Cons (-) I love this hotel! No frills, comfortable and great value.
Latest deals for The Gatsby Hotel
Amenities at The Gatsby Hotel
- Room service
- Free Wi-Fi
- Coffee machine
- Wi-Fi available in all areas
- Flat-screen TV
- TV
- Cable or satellite TV
- Free toiletries
- Internet
- Laundry service
Reviews of The Gatsby Hotel
6.7
Okay
1320 verified ratings
Wonderful
296
Very good
253
Good
235
Okay
124
Fair
159
Mediocre
65
Poor
188
Summary of reviews
Guests say
Guests overwhelmingly praised the hotel's excellent location, with many mentioning its proximity to subway stations, popular neighborhoods, and attractions. Cleanliness was also highlighted positively in several reviews, with guests appreciating clean rooms and linens. However, a major recurring issue was the malfunctioning or absent room key system, which caused significant inconvenience and occasional concerns about safety. Service received mixed feedback: some staff members were described as friendly and helpful, while others were seen as overwhelmed or unwelcoming. Room size was noted as small but typical for NYC, and value for price was generally considered fair.AI-Generated from customer reviews
Reviews(1)
Q&A(5)
Tips(10)
Sort by:Most recent
Score by provider
6.8 out of 10
762 reviews
5.7 out of 10
28 reviews
5.9 out of 10
12 reviews
8.9 out of 10
1 review
All reviews
AI-powered summary based on hotel reviews by KAYAK users. AI can make mistakes.
What are the pros of staying at The Gatsby Hotel?
The staff is very friendly and helpful, the room is clean and orderly, and the hotel offers no-frills, comfortable, and great value accommodations.
What are the cons of staying at The Gatsby Hotel?
Some guests experienced dirty rooms, uncomfortable beds, and noise issues. Additionally, there were instances of unavailability of prepaid reservations and inconveniences related to room amenities.
What practical amenities does The Gatsby Hotel offer?
The hotel provides free Wi-Fi, air-conditioned rooms, laundry facilities, and a microwave. Additionally, it offers cable or satellite TV and storage facilities.
When is the best time to visit The Gatsby Hotel?
The high season is in December, and the low season is in February. Visitors can consider these factors when planning their stay.
What can guests expect from the staff at The Gatsby Hotel?
Guests can expect kind and helpful staff who are accommodating and quick to address any issues. However, some guests experienced unprofessional behavior from the front desk.
AI-powered summary based on hotel reviews by KAYAK users. AI can make mistakes.
Opt for a Higher Floor
Guests recommend requesting a room on a higher floor to avoid street noise, especially if staying in a street-facing room.
Check Room Amenities
Some guests were disappointed by the lack of essential amenities in the room, such as a fridge, full-length mirror, or TV with sufficient channels. It's advisable to confirm the availability of these amenities before booking.
Consider Noise Levels
Guests staying in lower-level rooms facing the street experienced significant noise disturbances. Consider this when selecting a room, especially if sensitive to noise.
Verify Room Size
Some guests found the rooms to be small, so it's recommended to inquire about room size and consider upgrading to a larger room if space is a priority.
Be Mindful of Check-in Experience
A few guests had unpleasant experiences during check-in, resulting in delays. It's advisable to allow extra time for check-in, especially if arriving for a scheduled event.
Confirm Essential Facilities
Some guests encountered issues with essential facilities, such as the elevator and bathroom cleanliness. It's recommended to confirm the availability and proper functioning of these facilities upon arrival.
Explore Nearby Dining Options
The hotel's location offers a variety of dining options nearby, including bistros and specialty restaurants, providing convenient choices for guests.
Consider Parking Options
Guests found affordable parking options nearby, such as a garage offering a hotel-only rate. It's worth exploring these options for convenient and cost-effective parking.
Inquire About Room Views
Guests staying in rooms without windows or city views were disappointed. It's advisable to inquire about the room's view and natural lighting before booking.
Address Noise Concerns
Some guests experienced noise disturbances from neighboring rooms. It's recommended to address any noise concerns with the hotel staff for a more comfortable stay.
Location
135 East Houston Street, New York, NY 10002
What's nearby
- Brooklyn Bridge1.3 mi
- Wall Street1.5 mi
- Koreatown1.7 mi
- Empire State Building1.8 mi
- Madison Square Garden1.9 mi
- United Nations Headquarters2.2 mi
- Times Square2.5 mi
- Rockefeller Center2.5 mi
- Broadway2.6 mi
- Theatre District2.6 mi
- Museum of Modern Art2.7 mi
- Midtown Center2.8 mi
Policies
Check-in/Check-out | Check in anytime after 3:00 PM, check out anytime before 11:00 AM |
|---|---|
Cancellation/prepayment | Cancellation/prepayment policies vary by room type and provider. |
Essential information about The Gatsby Hotel
Low season | High season | Average price (weeknight) | Average price (weekend night) |
|---|---|---|---|
February | October | $338 | $397 |
Cheapest month to stay with an average 54% drop in price. | Most expensive month to stay with an average 24% rise in price. | Average Sun - Thu price over the last 2 weeks. | Average Fri & Sat price over the last 2 weeks. |
The Gatsby Hotel
Which month has the cheapest rates at The Gatsby Hotel?
Based on hotel prices found by KAYAK users over the last 12 months.
The cheapest month to stay at The Gatsby Hotel is January, with an average nightly rate of $156. The most expensive month is December at $408 per night.
What is the cheapest day to book The Gatsby Hotel?
Based on hotel prices found by KAYAK users over the last 12 months.
The cheapest day to book The Gatsby Hotel is Sunday, with an average nightly rate of $282. The most expensive day is Friday at $429 per night.
How far in advance should you book The Gatsby Hotel?
Based on hotel prices found by KAYAK users over the last 12 months.
To get the best price at The Gatsby Hotel, book around 1 week in advance. This could save you approximately 11% compared to booking last minute.
KAYAK's top tips for your stay at The Gatsby Hotel
FAQs when booking at The Gatsby Hotel
Nearby hotels and places to stay
Closest
See more nearby staysCheapest
See cheapest stays in New YorkMost recommended
See most recommended stays in New YorkGood to know
Distance to city center | Nearest Airport | Distance to airport |
|---|---|---|
2.3 mi | New York LaGuardia | 7.2 mi |