Trips

Find Cheap Flights from Indiana to New York

Search hundreds of travel sites at once for deals on flights to New York

Depart
Return
Any month
Compare vs. KAYAK |

Indiana to New York Flight Information

Flights Arrive in New York
Flights Depart from Indiana
Flight Price $173
Airlines American Airlines, United, Delta, Major Airline, Frontier

Book cheap flights from Indiana to New York (round-trip)

Airports
Origin
Indianapolis
$173
only
$173
Destination
New York
$177
only
$177
Islip
$218
only
$218
Syracuse
$174
only
$174
Newark
$178
only
$178
Buffalo
$173
only
$173
Tue, Oct 30
IND
Indianapolis
BUF
Buffalo
4h 26m
Wed, Oct 31
BUF
Buffalo
IND
Indianapolis
3h 43m
Trip: 2 days
7.2GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.2 Good
Based on 33,728 reviews
Overall
7.4
Boarding
7.5
Comfort
7.1
Crew
7.8
Entertainment
6.8
Food
6.7
DUB
ORD
Mediocre 3.3

Customer service when my flight was delayed twice and then cancelled.

I hated that there were sudden updates of delays just moments before we were supposed to board, then delayed for a day, then cancelled. I was fortunate to be re-routed to San Francisco (I am on the way) now, through United airlines. All in all, it was a stressful inconvenience.

CAK
CLT
Okay 5.3

Rude and disrespectful

DFW
MSP
Mediocre 2.6

Nothing

Condescending staff, lackadaisical crew, pitiful excuses of why we were delayed.

BOS
MIA
Excellent 8.3

Early arrival, plane not crowded

Onboard wifi not working so no inflight entertainment

PHL
BUD
Mediocre 3.6

The food was pretty good.

They had no accommodations for our baby, and didn’t let us board first. It was an old plane with basic entertainment, TVs above the middle row and not all do them worked. It was particularly freezing on board. Some of the crew was nice but overall not very friendly or welcoming.

Tue, Oct 30
IND
Indianapolis
SYR
Syracuse Hancock Intl
4h 42m
Wed, Oct 31
SYR
Syracuse Hancock Intl
IND
Indianapolis
4h 03m
Trip: 2 days
7.0GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.0 Good
Based on 59,480 reviews
Overall
7.2
Boarding
7.4
Comfort
7.0
Crew
7.7
Entertainment
6.5
Food
6.5
IAH
EWR
Mediocre 2.0

Lounge

Delayed flight which kept pushing back for more then 5 hours. Got booked on the next flight got middle seat. Flight attendant was rude and short with people. Not very personable. Plane was so hot everyone was sweating.

DEN
GJT
Good 6.0

Ease of boarding and good communication from pilot

Flight attendant was gruff when communicating. She seemed angry when providing information. It was a short flight, so not a lot was offered, which was totally fine. However, when she walked down the isle with water, she appeared to be looking at the ceiling and didn’t stop to check if many people wanted water, including me.

EWR
ATH
Excellent 8.0

The United flight had a great entertainment package (movies, tv shows, etc). The flight attendant who sat in front of us was awesome,and fun to talk to. She gave us some great tips about things to do while in Athens. The food was good (for airline food).

The flight from Newark to Athens was interesting. The flight changed gates at the last minute. The plane was towed to the new gate, then we found out that it was going to be delayed an additional hour due to required maintenance checks. Actually, I don't mind the additional maintenance checks, I want to arrive alive! We arrived in Athens 90 minutes after our expected time. We got seats in the exit row, however, we couldn't really enjoy the extra legroom for 2 reasons: 1) The exit hatch was right in front of my girlfriend who was sitting near the window. She couldn't extend her feet without kicking the door (I big no-no at 35,000 feet). 2) Our row was right in front of the bathrooms, so I had constant traffic bumping me in left shoulder and lines of people literally standing in front of me for the majority of the flight while waiting for their turn to use the bathroom. They are stepping on my feet constantly or passing gas in my face (I wish I was kidding).

RIC
ORD
Good 6.0

delayed. missed my connector and had to rebook to a later flight

FRA
SFO
Good 6.3

Easy boarding and finding seat; good food and liked that wine was available, good movies to choose from

Seat was not comfortable, I am 5'1" and the head rest was too high, fortunately I had my own foam neck support. Bathrooms could use more cleaning during flight as one was grossly covered with urine right after turbulence was experienced. One crew member appeared to be having a bad day and seemed unhappy to be at work and was impatient with all.

Wed, Oct 31
IND
Indianapolis
LGA
New York LaGuardia
2h 07m
Sat, Nov 3
LGA
New York LaGuardia
IND
Indianapolis
2h 20m
Trip: 4 days
8.5ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.5 Excellent
Based on 10 reviews
Overall
8.0
Boarding
8.1
Comfort
7.8
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
7.6
Food
7.4
IND
LGA
Excellent 9.3

The pilot was extremely informative The stewardesses were helpful It was a delayed flight and they made it relax

Bad weather at LGA

SEA
MSP
Okay 4.6

Hostess were professional and warm

Seats was too tight, no leg room and no room for stretching

AMS
DTW
Excellent 8.0

Didn’t like the fact that online check in didn’t work on the Delta app.di

IND
LGA
Good 6.0

Seat was narrow from side to side; so short from front to back that only half my thigh was supported; hard; and pitched slightly forward from uneven wear. This was an exit row, so I had legroom at least. I’m 5’4” and trim. A taller, or broader person would not fit!

SJD
LAX
Excellent 8.3

Crews were nice

Thu, Feb 14
IND
Indianapolis
EWR
Newark
2h 00m
Fri, Feb 22
EWR
Newark
IND
Indianapolis
2h 13m
Trip: 9 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Mon, Oct 1
IND
Indianapolis
ISP
Islip Long Island
18h 17m
Wed, Oct 3
ISP
Islip Long Island
IND
Indianapolis
28h 10m
Trip: 3 days
5.7OkayShow reviews
Overall 5.7 Okay
Based on 35,402 reviews
Overall
5.9
Boarding
6.4
Comfort
5.4
Crew
6.8
Entertainment
4.5
Food
4.7
PDX
DEN
Excellent 8.0

Airfare was $28 each way

No plug ins, hard seats, and an odd 20 minute delay to get a off the plane even though we were at the gate. They said it was because of the "balance". Really?

PWM
DEN
Mediocre 2.0

The first

This flight was canceled at the last minute and all passengers were told they needed to find another flight because the airline didn’t have any to rebook them on. Passengers had to pay out of pocket for new flights. Frontier said they would reimburse but I haven’t seen anything yet.

SNA
SAT
Excellent 10.0

I have a walker and it was stowed with the strollers. Was available soon after I arrived. Flight left on time and arrived early. Price was great, even with a few add ons.

WIsh they had pillows. I need lower back support and had to use my son's sweatshirt. I will know next time.

DEN
SEA
Mediocre 3.3

The crew was nice, boarding was easy

The seats and space are horrible, it is almost impossible to stay seated during the duration of the flight because the seats are so uncomfortable and if you are taller like I am you will have no leg room and no support past your shoulders

COS
ORD
Good 6.0

Efficient boarding process. Friendly staff. Free water! Whoa!

Seats were uncomfortable. My butt hurt for the two hours I was on the flight.

Mon, Oct 1
IND
Indianapolis
EWR
Newark
15h 16m
Wed, Oct 3
EWR
Newark
IND
Indianapolis
26h 40m
Trip: 3 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Tue, Oct 30
IND
Indianapolis
BUF
Buffalo
4h 26m
Wed, Oct 31
BUF
Buffalo
IND
Indianapolis
3h 43m
Trip: 2 days
7.2GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.2 Good
Based on 33,728 reviews
Overall
7.4
Boarding
7.5
Comfort
7.1
Crew
7.8
Entertainment
6.8
Food
6.7
ORD
SFO
Mediocre 2.0

Never made it to Chicago, rerouted through Washington DC.

ORD
LHR
Okay 4.6

What to like with AA?

Delayed by 2:38 hours at Chicago due to aircaft repair. Total layover 8:38 hours.

LGA
MIA
Excellent 10.0

It was great, but returning home was bad

BOS
MIA
Excellent 8.3

Early arrival, plane not crowded

Onboard wifi not working so no inflight entertainment

EWR
ORD
Okay 4.0

I like that I made it home alive.

Everything about Departing and arriving was a Poor experience. I might not be using this particular airline again. 4 Airlines now on my list of do not use.

Tue, Oct 30
IND
Indianapolis
SYR
Syracuse Hancock Intl
4h 42m
Wed, Oct 31
SYR
Syracuse Hancock Intl
IND
Indianapolis
4h 03m
Trip: 2 days
7.0GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.0 Good
Based on 59,480 reviews
Overall
7.2
Boarding
7.4
Comfort
7.0
Crew
7.7
Entertainment
6.5
Food
6.5
DEN
GJT
Good 6.0

Ease of boarding and good communication from pilot

Flight attendant was gruff when communicating. She seemed angry when providing information. It was a short flight, so not a lot was offered, which was totally fine. However, when she walked down the isle with water, she appeared to be looking at the ceiling and didn’t stop to check if many people wanted water, including me.

EWR
ATH
Excellent 8.0

The United flight had a great entertainment package (movies, tv shows, etc). The flight attendant who sat in front of us was awesome,and fun to talk to. She gave us some great tips about things to do while in Athens. The food was good (for airline food).

The flight from Newark to Athens was interesting. The flight changed gates at the last minute. The plane was towed to the new gate, then we found out that it was going to be delayed an additional hour due to required maintenance checks. Actually, I don't mind the additional maintenance checks, I want to arrive alive! We arrived in Athens 90 minutes after our expected time. We got seats in the exit row, however, we couldn't really enjoy the extra legroom for 2 reasons: 1) The exit hatch was right in front of my girlfriend who was sitting near the window. She couldn't extend her feet without kicking the door (I big no-no at 35,000 feet). 2) Our row was right in front of the bathrooms, so I had constant traffic bumping me in left shoulder and lines of people literally standing in front of me for the majority of the flight while waiting for their turn to use the bathroom. They are stepping on my feet constantly or passing gas in my face (I wish I was kidding).

ATL
ORD
Okay 4.3

It got us to London. My bags were quickly available.

The seats were SO. UNCOMFORTABLE. I didn't sleep at all and have a headache because of them. Absolutely atrocious. The food was meh. One of the flight attendants was so rude I dreaded every time she headed over. I'll be flying with Delta in the future.

IAH
EWR
Mediocre 2.0

Lounge

Delayed flight which kept pushing back for more then 5 hours. Got booked on the next flight got middle seat. Flight attendant was rude and short with people. Not very personable. Plane was so hot everyone was sweating.

RIC
ORD
Good 6.0

delayed. missed my connector and had to rebook to a later flight

Wed, Oct 31
IND
Indianapolis
LGA
New York LaGuardia
2h 07m
Sat, Nov 3
LGA
New York LaGuardia
IND
Indianapolis
2h 20m
Trip: 4 days
8.5ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.5 Excellent
Based on 10 reviews
Overall
8.0
Boarding
8.1
Comfort
7.8
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
7.6
Food
7.4
DTW
CLT
Excellent 8.0

Didn’t get our beverage and snack till we were almost ready to land at Charlotte

SEA
MSP
Okay 4.6

Hostess were professional and warm

Seats was too tight, no leg room and no room for stretching

SJD
LAX
Excellent 8.3

Crews were nice

IND
LGA
Good 6.0

Seat was narrow from side to side; so short from front to back that only half my thigh was supported; hard; and pitched slightly forward from uneven wear. This was an exit row, so I had legroom at least. I’m 5’4” and trim. A taller, or broader person would not fit!

JFK
LAS
Excellent 8.0

The wait

The screen didn’t change in time

Thu, Feb 14
IND
Indianapolis
EWR
Newark
2h 00m
Fri, Feb 22
EWR
Newark
IND
Indianapolis
2h 13m
Trip: 9 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Tue, Oct 30
IND
Indianapolis
BUF
Buffalo
4h 26m
Wed, Oct 31
BUF
Buffalo
IND
Indianapolis
3h 43m
Trip: 2 days
7.2GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.2 Good
Based on 33,728 reviews
Overall
7.4
Boarding
7.5
Comfort
7.1
Crew
7.8
Entertainment
6.8
Food
6.7
CAK
CLT
Okay 5.3

Rude and disrespectful

DUB
ORD
Mediocre 3.3

Customer service when my flight was delayed twice and then cancelled.

I hated that there were sudden updates of delays just moments before we were supposed to board, then delayed for a day, then cancelled. I was fortunate to be re-routed to San Francisco (I am on the way) now, through United airlines. All in all, it was a stressful inconvenience.

DFW
CLE
Excellent 10.0

It was a quick flight! The crew was nice & the landing went smothly!

It was a full plane!

ORD
SFO
Mediocre 2.0

Never made it to Chicago, rerouted through Washington DC.

ORD
LHR
Excellent 8.3

Crew, food and boarding.

Limited entertainment selection. Tight setting with minimal leg room.

Tue, Oct 30
IND
Indianapolis
SYR
Syracuse Hancock Intl
4h 42m
Wed, Oct 31
SYR
Syracuse Hancock Intl
IND
Indianapolis
4h 03m
Trip: 2 days
7.0GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.0 Good
Based on 59,480 reviews
Overall
7.2
Boarding
7.4
Comfort
7.0
Crew
7.7
Entertainment
6.5
Food
6.5
ATL
ORD
Okay 4.3

It got us to London. My bags were quickly available.

The seats were SO. UNCOMFORTABLE. I didn't sleep at all and have a headache because of them. Absolutely atrocious. The food was meh. One of the flight attendants was so rude I dreaded every time she headed over. I'll be flying with Delta in the future.

ICT
ORD
Good 7.3

Aircrew great along with gate agents.

First class flying is gone. No lounge access in the US. No meal (boarding at 1720 and arriving 2100) Beverage service the same in front as in back. Need to go back to Asia to get what you pay for.

EWR
DEN
Excellent 10.0

All great!

IAH
EWR
Mediocre 2.0

Lounge

Delayed flight which kept pushing back for more then 5 hours. Got booked on the next flight got middle seat. Flight attendant was rude and short with people. Not very personable. Plane was so hot everyone was sweating.

CHO
IAD
Good 7.6

Crew flight attendant was nice the whole trip. Other places they aren't always so warm or nice when you leave. Flight was pretty.

Nobody was checking tickets for checked bags we deboarded.

Wed, Oct 31
IND
Indianapolis
LGA
New York LaGuardia
2h 07m
Sat, Nov 3
LGA
New York LaGuardia
IND
Indianapolis
2h 20m
Trip: 4 days
8.5ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.5 Excellent
Based on 10 reviews
Overall
8.0
Boarding
8.1
Comfort
7.8
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
7.6
Food
7.4
IND
LGA
Excellent 10.0

Clean, modern plane, friendly crew, great service

I liked it all!

LAX
OGG
Okay 4.3

Why use old planes for such a long flight? Toilet overflowed, poor quality tv, and only peanuts?

IND
LGA
Excellent 10.0

the pretzels and drinks. The flight attendant was very polite and attentive.

SLC
AMS
Excellent 9.6

You guys did an all around great job and my flight experience was the best I’ve ever had. The quality of the service was exceptional.

SEA
MSP
Okay 4.6

Hostess were professional and warm

Seats was too tight, no leg room and no room for stretching

Thu, Feb 14
IND
Indianapolis
EWR
Newark
2h 00m
Fri, Feb 22
EWR
Newark
IND
Indianapolis
2h 13m
Trip: 9 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Fri, Dec 7
IND
Indianapolis
EWR
Newark
1h 58m
Sat, Dec 8
EWR
Newark
IND
Indianapolis
2h 19m
Trip: 2 days
7.2GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.2 Good
Based on 29 reviews
Overall
7.2
Boarding
7.4
Comfort
7.0
Crew
7.7
Entertainment
6.5
Food
6.5
IND
EWR
Mediocre 2.0

So first scheduled flight canceled., I broke land speed records and paid an additional 50 dollars to get booked on an earlier leaving flight. Boom it was cancelled as well. I'm attempting to fly out at creak of dawn today! Still not home! United had alot of work to do! !!!!!

IND
EWR
Good 7.6

Flight was ontime and crew was very curtious and professional.

One thing I would say that snacks was not good at all. Wasn't able to eat. Should change the snack item.

IND
EWR
Excellent 10.0

Courteous and friendly employees..helpful

Nothing

IND
EWR
Excellent 10.0

Nothing . It was ok

SEA
SFO
Mediocre 2.0

?

Delayed. Charged for my bag even tho i have the United explorer Visa. Skipped me with pretzels and when I asked for some, it was as if i was asking fir something extraordinary!

Mon, Oct 1
IND
Indianapolis
ISP
Islip Long Island
18h 17m
Wed, Oct 3
ISP
Islip Long Island
IND
Indianapolis
28h 10m
Trip: 3 days
5.7OkayShow reviews
Overall 5.7 Okay
Based on 35,402 reviews
Overall
5.9
Boarding
6.4
Comfort
5.4
Crew
6.8
Entertainment
4.5
Food
4.7
DEN
MSP
Good 6.0

Crew was first rate...

One hour late taking off but understandable...

SLC
AUS
Mediocre 2.6

I was charged to carry on my two bags. With added fees and taxes, it came to $168.20! The seats were very uncomfortable...not enough padding and way too crowded. They even charge for in flight snacks. Not a meal...the peanuts and soda you usually get free elsewhere. The flight attendant was rude to me. No wifi available for purchase that I could tell. Then at the end of the flight they had a big commercial-like announcement to push their credit card. It was very tacky.

DEN
SJC
Excellent 10.0

Direct flight. Cheap. Easy on and easy off.

Seat and tray size. But u get what u pay for, so I’d rather save the money

SEA
DEN
Mediocre 2.3

The flight arrives safely into Denver

We had to take a bus to the plane. The buses the shuttled us on, they packed tight and without apology. We then sat in our seats for over an hour on the tarmac without explanation or apologies or any courtesy shown at all to the woman who dared to get up to use the lavatory and was scorned by the crew. When we got to our destination. The crew did not even apologize for the hour delay in landing or even mention it.

LAS
CVG
Mediocre 2.0

It got me from point a to point b. That was the only positive thing about this flight.

Unidentified delays had me sitting in the airport for hours, seats were overwhelmingly uncomfortable, no in flight entertainment, the cabin crew kept the galley lights on so it was impossible to sleep on a late night trip, nickel and dimed over everything from a carry on bag to choosing my seat, no complimentary drinks or snacks, took forever to receive my checked bag

Tue, Oct 23
IND
Indianapolis
LGA
New York LaGuardia
2h 07m
Tue, Oct 30
LGA
New York LaGuardia
IND
Indianapolis
2h 23m
Trip: 8 days
8.5ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.5 Excellent
Based on 10 reviews
Overall
8.0
Boarding
8.1
Comfort
7.8
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
7.6
Food
7.4
SEA
MSP
Okay 4.6

Hostess were professional and warm

Seats was too tight, no leg room and no room for stretching

JFK
LAS
Excellent 8.0

The wait

The screen didn’t change in time

IND
LGA
Excellent 9.3

The pilot was extremely informative The stewardesses were helpful It was a delayed flight and they made it relax

Bad weather at LGA

IND
LGA
Good 6.0

Seat was narrow from side to side; so short from front to back that only half my thigh was supported; hard; and pitched slightly forward from uneven wear. This was an exit row, so I had legroom at least. I’m 5’4” and trim. A taller, or broader person would not fit!

IND
LGA
Excellent 10.0

the pretzels and drinks. The flight attendant was very polite and attentive.

Wed, Oct 31
IND
Indianapolis
LGA
New York LaGuardia
2h 04m
Fri, Nov 9
LGA
New York LaGuardia
IND
Indianapolis
2h 28m
Trip: 10 days
6.7GoodShow reviews
Overall 6.7 Good
Based on 7 reviews
Overall
7.4
Boarding
7.5
Comfort
7.1
Crew
7.8
Entertainment
6.8
Food
6.7
IND
LGA
Excellent 9.2

it was more or less on time. no aggravations very smooth flight despite weather condition. i am so glad that you have very qualified pilots...... thank you danielle

having the last seat so the back could not be reclined.

ORD
SFO
Mediocre 2.0

Never made it to Chicago, rerouted through Washington DC.

ORD
LHR
Okay 4.6

What to like with AA?

Delayed by 2:38 hours at Chicago due to aircaft repair. Total layover 8:38 hours.

CAK
CLT
Okay 5.3

Rude and disrespectful

IND
LGA
Excellent 8.6

Fast entry... Great crew

Entertainment

Fri, Jan 18
IND
Indianapolis
EWR
Newark
2h 11m
Sat, Jan 26
EWR
Newark
IND
Indianapolis
2h 24m
Trip: 9 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Fri, Dec 7
IND
Indianapolis
EWR
Newark
1h 58m
Sat, Dec 8
EWR
Newark
IND
Indianapolis
2h 19m
Trip: 2 days
7.2GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.2 Good
Based on 29 reviews
Overall
7.2
Boarding
7.4
Comfort
7.0
Crew
7.7
Entertainment
6.5
Food
6.5
IND
EWR
Excellent 10.0

Everything on time. Comfortable seating. Friendly stewardess.

IND
EWR
Excellent 10.0

Courteous and friendly employees..helpful

Nothing

IND
EWR
Good 7.3

Crew was outstanding . Boarding was easy. Ahead of schedule arrival

Return to terminal required a bus and then off loading like cattle for sale. Came in through maintenance area. One hour from landing to baggage claim. Terrible!

IAH
EWR
Mediocre 2.0

Lounge

Delayed flight which kept pushing back for more then 5 hours. Got booked on the next flight got middle seat. Flight attendant was rude and short with people. Not very personable. Plane was so hot everyone was sweating.

IND
EWR
Mediocre 2.0

Flight canceled. Forced us to stand in a four hour line to re-book. Phone calls not accepted. These incidents happen all the time- it is inexcusable that United handled the situation so poorly!

*
Prices are per person and are for e–tickets and include all taxes & fees in USD.

We attempt to get accurate prices, however, prices are not guaranteed.

Here's why:

We’re not the seller.
At KAYAK we don’t set the prices, so it’s not possible for us to guarantee what other companies are selling.

We compile tonnes of data for you
Our service lets you quickly and easily compare results from hundreds of travel sites at once. In this sense, KAYAK is a search engine and we can't guarantee prices we find.

Why aren’t prices accurate 100% of the time?
Prices on airline seats, hotel rooms and car rentals can change frequently. Several people may also be trying to buy the same travel option simultaneously. As a result, you may find, on occasion, that certain prices are no longer available.

If you have more questions or if you have a bad price to report to us,
please send us an and someone from our team will get back to you promptly.

Forgot password?

Enter the email associated with your account in the field below and we'll email you a link to reset your password.

Cancel