Find Cheap Flights from Indiana to New York

Search hundreds of travel sites at once for deals on flights to New York

Depart
Return
Any month
Compare vs. KAYAK |

Indiana to New York Flight Information

Flights Arrive in New York
Flights Depart from Indiana
Flight Price $193
Airlines Delta, American Airlines, Spirit Airlines, United Airlines, Major Airline

Book cheap flights from Indiana to New York (round-trip)

Airports
Origin
Fort Wayne
$324
only
$324
South Bend
$233
only
$233
Indianapolis
$193
only
$193
Destination
New York
$193
only
$193
$193
only
$193
Newark
$196
only
$196
Tue, Apr 23
IND
Indianapolis
JFK
New York John F Kennedy Intl
2h 19m
Sat, Apr 27
JFK
New York John F Kennedy Intl
IND
Indianapolis
2h 26m
Trip: 5 days
7.5GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.5 Good
Based on 3 reviews
Overall
8.1
Boarding
8.1
Comfort
7.8
Crew
8.5
Entertainment
7.7
Food
7.5
JFK
DEN
Good 7.2

Pros: Boarding was easy.

Cons: I am 6' 1" tall and weigh 220, so not out of the ordinary and I felt like I was stuffed into a sardine can.

CVG
ATL
Excellent 9.0

Pros: Crew was very professional. Seat uncomfortable. No entertainment. did get water or coffee.

Cons: Comfort

SEA
SAN
Excellent 10.0

Pros: It was a nice flight. No troubles

Cons: Nothing

JAX
JFK
Good 7.3

Cons: No in flight entertainment

SJD
ATL
Excellent 8.3

Pros: The crew very nice and helpful

Tue, Apr 23
IND
Indianapolis
LGA
New York LaGuardia
2h 07m
Sat, Apr 27
LGA
New York LaGuardia
IND
Indianapolis
2h 26m
Trip: 5 days
6.7GoodShow reviews
Overall 6.7 Good
Based on 7 reviews
Overall
7.4
Boarding
7.5
Comfort
7.2
Crew
7.9
Entertainment
6.8
Food
6.7
PDX
PHX
Good 7.2

Pros: The free movie

ORD
SJD
Okay 4.8

Pros: Crew was friendly.

Cons: 4.5 hour flight to international destination and no meal provided. As usual, if you want a snack pay more. Slow chaotic boarding.

LGA
MIA
Okay 4.3

Cons: The gate agents were rude. So happy with their ‘power’ over passengers who are loaded like cattle onto the plane. They barked at every other passenger that their carry on bag was too big and wouldn’t even listen to train when bags would fit into the size checking stand.

LAX
ATL
Excellent 9.6

Cons: Crew serving food passed me by by, seemed rushed and missed my row.

ORD
LHR
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Seat was really nice. So were the meals

Mon, Apr 8
IND
Indianapolis
EWR
Newark
26h 32m
Wed, May 1
EWR
Newark
IND
Indianapolis
12h 25m
Trip: 24 days
5.5OkayShow reviews
Overall 5.5 Okay
Based on 58,568 reviews
Overall
5.8
Boarding
6.1
Comfort
5.4
Crew
6.5
Entertainment
4.6
Food
4.7
EWR
FLL
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Yes! No delays.

Cons: Entertainment and seats can be better

BOS
TPA
Okay 4.5

Cons: Better Captain

SJU
BWI
Okay 4.8

Pros: We paid more for extra space and the seats were big. Nice. But the back was so upright and you couldn’t adjust it back. Super uncomfortable.

Cons: The crew is rather blah. It’s clearly a j-o-b.

KIN
FLL
Okay 4.5

Cons: Flight delayed 4h. No real communication about reason for delay.

DFW
PHL
Mediocre 2.0

Pros: Nothing. Had to pay for a bags that actually fit into the dimensions specified

Cons: Overall experience

Wed, Apr 17
IND
Indianapolis
EWR
Newark
1h 59m
Sun, Apr 21
EWR
Newark
IND
Indianapolis
2h 25m
Trip: 5 days
7.0GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.0 Good
Based on 30 reviews
Overall
7.3
Boarding
7.4
Comfort
7.0
Crew
7.7
Entertainment
6.5
Food
6.5
IND
EWR
Excellent 10.0

Pros: The flight was smooth. Boarding went past fast. Flight attendance was great.

Cons: The seats were a little small.

ORD
SFO
Good 6.3

Cons: Boarding/unloading

MCO
EWR
Mediocre 2.0

Pros: Absolutely horrible aircraft. I am 6 ft 3 and there was no way I could fit my body into the seat without crushing my knees. So I had one leg underneath the seat in front of me the other leg in the Isle. The flight attendant came down the aisle with the drink cart running it squarely into my knee.

Cons: I cried out in pain with tears in my eyes and all she could say was you shouldn't have your leg in the Isle.

IAH
NRT
Okay 4.6

Pros: Everything was mediocre at best.

Cons: The food was terrible. The cabin crew was aggressive. The seat and leg room was cramped. The temperature was unbelievably hot.

ORD
SFO
Excellent 8.6

Cons: If they had veggie options or any options for food when they arrived to my seat

Thu, Sep 5
IND
Indianapolis
EWR
Newark
2h 00m
Tue, Sep 17
EWR
Newark
IND
Indianapolis
2h 13m
Trip: 13 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Fri, May 31
FWA
Fort Wayne
LGA
New York LaGuardia
13h 49m
Mon, Jun 3
LGA
New York LaGuardia
FWA
Fort Wayne
8h 25m
Trip: 4 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Tue, May 7
IND
Indianapolis
JFK
New York John F Kennedy Intl
2h 10m
Sat, May 11
JFK
New York John F Kennedy Intl
IND
Indianapolis
2h 22m
Trip: 5 days
7.5GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.5 Good
Based on 3 reviews
Overall
8.1
Boarding
8.1
Comfort
7.8
Crew
8.5
Entertainment
7.7
Food
7.5
LGA
MIA
Excellent 8.3

Pros: Crew was very attentive and friendly

Cons: Boarding could be better.

SLC
SFO
Okay 5.6

Pros: Nice new seats

Cons: Was too warm inside the plane. Boarding address was mobbed and not very well managed

BRU
JFK
Mediocre 2.6

Cons: Healthier snacks instead of just candy and cookies... an apple for example would be great.

AMS
BOS
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Good seating, great food, good service.

ATL
CRW
Excellent 9.0

Pros: The ctew was awesome, super sweet and very acomodating

Cons: Its a flight to WV (my birth place).... it is what it is... smll planes, tight quarters and people who don’t get any of that and are not happy anout any of it

Tue, Sep 3
IND
Indianapolis
LGA
New York LaGuardia
2h 04m
Sat, Sep 14
LGA
New York LaGuardia
IND
Indianapolis
2h 21m
Trip: 12 days
6.7GoodShow reviews
Overall 6.7 Good
Based on 7 reviews
Overall
7.4
Boarding
7.5
Comfort
7.2
Crew
7.9
Entertainment
6.8
Food
6.7
MCO
JFK
Excellent 9.5

Cons: The hardest thing about any air travel is cramp seats in coach. That being said, AA makes the best of your cramp quarters with free online movies and television, and a power outlet for your cell on the headrest in front of you, which is so convenient and makes up for the tight seating!

STL
CLT
Mediocre 3.6

Cons: 2 hour delays on both flights of a round trip

CLT
PHX
Okay 4.6

Pros:

Cons: I know this flight was considered local so they get away with no serving food but Phoenix to Honolulu is 7 hours long. they need to consider that other passengers took that flight as connection to a previous flight mine was Charlotte to Phoenix 4:45 duration

IND
LGA
Excellent 8.0

Pros: Boarding the plane was incredibly fast. As for the crew, I got an iffy energy from one of the crew members whom I felt was trying to play on my intelligence.

Cons: I wish American offered more vegan and wheat/ gluten free options, as well as herbal tea options. I was determined to sleep during this flight, but I was hoping this plane would have the TV behind the chair. I enjoy watching the live map as we’re flying.

CLE
CLT
Excellent 8.0

Cons: Departing on time...30 minutes late.

Wed, May 8
IND
Indianapolis
LGA
New York LaGuardia
2h 04m
Tue, May 14
LGA
New York LaGuardia
IND
Indianapolis
2h 23m
Trip: 7 days
8.5ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.5 Excellent
Based on 10 reviews
Overall
8.1
Boarding
8.1
Comfort
7.8
Crew
8.5
Entertainment
7.7
Food
7.5
JFK
MSY
Excellent 9.0

Cons: Snacks

ATL
TPA
Okay 4.0

Pros: Boarded on time.

Cons: After boarding the door was closed and the jet way was moved back. 5 minutes later they said they were going to bring the jet way back and open door to let more people on board. They broke 2 FAA regulations by doing this and we were delayed an hour because Deltas computer would not allow this.

LGA
MIA
Excellent 8.3

Pros: Crew was very attentive and friendly

Cons: Boarding could be better.

JFK
DEN
Good 7.2

Pros: Boarding was easy.

Cons: I am 6' 1" tall and weigh 220, so not out of the ordinary and I felt like I was stuffed into a sardine can.

DUB
JFK
Excellent 8.0

Cons: The seats are not very comfortable for such a long flight

Wed, Sep 4
IND
Indianapolis
JFK
New York John F Kennedy Intl
2h 10m
Tue, Sep 17
JFK
New York John F Kennedy Intl
IND
Indianapolis
2h 35m
Trip: 14 days
7.0GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.0 Good
Based on 11 reviews
Overall
7.4
Boarding
7.5
Comfort
7.2
Crew
7.9
Entertainment
6.8
Food
6.7
CLT
PHX
Okay 4.6

Pros:

Cons: I know this flight was considered local so they get away with no serving food but Phoenix to Honolulu is 7 hours long. they need to consider that other passengers took that flight as connection to a previous flight mine was Charlotte to Phoenix 4:45 duration

DCA
ORD
Okay 5.6

Pros: Nice seating

Cons: They asked who would give there seat up for 600$ future flight credit and The first two people could be eligible. They ignored me (who was first) for a white couple who Came after me, and they got chosen and got the flight credit, but I was as clearly first. So I think it was more of a racist matter

JAX
CLT
Mediocre 3.6

Cons: The crew was great, but AA needs to step it up with comfort and amenities!

ORD
SJC
Okay 4.3

Cons: A toilet had no water. The internet was not working for the whole flight

MAD
JFK
Okay 4.6

Pros: The crew was good

Cons: More space in coach between seats

Thu, May 2
IND
Indianapolis
EWR
Newark
24h 01m
Tue, May 7
EWR
Newark
IND
Indianapolis
23h 17m
Trip: 6 days
5.5OkayShow reviews
Overall 5.5 Okay
Based on 58,568 reviews
Overall
5.8
Boarding
6.1
Comfort
5.4
Crew
6.5
Entertainment
4.6
Food
4.7
MCO
BWI
Good 6.0

Cons: Seats are uncomfortable

ORD
MCO
Mediocre 2.0

Pros: Nothing!

Cons: Had they not overbooked their first flight. Had they not bumped me off of my flight due to me not choosing a seat (an extra charge, mind you). Had they not overbooked the next flight out, which was 8 hours later. Had they not had a delay on the tarmat before takeoff. Terrible experience!

ORD
LGA
Mediocre 3.6

Pros: Very poor airline and all related services were very low standard

Cons: I suggest don’t travel on this cheap airline.

TPA
FLL
Okay 4.5

Cons: I was squished between 2 people a lot bigger then me, I wish the seats weren’t so close where you’re touching the person sitting next to you

DEN
LAS
Mediocre 3.2

Pros: Nothing this airline sucks.

Cons: Everything this airline sucks.

Thu, Apr 25
SBN
South Bend/Michiana
LGA
New York LaGuardia
7h 10m
Sun, Apr 28
LGA
New York LaGuardia
SBN
South Bend/Michiana
7h 03m
Trip: 4 days
7.0GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.0 Good
Based on 62,580 reviews
Overall
7.3
Boarding
7.4
Comfort
7.0
Crew
7.7
Entertainment
6.5
Food
6.5
LGA
DEN
Good 6.0

Cons: I was in coach. I am 6’2” and my legs were pressed against the seat in front of me for the full 4 hours. Uncomfortable.

IAH
SJO
Poor 0.0

Cons: Flight was canceled due to United's mismanagement of crews.

COU
ORD
Mediocre 2.0

Pros: Nothing

Cons: The flight was canceled, so taking off would have been an improvement.

MCO
SFO
Mediocre 2.3

Pros: That I made it to my destination.

Cons: Slow and inefficient boarding, small seats, terrible WiFi, No overhead space.

KOA
SFO
Okay 5.6

Cons: More room for your knees

Tue, Jun 4
IND
Indianapolis
JFK
New York John F Kennedy Intl
2h 10m
Sat, Jun 8
JFK
New York John F Kennedy Intl
IND
Indianapolis
2h 13m
Trip: 5 days
7.5GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.5 Good
Based on 3 reviews
Overall
8.1
Boarding
8.1
Comfort
7.8
Crew
8.5
Entertainment
7.7
Food
7.5
YYZ
ATL
Excellent 9.6

Pros: I liked the touch screen displays in each headrest. Seats and leg room comfortable

Cons: Boarding was somewhat unorganized

ATL
SJO
Excellent 10.0

Cons: Great flight. On time and friendly staff.

JFK
MSY
Excellent 9.0

Cons: Snacks

PWM
ATL
Excellent 9.2

Pros: Flight attendants were very friendly.

YEG
MSP
Excellent 9.0

Pros: WiFi and Entertainment

Thu, May 2
IND
Indianapolis
LGA
New York LaGuardia
2h 07m
Tue, May 7
LGA
New York LaGuardia
IND
Indianapolis
2h 26m
Trip: 6 days
6.7GoodShow reviews
Overall 6.7 Good
Based on 7 reviews
Overall
7.4
Boarding
7.5
Comfort
7.2
Crew
7.9
Entertainment
6.8
Food
6.7
JFK
MIA
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Calm no crowd organized and perfect

Cons: Umm

STL
CLT
Mediocre 3.6

Cons: 2 hour delays on both flights of a round trip

PHX
SEA
Good 6.6

Pros: comfortable seats

Cons: food

BWI
MIA
Excellent 8.0

Cons: When I made the reservation the code indicated that we would be able to purchase food on the flight. When I asked, the flight attendant said, nope, only choice is a pack of two cookies. We were starving on the 3.5 hour flight.

PHX
ONT
Excellent 9.5

Cons: No concerns What I expected for a quick flight

Tue, Jun 4
IND
Indianapolis
LGA
New York LaGuardia
2h 10m
Sat, Jun 8
LGA
New York LaGuardia
IND
Indianapolis
2h 29m
Trip: 5 days
8.5ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.5 Excellent
Based on 10 reviews
Overall
8.1
Boarding
8.1
Comfort
7.8
Crew
8.5
Entertainment
7.7
Food
7.5
IND
LGA
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Clean, modern plane, friendly crew, great service

Cons: I liked it all!

DEN
SEA
Good 7.0

Pros: On time flight, bag made it, great price, can’t complain.

Cons: Seat pretty tight for an average size adult man. No inflight phone charger.

HNL
FUK
Good 7.3

Cons: Ran out of hot water on flight

RDU
LGA
Good 6.0

Cons: Too much delay - departure was planned on March 15 @ 7 pm and take off happened on March 16 @ 12pm - a complete failure!!!!

ANC
SEA
Excellent 9.3

Pros: Good service

Cons: Video system locked up at my seat

Thu, May 16
IND
Indianapolis
LGA
New York LaGuardia
20h 24m
Wed, May 22
LGA
New York LaGuardia
IND
Indianapolis
24h 21m
Trip: 7 days
5.5OkayShow reviews
Overall 5.5 Okay
Based on 58,584 reviews
Overall
5.8
Boarding
6.1
Comfort
5.4
Crew
6.5
Entertainment
4.6
Food
4.7
CUN
FLL
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Boarding was quick and efficient !

Cons: N/a

LAS
MSP
Excellent 9.0

Pros: The crew was one of the best I have had on spirit.

Cons: nothing really, the few small things are ones that can’t change.

EWR
LAS
Mediocre 2.0

Pros: Nothing, was horrible

Cons: Better service

BWI
RSW
Good 7.6

Cons: Airfare price was great but a lot of other charges Luggage charge if you’re luggage was over fourty pound usually fifty pounds Beverage charge of three dollars-free on other airlines

EWR
MSY
Good 6.0

Cons: They have their own random process of checking in, boarding etc. If you try to interact with a person in any way they charge you for it. That's not how it works for other airlines, and their communications isn't particularly clear about this so charges are surprising

Wed, Jul 10
IND
Indianapolis
LGA
New York LaGuardia
2h 10m
Sat, Jul 13
LGA
New York LaGuardia
IND
Indianapolis
2h 29m
Trip: 4 days
8.5ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.5 Excellent
Based on 10 reviews
Overall
8.1
Boarding
8.1
Comfort
7.8
Crew
8.5
Entertainment
7.7
Food
7.5
SAN
LAS
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Great flight

ATL
SFO
Excellent 10.0

Pros: Yes

Cons: Took off late. Other than that very comfortable and great experience

ATL
TPA
Okay 4.0

Pros: Boarded on time.

Cons: After boarding the door was closed and the jet way was moved back. 5 minutes later they said they were going to bring the jet way back and open door to let more people on board. They broke 2 FAA regulations by doing this and we were delayed an hour because Deltas computer would not allow this.

MCI
DTW
Excellent 8.0

Cons: If there could have been some sort of service at DTW to take customers to the gate of their connecting flight, for cases of really short time window of course, it’d be extremely helpful.

MEM
MSP
Good 7.3

Cons: I booked a business class ticket through klm, but it was a delta code share flight. Delta was unable to locate me in their system, and I had to contact klm myself to straighten it out.

Thu, May 23
IND
Indianapolis
EWR
Newark
2h 01m
Mon, May 27
EWR
Newark
IND
Indianapolis
4h 25m
Trip: 5 days
7.0GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.0 Good
Based on 30 reviews
Overall
7.3
Boarding
7.4
Comfort
7.0
Crew
7.7
Entertainment
6.5
Food
6.5
SFO
PSP
Excellent 9.3

Pros: On time, rare for a full flight.

Cons: A little quicker on the baggage upon arrival would have been nice.

COU
ORD
Mediocre 2.0

Pros: Nothing

Cons: The flight was canceled, so taking off would have been an improvement.

PHX
SFO
Excellent 8.3

Pros: Seats were very comfortable in first class. Very happy with that experience for short haul flight. Enjoyed the service. Flight attendant checked on me multiple times and offered beverages.

Cons: Snack/food choices.

SEA
IAH
Good 6.4

Pros: The flight attendants were great.

Cons: Cabin was very very stuffy and hot. Very uncomfortable. Paying for WiFi? When other airlines offer it for free????

SFO
HNL
Good 6.0

Pros: crew good, seats good

Cons: The delay was over 2- 1/2 hours on the run way to honolulu..

Wed, Jul 31
IND
Indianapolis
JFK
New York John F Kennedy Intl
2h 15m
Sat, Aug 3
JFK
New York John F Kennedy Intl
IND
Indianapolis
2h 13m
Trip: 4 days
7.5GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.5 Good
Based on 3 reviews
Overall
8.1
Boarding
8.1
Comfort
7.8
Crew
8.5
Entertainment
7.7
Food
7.5
ATL
MSY
Okay 5.2

Cons: CheezIts were too salty. We had to sit on NO tarmac for over 10 minutes because a plane was stuck at our gate...several other gates empty - what's up?

ATL
CRW
Excellent 9.0

Pros: The ctew was awesome, super sweet and very acomodating

Cons: Its a flight to WV (my birth place).... it is what it is... smll planes, tight quarters and people who don’t get any of that and are not happy anout any of it

CHS
ATL
Okay 5.0

Cons: I had window seats on all flights and was boarded after those in middle/aisle seats 3 out of 4 times. Less legroom in the cheap seats. High whining pitch on speaker during announcements on last leg.

BRU
JFK
Excellent 8.0

Pros: great flight attendant

BTV
DTW
Excellent 9.3

Cons: The gate was changed but it was not updated to the app. Many of us were waiting in the wrong gate until 10 mins before departure.

Fri, Apr 5
FWA
Fort Wayne
LGA
New York LaGuardia
6h 27m
Mon, Apr 8
LGA
New York LaGuardia
FWA
Fort Wayne
16h 40m
Trip: 4 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
*
Prices are per person and are for e–tickets and include all taxes & fees in USD.

We attempt to get accurate prices, however, prices are not guaranteed.

Here's why:

We’re not the seller.
At KAYAK we don’t set the prices, so it’s not possible for us to guarantee what other companies are selling.

We compile tonnes of data for you
Our service lets you quickly and easily compare results from hundreds of travel sites at once. In this sense, KAYAK is a search engine and we can't guarantee prices we find.

Why aren’t prices accurate 100% of the time?
Prices on airline seats, hotel rooms and car rentals can change frequently. Several people may also be trying to buy the same travel option simultaneously. As a result, you may find, on occasion, that certain prices are no longer available.

If you have more questions or if you have a bad price to report to us,
please send us an and someone from our team will get back to you promptly.