Montauk car rentals

Montauk car rentals

Compare hundreds of rental car sites at once for car rental deals in Montauk, New York

Same drop-off
Thu 6/8
Noon
Thu 6/15
Noon

Let KAYAK do the searching

Save 32% or more

Compare hundreds of rental car sites at once for car rental deals in Montauk, New York State

We’re completely free to use – no hidden charges or fees

Filter by car type, free cancellation and more

Montauk car rental information

Pick-up locationMontauk
Car typesFull-size SUV, Intermediate, Intermediate SUV, Luxury, Luxury coupe, Open air all terrain, Pickup truck, Premium, Premium SUV, SUV
Rental locations1
Airport locations0
Popular agenciesTuro

Cheap car rentals in Montauk

Intermediate$46/day
SUV$88/day
Full-size SUV$130/day
Premium$64/day
Luxury$60/day
Pickup truck$50/day
Premium SUV$71/day
Intermediate SUV$51/day
Luxury coupe$86/day
Open air all terrain$106/day
Best rates found by KAYAK users in the past 48 hours.

Top tips for renting a car in Montauk

  • 25% of our users found rental cars in Montauk for $102 or less

FAQs about renting a car in Montauk

  • How much does it cost to rent a car in Montauk?

    On average a rental car in Montauk costs $116 per day. But prices differ between operators and you can save money through a price comparison of car rental deals from different agencies. The cheapest price for a car rental in Montauk found in the last 2 weeks is $69.

  • What is the cheapest car rental company in Montauk?

    In the past 72 hours, the cheapest rental cars were found at {0} ({1}/day).

  • How much is gas price in Montauk?

    The average gas price in Montauk is $3.82 per gallon over the past 30 days. Filling up a gas tank costs between $46 and $61, depending on the car size.

  • Which car rental companies are at Long Island airport (ISP)?

    The only car rental company onsite at Long Island airport is Hertz.

  • Which car rental companies will pick you up at Long Island airport (ISP)?

    Car rental companies that offer shuttle or pick-up services from Long Island airport to off-airport locations include Thrifty, Budget, Enterprise Rent-A-Car, Avis, Hertz, and National.

  • How can I find car rentals near me in Montauk?

    Take a look at our extensive car rental location map to find the best rental cars near you.

  • How much does it cost to rent a car for a week in Montauk?

    On average a rental car in Montauk costs $809 per week ($116 per day).

  • How much does it cost to rent a car long term for a month in Montauk?

    On average a rental car in Montauk costs $3,469 per month ($116 per day).

  • Should I get insurance when renting a car in Montauk?

    Most car rental providers in Montauk offer insurance but the level of protection can differ substantially. If you're unsure whether to get extra protection for your car rental in Montauk, check out KAYAK's car rental insurance guide.

  • How many car agencies are operating in Montauk?

    KAYAK has deals for you to compare from 1 car rental agencies in Montauk.

  • Which car rental companies in Montauk have updated their vehicle cleaning and safety policies because of Coronavirus (COVID-19)?

    One car rental company which has updated their car rental health and safety policies due to COVID-19 to make sure vehicles are clean and disinfected is Enterprise Rent-A-Car

  • What do I need to know before booking a car rental in Montauk?

    Finding the right price, understanding the add-ons and staying up to date with policy changes can be a challenge. That’s why KAYAK has produced the ultimate guide to renting a car to help you cut though the jargon and make the right choice for your rental car. Find tips and insights for how to book your rental, what car rental insurance you’ll need, how to deal with a car rental agency and what extra fees to expect (and avoid!).

  • Why should I use KAYAK to rent a car in Montauk?

    KAYAK searches thousands of car rental agencies to provide you with offers from all car rental agencies operating in Montauk so that you can compare car rental rates, reviews and pick-up and drop-off locations to find the best deal for you.

Montauk car rental reviews and directory

Budget

6.0

Best rated

Cleanliness

6.0

Comfort

6.0

Pick-up/Drop-off

6.0

Value for money

5.0

One location in Montauk

Show locations

Locations in Montauk

155 Tower Avenue

+1 860 405 8378

Monday08:00 - 18:00
Tuesday08:00 - 18:00
Wednesday08:00 - 18:00
Thursday08:00 - 18:00
Friday08:00 - 18:00
Saturday09:00 - 13:00
Sunday09:00 - 13:00
View deals

Filters

Reviews

5.2 Fair

Sep 2017

KAYAK

Cons:

When I went to pick up the car the guy behind the front desk was more interested in watching tv and getting off early then helping me get the paperwork and car pick up( pick up was at 1700 and they are open till 1800)When I got the keys and was doing a walk around the clerk was already out the door and zooming off in his personal vehicle. The rental wasn't cleaned that well, there was trash and receipts from the previous driver. When I dropped the car off one of their people jumped in the rental and left before I could go over the car with them.

2.0 Poor

Aug 2017

KAYAK

Pros:

nothing

Cons:

I made this car rental reservation weeks in advance. The morning I was supposed to pick up the car, Budget called me and said there will NOT be a car available.

1 out of 1

Hertz

4.9

Mediocre

22 reviews

Cleanliness

5.7

Comfort

5.1

Pick-up/Drop-off

5.3

Value for money

4.3

3 locations in Montauk

Show locations

Locations in Montauk

1640 Montauk Highway

+1 631 237 4518

Monday09:00 - 13:00
Tuesday09:00 - 13:00
Wednesday09:00 - 13:00
Thursday09:00 - 13:00
Friday09:00 - 13:00
Saturday09:00 - 13:00
View deals

200 Daniels Hole Road

+1 631 283 1584

Monday09:00 - 13:00
Thursday09:00 - 13:00
Friday09:00 - 13:00
Saturday09:00 - 13:00
Sunday09:00 - 13:00
View deals

320 Thomas Rd

+1 860 446 1200

Monday08:00 - 18:00
Tuesday08:00 - 18:00
Wednesday08:00 - 18:00
Thursday08:00 - 18:00
Friday08:00 - 18:00
Saturday09:00 - 13:00
View deals

Filters

Show reviews that mention

Reviews

2.0 Poor

Jun 2020

KAYAK

Pros:

Nothing teribile experience

Cons:

Wrong car, no contract (“computer not working-will send later” - never received) higher than expected price

8.0 Very good

Aug 2019

KAYAK

Pros:

Only one person on staff - she was on the phone when I came in but she helped me as soon as she got off.

Cons:

One other staff person would have made the pick-up faster.

3.6 Poor

Sep 2017

KAYAK

Cons:

Pickup and dropoff was disorganized, they overcharged me, and the car was dirty and barely had 1/4 tank of gas.

2.0 Poor

Jul 2017

KAYAK

Cons:

I was able to make a reservation through kayak for Sunday-Sunday at water mill. This despite the water mill location being closed on sundays, unbeknownst to me. I had to pick up my car a day late, drop it off in a different location, and hertz tried to charge me double to rebook my reservation to accommodate the correct times. Totally unacceptable, basically a bait and switch.

10.0 Wonderful

May 2017

KAYAK

Cons:

Wish there was afterhour drop off in locations north of Bradley airport

10.0 Wonderful

Jul 2016

KAYAK

Pros:

Great experience and service and I always have a bad one with renting a car but price was accurate and car was great

1 out of 4

Avis

4.0

Mediocre

2 reviews

Cleanliness

2.0

Comfort

8.0

Pick-up/Drop-off

2.0

Value for money

6.0

One location in Montauk

Show locations

Locations in Montauk

155 Tower Avenue

+1 860 445 8585

Monday07:30 - 18:00
Tuesday07:30 - 18:00
Wednesday07:30 - 18:00
Thursday07:30 - 18:00
Friday07:30 - 18:00
Saturday09:00 - 13:00
Sunday09:00 - 13:00
View deals

Filters

Reviews

4.0 Mediocre

Feb 2023

KAYAK
The staff was nice. However the vehicle was dirty and returned vehicle earl by several hours but still counted as a day by Avis. So no price adjustment. The phone line to Groton -Avis does not work but only rings. It’s never busy there so surprised no one ever answers.

1 out of 1

Enterprise Rent-A-Car

No score available yet

Cheapest deal
Most popular

Locations in Montauk

185 Tower Ave

+1 860 448 0422

Monday07:30 - 18:00
Tuesday07:30 - 18:00
Wednesday07:30 - 18:00
Thursday07:30 - 18:00
Friday07:30 - 18:00
Saturday09:00 - 13:00
Sunday00:00 - 00:00
View deals

200 Daniels Hole Road

+1 631 537 4800

Opening times not available

View deals

59 Star Island Rd

+1 631 283 0055

Monday00:00 - 00:00
Tuesday00:00 - 00:00
Wednesday00:00 - 00:00
Thursday00:00 - 00:00
Friday00:00 - 00:00
Saturday00:00 - 00:00
Sunday00:00 - 00:00
View deals

Filters

Reviews

7.6 Good

Oct 2015

KAYAK

Pros:

Service at pick up was good and thorough

Cons:

Details of pick up were not detailed enough and let to confusion on location.

1 out of 1

Easirent

No score available yet

2 locations in Montauk

Show locations

Locations in Montauk

East Hampton Airport

Opening times not available

View deals

Groton-New London Airport

Opening times not available

View deals

Filters

No reviews available

31 travelers who rented a car in Montauk gave the car agency they used an average rating of 5.0

Car rental locations in or near Montauk

Good to know

Most popular agency

Enterprise Rent-A-Car

Average price

$116/day

Good deal

$102/day

When to book a rental car in Montauk

Average daily price per month
Rental car prices as pick-up date approaches