Shelter Island Heights Bed & Breakfasts

10 of 33 hotels
Fri 8/18
Sat 8/19
Compare vs. KAYAK all | none
Go to list
Stars reset
Review Score reset
Price reset
Hotel Name reset
Location reset
Neighborhoods reset
9.6
Excellent
164 reviews
Nearby
Gardiner's Bay Country Club
Sylvester Manor
Check-in
Check-out

$200+

9.5
Excellent
15 reviews
Nearby
Orient Point Park
Horton Point Park
Check-in
Check-out

$367+

9.2
Excellent
60 reviews
Nearby
Horton Point Park
Check-in
Check-out

$296+

8.8
Excellent
53 reviews
Nearby
Horton Point Park
Check-in
Check-out

$296+

Check-in
Check-out

$366+

No reviews yet
Nearby
Orient Point Park
Check-in
Check-out

$219+

9.3
Excellent
24 reviews
Nearby
Old Whalers Church
Pollack-Krasner House and Studio
Check-in
Check-out

$285+

9.5
Excellent
19 reviews
Amenities
Check-in
Check-out

$285+

9.6
Excellent
12 reviews
Nearby
Horton Point Park
Check-in
Check-out

$262+

No reviews yet
Check-in
Check-out

$290+

Bed & Breakfasts

Accommodations