Find Cheap Flights from New York to Toronto Island (NYC - YTZ)

Search hundreds of travel sites at once for deals on flights to Toronto Island

Sat 2/24
Sat 3/3
Any month
Compare vs. KAYAK |

Good to Know

Low Season:
January
Best time to beat the crowds
2%
expected price decrease
High Season:
March
Most popular time to fly
11%
expected price increase
Average Price:
$247
(avg. price over the last 2 weeks)
Good Deal:
$208
or less (round trip)

When to Book Flights from New York to Toronto Island

Average price per month
Flight prices as travel date approaches
-1 day
-2 days

Top tips for Finding a Cheap Flight

Looking for a cheap flight? 25% of our users found flights on this route for $207 or less.
The cheapest flight from New York to Toronto Island was found 76 days before departure, on average.
Book at least 3 weeks before departure in order to get a below-average price.
High season is considered to be February, March and April. The cheapest month to fly is January.
Morning departure is around 4% cheaper than an evening flight, on average*.
*Average of the lowest prices shown in KAYAK’s search results for departures within the next 30 days

FAQs for Booking New York to Toronto Island Flights

How long does a flight from New York to Toronto Island take?
An average nonstop flight takes 1h 30m, covering a distance of 341 miles.
How many flights are there between New York and Toronto Island?
There are 98 (nonstop) flights between New York and Toronto Island per week, averaging 14 per day.
Which airlines provide the cheapest flights from New York to Toronto Island?
In the past 3 days, the cheapest round-trip tickets were found on Air Canada ($197), Porter Airlines ($246) and Multiple Airlines ($339).
Do I need a passport to fly between New York and Toronto Island?
Yes.
Which airlines fly most frequently between New York and Toronto Island?
Porter Airlines (14 times daily) are the most frequent flyers on this route.
What’s the cheapest day of the week to fly New York to Toronto Island?
For New York to Toronto Island, Wednesday is the cheapest day to fly on average and Tuesday is the most expensive. Flying from Toronto Island back to New York, the best deals are generally found on Friday, with Wednesday being the most expensive.

Book cheap flights from New York to Toronto Island (round-trip)

Airports
Origin
New York
$197
only
$197
$352
only
$352
Newark
$246
only
$246
Destination
Toronto
$197
only
$197
Wed, Apr 4
LGA
YTZ
4h 00m
Sat, Apr 7
YTZ
LGA
4h 15m
Trip: 4 days
7.1GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.1 Good
Based on 21542 reviews
Overall
7.2
Boarding
7.3
Comfort
7.0
Crew
7.7
Entertainment
6.9
Food
6.5
YYC
LHR
Mediocre 2.0

JustFly did not release my coupon to Lufthansa or Air Canada, and so I was nearly prevented from flying.

ATL
YYZ
Okay 5.0

I arrived safely

I didn't appreciate losing my luggage as I came to Canada for a wedding and I didn't have access to my things. The flight was direct so I don't understand why my luggage was lost.

LAX
YYZ
Excellent 8.0

Plane delayed 1 hour and a half. No compensation.

LIR
YYZ
Okay 5.3

Uncomfortable

YUL
YVR
Okay 4.3

Generous leg room in coach class

Sat on the runway for almost an hour both to and from my destination

Fri, Jun 15
EWR
YTZ
1h 34m
Mon, Jun 18
YTZ
EWR
1h 30m
Trip: 4 days
8.1ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.1 Excellent
Based on 174 reviews
Boarding
8.0
Comfort
8.0
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
7.0
Food
7.9
EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Why would you go any other way? Dependable service, complimentary in-flight wine, the world's best shortbread cookies, breeze through customs and the arrival gate is within walking distance of your hotel.

Are you kidding?

EWR
YTZ
Good 6.0

Delay

EWR
YTZ
Good 6.6

Either my mistake or a computer glitch gave me a ticket for an evening flight when I was looking for a morning flight. I was able to avoid switching fees by showing up at the airport for the first flight, and I was able to be seated comfortably. The staff at the check in was very nice and helpful. There is no entertainment so I gave that a one. On the short flight that I was on there was a choice of snacks, I chose almonds, thank you very much for the almonds and beverage. Happy travels, everyone!

They wanted me to check my carry on which could easily have fit under the seat in front of me.

EWR
YTZ
Okay 5.0

The flight attendants were nice and pleasant

EWR
YTZ
Okay 4.0

Dirty toilet. Flight before us by Porter got delayed...all flights after also got delayed. ..poor logistics and no proper staffing at Newark airport.

Fri, Mar 16
LGA
YTZ
6h 15m
Tue, Mar 20
YTZ
LGA
6h 10m
Trip: 5 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Mon, May 7
LGA
YTZ
3h 50m
Fri, May 11
YTZ
LGA
4h 22m
Trip: 5 days
7.1GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.1 Good
Based on 21542 reviews
Overall
7.2
Boarding
7.3
Comfort
7.0
Crew
7.7
Entertainment
6.9
Food
6.5
ATL
YYZ
Okay 5.0

I arrived safely

I didn't appreciate losing my luggage as I came to Canada for a wedding and I didn't have access to my things. The flight was direct so I don't understand why my luggage was lost.

YUL
YVR
Okay 4.3

Generous leg room in coach class

Sat on the runway for almost an hour both to and from my destination

YYC
LHR
Mediocre 2.0

JustFly did not release my coupon to Lufthansa or Air Canada, and so I was nearly prevented from flying.

YVR
YYZ
Mediocre 3.6

The service was terrible, the crew did not care about anything and not willing to help or resolve issues.

I did not like the Air Canada service.

SAN
YVR
Good 6.0

Overhead bins were tiny.

Wed, Apr 11
EWR
YTZ
1h 38m
Fri, Apr 13
YTZ
EWR
1h 30m
Trip: 3 days
8.1ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.1 Excellent
Based on 174 reviews
Boarding
8.0
Comfort
8.0
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
7.0
Food
7.9
EWR
YTZ
Okay 4.3

Convenience to island airport in Toronto (that’s it)

Delayed flights to and from YTZ-EWR (due to missing crew members) Aircraft felt like it was shaking and floor vibrating the whole time (uncomfortable) Problems boarding, Porter did not check passports and allowed two passengers to board with expired passports so they had to be ejected off the aircraft once boarding was complete and took 40+ mins to find their bags Rude staff on the surround sound and when I asked for a bottle of water I would rather pay LESS and take the UP express to Pearson than EVER fly Porter again

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 8.0

I was so happy to have been bumped up to an earlier flight so easily! The staff was very friendly and the trip was very enjoyable

EWR
YTZ
Mediocre 2.0

I didn't like taking a bus to Toronto instead of a planr

Being told my flight was cancelled as I approached the counter. No email, call, or text.

EWR
YTZ
Good 6.6

Either my mistake or a computer glitch gave me a ticket for an evening flight when I was looking for a morning flight. I was able to avoid switching fees by showing up at the airport for the first flight, and I was able to be seated comfortably. The staff at the check in was very nice and helpful. There is no entertainment so I gave that a one. On the short flight that I was on there was a choice of snacks, I chose almonds, thank you very much for the almonds and beverage. Happy travels, everyone!

They wanted me to check my carry on which could easily have fit under the seat in front of me.

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

I have flown on Porter numerous time but this was the first for my family. They enjoyed the Porter lounge and convenience of flying from the Toronto island right into EWR. We were able to take the NJ Train right to Penn Station (NYC) faster than any taxi.

Thu, May 10
EWR
YTZ
1h 35m
Mon, May 14
YTZ
EWR
1h 30m
Trip: 5 days
8.1ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.1 Excellent
Based on 174 reviews
Boarding
8.0
Comfort
8.0
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
7.0
Food
7.9
EWR
YTZ
Excellent 8.0

I was so happy to have been bumped up to an earlier flight so easily! The staff was very friendly and the trip was very enjoyable

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Why would you go any other way? Dependable service, complimentary in-flight wine, the world's best shortbread cookies, breeze through customs and the arrival gate is within walking distance of your hotel.

Are you kidding?

EWR
YTZ
Okay 5.0

The flight attendants were nice and pleasant

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Good service. Thanks

EWR
YTZ
Good 6.0

They keep us updated at all times about the delays

1 hour delay!!!! And no storm

Thu, May 24
EWR
YTZ
1h 35m
Mon, May 28
YTZ
EWR
1h 30m
Trip: 5 days
8.1ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.1 Excellent
Based on 174 reviews
Boarding
8.0
Comfort
8.0
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
7.0
Food
7.9
EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Why would you go any other way? Dependable service, complimentary in-flight wine, the world's best shortbread cookies, breeze through customs and the arrival gate is within walking distance of your hotel.

Are you kidding?

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Good service. Thanks

EWR
YTZ
Good 6.0

Delay

EWR
YTZ
Good 6.6

Either my mistake or a computer glitch gave me a ticket for an evening flight when I was looking for a morning flight. I was able to avoid switching fees by showing up at the airport for the first flight, and I was able to be seated comfortably. The staff at the check in was very nice and helpful. There is no entertainment so I gave that a one. On the short flight that I was on there was a choice of snacks, I chose almonds, thank you very much for the almonds and beverage. Happy travels, everyone!

They wanted me to check my carry on which could easily have fit under the seat in front of me.

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 8.0

I was so happy to have been bumped up to an earlier flight so easily! The staff was very friendly and the trip was very enjoyable

Sat, Mar 24
EWR
YTZ
1h 35m
Tue, Mar 27
YTZ
EWR
1h 30m
Trip: 4 days
8.1ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.1 Excellent
Based on 174 reviews
Boarding
8.0
Comfort
8.0
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
7.0
Food
7.9
EWR
YTZ
Okay 4.3

Convenience to island airport in Toronto (that’s it)

Delayed flights to and from YTZ-EWR (due to missing crew members) Aircraft felt like it was shaking and floor vibrating the whole time (uncomfortable) Problems boarding, Porter did not check passports and allowed two passengers to board with expired passports so they had to be ejected off the aircraft once boarding was complete and took 40+ mins to find their bags Rude staff on the surround sound and when I asked for a bottle of water I would rather pay LESS and take the UP express to Pearson than EVER fly Porter again

EWR
YTZ
Good 6.0

They keep us updated at all times about the delays

1 hour delay!!!! And no storm

EWR
YTZ
Good 6.0

Delay

EWR
YTZ
Okay 4.0

Dirty toilet. Flight before us by Porter got delayed...all flights after also got delayed. ..poor logistics and no proper staffing at Newark airport.

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Lounge Wine

Tue, Mar 20
LGA
YTZ
6h 55m
Tue, Mar 27
YTZ
LGA
6h 31m
Trip: 8 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Fri, Mar 16
LGA
YTZ
5h 00m
Mon, Mar 19
YTZ
LGA
3h 42m
Trip: 4 days
7.1GoodShow reviews
Overall 7.1 Good
Based on 21542 reviews
Overall
7.2
Boarding
7.3
Comfort
7.0
Crew
7.7
Entertainment
6.9
Food
6.5
LAX
YYZ
Excellent 8.0

Plane delayed 1 hour and a half. No compensation.

TLV
YYZ
Mediocre 2.0

Connecting flight in Toronto late 4 HOURS!!!!! There is no excuse for such delay. Another plane should have been made available for the flight.

YUL
ORD
Excellent 9.6

Friendliness of staff My familly got to follow my flight very closely.

Delays and harsh trubulance (altough i know that wasn’t air Canada’s fault for the weather) The changing of gates and the changing of boarding time without being updated on the application. The changing of the gate was changed moments before the boarding

YYZ
HKG
Excellent 9.6

Skyscrapers

Fatigue from job

YVR
YYZ
Mediocre 3.6

The service was terrible, the crew did not care about anything and not willing to help or resolve issues.

I did not like the Air Canada service.

Tue, Apr 10
EWR
YTZ
1h 30m
Wed, Apr 18
YTZ
EWR
1h 30m
Trip: 9 days
8.1ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.1 Excellent
Based on 174 reviews
Boarding
8.0
Comfort
8.0
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
7.0
Food
7.9
EWR
YTZ
Excellent 8.0

I was so happy to have been bumped up to an earlier flight so easily! The staff was very friendly and the trip was very enjoyable

EWR
YTZ
Good 6.0

Delay

EWR
YTZ
Good 6.6

Either my mistake or a computer glitch gave me a ticket for an evening flight when I was looking for a morning flight. I was able to avoid switching fees by showing up at the airport for the first flight, and I was able to be seated comfortably. The staff at the check in was very nice and helpful. There is no entertainment so I gave that a one. On the short flight that I was on there was a choice of snacks, I chose almonds, thank you very much for the almonds and beverage. Happy travels, everyone!

They wanted me to check my carry on which could easily have fit under the seat in front of me.

EWR
YTZ
Good 6.0

They keep us updated at all times about the delays

1 hour delay!!!! And no storm

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Lounge Wine

Fri, Mar 16
JFK
YTZ
6h 15m
Mon, Mar 19
YTZ
JFK
5h 02m
Trip: 4 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Fri, May 11
EWR
YTZ
1h 34m
Sun, May 13
YTZ
EWR
1h 30m
Trip: 3 days
8.1ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.1 Excellent
Based on 174 reviews
Boarding
8.0
Comfort
8.0
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
7.0
Food
7.9
EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Good service. Thanks

EWR
YTZ
Okay 4.0

Dirty toilet. Flight before us by Porter got delayed...all flights after also got delayed. ..poor logistics and no proper staffing at Newark airport.

EWR
YTZ
Good 6.6

Either my mistake or a computer glitch gave me a ticket for an evening flight when I was looking for a morning flight. I was able to avoid switching fees by showing up at the airport for the first flight, and I was able to be seated comfortably. The staff at the check in was very nice and helpful. There is no entertainment so I gave that a one. On the short flight that I was on there was a choice of snacks, I chose almonds, thank you very much for the almonds and beverage. Happy travels, everyone!

They wanted me to check my carry on which could easily have fit under the seat in front of me.

EWR
YTZ
Good 6.0

Delay

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Why would you go any other way? Dependable service, complimentary in-flight wine, the world's best shortbread cookies, breeze through customs and the arrival gate is within walking distance of your hotel.

Are you kidding?

Tue, Apr 3
JFK
YTZ
6h 55m
Fri, Apr 27
YTZ
JFK
6h 57m
Trip: 25 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Sat, Mar 31
EWR
YTZ
1h 30m
Tue, Apr 3
YTZ
EWR
1h 30m
Trip: 4 days
8.1ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.1 Excellent
Based on 174 reviews
Boarding
8.0
Comfort
8.0
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
7.0
Food
7.9
EWR
YTZ
Okay 4.0

Dirty toilet. Flight before us by Porter got delayed...all flights after also got delayed. ..poor logistics and no proper staffing at Newark airport.

EWR
YTZ
Okay 5.0

The flight attendants were nice and pleasant

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

I have flown on Porter numerous time but this was the first for my family. They enjoyed the Porter lounge and convenience of flying from the Toronto island right into EWR. We were able to take the NJ Train right to Penn Station (NYC) faster than any taxi.

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Lounge Wine

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 8.0

I was so happy to have been bumped up to an earlier flight so easily! The staff was very friendly and the trip was very enjoyable

Mon, Mar 19
LGA
YTZ
5h 45m
Thu, Mar 22
YTZ
LGA
6h 59m
Trip: 4 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Fri, May 4
EWR
YTZ
1h 38m
Sat, May 12
YTZ
EWR
1h 30m
Trip: 9 days
8.1ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.1 Excellent
Based on 174 reviews
Boarding
8.0
Comfort
8.0
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
7.0
Food
7.9
EWR
YTZ
Okay 4.0

Dirty toilet. Flight before us by Porter got delayed...all flights after also got delayed. ..poor logistics and no proper staffing at Newark airport.

EWR
YTZ
Okay 5.0

The flight attendants were nice and pleasant

EWR
YTZ
Good 6.6

Either my mistake or a computer glitch gave me a ticket for an evening flight when I was looking for a morning flight. I was able to avoid switching fees by showing up at the airport for the first flight, and I was able to be seated comfortably. The staff at the check in was very nice and helpful. There is no entertainment so I gave that a one. On the short flight that I was on there was a choice of snacks, I chose almonds, thank you very much for the almonds and beverage. Happy travels, everyone!

They wanted me to check my carry on which could easily have fit under the seat in front of me.

EWR
YTZ
Okay 4.3

Convenience to island airport in Toronto (that’s it)

Delayed flights to and from YTZ-EWR (due to missing crew members) Aircraft felt like it was shaking and floor vibrating the whole time (uncomfortable) Problems boarding, Porter did not check passports and allowed two passengers to board with expired passports so they had to be ejected off the aircraft once boarding was complete and took 40+ mins to find their bags Rude staff on the surround sound and when I asked for a bottle of water I would rather pay LESS and take the UP express to Pearson than EVER fly Porter again

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Why would you go any other way? Dependable service, complimentary in-flight wine, the world's best shortbread cookies, breeze through customs and the arrival gate is within walking distance of your hotel.

Are you kidding?

Thu, Mar 22
JFK
YTZ
6h 25m
Mon, Mar 26
YTZ
JFK
4h 47m
Trip: 5 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Fri, Mar 30
EWR
YTZ
1h 35m
Sat, Apr 7
YTZ
EWR
1h 30m
Trip: 9 days
8.1ExcellentShow reviews
Overall 8.1 Excellent
Based on 174 reviews
Boarding
8.0
Comfort
8.0
Crew
8.4
Entertainment
7.0
Food
7.9
EWR
YTZ
Okay 4.0

Dirty toilet. Flight before us by Porter got delayed...all flights after also got delayed. ..poor logistics and no proper staffing at Newark airport.

EWR
YTZ
Mediocre 2.0

I didn't like taking a bus to Toronto instead of a planr

Being told my flight was cancelled as I approached the counter. No email, call, or text.

EWR
YTZ
Good 6.6

Either my mistake or a computer glitch gave me a ticket for an evening flight when I was looking for a morning flight. I was able to avoid switching fees by showing up at the airport for the first flight, and I was able to be seated comfortably. The staff at the check in was very nice and helpful. There is no entertainment so I gave that a one. On the short flight that I was on there was a choice of snacks, I chose almonds, thank you very much for the almonds and beverage. Happy travels, everyone!

They wanted me to check my carry on which could easily have fit under the seat in front of me.

EWR
YTZ
Excellent 10.0

Good service. Thanks

EWR
YTZ
Okay 4.3

Convenience to island airport in Toronto (that’s it)

Delayed flights to and from YTZ-EWR (due to missing crew members) Aircraft felt like it was shaking and floor vibrating the whole time (uncomfortable) Problems boarding, Porter did not check passports and allowed two passengers to board with expired passports so they had to be ejected off the aircraft once boarding was complete and took 40+ mins to find their bags Rude staff on the surround sound and when I asked for a bottle of water I would rather pay LESS and take the UP express to Pearson than EVER fly Porter again

Tue, Apr 3
JFK
YTZ
6h 55m
Wed, Apr 18
YTZ
JFK
6h 22m
Trip: 16 days
Overall 0.0 Poor
Based on 0 reviews
Show more results

New York to Toronto Island Flight Information

Avg. Flight Duration 1h 32m
Flights Arrive in Toronto Island
Flights Depart from New York
Flight Price $197
Distance 341 miles
Airlines Air Canada, Porter Airlines
*
Prices are per person and are for e–tickets and include all taxes & fees in USD.

We attempt to get accurate prices, however, prices are not guaranteed.

Here's why:

We’re not the seller.
At KAYAK we don’t set the prices, so it’s not possible for us to guarantee what other companies are selling.

We compile tonnes of data for you
Our service lets you quickly and easily compare results from hundreds of travel sites at once. In this sense, KAYAK is a search engine and we can't guarantee prices we find.

Why aren’t prices accurate 100% of the time?
Prices on airline seats, hotel rooms and car rentals can change frequently. Several people may also be trying to buy the same travel option simultaneously. As a result, you may find, on occasion, that certain prices are no longer available.

If you have more questions or if you have a bad price to report to us,
please send us an and someone from our team will get back to you promptly.

^
The fares displayed include all taxes and fees for economy class travel and were found by the provider in the last 72 hours. Seats are limited and may not be available on all flights and days. Fares are subject to change and may not be available on all flights or dates of travel. Some carriers charge additional fees for extra checked bags. Please check the carriers' sites.