Find cheap flights to Montauk

Find cheap flights to Montauk

Search hundreds of travel sites at once for deals on flights to Montauk

Round-trip
Economy
Boston (BOS)
Montauk
Sun 4/18
Sun 4/25
Any month
Compare vs. KAYAK |

Good to know

Low season

JanuaryBest time to beat the crowds with an average 11% drop in price.

High season

DecemberMost popular time to fly with an average 24% increase in price.

Average price round-trip

$373(avg. price over the last 2 weeks)

Good deal round-trip

$97or less

Good deal one-way

$68or less

Top tips for finding cheap flights to Montauk

  • There is no major airport in Montauk. It is instead served by Long Island Airport.
  • Looking for cheap airfare to Montauk? 25% of our users found tickets to Montauk for the following prices or less: From Miami $128 one-way - $155 round-trip, from Chicago $159 one-way - $171 round-trip, from Los Angeles $182 one-way - $269 round-trip
  • Book at least 1 week before departure in order to get a below-average price.
  • High season is considered to be January, February and December. The cheapest month to fly to Montauk is January.
  • Enter your preferred departure airport and travel dates into the search form above to unlock the latest Montauk flight deals.

FAQs - booking Montauk flights

Which airlines have a flexible cancellation policy for flights to Montauk due to COVID-19?

How to fly to Montauk?

What airports are near Montauk?

How far is Islip Airport from central Montauk?

How does KAYAK find such low prices on flights to Montauk?

How does KAYAK's flight Price Forecast tool help me choose the right time to buy my flight ticket to Montauk?

What is the Hacker Fare option on flights to Montauk?

What is KAYAK's "flexible dates" feature and why should I care when looking for a flight to Montauk?

Top airlines flying to Montauk

Scores according to KAYAK customer reviews

7.2
American Airlines
Overall score based on 45,385 reviews
7.5
Boarding
7.1
Comfort
7.8
Crew
6.9
Entertainment
6.7
Food
Airline reviews

Cons: "Got stuck between two over weight people."

Pros: "The fact that I was finally going home and could take a shower and change my clothes"

Pros: "Flights being on time"

Pros: "Fast"

Pros: "Everything was ok"
Cons: "Nothing"

Cons: "services was bad"

Pros: "Everything was generally very professional."
Cons: "Legroom tight."

Cons: "Cancelled for unknown mechanical issue."

Pros: "On time service."
Cons: "Nothing."

Pros: "The airplale MD 80 are old"

Pros: "On time"
Cons: "Seating"

Pros: "mango juice and soft blankets"
Cons: "too much time between meals"

Pros: "Clean environment of the terminals and the speed of the shuttle."
Cons: "no comment."

Pros: "It took off on time and life was good."

Pros: "Great service!"

Pros: "Everything"

Cons: "Same as previous response."

Pros: "The entertainment was amazing"
Cons: "We were delayed multiple times and landed extremely late"

Pros: "Very affordable! Traveling can be difficult, especially from Chicago O'hare - one of the busiest airports in the country - but everything was made easy for me and was a breeze!"
Cons: "No complaints here!"

Pros: "Almost always on time, captain keeps us updated, friendly airline staff"
Cons: "Nothing"

Pros: "On time"

Pros: "Everyone was polite, helpful, and courteous."

Pros: "There were too many gate changes ."

Pros: "I like that they have complimentary snacks"

Cons: "Delay boarding and then dropped us off at a remote runway and had to wait 45 minutes for a bus to main terminal!"

Pros: "Nothing"
Cons: "4 hora de retraso ni una cortesía empleados bien carnepuercos"

Pros: "Price space, time"
Cons: "Waiting.. but better to be early than late"

Pros: "Everything was pretty decent.. Best part was the price.. Boarding was good staff was good"
Cons: "Wasn't enough room.. kind of tight.. Couple more inches all around would have been perfect though"

Pros: "Ease of travel"

Pros: "Everything"
Cons: "No dislikes"

Pros: "No complaints"

Pros: "N/A"
Cons: "The flights were delayed multiple times. No communication at your gates. Oh and I think my favorite was changing terminals and gates 5 TIMES within 1 hour at DFW! RIDICULOUS AND UNACCEPTABLE. NEVER AGAIN!"

Pros: "All personnel where polite,helpful, and respectful. Greg to have wifi and power chargers."
Cons: "There was no real entertainment on the screens. No movies."

Pros: "Everybody was nice my ride was comfortable and they treat me with respect"
Cons: "I like everything"

Pros: "On time."

Cons: "1 hour late. And when the pilot made announcements during the movie it would not pause. We missed parts of the movie. It was annoying."

Pros: "very good no problems.."
Cons: "all good thanks much"

Cons: "Delayed"

Pros: "The ride was smooth the airplane was the food was OK the stewardess were kind"
Cons: "The ride was smooth the airplane was the food was OK the stewardess were kind"

Pros: "Nothing"
Cons: "Constant delays and cancellenations"

Pros: "Smooth, simple and easy process. Over good experience."
Cons: "I got nothing here."

Cons: "Same as above but I missed a whole day with my relatives at the lake :("

Pros: "The movies"
Cons: "Everything else"

Pros: "That I got a soda"
Cons: "Delayed at Ohare by an hour. Sitting on the Tarmac for a half hour in Reagan, waiting for a gate. This was our leg back to DC, after our leg to Chicago four days previously. On that trip I did a review and gave the whole trip a 1 out of 5 stars. That trip was the trip from hell, with delays, waiting on the Tarmac, deplaning, almost cancelled, more waiting on the Tarmac, wheels up in Reagan, wheels down in ORD, and then more Tarmac waiting for a gate. So I was already more than perturbed when this trip had similar outcomes."

Pros: "Love bed it! Would recommend to family/friends"

Pros: "Smooth trip"
Cons: "Delay delay delay on the flights"

Pros: "I loved the entertainment options"
Cons: "I did not like"

Pros: "It was a good nice ride. The employee was nice."

Cons: "No AC or USB charging ports, no individual entertainment screens."

Pros: "Leg room"

Pros: "Nothing"

Pros: "At least a beverages"

Pros: "Great deal for short notice."

Pros: "They could move my seat to accommodate me. Very nice."

Cons: "ONE AGENT at the Ticket counter, and ONE AGENT helping her, sauntering on the floor with 2 ladies' 'carry-ons'? THen the ladies are checking credit cards, something about moving clothes from one cas to another.... I was the Next one in line, WAITING AND WAITING, 20+ minutes, and NOW THE CHECK-IN LINE BEHIND ME IS FULL!!! And these Two AGENTS are still playing with these 2 ladies. (I dare say the race card was played here!) THIS IS UNACCEPTABLE. THE OTHER AGENT SHOULD HAVE BEEN ABLE TO GET BEHIND THE COUNTER AND START 'WORKING'!"

Pros: "Roomy and lots of storage space"
Cons: "The long lines to board"

Cons: "I have back problems and the seat did not lean back which helps relieve discomfort"

Cons: "The stewardess"

Pros: "Very good!!"

Cons: "Due to COVID 19 and government travel advisories resulting from this world pandemic my trip needed to be cancelled. After numerous requests Frontier held firm on not refunding me my money."

Cons: "Mild turbulence"

Cons: "the flight was cancelled and never re booked."

Cons: "The flight was cancelled and we were only notified once we reached the airport. I will never fly Frontier again."

Pros: "Cheap prices"

Pros: "Giant fat guy sitting in the middle seat next to me!"
Cons: "Not being delayed?"

Cons: "Free food and baggage"

Cons: "Just a bit delayed"

Cons: "Couldn’t get my precheck or global entry number to work so had to stand in line for 45 min"

Cons: "Waited 1 hour and 20 minutes for luggage. No excuse. Left us alone for an hour and then sent someone who was embarrassed to face us."

Pros: "Getting off the plane"
Cons: "Everything before that."

Pros: "Handicapped so very uncomfortable seating the rows are to close together if you can't bend legs well"
Cons: "Not handicapped friendly but staff was top notch and drinks food was ridiculesly high"

Cons: "Delay for 3 hrs with very little explanation"

Cons: "How are you gonna charge me for a cup of ice...was thirsty the whole flught"

Pros: "Cost- this was round trip flight. Both were fine. Although further from my house ISP was easy to get to, easy to check in/security lines non existent and food service while waiting was sufficient. I had booked thru KIWI for 1st time and was concerned when they could not auto check me in/send me boarding pass to print due to computer issues. I like to check in before hand , have boarding pass in hand but my counter check in was fast and easy with no additional fees. Clean new planes"
Cons: "Nothing. Knew what low cost flight required, packed accordingly to avoid extra fees, but would have paid if that did not work out."

Pros: "Easy departure from Tampa. Captain kept us well informed."

Pros: "Great fight attendants"

Pros: "The flight crew was good."
Cons: "Carry on charges are asinine. The same charge for checking in baggage is the same for carry-ons. Clarification needs to be in writing so that options are weighted prior to making my way to the counter."

Pros: "Gave me a great seat"

Pros: "I am probably a little more biased because tampa airport was celebrating the innaguration of the flight. Also the flight was very affordable and the plane seemed new and clean. Staff was very sweet and pilots were early."
Cons: "Snacks and drinks were all at a fee and there wasn't much leg room after the people in front of you lean back. We were unable to choose our seats. The seats themselves were extremely firm and uncomfortable. There was also no entertainment option, even for a fee or wifi available during a 3 hour flight. Deboarding took a while."

Cons: "Will not be using. Hidden charges doe luggage. No complimentary drinks. Filthy conditions. Will not be using frontier ever again."

Cons: "Charged for the food. The prices were not reasonable"

Pros: "Fast and smooth"
Cons: "Stewardess are not attentive to passengers needs"

Pros: "Staff was very timely, considerate, and very accommodating."

Pros: "We could not print our boarding passes and the woman at the desk was very helpful. She also worked out the best way with our checked and carry on luggage. We liked not being held up by everyone retrieving so much stuff in the overhead compartments."

Pros: "Great experience. Will do it again!"

Pros: "Service was fast and friendly and very efficient!!"

Pros: "One of the best flights taken."

Cons: "Take off"

Cons: "They were unable to check our luggage because we were a little bit late and told us it was our problem to figure it out."

Pros: "There is not a lot of leg room and I'm 5'6""

Pros: "Everything was good and very friendly staff"

Pros: "That it was non stop"

Cons: "4 hr delay"

Cons: "The delay in departure"

Pros: "Inside staff where very friendly"
Cons: "Ground staff horrible , terrible"

Cons: "You have to pay for non-alcoholic drinks."

Pros: "Nice and smooth"

Pros: "The fare"
Cons: "Got to Denver a half hour early. Frontier Operations didn't have a gate for us to park at and we sat on the Tarmac for OVER AN HOUR. Why wouldn't the pilot have radioed ahead to alert Operations that we were coming in early? Why didn't anyone apologize for our inconvenience? Pretty fed up with Frontier at this point."

Cons: "Baggage issue"

Read more about American Airlines
COVID-19 information

Safety measures for airlines flying to Montauk

Airlines flying to Montauk have enacted additional safety measures and adjusted policies to better accommodate travelers. Policies vary by airline.

Heightened sanitation

Daily cleaning, installation of cabin HEPA filters on flights to Montauk

Mandatory masks

Masks required on board, masks provided on flights to Montauk

Social distancing seating

Middle seats unavailable to book on flights to Montauk

Pre-flight testing

Testing for antibodies, testing for symptoms for flights to Montauk

Book Cheap Montauk Plane Tickets

Recent round-trip flight deals

5/20
Thu
nonstop
Frontier
2h 39m
MCO - ISP
5/24
Mon
nonstop
Frontier
2h 51m
ISP - MCO
5/21
Fri
nonstop
Frontier
2h 27m
MCO - ISP
5/24
Mon
nonstop
Frontier
2h 51m
ISP - MCO
4/23
Fri
nonstop
Frontier
2h 34m
MCO - ISP
4/26
Mon
nonstop
Frontier
2h 46m
ISP - MCO
5/13
Thu
nonstop
Frontier
2h 27m
MCO - ISP
5/20
Thu
nonstop
Frontier
2h 44m
ISP - MCO
4/29
Thu
nonstop
Frontier
2h 34m
MCO - ISP
5/3
Mon
nonstop
Frontier
2h 46m
ISP - MCO
5/21
Fri
nonstop
Frontier
2h 37m
TPA - ISP
5/24
Mon
nonstop
Frontier
2h 55m
ISP - TPA
4/23
Fri
nonstop
Frontier
2h 34m
MCO - ISP
4/25
Sun
nonstop
Frontier
2h 44m
ISP - MCO
5/14
Fri
nonstop
Frontier
2h 37m
TPA - ISP
5/17
Mon
nonstop
Frontier
2h 55m
ISP - TPA
4/23
Fri
nonstop
Frontier
2h 27m
MCO - ISP
4/28
Wed
nonstop
Frontier
2h 46m
ISP - MCO
4/28
Wed
nonstop
Frontier
2h 27m
MCO - ISP
5/5
Wed
nonstop
Frontier
2h 52m
ISP - MCO
5/13
Thu
nonstop
Multiple Airlines
2h 27m
MCO - ISP
5/18
Tue
1 stop
Multiple Airlines
5h 34m
ISP - MCO
5/12
Wed
nonstop
Multiple Airlines
2h 38m
MCO - ISP
5/17
Mon
1 stop
Multiple Airlines
5h 34m
ISP - MCO
5/13
Thu
nonstop
Multiple Airlines
2h 37m
MCO - ISP
5/18
Tue
2 stops
Multiple Airlines
6h 35m
ISP - MCO
5/20
Thu
nonstop
Multiple Airlines
2h 39m
MCO - ISP
5/24
Mon
2 stops
Multiple Airlines
14h 15m
ISP - MCO
5/11
Tue
nonstop
Multiple Airlines
2h 37m
MCO - ISP
5/18
Tue
1 stop
Multiple Airlines
5h 34m
ISP - MCO
4/26
Mon
1 stop
Multiple Airlines
9h 19m
FLL - ISP
4/27
Tue
1 stop
Multiple Airlines
13h 06m
ISP - FLL
4/29
Thu
1 stop
American Airlines
18h 52m
DFW - ISP
5/6
Thu
1 stop
American Airlines
14h 54m
ISP - DFW
5/7
Fri
1 stop
American Airlines
20h 26m
DFW - ISP
5/10
Mon
1 stop
American Airlines
6h 48m
ISP - DFW
4/24
Sat
2 stops
American Airlines
16h 27m
DFW - ISP
4/26
Mon
1 stop
American Airlines
6h 55m
ISP - DFW
5/13
Thu
1 stop
American Airlines
8h 06m
DFW - ISP
5/16
Sun
2 stops
American Airlines
23h 12m
ISP - DFW
Show more results

Recent one-way flight deals

5/13
Thu
nonstop
Frontier
2h 27m
MCO - ISP
5/18
Tue
nonstop
Frontier
2h 37m
MCO - ISP
5/22
Sat
nonstop
Frontier
2h 27m
MCO - ISP
5/14
Fri
nonstop
Frontier
2h 27m
MCO - ISP
5/23
Sun
nonstop
Frontier
2h 37m
MCO - ISP
4/24
Sat
nonstop
Frontier
2h 27m
MCO - ISP
5/14
Fri
nonstop
Frontier
2h 37m
TPA - ISP
4/22
Thu
nonstop
Frontier
2h 34m
MCO - ISP
5/21
Fri
nonstop
Frontier
2h 37m
TPA - ISP
4/26
Mon
1 stop
Multiple Airlines
9h 19m
FLL - ISP
5/13
Thu
1 stop
American Airlines
8h 06m
DFW - ISP
4/22
Thu
2 stops
American Airlines
11h 12m
DFW - ISP
4/27
Tue
1 stop
Multiple Airlines
11h 01m
ATL - ISP
4/28
Wed
1 stop
Multiple Airlines
27h 05m
FLL - ISP
5/2
Sun
1 stop
American Airlines
22h 27m
DFW - ISP
5/7
Fri
1 stop
American Airlines
18h 51m
DFW - ISP
4/28
Wed
2 stops
Multiple Airlines
22h 26m
MCO - ISP
5/17
Mon
1 stop
American Airlines
5h 21m
ORD - ISP
5/11
Tue
1 stop
Multiple Airlines
27h 57m
FLL - ISP
6/25
Fri
1 stop
Major Airline
11h 29m
ORD - ISP
Show more results
-
1
  • Round-trip
  • One-way
  • Multi-city
  • Trip Builder
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
  • Multiple
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First
Economy
  • Economy
  • Premium Economy
  • Business
  • First