$47 Find Cheap Flights from New York to Islamorada

This is the cheapest one-way flight price found by a KAYAK user in the last 72 hours by searching for a flight from New York to Islamorada departing on 4/16. Fares are subject to change and may not be available on all flights or dates of travel. Click the price to replicate the search for this deal.
1 adult
1 adult, Economy, 0 bags

KAYAK searches hundreds of travel sites at once for deals on flights from New York to Islamorada

Travelers love KAYAK
41,299,237 searches in the past 7 days on KAYAK

Save 23% or moreCompare multiple travel sites with one search.

Track pricesNot ready to book? Create a price alert for when prices drop.

Free to useThere are no hidden charges or fees.

Filter your dealsChoose cabin class, free Wi-Fi and more.

Everything you should know

Cheapest round-trip
$100
Typical prices: $349-$163
Spirit Airlines
Sat 5/2Sat 5/16
LGA - MIA • Non-stop
Cheapest one-way
$47
Typical prices: $98-$234
Spirit Airlines
Thu 4/16
LGA - MIA • Non-stop
Arrival airport
You can't fly directly to Islamorada. It is served by Miami (MIA), located 63.9 miles from Islamorada.
FAQs
FAQs
FAQs
FAQs
Start a new search
KAYAK searches 100s of sites at once to find you the best travel deals.
We hope you love your trip to Islamorada!
Flight Deals
Useful Info
Flight Deals

Cheap Flights from New York to Islamorada (NYC-MIA)

 
Here are some of the best deals found on KAYAK recently from the most popular airlines for round-trip flights from New York to Islamorada that are departing in the next months. While these flights were available on KAYAK in the last 72 hours, prices and availability are subject to change and deals may expire.
Discover the best prices for you by selecting your travel dates on KAYAK.

Recent round-trip flight deals from New York to Islamorada

Sat, May 2 - Sat, May 16
Spirit Airlines Logo
9:59 am - 1:04 pm
LGA
-
MIA
3h 05mnonstop
Spirit Airlines Logo
9:39 am - 12:36 pm
MIA
-
LGA
2h 57mnonstop
$100Spirit Airlines
Wed, Apr 22 - Wed, Apr 29
Spirit Airlines Logo
9:59 am - 1:04 pm
LGA
-
MIA
3h 05mnonstop
Spirit Airlines Logo
4:05 pm - 7:00 pm
MIA
-
LGA
2h 55mnonstop
$101Spirit Airlines
Mon, May 4 - Fri, May 15
Spirit Airlines Logo
9:59 am - 1:04 pm
LGA
-
MIA
3h 05mnonstop
Spirit Airlines Logo
4:03 pm - 7:00 pm
MIA
-
LGA
2h 57mnonstop
$103Spirit Airlines
Fri, May 8 - Sat, May 16
Spirit Airlines Logo
9:59 am - 1:04 pm
LGA
-
MIA
3h 05mnonstop
Spirit Airlines Logo
9:39 am - 12:36 pm
MIA
-
LGA
2h 57mnonstop
$104Spirit Airlines
Sun, May 10 - Sat, May 16
Spirit Airlines Logo
9:59 am - 1:04 pm
LGA
-
MIA
3h 05mnonstop
Spirit Airlines Logo
9:39 am - 12:36 pm
MIA
-
LGA
2h 57mnonstop
$105Spirit Airlines
Mon, May 11 - Thu, May 14
Spirit Airlines Logo
9:59 am - 1:04 pm
LGA
-
MIA
3h 05mnonstop
Spirit Airlines Logo
4:03 pm - 7:00 pm
MIA
-
LGA
2h 57mnonstop
$106Spirit Airlines
Mon, Apr 13 - Tue, Apr 21
Frontier Logo
10:55 pm - 2:11 am
LGA
-
MIA
3h 16mnonstop
Frontier Logo
1:05 pm - 8:59 pm
MIA
-
LGA
7h 54m
1 stop
$108Frontier
Mon, Apr 13 - Tue, Apr 21
Frontier Logo
11:30 am - 2:47 pm
JFK
-
MIA
3h 17mnonstop
Frontier Logo
7:04 pm - 11:50 am
MIA
-
JFK
16h 46m
1 stop
$111Frontier
Mon, Apr 13 - Tue, Apr 21
Frontier Logo
11:30 am - 2:47 pm
JFK
-
MIA
3h 17mnonstop
Frontier Logo
1:05 pm - 11:50 am
MIA
-
JFK
22h 45m
1 stop
$113Frontier
Wed, Apr 15 - Thu, Apr 23
Multiple Airlines Logo
1:19 pm - 4:22 pm
EWR
-
MIA
3h 03mnonstop
Multiple Airlines Logo
11:12 am - 5:29 pm
MIA
-
EWR
6h 17m
1 stop
$122Multiple Airlines
Useful Info

Good to know

Low seasonSeptember
Cheapest flight$47
Best time to beat the crowds with an average 35% drop in price.
Most popular time to fly with an average 16% increase in price.
Flight from New York LaGuardia Airport to Miami

When to book flights from New York to Islamorada

Are your dates flexible? Find out the best times to travel from New York to Islamorada based on our flight data from the last year. Discover the cheapest month and even day to fly.
Estimated round-trip price

Flights from New York to Islamorada: the best tips from KAYAK users' own experiences

Insights shared by verified travelers who flew the route from New York to Islamorada 
Verified travelerFlew with Frontier
LGA
-
MIA
Feb 2025
Get to the airport early. Miami is a popular destination and it’s better to be at the gate early.
Verified travelerFlew with Spirit Airlines
LGA
-
MIA
Jan 2025
You don't need to be there that early, an hour earlier than the departure for a local airport is fine.
ScottFlew with United Airlines
EWR
-
MIA
Jan 2025
Long walk / train to rental counter Newark from manhattan is faster than jfk
deepakFlew with Spirit Airlines
EWR
-
MIA
Dec 2024
Do not check in baggage and keep everything in carry on as much as possible. Also this is a cheap flight with cheap service so expect anything to happen
AmranulFlew with Delta
JFK
-
MIA
Apr 2024
If you have a child who is under two years old or older, make sure they have seat right next to you otherwise they will make you sit far from them

FAQs for booking flights from New York to Islamorada

  • Which airports will I be using when flying from New York to Islamorada?

    When flying out of New York you’ll be using one of these airports: Newark, New York John F Kennedy Intl or New York LaGuardia. Islamorada does not have its own airport so you’ll be flying into nearby Miami airport, which is 63.9 mi away.

  • How long does a flight from New York to Islamorada take?

    Direct flights cover the 1,094 miles separating New York and Islamorada in about 3h 02m.

  • How many flights are there between New York and Islamorada?

    150 direct flights run between New York and Islamorada on a daily basis. On average, there are about 1,051 departures each week.

  • What’s the cheapest day of the week to fly between New York and Islamorada?

    Consider leaving on a Monday and avoid Thursdays if you are looking for the best rates. For your return to New York, you’ll find the best rates on Wednesdays and the most expensive ones on Sundays.

  • How does KAYAK find such low prices on flights from New York to Islamorada?

    KAYAK is a travel search engine. That means we look across the web to find the best prices we can find for our users. With over 2 billion flight queries processed yearly, we are able to display a variety of prices and options on flights from New York to Islamorada.

  • How does KAYAK's flight Price Forecast tool help me choose the right time to buy my flight ticket from New York to Islamorada?

    KAYAK’s flight Price Forecast tool uses historical data to determine whether the price for a flight to Islamorada from New York is likely to change within 7 days, so travelers know whether to wait or book now.

  • What is the Hacker Fare option on flights from New York to Islamorada?

    Hacker Fares allow you to combine one-way tickets in order to save you money over a traditional round-trip ticket. You could then fly to Islamorada with an airline and back to New York with another airline.

  • What is KAYAK's "flexible dates" feature and why should I care when looking for a flight from New York to Islamorada?

    Sometimes travel dates aren't set in stone. If your preferred travel dates have some wiggle room, flexible dates will show you all the options when flying to Islamorada from New York up to 3 days before/after your preferred dates. You can then pick the flights that suit you best.

  • Which airlines provide the cheapest flights from New York to Islamorada?

    In the last 72 hours, the cheapest one-way ticket between New York and Islamorada found on KAYAK was with Frontier for $28. Frontier offered a round-trip connection from $43 and Spirit Airlines from $66.

Top tips for finding cheap flights from New York to Islamorada

  • There is no airport in Islamorada. Instead, you’ll be flying into Miami Airport when flying between New York and Islamorada.
  • The cheapest flight from New York to Islamorada was found 14 days before departure, on average.
  • Book at least 2 weeks before departure in order to get a below-average price.
  • High season is considered to be November, December and January. The cheapest month to fly is September.

Reviews of the top 5 airlines serving New York to Islamorada

 
Need help choosing which airline to fly with from New York to Islamorada? KAYAK airline reviews give an overall score for each airline based on loads of factors, including comfort, boarding, in-flight entertainment and more, to make your decision easier. See airline scores according to verified KAYAK customer reviews.
7.9
DeltaOverall score based on 8374 reviews
7.2Food
7.8Entertainment
8.1Boarding
8.5Crew
7.9Comfort
Airline reviews

Flight delayed. Air broken. Cabin was hot enough to pass out. Delta shuttle’s becoming worse and worse.

2.0 MediocreWilliam, Apr 2026
LGA - BOS
Read more Delta reviews

Flight delayed. Air broken. Cabin was hot enough to pass out. Delta shuttle’s becoming worse and worse.

my mom urmila patel needed a wheelchair which was not available on the curbside. she needed to walk almost 50 meters inside (at the risk of falling) and then had to wait in line to get a wheelchair (this is not ok). Once obtained she had to seat in it for 30-45 minutes for someone to take her in thru the checkin process (which was fairly smooth and easy). the lady who helped her with her checkin process was very courteous and helpful

This was the worse experience. They delayed our flight twice and we still had to find another flight to get home sooner which was alos delayed. Also, the flight attendant named Ginny on DL9890 leaving at 4:13pm on 3/23/26 was extremely rude.

I love Delta the flight attendants were personable and the flight arrived 1/2 earlier thanks expected. All a plus. The gate agent was a bit flustered but even with that I still had a good experience. Her supervisor assisted me.

I am still at the Airport! Delayed Delayed and Delyaed

Love delta smaller commuter plane so no entertainment and paid wifi on MKE-LGA leg was extremely unreliable and slow

Delayed. Hot. Passenger next to me was so large I couldn’t move.

The flight went very well, but the flight attendants didn't serve and food or drinks other than 1st class due to rough air but to be honest it wasn't that bumpy and I felt that they could've at least offered water and coffee perhaps. Also serving 1st class only is a bad look. I've been in 1st class many times and I would've felt that if the turbulence was too rough for the main cabin, it would be too rough for 1st class too.

There was an unruly family behind us that made the short flight miserable!!! The cabin crew did nothing to contain it.

My seatback screen didn’t work so that sucked because that’s what I was going to do on the plane.

They promise free wi-fi prior to boarding and then once on board you are informed you have to purchase wifi even after being a mileagePlus member.

3 hour delay…. Nearly 2 hours sitting on tarmac. Do better, United. Or at least have the sense to not say “we hope you enjoyed your flight with us” upon disembarking.

Both our flights were delayed. Almost didn’t get in the second flight. Staff was rude to the bone.

Everything went well except the turbulence what no one have a control of but pilot and crew handled very good!

Much better than Spirit. I was please by the easy fast check in and boarding

Everything except the food and entertainment. It was a great experience though

The attendant on board was amazing. She should be doing business/first international long haul.

Perfect flight. Smooth flight. Arrived 20 minutes early at destination. Excellent service.

Flight was delayed 8 times. We were sitting at the airport for 14 hours. We got 2 hours of sleep (if that) on what was not meant to be a red-eye.

Plane boarded early a quickly, was mostly full. We left close to on time. And landed early.

For an international flight the seats were smaller than most flight I have been on in economy. I don’t know the size of the seats or perhaps it was the size of the seat dividers that made the seats feel smaller and little amount of space to even turn your body if you needed to

My flight from LGA was cancelled and my rebooked flight from JFK was delayed numerous times. I will now be getting home after 2am.

Flight was delayed half hour before boarding, but when I checked flight aware the plane that would Pick us up had a delay of more than an hour. AA should let us know in advance to avoid waiting several hours in the airport

Not really sure I enjoyed the flight at all. The flight attendants seemed a little tired and rude at times. The snacks were lacking in taste and sustenance. The flight was incredibly turbulent for three plus hours and the pilot had to do a second pass to land at our final destination because he was coming in so fast. He must have taken a short cut and because of it we had to suffer the violent turbulence and the dropping down. It had to be one of if not the worse flights I have ever been on and have traveled vastly all over the world.

Aging planer and NO wifi on a 14 hour day flight. Unless you are retired or don't need to work or be in touch with the world... The lack of Wifif really ruined the flight. And the old plane - really showing it's age, wasn't great

There was no inflight service. Once we landed we were delayed to find a gate for an hour and a half which was 1/2 the total time in the air.

The gate agent had a really bad attitude and refused to help me get on the standby list. She just handed me a card and said I needed to call a number. I asked her to help with the AA app on my phone and she just shrugged and said she didnt know. After a few phone calls, I eventually just went to a different gate agent on the other side of the terminal and got the help I needed.

One day, I do so hope for a gluten free snack! Seems like with the rest of the world FINALLY figuring out what gluten free is, American Airlines would too. Fingers crossed!!

I would like the crew to talk LESS over the PA and specifically about credit card offers. I am trying to work, sleep, watch a movie and the PA was booming about a credit card offer. Could we go back to the days when the customer was more important than selling a credit card?

There were no TV screens - even in Business class. 5 delays, and only given $12 meal voucher! Terrible!

The flight was supposed to leave at 6:22pm we are just now leaving the gate after deplaning twice at 1:07am.

Flight attendant was all so sweet and pilot got us to our destination safely and on time

Sadly the flight was delayed by 4 hours due to the weather snd sir traffic control staffing. Otherwise the crew was amazing and the flight was perfect.

Delayed both in takeoff and landing, trash plane no amenities, I've said it before but I'll never fly Spirit again.

Checking in and getting to gate fast and leasy at Laguardia airport. There is no entertainment on the plane and food was for purchase. Great experience flying with spirit

The flight was delayed over an hour which got us into DFW at approximately 2:20 am

Kayak and Spirit could not meaningfully share itinerary data, leading to many hours of remediation.

Do not fly with Spirit. They will leave you canceled if their flight is not 110% booked.

Terrible Flight was cancelled last minute with no other flights available

More comfortable seats, free snacks and soft drinks, some sort of entertainment or WiFi.

The crew acted like they had never done this and kept barking passive aggressive orders at people. + the security line + the delay + sitting on the tarmac for 2 hours + none of the apps or signage updating with correct times

My flight was originally from SAT to MCO connecting from MCO to ORD. We got diverted to ATL and than Frontier staff there was sooo un helpful first they said they couldn’t give us any accommodation since our flight first got delayed that cancelled and now it’s 221am and I am still in ATL since they said they need to create a new flight my final destination is ORD and I have been delayed twice and cancelled. With no real help the frontier app didn’t work no email updates over all such a horrible experience

Flight was canceled. Most upsetting was message from Kayak, stating that the flight was canceled and click with Kayak for details regarding rebook, refund details. THERE'S NO INFORMATION PROVIDED BY KAYAK EXCEPT THAT FLIGHT IS CANCELED. AND NOW THIS SURVEY TO FIND OUT HOW WAS THE FLIGHT !!!!!!!

I am writing to express my disappointment with my recent Frontier Airlines flight. I was charged $99 at the gate because my bag was said to be too large, yet once onboard there was no available overhead bin space, and I was required to place the bag under the seat in front of me anyway. This made the charge feel unnecessary and unfair. Additionally, before the flight even took off, I was asked to move from the seat I paid for into a middle seat so another passenger and her cat could have my seat to themselves. I was not offered compensation or an explanation for being moved from a paid seat. Between the unexpected bag fee and being forced to give up my seat, this experience fell well below acceptable customer service standards. I would appreciate a review of this situation and appropriate compensation.

One of the worst travel experiences I've had. Had a flight scheduled with CVG to RSW on VLSWQX this morning departing at 5:30. Two individuals at the gate and one was in training. Not her fault but she didn't have the ability to check people in resulting in at least 15 families that didn't make it on the plane because they weren't checked into the system in time. When arriving at the airport to drop off our prepaid checked bags, the bag drop off agent asked if we could check our bags at the gate because of the long line. We said no problem so arrived at the gate by 5:00. They told those people that had previously paid for checked bags to stand off to the side while they let others that either didn't have a checked bag or their bag was already on the plan through. Realizing the gate workers had an issue, they either called for help or this lady showed up late for work as she didn't arrive until 5:15. The worker who had been there training the other individual and working diligently to make sure all passengers got on board. He even said that at one point all people that are currently in line are fine but asked the person in training to stand outside the ticketing area around 5:15 to notify any late travels that the flight was in boarding process and they arrrived too late. At that point, we're sill standing off to the side with our pre-paid checked bags patiently waiting. When the new lady arrived she couldn't have been more rude. It was an awful seen. Essentially they had asked for those without an assigned seat to board last, those with pre-paid checked bag stand off to the site and any traveling with a larger items that needed to be checked at the gate (such as a stroller), wait on the side. They realized that the flight needed to leave on time so the gate attendant shut the gate. So anyone without a seat assignment, those that had pre-checked bags, and the worst one I saw was a mother with two infant children was in line with use because she was asked to stand to the side because her stroller. When they shut the door to the plan they told her she could no longer get on. Her checked bags were already on the plane with her car keys in them, and the lady told her we couldn't accept anyone else on because the door was shut. She didn't even have a way to get home from the airport. Truely evil behavior. I've flown Frontier enough to know customer service is not a top priority in the company's mission, but this was an all-time low. I'm sending this after an 18 hour drive that our family just completed to Bonita Springs . I felt really bad for the lady being trained and the other individual trying to help, but when the new lady came to the gate she was truly one of the rudest individuals I've ever met. One lady had been there since 4am but because she didn't have an assigned seat they wouldn't let her on the plan.

Better than expected. Staff were friendly and nice on both flights.

Terrible. Flight cancelled with no reasoning and no flights to rebook. Employees were useless and did nothing to help. Did not even know where to retrieve luggage from the cancelled flight. Flyers beware.

No fault of Frontier staff: plane was very late, reached Orlando at 1 am, took a while to get luggage. Weather, gov financial shutdown impact on TSA, air controllers seemed to have multiple flights backed up. Frontier staff seemed to cope as gracefully as possible. It did reassure me that I and my new hip could adapt to travel challenges. Food/entertainment were irrelevant to my trip.

It was well done. It was my first time flying with them and I was nervous b/c I have heard of many cancelled and/or delray flights. Everything went smoothly.

Frontier is the Walmart of airlines. Frontier has removed adjustability and comfort from their seats to make the flight lighter and save gas. This makes it impossible to sleep on their flights. Their customer service is abysmal. Once, I bought a drink on the plane, and they swiped my credit card on the plane to pay for it. Then I got three weeks of daily notices from my bank telling me they tried to charge the wrong card number over and over again. I tried to call them, but they removed the ability to actually talk to someone that can resolve such a problem from their company to cut corners. The only way to talk to someone in person is to go to the check-in counter at the airport (40 minutes drive from my house). Eventually their system gave up on trying to charge the card, after 21 days of repeated tries. They don't pad their prices even a little to handle customer service issues like missed flights. They also have a blanket policy preventing helping you reschedule a missed flight if their system says you "cancelled" your own flight online. This is a major problem because their website is broken on mobile devices, the only web browser you have at the airport when their gate staff tell you that you have to reschedule your own missed flight online because they can't help you. I tried to reschedule my flight on my android device and instead, their website crashed and "cancelled" my missed flight. When I got to the counter, the agent argued with me for 5 minutes insisting that I intentionally cancelled my own flight (implying I had to buy another flight). She missed the point: the problem was that I could not buy another flight because their website is broken. I left to avoid more conflict with the "customer service" agent. I tried to redress my issue with their only other "customer service" chanel available: the contact form on their website. The response I got was more of the same: you cancelled your own flight, according to our website / computer records, therefore we won't help you. I was trying to explain the problem with their broken website that cost me hundreds of dollars by crashing / malfunctioning and resulting in a cancelled flight, but they only had deaf ears for this problem. Worst customer service I have ever experienced. I will never buy another Frontier flight again, because it is a risky, painful move that I will likely regret often.

Everything you need to know for your flight from New York to Islamorada

Complete your trip to Islamorada with a hotel stay or car rental