Find cheap flights from New York to Indiana from $42
This is the cheapest one-way flight price found by a KAYAK user in the last 72 hours by searching for a flight departing on 10/18. Fares are subject to change and may not be available on all flights or dates of travel. Click the price to replicate the search for this deal.
Round-trip
1 adult
Economy
Sat 10/28
Sat 11/4
In the last 7 days travellers have searched 44,168,898 times on KAYAK, and here is why:
Save 21% or moreCompare multiple travel sites with one search.
Track pricesNot ready to book? Create a price alert for when prices drop.
Filter your dealsChoose cabin class, free Wi-Fi and more.
Bundle and saveSave money when you bundle your flight + hotel.
Search hundreds of travel sites at once for deals on flights to Indiana
...and more
Latest Indiana Flight Deals
Best round-trip prices found by our users on KAYAK in the last 72 hours
Nonstop from $57
1 stop from $236
1 stop from $263
1 stop from $379
Nonstop from $86
Nonstop from $228
Good to know
Top tips for finding cheap flights to Indiana
- Book at least 2 weeks before departure in order to get a below-average price.
- High season is considered to be May, June and July. The cheapest month to fly from New York is January.
- Morning departure is around 2% cheaper than an evening flight, on average*.
FAQs - booking Indiana flights
Which airlines have a flexible cancellation policy for flights from New York to Indiana due to COVID-19?
Delta, American Airlines and United Airlines have all waived their change and cancellation fees on flights from New York to Indiana. Confirm policies on booking site.
How does KAYAK find such low prices on flights from New York to Indiana?
KAYAK is a travel search engine. That means we look across the web to find the best prices we can find for our users. With over 2 billion flight queries processed yearly, we are able to display a variety of prices and options on flights from New York to Indiana.
How does KAYAK's flight Price Forecast tool help me choose the right time to buy my flight ticket from New York to Indiana?
KAYAK’s flight Price Forecast tool uses historical data to determine whether the price for a flight to Indiana from New York is likely to change within 7 days, so travelers know whether to wait or book now.
What is the Hacker Fare option on flights from New York to Indiana?
Hacker Fares allow you to combine one-way tickets in order to save you money over a traditional round-trip ticket. You could then fly to Indiana with an airline and back to New York with another airline.
What is KAYAK's "flexible dates" feature and why should I care when looking for a flight from New York to Indiana?
Sometimes travel dates aren't set in stone. If your preferred travel dates have some wiggle room, flexible dates will show you all the options when flying to Indiana from New York up to 3 days before/after your preferred dates. You can then pick the flights that suit you best.
Top 5 airlines serving from New York to Indiana
8.1
JetBlueOverall score based on 19489 reviews
83boarding
78food
82overall
82comfort
86crew
79entertainment
Airline reviews
Pros: "Fine flight, nice Attendants (albeit a bit unresponsive)"
Cons: "My internet and television did not work. It’s really the main reason I fly with JetBlue for the internet in television s my screen was even fuzzy, and the movies didn’t work at all. My previous flight had the same issue and we were promised a voucher. I’d like the same for this flight please."
Pros: "Fine flight, nice Attendants (albeit a bit unresponsive)"
Cons: "My internet and television did not work. It’s really the main reason I fly with JetBlue for the internet in television s my screen was even fuzzy, and the movies didn’t work at all. My previous flight had the same issue and we were promised a voucher. I’d like the same for this flight please."
Pros: "Comfortable."
Cons: "There was a 40 minute delay texted to us 8 hours prior to the flight, but we were told to arrive at the normal time. Then, on arrival, two of the flight attendants announced they weren't feeling well, and we waited another hour, with few announcements which were audible only at the gate."
Cons: "The TVs were unavailable on both trips. Not a deal brraker but less then ideal. Otherwise, excellent service."
Pros: "Great crew. Extra space seats are worth it. They added another flavor of pop chips!"
Cons: "I wish there were more movies offered. I love that they are there and there is live tv-but that offering could be improved."
Pros: "The personnel were courteous and listen to your request ,the flight was exceptional.."
Cons: "No comments at this time."
Pros: "The flight was very smooth and the staff was very nice."
Cons: "The wifi did not work at all and my TV did not work so I had to listen to my music the entire trip."
Pros: "Friendly staff and a smooth takeoff and landing. All I could ask for. This was the 1st time that I flew JetBlue and I was impressed."
Cons: "The middle seat but that was probably my fault."
Pros: "Crew was great"
Cons: "Got home at 3am. Ruined the next day getting in so late"
Cons: "Delayed and departure time changed but wasn’t reflected until I was at the gate. They also changed my seat from the front to very back of the plane"
Pros: "Plenty of leg room and nice to still get a few snacks!"
Pros: "Fue un vuelo muy tranquilo y todos muy amables gracias!!"
Cons: "Muy cómodo el avión y el personal"
Cons: "For some reason, we were asked several times for Passports. This didn’t make any sense since we are US citizens with drivers license. They even had TSA talk to us. This has to be fixed. Otherwise, Delta experience was great."
Pros: "Cabin crew was great. Was told they don’t feel they can do a good job of serving 48 passengers in Premium Select with 2 crew."
Cons: "Image recognition step slowed boarding down a lot. Food and amenities on Delta Premium Select seem to be getting worse"
Cons: "During this trip all my flights got delayed and I was told that I could not get a hotel room and had to pay for myself."
Pros: "The service by delta employees for this leg of my journey was beyond great. The leg room was above average."
Cons: "Leg room. Never can have enough leg room."
Pros: "This had one of the best attendants I have encountered. She was extra friendly and made us feel good."
Cons: "Had to wait for the crew from another flight before boarding p"
Pros: "Quickly boarded and took off as well. It was a really smooth flight!"
Pros: "Cabin service was decent"
Cons: "Food was cold. First class service could have been more attentive. While trying to sleep crew talked the entire time."
Pros: "The food was good The crew was fantastic, friendly and accommodating Flight was on time"
Cons: "I was near the bathroom.. stank a bit"
Cons: "The fish is terrible - no matter it is regular or low salt meal."
Pros: "Seats were very comfortable and so were the entertainment options"
Cons: "The food was really sub-par in terms of quality. Also the it took over an hour for bags to come through which if we are flying business is a little sub-par"
Cons: "There is only a food box which contains a small sandwich, a small cake and a small cup of fruit pieces with a drink of 250ml ice tea for this three hour flight. I would think this kind of catering is not good enough."
Pros: "Beautiful, new plane. Amazing, elegant, classy, patient crew. Lot so of nice customer service touches."
Cons: "The food could have been a bit more exciting, but it was solid."
Cons: "The sound at my seat didn’t work so I had a a 14 hour flight with no soundtrack. I watched one Japanese movie with subtitles and then gave up"
Pros: "The crew was wonderful. Very polite and professional. The movie selection was the best I had ever had.......great job there!"
Cons: "I am 6-4, so I always struggle with comfort. My legs cramp and my back aches. The meals look good and I even try them sometimes, but me and airline food seldom work out."
Pros: "Excellent ..."
Cons: "We were served only breakfast and lunch ... in 16 hour travel with a cup of noodles if you asked, the stewardess needed to get reminders couple of times. The steward serving food was excellent. No coffee nor drinks were offered after meals. Food was good though."
Pros: "The very nice lady at Hong Kong station who checked me in was kind enough to give me an upgrade when the flight was full."
Cons: "The food on Cathay still has not improved compared to other airlines'"
Pros: "Not much, quick though"
Cons: "Plane is old, seats are terrible, hard awkward, strange seatbelt clunk of foam plastic, food was horrible, never saw the crew, it was hot, needed water has to go track it down, it was an overnight flight so not all the crews fault"
Pros: "I am frequent air traveler that logs about 100k miles a year and this is the first time I felt like writing a review about an airline. I traveled with my 4 year old son on this trip. Excellent service, high quality food options and flight amenities. I really enjoyed the food as did my son. My son left his backpack behind on the first leg and the airline staff retreived it and delivered it to the lounge in less than 15 minutes. I was astounded and had almost given up on seeing the bag again, given my experience with other airlines in the past. This is going to be airline of choice for future trips!"
Pros: "Your willingness to proceed with flying into a pandemic zone with total travel lockdown."
Cons: "allowing travelers that have been advised not to travel to Europe to either change or refund their flights. Your system for this is a bureaucratic nightmare, and the responsible thing to do in a time of crisis is allow people to make the right decision to stay in place. I am done using your service."
Cons: "This was a red-eye from Costa Rica to Chicago. I sat in the very back row, so I really felt the turbulence back there. But I had no chance of sleeping through it because my seat would not lean back; in fact it was so far upright that I was almost leaning forward. I can normally sleep on any flight but this was like sitting in a tiny cage designed to prevent me from finding any remotely comfortable position or getting any rest at all. They should not be allowed to sell a seat like this."
Pros: "..."
Cons: "I got stuck in the airport through the whole night"
Pros: "I liked the free in ight movies which makes a 5 hr plane ride a a lot more enjoyable. Having 2 rounds of free beverages was also what I liked. The seats are comfortable, plenty of leg room, love that there are plug/ports to charge you electronic devices."
Cons: "What could have been better especially on a 5hr flight to Honolulu would be free wifi, free meals, if not free meals then 2 rounds of snacks, and I know it's out of the airlines control, but families with their screaming babies who's parents leave the tray down to keep their toddler entertained so she could kick it up and down through out the flight. I feel the airlines should place families with babies and toddlers together on a portion of the plane."
Pros: "The taste of the food was delicious."
Cons: "I’d have liked larger portion sizes as I was still a little hungry after each meal and snack."
Cons: "Flight was delayed. Least amount of leg room on any flight I have ever been on."
Pros: "Having a nice breakfast at Ruby's in between flights. Houston is a beautiful airport. When my sciatica got too painful from dragging my baggage allover the airports, United instantly got me setup with a wheelchair and a very helpful person that made everything more bearable. The food was overpriced but good."
Cons: "The long walks between domestic and international terminals. and broken people movers. Houston is huuuuuuuge!"
Pros: "Relatively comfortable seat, decent entertainment and nice crew."
Cons: "50 minutes on the tarmac in Newark waiting for the gate."
Pros: "We got earlier than anticipated."
Cons: "There is no food to offer unless you pay for it when you are asked. I got a bag of chips that isually goes for 1.99 at the store but they sell it for 4.99. They only give you 2 cookies and a drink for a 5 hour flight. The entertaiment was not present for 98% of the flight even when it says that wifi is available and to choose the movies or shows from their website. There's no disclaimer saying wifi does not work over the sea which was thru almost the entire flight. When you could finally connect to it, it wouldn't load. Most airplanes have an entertainment system in the back of the seat even for less than 3 hour flights but not on this one. Very disappointing."
Cons: "I never made it to this flight due to delay when flying CPH-EWR"
Cons: "Boarding process should be better, the seats should be more comfortable, no extra fees should be imposed. All around terrible Flight. Will never fly spirit again ."
Pros: "Crew was OUTSTANDING!!!"
Cons: "Best trip by plane trip I’ve experienced so far."
Cons: "Spirit’ kiosk bag check is a waste of travelers’ time. Takes agent just as long to process—plus waiting in line a second time"
Cons: "1.5 hour flight delay. Very uncomfortable seats. Confusing boarding upgrade and seat assignment."
Pros: "N/A"
Cons: "My fly was canceled I lost a day of vacation and money with all my reservations"
Pros: "Nothing"
Cons: "Flight scheduled to leave at 8:25 AM. Did not leave until 1:45 PM. Was delayed four times because of a Crew issue on Easter Sunday. Missed our entire Easter celebration because spirit was unable to man a plane Will never fly this airline again. Customer service was rude on top of it. They need to be prepared for crew to call out on a holiday. 5 1/2 hour delay with no weather emergency is unacceptable. A 50 dollar voucher does not make up for ruining a family hokiday"
Pros: "Window seat via random selection!!!!!! Fabulous and friendly stewards (ess)"
Cons: "I did not like the $20 cocktail in the airport."
Pros: "The flight attendants made the trip fun, they put their own spin on the safety announcements."
Pros: "Airport waiting area was very nice with lots of different seating options. The boarding went very quickly, but that was because the flight was mostly empty. Can't believe how expensive the luggage was. I guess that is why the ticket is less expensive."
Cons: "The seats were hard and the tray table was almost non-existent."
Cons: "I didn't like that you are only allowed to take one personal item on them flight."
Book cheap flights from New York to Indiana
Recent round-trip flight deals
10/18Wed
nonstopSpirit Airlines
2h 11mEWR-IND
10/19Thu
nonstopSpirit Airlines
2h 05mIND-EWR
$71
11/23Thu
nonstopSpirit Airlines
2h 25mEWR-IND
11/28Tue
nonstopSpirit Airlines
1h 50mIND-EWR
$74
10/27Fri
nonstopSpirit Airlines
2h 11mEWR-IND
11/3Fri
1 stopSpirit Airlines
6h 46mIND-EWR
$78
11/20Mon
nonstopDelta
2h 26mJFK-IND
11/28Tue
nonstopDelta
2h 23mIND-JFK
$158
11/20Mon
nonstopDelta
2h 32mLGA-IND
11/29Wed
nonstopDelta
2h 09mIND-LGA
$158
10/28Sat
nonstopAmerican Airlines
2h 22mJFK-IND
10/30Mon
nonstopAmerican Airlines
2h 14mIND-JFK
$159
10/19Thu
nonstopUnited Airlines
2h 06mEWR-IND
10/21Sat
nonstopUnited Airlines
2h 09mIND-EWR
$163
12/16Sat
nonstopUnited Airlines
2h 16mEWR-IND
1/6Sat
1 stopUnited Airlines
7h 01mIND-EWR
$168
10/26Thu
nonstopAmerican Airlines
2h 21mJFK-IND
10/30Mon
nonstopAmerican Airlines
2h 15mIND-JFK
$174
11/3Fri
1 stopFrontier
17h 19mLGA-IND
11/5Sun
1 stopFrontier
25h 14mIND-LGA
$184
Search by stops
Search by airline
Search by price
Recent one-way flight deals
10/18Wed
nonstopSpirit Airlines
2h 11mEWR-IND
$42
10/25Wed
1 stopSpirit Airlines
8h 20mEWR-IND
$49
11/1Wed
1 stopSpirit Airlines
8h 20mEWR-IND
$59
12/4Mon
1 stopFrontier
16h 39mLGA-IND
$73
10/18Wed
nonstopDelta
2h 17mJFK-IND
$79
10/18Wed
nonstopDelta
2h 19mLGA-IND
$79
10/18Wed
nonstopUnited Airlines
2h 24mEWR-IND
$79
12/20Wed
nonstopAmerican Airlines
2h 46mJFK-IND
$81
10/25Wed
1 stopFrontier
14h 39mLGA-IND
$85
10/30Mon
1 stopAmerican Airlines
5h 20mLGA-SBN
$118
Search by stops
Search by airline
Search by price
Last minute flights from New York to Indiana
Last minute flight, train and bus deals
10/3Tue
nonstopSpirit Airlines
2h 09mEWR-IND
10/4Wed
nonstopSpirit Airlines
2h 05mIND-EWR
$142
10/2Mon
nonstopSpirit Airlines
2h 09mEWR-IND
10/4Wed
nonstopSpirit Airlines
2h 05mIND-EWR
$185
10/3Tue
multi-stopMultiple Airlines
20h 27mEWR-IND
10/4Wed
nonstopMultiple Airlines
2h 05mIND-EWR
$208
9/30Sat
multi-stopDelta
5h 33mLGA-IND
10/5Thu
nonstopDelta
2h 05mIND-LGA
$328
10/1Sun
multi-stopMultiple Airlines
15h 20mEWR-IND
10/3Tue
nonstopMultiple Airlines
2h 05mIND-EWR
$342
9/30Sat
nonstopAmerican Airlines
2h 14mJFK-IND
10/9Mon
nonstopAmerican Airlines
2h 14mIND-JFK
$348
9/30Sat
nonstopAmerican Airlines
2h 14mLGA-IND
10/5Thu
nonstopAmerican Airlines
2h 00mIND-LGA
$348
9/29Fri
nonstopDelta
2h 30mJFK-IND
10/1Sun
nonstopDelta
2h 19mIND-JFK
$358
9/29Fri
nonstopUnited Airlines
2h 09mEWR-IND
10/1Sun
nonstopUnited Airlines
2h 14mIND-EWR
$358
9/29Fri
nonstopUnited Airlines
2h 24mEWR-IND
10/1Sun
nonstopUnited Airlines
2h 14mIND-EWR
$400