

FLL
RDU
Excellent 8.3

The departure and arrival times were accurate. Actually we arrived about 15 minutes early.

There was only one individual checking people boarding. Two individuals at the boarding gate would have been even more efficient.

JFK
SYR
Good 7.0

TV didn't work

BOS
PBI
Excellent 8.3

my attendant

MCO
DCA
Excellent 10.0

Left on time and arrived early both ways.

Tue, Dec 26
EYW
EWR
17h 37m
Mon, Jan 1
EWR
EYW
7h 07m
Trip: 7 days
8.7ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.7 Excellent
Based on 2 reviews
Overall
7.2
Boarding
7.4
Comfort
6.9
Crew
7.7
Entertainment
6.5
Food
6.4
RSW
EWR
Okay 5.3

Boarding quickly

No PED was available didn’t have anything for entertainment if you weren’t buying it seems every thing available for 3 hour flight and flight was scheduled for 2 hours and 55 minutes No snacks made available came thru once had a small bag of pretzels cup of coffee and never came back

IAD
CDG
Good 7.6

The food was particularly poor this flight.

PUJ
EWR
Good 7.3

The flight was very hot and uncomfortable

RSW
EWR
Okay 5.3

Waiting

EYW
EWR
Good 7.3

crew

entertainment was missing movies it said it had. also kept skipping ahead throughout time. also would have been nice to have a refill

Fri, Dec 29
EYW
LGA
6h 24m
Mon, Jan 1
LGA
EYW
5h 54m
Trip: 4 days
7.2GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.2 Good
Based on 26055 reviews
Overall
7.3
Boarding
7.5
Comfort
7.1
Crew
7.8
Entertainment
6.7
Food
6.6
JFK
CDG
Mediocre 2.0

Nothing. From the plane to the awful delay and poor service.

Lack of communication. Old plane, no comfort and 6 HOURS DELAYED. Truly disappointed by the airline

CLT
SJU
Mediocre 3.3

Direct flight

Horrible customer service, excessive baggage fees, rude counter staff, no leg room, narrow seats

JFK
MXP
Mediocre 2.6

Plane was old and dirty, seat pocket had junk in it. Seat was broken and couldn’t stay up. In flight movies were from few years back with a center tv and no head rest screen. Crew on overseas flights tend to be older in age and less tolerant..much better on continental on the same route.

DFW
SCL
Excellent 9.6

The food is very tasty, but AA has not changed the menu in at least one year.

ORD
LAX
Excellent 9.5

Easy, smooth.

Mon, Dec 25
EYW
EWR
8h 34m
Wed, Jan 3
EWR
EYW
7h 48m
Trip: 10 days
8.2ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.2 Excellent
Based on 7213 reviews
Overall
8.2
Boarding
8.3
Comfort
8.3
Crew
8.6
Entertainment
8.0
Food
7.8
FLL
LAS
Good 6.3

The flight was delayed by 2 hours

MCO
DCA
Excellent 10.0

Left on time and arrived early both ways.

SEA
JFK
Excellent 8.0

no power outlets

FLL
RDU
Excellent 8.3

The departure and arrival times were accurate. Actually we arrived about 15 minutes early.

There was only one individual checking people boarding. Two individuals at the boarding gate would have been even more efficient.

FLL
KIN
Okay 4.0

The flight attendants were pleasant and courteous

The boarding was delayed and the boarding area was crowded, Boarding was delayed due to high number of wheelchair passengers. I was seated in an Even More Space seat, yet was placed beside a woman who was obviously suffering from some degenerative condition, and was slumped over towards my seat. The result was that I was uncomfortable the whole way back to Kingston.

Fri, Dec 29
EYW
EWR
3h 05m
Wed, Jan 3
EWR
EYW
3h 31m
Trip: 6 days
8.7ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.7 Excellent
Based on 2 reviews
Overall
7.2
Boarding
7.4
Comfort
6.9
Crew
7.7
Entertainment
6.5
Food
6.4
EWR
BTV
Excellent 10.0

All the effort to make my need for wheelchair problem free

RSW
EWR
Okay 5.3

Boarding quickly

No PED was available didn’t have anything for entertainment if you weren’t buying it seems every thing available for 3 hour flight and flight was scheduled for 2 hours and 55 minutes No snacks made available came thru once had a small bag of pretzels cup of coffee and never came back

MCO
EWR
Excellent 10.0

Excellent support from everyone as all were very helpful with assisting my need for wheel chair.

PUJ
EWR
Good 7.3

The flight was very hot and uncomfortable

IAD
MUC
Good 6.3

Crew and food.

The old bait and switch. United is not and will never be Lufthansa. Cattle call seating.

Fri, Mar 16
EYW
JFK
10h 17m
Mon, Mar 19
JFK
EYW
5h 52m
Trip: 4 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Thu, Dec 28
EYW
JFK
5h 46m
Mon, Jan 1
JFK
EYW
5h 19m
Trip: 5 days
7.8GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.8 Good
Based on 14257 reviews
Overall
8.0
Boarding
8.1
Comfort
7.7
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
7.5
Food
7.3
ATL
DFW
Excellent 10.0

My entire flight experience was delightful. Was dry impressed with the staff both at Hartsfield-Jackson and DFW...and our flight crew was positively sublime.

MSP
YXE
Excellent 9.3

I was traveling for medical reasons and the Delta crew took great care of me, made sure I was at my connecting gate on time, and even put me in a better seat on the plane. Not sure if that was a coincidental upgrade, or intentional, but it was perfect.

GSO
ATL
Excellent 10.0

Plane nice and comfortable

DEN
ATL
Excellent 8.6

On two of the legs of the trip they notice I was a tall person with long legs and upgraded me to seats with more leg room!! I didn't even ask. Thank you.

On the way back there were open seats with extra leg room and I asked the gate attendant if it was possible to switch my seat to one with more room and they said they only could if I paid extra.

JFK
MIA
Okay 5.3

Some of the flight attendants were rude and not very welcoming at all.

Tue, Dec 26
EYW
EWR
11h 11m
Tue, Jan 2
EWR
EYW
6h 54m
Trip: 8 days
7.2GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.2 Good
Based on 26055 reviews
Overall
7.3
Boarding
7.5
Comfort
7.1
Crew
7.8
Entertainment
6.7
Food
6.6
SFO
DFW
Excellent 10.0

On time. Comfortable seat. Courteous crew. Easy transfer.

YUL
MIA
Excellent 10.0

First time flyer with American airlines and the service was impeccable

Nothing to dislike

LAX
AKL
Okay 5.6

Smooth operation, on time

Seat pitch on the plane unbelievably cramped. When seats are so close that if you drop something on the floor you have to be a contortionist to get it, you know it's a problem NEVER fly the 787-900 economy.

JFK
CDG
Mediocre 2.0

Nothing. From the plane to the awful delay and poor service.

Lack of communication. Old plane, no comfort and 6 HOURS DELAYED. Truly disappointed by the airline

CLT
SJU
Mediocre 3.3

Direct flight

Horrible customer service, excessive baggage fees, rude counter staff, no leg room, narrow seats

Sat, Jan 6
EYW
JFK
5h 32m
Wed, Jan 10
JFK
EYW
5h 25m
Trip: 5 days
7.2GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.2 Good
Based on 26055 reviews
Overall
7.3
Boarding
7.5
Comfort
7.1
Crew
7.8
Entertainment
6.7
Food
6.6
LAX
AKL
Okay 5.6

Smooth operation, on time

Seat pitch on the plane unbelievably cramped. When seats are so close that if you drop something on the floor you have to be a contortionist to get it, you know it's a problem NEVER fly the 787-900 economy.

YUL
MIA
Excellent 10.0

First time flyer with American airlines and the service was impeccable

Nothing to dislike

BNA
DFW
Good 7.3

Everything else

JFK
MXP
Mediocre 2.6

Plane was old and dirty, seat pocket had junk in it. Seat was broken and couldn’t stay up. In flight movies were from few years back with a center tv and no head rest screen. Crew on overseas flights tend to be older in age and less tolerant..much better on continental on the same route.

DFW
SCL
Excellent 9.6

The food is very tasty, but AA has not changed the menu in at least one year.

Show more results
*
Prices are per person and are for e–tickets and include all taxes & fees in USD.

We attempt to get accurate prices, however, prices are not guaranteed.

Here's why:

We’re not the seller.
At KAYAK we don’t set the prices, so it’s not possible for us to guarantee what other companies are selling.

We compile tonnes of data for you
Our service lets you quickly and easily compare results from hundreds of travel sites at once. In this sense, KAYAK is a search engine and we can't guarantee prices we find.

Why aren’t prices accurate 100% of the time?
Prices on airline seats, hotel rooms and car rentals can change frequently. Several people may also be trying to buy the same travel option simultaneously. As a result, you may find, on occasion, that certain prices are no longer available.

If you have more questions or if you have a bad price to report to us,
please send us an and someone from our team will get back to you promptly.

^
The fares displayed include all taxes and fees for economy class travel and were found by the provider in the last 72 hours. Seats are limited and may not be available on all flights and days. Fares are subject to change and may not be available on all flights or dates of travel. Some carriers charge additional fees for extra checked bags. Please check the carriers' sites.